[BASIC] Disney Mafia Game Thread - GAME OVER: SK WINS!

[Ironeyes]

It's spelled Maleficent.

[Nolder]

go town

[peacesells]

Tina, I think it is safe to assume you can vet 1 player now? Who did you protect last night? We can get this down to 4 unknowns (including me) you let us know who you protected.

 

Ok..the whole Song/now Arez thing is bothering me. Song disappears and is replaced by Arez. He comes in and makes 1 strange post then disappears. Deadline approaching and he doesn't vote anyone. It's like he is hiding too. So, I'm gonna VOTE AREZ. I'll remove the vote if Tina states she protected him last night.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Where did my response disappear..

 

Oh, So let me get this straight. I replace Tress, scumhunt (Aka, post my thoughts) and then go to sleep. Barley 9 posts after (which of almost none were relevant) you attack me for not making another post within that limit?

 

That move was really scummy.

[peacesells]

You made 1 post of half assed scum hunting. So half assed you didn't even vote even though a deadline was approaching. So, yeah, I think you/song are scummy.

[Basel Gill]

Song and Red's distancing act on Day 1 still sticks out in my mind. If Song was scum, and Arez is taking over her role, then Arez is also scum. And he was pinged evasiveness when replying to Peace's vote. What he did say was valid, he made one post and then went to bed, and notes Peace is going after him for not making another post nine posts later while he was asleep.

 

But: it is what he leaves out that pings. He tries to dodge suspicion by answering one bit and making it look like he is coming up with a good defense for himself, while he totally fails to mention why he never voted.

 

Hello there fellows! Why the FUDGE do you have to be so hard to read?! REALLY. I've been changing my opinion on who is scum and who is not like 1 time every 3 pages >_< FRUSTRATING.

 

Okey, so far, I've come up with two people I think are acting scummy.

 

First we have Nolder. I was hoping I'd be able to replace before people started voting him, now it'll just seem like a bandwaggon.

So why do I think Nolder is scum? He's not said anything of vital importance up until page 10-12 or something?

 

What did he have to say for himself? "I don't know who to vote..."

 

Then suddenly *BOOM!!!!* activity in the game goes SKY HIGH. Typical scum reaction when getting called out.

 

Next person. I know people are going to go all WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU, but I feel that I have to add it xD

 

Aiel Heart.. *BUUUUU, YOU SUCK AREZZZ, GO TO HELL* Relax relax. Just hold your horses.

The thing I reacted most on was her "so called list". To make things worse for you guys, I'm going to say I think she's scum because of META.. *Oh no you didn't!!* YES I DID.

 

She never uses her list anymore, not as town anyway.. To me it just seems like a way to reinforce positive influence and assurance that she IS town, which I doubt. I had other reasons.. I think, but I didn't get replaced fast enough so now I have to fudging re-read 10 minutes after I just read the whole thread.............................................

 

You mention two separate people you consider to be scum, Arez: Nol and AH. You never voted either one of them. You never voted at all. And then when Peace called you out on it, you never explained your voting actions. Or lack thereof. Vote Arez.

 

Oh, and Tress isn't even in this game. You are replacing Song, not Tress.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Oh, I'm replacing Song of Fire and Ice? Thought it was Songstress.

 

I don't like how the FIRST post each of you two made had a vote in it for me. Seems like scum rushing a lynch before anyone has a time to argue and think.

And also Basel, You're fence-sitting

 

"Yeah, Arez says valid things and such, but he didn't vote , so he's scum"

 

I wasn't aware the deadline was so close, but it doesn't matter, as it was a "trap", crudly made, but it seems to have done the trick.

 

As for what Song did before, I can't answer for that. When I did my read before replacing, I got a scum vibe from her in the beggining aswell. Seemed like her and Red pulling of a Turin/Mynd thing. (Mynd accused Turin, Turin went Awall, mental breakdown, but Turin and Mynd was both scum from the beginning.

 

I'm going to Vote Basel

He jumped on the weak case Peace made against me ===> opportunistic.

[Razen]

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

Arez (2) - Peace, Basel

Basel (1) - Arez

 

Not voting (3) - AH, Ironeyes, Tina

 

It is now Day 4. With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Your deadline is 7pm CDT (Minneapolis time) on Sunday, July 22nd.

Countdown timer: http://www.timeandda...til Day 4 Ends:

[Niniel]

I protected AH last night since she is the only one I have a town read on. So we can assume that mafia tried to kill her which makes her not mafia. However, we can´t be sure that she is town because it seems like we have a sk that can kill on even nights or maybe had just one shot.

 

So would scum right now hurry to get a lynch or would they sit back and see what happens? I need to re-read before I vote.

 

To mod and players: I´m going away tomorrow and will be gone until Tuesday. I will probably be able to use my phone but I´m not sure. So I might not post on Sunday and Monday.

[Niniel]

After re-reading the thread I´m not going to vote Arez or AH. I don´t think either of them are mafia. I feel really stupid but it was first now, when I read the thread again, that I realised that Rand must have viewed Song. Why would he state so clearly that he had changed his mind about her. I have no idea how a sk would look to a cop. Sometimes mods give town/not town results and sometimes mafia/not mafia. To sum it up - Arez and AH could be the sk but I don´t think they are mafia.

 

I agree with Ironeyes that it looks like there are two more mafia since the scene show someone else than Ursula and Queen of Hearts. Someone was protected and I guess it was me protecting AH but the way the scene is written I don´t recognize myself in it. But I don´t know much about this character. Hm...

 

So this leaves me with Basel, Peace and Ironeyes. I could put up cases on all of them but from the eager votes today I would like to say that the remaining mafia is Basel and Peace. I would rather vote Peace than Basel since he has pinged me more. Arez - are you willing to switch to Peace instead?

 

What I have on Peace:

- Iza avoided the Red/Song/Rand argument - voted Peace 1.0 instead

- she hammered Red after my reveal. It´s safe to vote a scum mate when you know they are going down.

- She got two votes early day 2 from Nolder and me. She "defended" herself but never told us who she thought was scummy.

- Peace took over and put all of his energy in lynching Song. He didn´t want to keep a "lurker". Strange when he knew that she had disappeared from another game he is in.

- He make this awful post in the night where he tells us that he won´t give us his thoughts until day because he often gets nk´d. Isn´t that a good way to show how townie he is.

- He then votes Nolder.

- And now he is after Song again.

 

Note - