[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Darthe]

So which policy is that? Just to be clear? Is that the EP policy, the role hint policy, the campaign policy, or the D1 policy? Wow the poor guy has a lot against him before we even consider how he is playing.

[Gabriel Kross]

Wait so Des thinks I'm hinting, and the only 2 characters that could possibly fall under the kind of hint he is suggesting I made would have to be town. I really hope this isn't a faction game, because right now it looks like Red, Verb, and Des are all on the same team trying to push an "easy" lynch.

[peacesells]

I don't think, considering the subject matter, that any group must be considered town.

 

How many different factions have so called rightful claims to the thrown?

 

We had this discussion in detail last advanced GOT game. The possibilities are endless. So even if you are one of the two bastards you aren't off the hook.

 

There's even another angle you could be pushing. You could be neither and an actual scum and be dropping bastard hints trying to make you look town cause a counter claim with 2 options is tough to make.

[Nolder]

just btw there are three bastards that I can think of offhand and one of them is a very very bad man

[Nolder]

It's the kind of misleading statement you'd leave for a lie detector if you're the bad bastard now that I think about it because most people will probably think of the other two first

[Gabriel Kross]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

[Songstress]

Good job there EP.

[Gabriel Kross]

I'm pretty sure atleast 1 of my 3 suspects is mafia.

[John Snow]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

 

Lies. I'm John Snow.

Or do you mean Jon Snow?

[John Snow]

It's the kind of misleading statement you'd leave for a lie detector if you're the bad bastard now that I think about it because most people will probably think of the other two first

 

What makes you think there's a lie detector?

[John Snow]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

hardly a spoiler, but just to be safe, the names of the 3 main bastards

 

Jon Snow, Joeffry Baratheon, and the one guy from the Iron Isles

 

[Nolder]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

hardly a spoiler, but just to be safe, the names of the 3 main bastards

 

Jon Snow, Joeffry Baratheon, and the one guy from the Iron Isles

 

Wat

No you are forgetting one

[Gabriel Kross]

Oh and ftr, I purposely drew attention to push myself into a reveal. I have my reasons, I do like the reactions that I recieved though.

 

Nol pretty much ignored it, until I went back on Desp. Slight town read on him.

Verb, reasonable reaction, but looks bad in association with how Red reacted. I understand that it could be a set up on Verb by Red, but I want to see what plays out between Red and Verb from here on.

Desp: Illogical responses are illogical.

Red Defense of Verb, calling my reason for voting verb a stretch when half of her reason for voting me was for replying to Nolder's comment about Verb's.

Ed Nil read

 

and yes John, I meant Jon, I did mispell it.

[Nolder]

Oh and ftr, I purposely drew attention to push myself into a reveal. I have my reasons, I do like the reactions that I recieved though.

 

Nol pretty much ignored it, until I went back on Desp. Slight town read on him.

Verb, reasonable reaction, but looks bad in association with how Red reacted. I understand that it could be a set up on Verb by Red, but I want to see what plays out between Red and Verb from here on.

Desp: Illogical responses are illogical.

Red Defense of Verb, calling my reason for voting verb a stretch when half of her reason for voting me was for replying to Nolder's comment about Verb's.

Ed Nil read

 

and yes John, I meant Jon, I did mispell it.

I'm mod confirmed town you nut

[Gabriel Kross]

Oh and I forgot Nol is mod confirmed so I guess his reactions are moot anyways lol.

[hazelkrs1]

So which policy is that? Just to be clear? Is that the EP policy, the role hint policy, the campaign policy, or the D1 policy? Wow the poor guy has a lot against him before we even consider how he is playing.

 

I think it's very clear what policy I was talking about when I voted him.

 

You're on my list too btw, for that provocation post you had when you asked Ed what was pinging about EP.

 

Wait so Des thinks I'm hinting, and the only 2 characters that could possibly fall under the kind of hint he is suggesting I made would have to be town. I really hope this isn't a faction game, because right now it looks like Red, Verb, and Des are all on the same team trying to push an "easy" lynch.

 

Nol already made this point for me, but to clarify: One of the most evil characters in the whole series is a bastard, Roose Bolton's bastard.

 

And I'll say this: most people think linking players too early is scummy, but I personally don't really see a problem with it. But you do introduce some setup talk there with that part about factions, which is scummy.

 

Either way, it's an amateur move to say everyone voting you is mafia. You should know better.

 

I don't think, considering the subject matter, that any group must be considered town.

 

How many different factions have so called rightful claims to the thrown?

 

We had this discussion in detail last advanced GOT game. The possibilities are endless. So even if you are one of the two bastards you aren't off the hook.

 

There's even another angle you could be pushing. You could be neither and an actual scum and be dropping bastard hints trying to make you look town cause a counter claim with 2 options is tough to make.

 

We did have that discussion last game. Thing is, it was mostly scummy wifom generated to help keep town paranoid about everyone. I should know, I was one of the mafiosos pushing that discussion. I said what I said then because I was trying to help my team win. The fact is, I think the vast majority of GoT-themed games will have the Starks as town.

