[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[RandA lThor]

Yeah, I should definitely be able to change it, we do nothing in media production.

[keyholder21]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

(Just for you, Ed)

 

Basel (11) - Mish, leelou, Ishy, Ed, JLM, Red, Nolder, BG, Razen, Songs, Kaylee

BG (5) - Darthe, peace, Cyan, Des, Rand

Ishy (1) - Basel

John Snow (1) - Lenlo

JLM (1) - EP

Songs (1) - Nightstrike

Nightstrike (1) - John Snow

 

 

Not voting (3): Verb, dice, WoT

 

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

 

DL: http://www.timeandda... Deadline&csz=1 FIVE HOURS.

[Nightstrike]

 

Not voting (4): Kaylee, Verb, dice, WoT

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

I don't know whether Basel tells the truth or not. If he is telling the truth, then he probably won't live long after today, right? I mean, once he's claimed everybody with some killing power are likely to target him, right? I don't like bg as the lynch option either. I doubt he's scum, but he could be of course. I don't think there's a great case against him, either way. If we're to have a random on an inactive player, then we won't get the coroner's report. That would be terribly bad. We should try and get some sort of info out of the lynch, at the very least. Does anyone have any evidence pointing towards any of those 4 non-voters being scum? I haven't seen anyone voting any of them, so this seems like a really bad alternative for town.

[Nightstrike]

If Basel tells the truth, then even 1 night action of his would be of value. Is this bad luck on our part or is it a clever move on Basel's?

[bgrishinko]

If Basel tells the truth, then even 1 night action of his would be of value. Is this bad luck on our part or is it a clever move on Basel's?

 

Even 1 Night action could also kill Doc/Cop or some other good role.

 

I highly doubt we'd be able to consolidate 13 votes on an inactive. The only criteria I'd put for lynching one of them is highly active elsewhere and not here.

 

 

Also, Kaylee has placed a vote.

[Nightstrike]

I do think it's likely that he is Jaqen H'gar. I've not idea whether he's town, 3:rd party or something else. Assuming it's 50/50 he's town, I'd say he could probably to more harm if he's something other than town, than he could do good if he's town. That's because of the fact that he has already exposed himself. Of all the likely lynch candidates, he's probably town's best chance, in my opinion. Unvote . Vote Basel .

[Nightstrike]

We're now at L-1, so the next to vote will be the hammer.

[RandA lThor]

You may now post. In the Game of Thrones, you win, or you die.

 

R&R to your role PM before posting.

 

Town win condition: You win with the town when all threats to the town have been removed.

 

Mafia win condition: You win when you gain a voting majority.If some of your role pm win conditions are worded differently, it was my mistake.

 

THESE ARE THE CORRECT WIN CONDITIONS.

 

There is no third party!

[Nightstrike]

Different mafia factions - isn't that a possibility? It doesn't say that there is no third party, it just lists win conditions for town and mafia. Not that I say there is a third party, but maybe ...

[hazelkrs1]

Desp, I think we have good day 1 options as is. But, I do understand that in a no lynch game an inactive would be good..but only if Basel hadn't claimed yet. Your idea would be good if were getting down to the nitty gritty and he had a last minute claim of an role we shouldn't lynch at all like cop.

 

Then having an inactive in our pocket would be a great choice. But Basel has claimed. And I think that changes the scenario greatly.

 

Something is troubling me though. I don't really believe his claim, but I could be wrong so I'm hesitant to pull the trigger. Lately we've had some very successful town vigs in games. They can holster when unsure and put to sleep a scummy player that seems unlynchable for some reason.

 

What I am finding really interesting is several people have claimed they are willing to vote BG but are voting Basel instead with comments like "even a town vig can be bad for town." Imo, that's a very weak reason. If you think someone is likely innocent, don't vote for them. Especially when you have another viable option that several others agree with. This is really nagging at me.

 

Even if there isn't enough initially to lynch BG, two trains is great day 1 info and can set the rest of the game up nicely for town.

 

It's a bit late to try setting up competing trains most likely tho.

 

But I'd be willing to follow onto BG if it seems like enough people would do the same.

 

In fact,

 

Unvote, Vote BG

Actually, he has a point. Now with this, it takes out the whole Basel is 3rd party. Not good, he probably is the vig, unvote vote BG

 

Looking at this objectively (and ignoring the fact you moved your votes to me) it looks like some folks are okay with having a Random from the pool of Non-Voters and are hoping to split the vote the rest of the day.

