BASE MAFIA - Mafia Wins!

[dapianoplay3r]

Cant you see sarcasm when it is presented?

 

I seem to remember you calling me out for just that

[peacesells]

Cant you see sarcasm when it is presented?

 

I seem to remember you calling me out for just that

 

 

yeah I saw it..but thought you'd might appreciate the same kind of BS case you made on me.

[dapianoplay3r]

My reasoning was fine. It was a little thin on one point which you are attacking

 

TBH I don't find your posts trying to explain very useful at all. They don't really do much to sway me, I'm fact they make me more sure. But you seem to get really riled by me lol

[peacesells]

I'm not trying to sway you.  I'm just making sure our readers know your case is bogus.  I have rarely seen someone back off a case after a response.  So I haven't expected you to remove your vote.

 

Others will see how thin you are though.

 

 

You don't rile me.  This is fun.  This is why we play.  The only thing that bugs me is it's the same old contributors.  Without You, Turin, Aj and me..this game would be a ghost town. 

[dapianoplay3r]

A fair bit of that I'm sure is the DM issue

[peacesells]

A fair bit of that I'm sure is the DM issue

Day 1, same players...yet add Tink.

[Andrej]

Dap you do seem to be looking for the smallest things to case people on.

 

Our little rout the other day for perfect example, didn't quite cast me in the scummy light I think you were hoping for. Tbh though, I really don't know who I want to vote right now. I'm pretty mixed up.

 

I want to see Ishy's take on the game thus far, Rand certainly started him off with a handicap.

[peacesells]

signing off guys...time will be limited this weekend if I still have trouble accessing DM from my phone.

[Andrej]

Take it easy.

[wheeloftime13]

Official Vote Count (Should be accurate)

 

 

Turin(1/7): Hally

AJ(1/7): TG

Peace(1/7): Dap

Hally(2/7): Peace, Turin

 

Note Voting:(7/12)

 

 

chuckles, Snow, AJ, Mish, RTE, WoT, Rand

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Countdown: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20130217T17&p0=%3A&fg1=f00&fg2=0f0&msg=Day+Ends

 

I extended the deadline by 24 hours because of DM problems. I have been experiencing them to.

I thought I voted for snow?? didn't RTE do so as well?

[Lenlo]

I am going to sleep. I will go back and look at everything since the beginning of the day when I wake. I really dont remember those though.

[dapianoplay3r]

I still think that's a slip on your part

[Andrej]

Was that for me Dap or were you poking the Mod now?

[Andrej]

 

Official Vote Count (Should be accurate)

 

 

Turin(1/7): Hally

AJ(1/7): TG

Peace(1/7): Dap

Hally(2/7): Peace, Turin

 

Note Voting:(7/12)

 

 

chuckles, Snow, AJ, Mish, RTE, WoT, Rand

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Countdown: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20130217T17&p0=%3A&fg1=f00&fg2=0f0&msg=Day+Ends

 

I extended the deadline by 24 hours because of DM problems. I have been experiencing them to.

I thought I voted for snow?? didn't RTE do so as well?

Time you're starting to get on my radar. Either you just aren't paying attention or hardcore skimming. Len already explained that he reset the votes when Rand was replaced as he had seen other mods do in game he's played in. Also... something about your post earlier that I hadn't noticed originally. Lemme get the quote...

[Andrej]

 

okay... so the OP says that there are 10 town and 3 mafia, but there were actually 14, so given the extra person who wasn't counted, there's either 1 more mafia or 1 more town...  i've made a list saying who I think is who... color codes: dead town, people I think are mafia, people I think are town, unsure...

 

1. Hally (Mentored by Kaylee)- mostly new player, her thoughts could be "parroting" or they could be treading carefully somewhat like I normally do...

2. Mish- unsure...

3. Andrej- pretty hard first time player... obviously been reading up... somewhat pushy in a way, but im getting a town read

4. Rand- scummy to me... mostly from the beginning... but he hasn't been on much, so i can't make a really good opinion or case...

5. Chuckles- not enough to tell really...

6. RTE- some of his posts confuse me, and i'm suspicious of him... plus i disagree with his day 1 opinion...  he's also acting pushy in my opinion

7. TG- hasn't been playing like normal but he says that he can only get on occasionally daily... unsure

8. Snow- pleads DM issues (i believe most definitely), schedule, and sleep... okay understood... but he has this "gut feeling" about a post of Turin's being off and says that one of his posts may appear scummy when he was stating a fact... gut feelings can happen, but it's good in my opinion if you can at least back part of it up with even a small piece of evidence for your gut feeling... as pointed out, it could also be used as an excuse to lynch town if you are mafia without making a good case on someone...

