The Hunger Games Mafia [Advanced] Game over! Town and TG wins!

[Hallia]

IT'S ALIVE

[Razen]

Welcome back, Basel.

[bgrishinko]

Well, that works well.

 

Razen, how about explaining your vote yesterday. I was already suspicious of Tress and yesterday didn't help your cause.

[Hallia]

Via was the last person to vote for Rhea before the execution, so she might be worth considering as well, though it's hard to know if she did it because like me, she didn't know there was an exec. or that she was the hammer.

[Razen]

At the time, what I was thinking was that the mafia could have tried to frame Cloud, because he did claim cop, I wanted to at least consider what he had to say.  You don't just lynch a cop claim without considering what you're doing.  In hindsight, I felt REALLY dumb afterward, because the twist with Cloud being an executioner, and being able to kill Rhea with only half of the necessary votes, completely blew my mind.

 

There was also an underlying reason for my willingness to consider Cloud's claim.  I had one shot remaining from Tress's vig role.  Tress had used a shot to kill Cindy (why she did,  I have ABSOLUTELY no idea, as Cindy made a lot of sense when I was reading through the game) and left me one shot to use for the future.  I had figured that if Cloud had been lying, I'd shoot him and kill him.  And so I did.

[Hallia]

Well you got him at least, and that's good!

[Razen]

As for what I found interesting when I was reading through the game, I found two people that really stuck out to me.

 

Hally, for her style of "I'm here but not actually contributing to the game" mentioned earlier on in the game.  But this one stuck out to me.  Given that we know that Tina was town, I am inclined to trust what she had to say about Hally.  Regardless of the case, what I found interesting was the second part of the statement.  Bulldogging, as a town strategy, may not always be the most effective way to go about things, but the fact that Hally was suspicious of Tina just for bulldogging her made me think.  I'm going to Vote: Hallia.

 

*nod* That is a solid case, I agree.  The way she'd been doggedly pursuing me made me suspicious already, but that just seals it.

 

 

Vote Tina

 

I also am suspicious of Kronos.  This one is much more of a gut feeling than what I believe about Hallia, because I'm not seeing a lot of actual scum-hunting from him.  It's all a lot more of clarifications to little points that others have already made, trying to appear helpful, and not offering much of his own thoughts.

 

Those are the two that I thought were mostly likely to be scum when I read through the game.

[bgrishinko]

Hmm. If you did kill cloud that means there's no way you are mafia. Doesn't rule out SK or x-shot survivor though. How do we know you aren't a SK willing to win with whoever?

 

Darthe, why you so incredibly certain of Razen?

[bgrishinko]

Well you got him at least, and that's good!

This feels like you are a bit too anxious to be seen trusting Razen so quickly.

[Hallia]

That's just my chipper personality.

[Basel Gill]

Hmm. If you did kill cloud that means there's no way you are mafia. Doesn't rule out SK or x-shot survivor though. How do we know you aren't a SK willing to win with whoever?

 

Darthe, why you so incredibly certain of Razen?

How can you be so sure he isn't mafia? I've seen scum kill their own teammates for town cred and then claim Vig. I've even been scum when it happened. And won.

[Graendals favourite]

wow, that happened fast

[Hallia]

I'm leaning one of the two quieter people; gf or wolfie.  They wouldn't want to get attention after all of that, methinks.

 

Vote GF

[bgrishinko]

 

Hmm. If you did kill cloud that means there's no way you are mafia. Doesn't rule out SK or x-shot survivor though. How do we know you aren't a SK willing to win with whoever?

 

Darthe, why you so incredibly certain of Razen?

How can you be so sure he isn't mafia? I've seen scum kill their own teammates for town cred and then claim Vig. I've even been scum when it happened. And won.

Fair enough. I thought about that considering Cloud was dead man walking anyway, could have been a good way to vet someone. But then who killed you version 1? unless you are saying the mafia had 2 NKs yesterday for some reason. Or that someone else is the vig/sk.

[Basel Gill]

I

 

 

Hmm. If you did kill cloud that means there's no way you are mafia. Doesn't rule out SK or x-shot survivor though. How do we know you aren't a SK willing to win with whoever?

 

Darthe, why you so incredibly certain of Razen?

How can you be so sure he isn't mafia? I've seen scum kill their own teammates for town cred and then claim Vig. I've even been scum when it happened. And won.

 

Fair enough. I thought about that considering Cloud was dead man walking anyway, could have been a good way to vet someone. But then who killed you version 1? unless you are saying the mafia had 2 NKs yesterday for some reason. Or that someone else is the vig/sk.

 

I think that with the available data, we can't tell accurately which NK was done by scum. I'm going to bed, I'll figure out my vote tomorrow. I was all set to vote Cloud today, so not having him around means I need to rethink.

[bgrishinko]

I'm leaning one of the two quieter people; gf or wolfie. They wouldn't want to get attention after all of that, methinks.

 

Vote GF

Why GF over Kronos? If you want to focus on them what else makes GF a better target?

[Hallia]

Because the way he was following along so easily on lynches earlier in the game.

[Darthe]

Razen actually contributes as town and ducks away as mafia.

 

However, I was more attempting to pull the NK than actually case him there.  This in mind I wouldn't be sad to see him die.

[Razen]

I'm leaning one of the two quieter people; gf or wolfie.  They wouldn't want to get attention after all of that, methinks.

 

Vote GF

 

What's interesting here is who you left out of consideration.  Where's Lenlo in this whole equation?  He's posted almost nothing, and nobody's said anything about that.  Yet when you bring up going after the quiet ones, he's not on your list.

[Hallia]

Hrm; that's a good point actually.  He'll need a look into.

[Hallia]

Went back as far as page 64 so far and nothing; could he be silenced?

[Darthe]

wow, that happened fast

who r u?

[Razen]

It's certainly something we should consider.  However, I went and found his last post - it was on page 36.  That was Day 2.  It's now Day 5.  Granted, Day 4 was really short.  I'm not sure what to think about that.

[Darthe]

Replacement?

[Graendals favourite]

 

wow, that happened fast

who r u?

 

Can't say that, but I from district 12.