[Nolder]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

hardly a spoiler, but just to be safe, the names of the 3 main bastards

 

Jon Snow, Joeffry Baratheon, and the one guy from the Iron Isles

 

Wat

No you are forgetting one

Scratch that you are crazy anyway

Joffery is not a bastard and I dunno who you are talking about from the Iron Isles

 

I was referring to the Bolton bastard

[Gabriel Kross]

It's the kind of misleading statement you'd leave for a lie detector if you're the bad bastard now that I think about it because most people will probably think of the other two first

 

What makes you think there's a lie detector?

 

It would fit, I wouldn't know who'd best play that role but in a cannon where lies are everything someone is bound to be.

[Gabriel Kross]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

hardly a spoiler, but just to be safe, the names of the 3 main bastards

 

Jon Snow, Joeffry Baratheon, and the one guy from the Iron Isles

 

Wat

No you are forgetting one

Scratch that you are crazy anyway

Joffery is not a bastard and I dunno who you are talking about from the Iron Isles

 

I was referring to the Bolton bastard

 

I'm not that far Nol, I don't know who Bolton is. I know the Blacksmith (Baratheon's forget his name) and Jon.

[John Snow]

There's a third? I only knew of Baratheon's and Stark's. Well to get us back focused. I'm John Snow. Roll unessesary at current, but I am town.

hardly a spoiler, but just to be safe, the names of the 3 main bastards

 

Jon Snow, Joeffry Baratheon, and the one guy from the Iron Isles

 

Wat

No you are forgetting one

Scratch that you are crazy anyway

Joffery is not a bastard and I dunno who you are talking about from the Iron Isles

 

I was referring to the Bolton bastard

 

 

Um, yeah he is

Bastard of incest between the Lannister twins

 

[hazelkrs1]

Oh and ftr, I purposely drew attention to push myself into a reveal. I have my reasons, I do like the reactions that I recieved though.

 

Nol pretty much ignored it, until I went back on Desp. Slight town read on him.

Verb, reasonable reaction, but looks bad in association with how Red reacted. I understand that it could be a set up on Verb by Red, but I want to see what plays out between Red and Verb from here on.

Desp: Illogical responses are illogical.

Red Defense of Verb, calling my reason for voting verb a stretch when half of her reason for voting me was for replying to Nolder's comment about Verb's.

Ed Nil read

 

and yes John, I meant Jon, I did mispell it.

I'm mod confirmed town you nut

Oh and I forgot Nol is mod confirmed so I guess his reactions are moot anyways lol.

 

 

How was any response of mine illogical so far EP?

 

I'm once again both rolling my eyes and chuckling at your "Oh I meant to act scummy to draw votes and necessitate a reveal" thing.

 

If you wanted to claim, why not claim right out the gate? It's not like it would look any more suspect than claiming with what... 3 votes on you so far?

[John Snow]

Oh, yeah, the Iron Isles guy wasn't a bastard, he was a ward. Whoops.

[Gabriel Kross]

So which policy is that? Just to be clear? Is that the EP policy, the role hint policy, the campaign policy, or the D1 policy? Wow the poor guy has a lot against him before we even consider how he is playing.

 

I think it's very clear what policy I was talking about when I voted him.

 

You're on my list too btw, for that provocation post you had when you asked Ed what was pinging about EP.

 

Wait so Des thinks I'm hinting, and the only 2 characters that could possibly fall under the kind of hint he is suggesting I made would have to be town. I really hope this isn't a faction game, because right now it looks like Red, Verb, and Des are all on the same team trying to push an "easy" lynch.

 

Nol already made this point for me, but to clarify: One of the most evil characters in the whole series is a bastard, Roose Bolton's bastard.

 

And I'll say this: most people think linking players too early is scummy, but I personally don't really see a problem with it. But you do introduce some setup talk there with that part about factions, which is scummy.

 

Either way, it's an amateur move to say everyone voting you is mafia. You should know better.

 

I don't think, considering the subject matter, that any group must be considered town.

 

How many different factions have so called rightful claims to the thrown?

 

We had this discussion in detail last advanced GOT game. The possibilities are endless. So even if you are one of the two bastards you aren't off the hook.

 

There's even another angle you could be pushing. You could be neither and an actual scum and be dropping bastard hints trying to make you look town cause a counter claim with 2 options is tough to make.

 

We did have that discussion last game. Thing is, it was mostly scummy wifom generated to help keep town paranoid about everyone. I should know, I was one of the mafiosos pushing that discussion. I said what I said then because I was trying to help my team win. The fact is, I think the vast majority of GoT-themed games will have the Starks as town.

 

Didn't say ed is mafia, Verb isn't voting me. You and Red just have horrible reasons for voting me so I don't see how you 2 could be town.

[hazelkrs1]

I think the three we were all thinking of were Snow, Gendry, and Ramsay (thanks got wiki) Bolton

[Nightstrike]

Why role claim or hint so early? Why? I think it's bad for town. It's seemed that way in the games I've been in so far, anyway. Maybe confirmed townies aren't always all good, either, I don't know?