9. WoT

10. Turin- town in my opinion...

11. Peace- not really sure actually

12. Tiink- vanilla town, lynched Day 1

13. LZM- vanilla town, killed Night 1

14. Dap- getting a town read... helpful insight as well as good posts even if that is a tactic of mafia sometimes... for now, i think he's town...

Your take on Rand. It had already been established at this point he was being replaced.

[dapianoplay3r]

You AJ

[Andrej]

Lemme put it to you this way man.

 

I drive a truck. I ride motorcycles as well.

[dapianoplay3r]

My English rules are shaky but I feel like there is a different use of the verb or article or something there

[Andrej]

Lol well I can't hold that against you.

 

Anyway, still unsure about the Peace thing. I need to look back on it... but I'm holding my vote for now. TG came back pretty nicely, but  it reaffirmed my thoughts on him. Either town who thinks I'm scum (more likely) or mafia. Mish needs to poke in... I didn't like her simple answer about Turin when I asked why she thought he was town. I agree with her, somewhat, but her 'gut feeling' was an easy way out IMO.

[michellem]

Oh I love it when I'm reading up and the last post mentions me Good morning.

 

I wasn't able to get on parts on the forum yesterday; got cloudflare at certain parts, but not on others. Anyone else experienced that?

 

Akward poke on me there though AJ. Why me, and not Snow, Chuckles, or TG? They have been way more quiet in the whole game and missing for longer.

 

My town vibe on Turin comes from having been town with him; masons, so I feel like I am quite familar with his town meta, and he's on it. I dislike using meta as a reason, but there it is.

 

 

 

 

Now I think it was Dap that mentioned earlier that he didn't like me musing about the NK and potential set-up on TG. I'm more curious that nobody else mentioned it. Nightkills are always for a reason; they can be used to cast or remove suspicion from someone. You just brushing that off, is worrying for me.

 

I'm always loathe to vote replacements on the day they get in. Been in enough games to know that both town and mafia gets replaced at an equal rate, you really can't use it as a scum tell. And slight FoS on those who did just that. I'm not saying Rand didn't dig a deep hole; he did. But those who used him asking to be replaced as a tell big enough to place a vote... That's scum tactics. That goes especially for you Peace.

 

Actually, vote Peace

[michellem]

Oh, and I almost forgot:

 

Ishy!

[lolguy26]

So I did a reread and my thoughts

 

Turin leaning town

Dap leaning town

AJ overeager town

Mish null but I'm getting a town vibe

Time null to a slight mafia vibe

Hal has all ready said she lurks but I guess null

Snow,peace,tg,rte all nulls

 

 

And yes I know I've not been active dm not letting me on and school

 

And welcome to the game ishy

[Andrej]

Good morning to you as well Mish And welcome back Chuckles. So what gives you your mafia read on Time?

 

Also, I don't really think the poke was that awkward. Snow is... strange to me right now, and Chuckles hasn't really played all game. TG was on earlier and I've already had my argument with him. Basically, I wanted you to come back so I could continue to watch you lol

 

Basing gut feels off meta, another easy answer but I get what you're saying.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 

 

Official Vote Count (Should be accurate)

 

 

Turin(1/7): Hally

AJ(1/7): TG

Peace(1/7): Dap

Hally(2/7): Peace, Turin

 

Note Voting:(7/12)

 

 

chuckles, Snow, AJ, Mish, RTE, WoT, Rand

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Countdown: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20130217T17&p0=%3A&fg1=f00&fg2=0f0&msg=Day+Ends

 

I extended the deadline by 24 hours because of DM problems. I have been experiencing them to.

I thought I voted for snow?? didn't RTE do so as well?

Time you're starting to get on my radar. Either you just aren't paying attention or hardcore skimming. Len already explained that he reset the votes when Rand was replaced as he had seen other mods do in game he's played in. Also... something about your post earlier that I hadn't noticed originally. Lemme get the quote...

 

This is complete BS. I just checked and the votes on that VC were also from before Ishy joined the game. WoT's and my vote should be there. Dap what are you up to? Almost all those votes were there from before Ishy joined.

[Andrej]

That's another slip RTE. I posted that, not Dap.