[Advanced] Hobbit Mafia Town Wins!

[beanie]

Dice, that would be my game :P

 

And guys...I think I'm going to ask to be replaced. I really don't have time to reread this whole thread and as it is now I've forgotten all of my initial thoughts. Sorry =\

[Songstress]

If Darthe flips town I will be shocked.  But I understand what you're thinking Mish.  

[michellem]

Cyan, honestly, I think that is a really unfair thing to do both for the replacement and for the rest of the players. Sorry, but that is my honest opinion.

[beanie]

It's not like I want to do it, but seriously my replacement knows as much about this game as I do atm. Only thing I remember is Starry claiming poision doc and being random killed on D1 and Turin and you claiming masonizers.

[dicetosser1]

headdesk!!

 

sorry folks   I even went to type Roo at first and changed it!

 

 

Mish why do you think it is so unfair thaqt cyan be replaced?

[Tyler Glembo]

Yes, Dice...what do you think about that case? 

 

Guys, Darthe is scum.  I'd bank the game on it.  Neighborizer is a scum role especially since we have a confirmed masonizer. 

 

I think that between you and Darthe there are two good lynches where we can get a lot of information.  I do find it interesting how people keep dying around Darthe though.

 

I still think TGlems is scum.  Notice how he's laid low since I stated my opinion?

 

No, not really.  But nice of you to keep deflecting on to me based on me saying that I did not want to lynch townies.  I still think that there are a couple scum who are laying low and they need to be drawn out.  LZM for instance has posted a couple fluff posts and nothing more. 

 

Sorry this is kind of disjointed... I've got a bit of a headache and I had a really late night last night and not enough sleep.  I can elaborate later if need be.

 

Vote Darthe

 

As stated previously, I don't believe there is a town neighborizer when there is a confirmed town masonizer.  Darthe is a very deliberate player and a good manipulator.  Every time I can think of that he's appeared to make a mistake within a game, it's been a deliberate gameplay choice.

 

I'm also concerned about TG and have been since early on.  The bit during the attempt to secure a lynch D4 in which we had to argue with him that a controlled lynch of a claimed vanilla town was better for town than risking a random didn't help any at all.

 

I trust Mish and Dice at this point, and one other person who I will not name.  I expect I will have to claim at some point and do not want to let anything slip that will endanger this person.

 

Mish, were you able to masonize Cyan last night?  You're still alive, and that's a good sign.

 

I forgot LZM was even in this game. 

 

vote Darthe

 

If Darthe flips town, at least we get some good info on his interactions.  I also find his "bring it on" comment scummy.  It was just a bit too much for him to invite any and all action.

[michellem]

I'm just not fan of people dropping out mid-game, for no better reason than lack of time. I see it as a commitment when I sign up for a game; and if I commit, I stick. It's just my own fault if I can't manage to keep up with the game and then it's my responsobility to make that up to my fellow players. The only time I've ever dropped out a game was at the very beginning, I was in two other games and just before that game started my computer died and my phone is a nightmare to navigate DM on; I knew my play in that game would suffer for it and so I asked to be replaced. I still don't like that I had to be replaced. So yeah, it's just my own opinion that you do take on a commitment when you sign up for a game; mafia isn't a game without the players after all...

 

That's my opinion and I know that it's not an opinion everyone has.

[beanie]

Eh you think I like dropping out? Would you prefer if I continued to play, knowing full well that I'm not going to be able to manage a reread? I can reread the last day phase maybe, or part of it at least. If you don't mind that then I'll continue to play. But see, then everyone will be constantly jumping on me for not remembering stuff, and I don't have my notes anymore so it's not like I can just look back through for a summary. 

 

How 'bout the mafia just NK me and then ta-da problem solved! Or you could lynch me. Either way works.