 

See now this post tells me even more that you're prob mafia. Trying to make it seem objective even tho you're fos'ing people on your train...

 

And it should be easy enough to secure a lynch when someone is already L-2 with a few hours left. Razen and BG def pinging pretty big right now

[Songstress]

You may now post. In the Game of Thrones, you win, or you die.

 

R&R to your role PM before posting.

 

Town win condition: You win with the town when all threats to the town have been removed.

 

Mafia win condition: You win when you gain a voting majority.If some of your role pm win conditions are worded differently, it was my mistake.

 

THESE ARE THE CORRECT WIN CONDITIONS.

 

There is no third party!

 

Do you seriously expect the mods to list "SERIAL KILLER WIN CONDITION:" there?

[RandA lThor]

You may now post. In the Game of Thrones, you win, or you die.

 

R&R to your role PM before posting.

 

Town win condition: You win with the town when all threats to the town have been removed.

 

Mafia win condition: You win when you gain a voting majority.If some of your role pm win conditions are worded differently, it was my mistake.

 

THESE ARE THE CORRECT WIN CONDITIONS.

 

There is no third party!

 

Do you seriously expect the mods to list "SERIAL KILLER WIN CONDITION:" there?

If there was, I don't see a reason for them to list the other win conditions.

[Verbal32]

Wait, Verb is playing in this one?

 

Hahahahaha.

 

Haha.

 

Ha.

 

I'm back.

[Verbal32]

Deadline coming - no way another lynch is secured.

 

Vote: Basel

[bgrishinko]

Desp, I think we have good day 1 options as is. But, I do understand that in a no lynch game an inactive would be good..but only if Basel hadn't claimed yet. Your idea would be good if were getting down to the nitty gritty and he had a last minute claim of an role we shouldn't lynch at all like cop.

 

Then having an inactive in our pocket would be a great choice. But Basel has claimed. And I think that changes the scenario greatly.

 

Something is troubling me though. I don't really believe his claim, but I could be wrong so I'm hesitant to pull the trigger. Lately we've had some very successful town vigs in games. They can holster when unsure and put to sleep a scummy player that seems unlynchable for some reason.

 

What I am finding really interesting is several people have claimed they are willing to vote BG but are voting Basel instead with comments like "even a town vig can be bad for town." Imo, that's a very weak reason. If you think someone is likely innocent, don't vote for them. Especially when you have another viable option that several others agree with. This is really nagging at me.

 

Even if there isn't enough initially to lynch BG, two trains is great day 1 info and can set the rest of the game up nicely for town.

 

It's a bit late to try setting up competing trains most likely tho.

 

But I'd be willing to follow onto BG if it seems like enough people would do the same.

 

In fact,

 

Unvote, Vote BG

Actually, he has a point. Now with this, it takes out the whole Basel is 3rd party. Not good, he probably is the vig, unvote vote BG

 

Looking at this objectively (and ignoring the fact you moved your votes to me) it looks like some folks are okay with having a Random from the pool of Non-Voters and are hoping to split the vote the rest of the day.

 

See now this post tells me even more that you're prob mafia. Trying to make it seem objective even tho you're fos'ing people on your train...

 

And it should be easy enough to secure a lynch when someone is already L-2 with a few hours left. Razen and BG def pinging pretty big right now

 

Whatever man, I'm just calling it like it is.

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Ishy (1) - Basel

John Snow (1) - Lenlo

BG (5) - Darthe, peace, Cyan, Des, Rand

JLM (1) - EP

Nightstrike (1) - John Snow

Basel (13) - Mish, leelou, Ishy, Ed, JLM, Red, Nolder, BG, Razen, Songs, Kaylee, Nightstrike, Verbal

 

 

Not voting (2): dice, WoT

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

 

That's a lynch! Scene coming.

 

Leelou and Lenlo have asked to be replaced.

[Sakaea]

Some housekeeping first: Leelou has asked to be replaced because somebody on the mafia team told somebody else about this game and who was who, and that somebody didn't know Leelou was in this game and told her.

 

YOU ARE NOT TO TALK ABOUT ONGOING MAFIA GAMES WITH ANYONE. This has made it so we have to find more replacements, and that has narrowed the pool of possibles down as well. I'm not gonna ask who did it, but if I find out anyone else does it, or is continuing to do it, you will be modkilled without hesitation. I want everyone to R&R this statement please.

[Sakaea]

Basel, Jaquin H'Ghar, SK, one time BPV, has been lynched.

 

It is now Night 1. All NA's must be submitted AS A RESPONSE TO YOUR ROLE PM, by 10am on Thursday.

 

DL: http://timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?year=2012&month=oct&day=11&hour=10&min=00&sec=00&p0=2440&msg=Night+1+DL#

 

Basel, PM me ASAP if you would like to replace back in.

[bgrishinko]

R&R

[RandA lThor]

R&R

 

Well, it appears you guys were right that the mods just posted the town and mafia conditions. And with your canon knowledge as well. Nicely done guys, I was wrong.

[Songstress]

Some housekeeping first: Leelou has asked to be replaced because somebody on the mafia team told somebody else about this game and who was who, and that somebody didn't know Leelou was in this game and told her.

 

YOU ARE NOT TO TALK ABOUT ONGOING MAFIA GAMES WITH ANYONE. This has made it so we have to find more replacements, and that has narrowed the pool of possibles down as well. I'm not gonna ask who did it, but if I find out anyone else does it, or is continuing to do it, you will be modkilled without hesitation. I want everyone to R&R this statement please.

 

R/U Ms. Moddess.

[Nightstrike]

YOU ARE NOT TO TALK ABOUT ONGOING MAFIA GAMES WITH ANYONE. This has made it so we have to find more replacements, and that has narrowed the pool of possibles down as well. I'm not gonna ask who did it, but if I find out anyone else does it, or is continuing to do it, you will be modkilled without hesitation. I want everyone to R&R this statement please.

R & U

[John E. Kelley]

R&R sis.

 

And SK......I wonder who brought up that possibility.....

 

*totally patting self on the back*

[ed2funy]

Do we? This is a game of lies and deceit, that's why people like Rand who slip up and admit to being mafia/third party they are judged for what they said not what they meant to say.

 

Uhhh, seeing as how I have mentioned it before, then yes. Nice try, though.

 

(Just for you, Ed)

 

 

 

Some housekeeping first: Leelou has asked to be replaced because somebody on the mafia team told somebody else about this game and who was who, and that somebody didn't know Leelou was in this game and told her.

 

YOU ARE NOT TO TALK ABOUT ONGOING MAFIA GAMES WITH ANYONE. This has made it so we have to find more replacements, and that has narrowed the pool of possibles down as well. I'm not gonna ask who did it, but if I find out anyone else does it, or is continuing to do it, you will be modkilled without hesitation. I want everyone to R&R this statement please.

o_O

Bad juju. Bad Despo. Silly mafia.

 

Read and Understood.

 

 

 

Also, still noting how he deflected with spam. I'm not that easy, Desp.

 

And Rand, you're an ultra-cheerleader now. Talking about the win conditions.

 

 

 

And yes, Kae, yes I was expecting to post all the win conditions. lol, I guess it makes sense not to, though. But hmph. imo, it's all or none.

Not that I'm getting on your case.

Despo hasn't cased the mods before.

[RandA lThor]

Do we? This is a game of lies and deceit, that's why people like Rand who slip up and admit to being mafia/third party they are judged for what they said not what they meant to say.

 

Uhhh, seeing as how I have mentioned it before, then yes. Nice try, though.

 

(Just for you, Ed)

 

 

 

Some housekeeping first: Leelou has asked to be replaced because somebody on the mafia team told somebody else about this game and who was who, and that somebody didn't know Leelou was in this game and told her.

 

YOU ARE NOT TO TALK ABOUT ONGOING MAFIA GAMES WITH ANYONE. This has made it so we have to find more replacements, and that has narrowed the pool of possibles down as well. I'm not gonna ask who did it, but if I find out anyone else does it, or is continuing to do it, you will be modkilled without hesitation. I want everyone to R&R this statement please.

o_O

Bad juju. Bad Despo. Silly mafia.

 

Read and Understood.

 

 

 

Also, still noting how he deflected with spam. I'm not that easy, Desp.

 

And Rand, you're an ultra-cheerleader now. Talking about the win conditions.

 

 

 

And yes, Kae, yes I was expecting to post all the win conditions. lol, I guess it makes sense not to, though. But hmph. imo, it's all or none.

Not that I'm getting on your case.

Despo hasn't cased the mods before.

 

Ultra-cheerleader? Here take a look at this. http://lmgtfy.com/?q=definition+of+cheerleader

 

I was trying to do the opposite of what everyone else was doing, I was advocating the exact opposite side. I was wrong, but I definitely was not cheerleading.