[Tyler Glembo]

I'm just not fan of people dropping out mid-game, for no better reason than lack of time. I see it as a commitment when I sign up for a game; and if I commit, I stick. It's just my own fault if I can't manage to keep up with the game and then it's my responsobility to make that up to my fellow players. The only time I've ever dropped out a game was at the very beginning, I was in two other games and just before that game started my computer died and my phone is a nightmare to navigate DM on; I knew my play in that game would suffer for it and so I asked to be replaced. I still don't like that I had to be replaced. So yeah, it's just my own opinion that you do take on a commitment when you sign up for a game; mafia isn't a game without the players after all...

 

That's my opinion and I know that it's not an opinion everyone has.

 

It can make a big difference though.  Since we are mixing up games Dice sub'd into the PJ game Cyan mentioned and has done a lot to liven things up by being very active.  Yes, it would be nice if everybody could be very active and never sub out, but life happens.

[peacesells]

Mish..what's to defend.  You've stated some of my actions seem scummy to you but haven't stated why they are scummy.  The worst thing I've done is make a mistake on the vanilla claim. 

 

If you want to explain why those actions are scummy...then maybe I can defend.  Dice has been the same too btw.

 

Thing I don't want to do is get in a tit for tat with someone I'm pretty sure is town. 

[Darthe]

Wow. Some of you feel very strongly about my alignment. Peace and Tress strike me as very overdone in their play these last few pages. I am beginning to think they are working together. I will have more to say later.

[Darthe]

Oh, I almost forgot to mention this. My least favorite thing about the votes on me currently are that they are not based on my play or interactions, but rather my role.

[lolguy26]

ok ive just been reading 

 

i get what cyans about (a few months ago i had to drop out all my games cuz school and parents )

 

and i cant really discuss whether darthe's role is town or mafia cuz its my first time, but i have a question i cant remember who exactly mentioned this (i think it was you mish), but something about two mafia teams there?

 

and i havent seen LZM since ive actually been in the game 

 

@rand: is he on LOA or something??

[michellem]

lolguy, I specified why I thought that two or three pages back...

[dicetosser1]

all right you lot  do me a favour while im at work and get your heads around this vote. We have a bit over a day left 2 possibilities have been thrown up already  so lets NOT let this go random or get REALLY REALLY close to the deadline please

[michellem]

Rand, could we get a VC?

[peacesells]

Rand, could we get a VC?

Rand, you should really be trying to get a VC in once a real day..or at least every 2 days.  It will help motivate people to post more.

[Darthe]

Waste of time. Mafia is biding to use me as a consolidation, that is clear. Just go ahead and lynch me so I can mod my upcoming games.

[peacesells]

Waste of time. Mafia is biding to use me as a consolidation, that is clear. Just go ahead and lynch me so I can mod my upcoming games.

 

 

Never thought I'd see you go all EMO Darthe.  Pretty disappointing.  Makes me even more sure of your guilt.

[Darthe]

That is a misuse of te term emotional response. You're implication is that I am reacting from a state of emotionality to avoid being lynched by means of guilt. However, I have instead merely stated te truth in a way that may draw reaction. Quite suspect of you peace.

[RandA lThor]

I am supposed to be working on my anthropology paper, and my parents are keeping a strict eye on me, sorry guys.  I will try to sneak in a VC, but my parents are really cracking down on me today. :(

[peacesells]

That is a misuse of te term emotional response. You're implication is that I am reacting from a state of emotionality to avoid being lynched by means of guilt. However, I have instead merely stated te truth in a way that may draw reaction. Quite suspect of you peace.

The truth is you were emotional.  Backtracking now is pretty obvious. 

[Darthe]

I wasn't and am not. Don't mistake my attitude for emotionality, it is a demeaning play.

 

You may as well face that my lynch is based on my role and not my plays. If you expect me to not have an issue with that then you're highly mistaken as I could simply have avoided revealing myself and recruited Mish if that were the problem.

 

After all, where is the fun in being cased for the moderators game design?

[peacesells]

Recruiting Mish wouldn't have had any affect on your alignment.  You've claimed a scum role.  Period.

[peacesells]

Waste of time. Mafia is biding to use me as a consolidation, that is clear. Just go ahead and lynch me so I can mod my upcoming games.

 

Bolded is an emotional cop out.  Denying that it was is not helping your case.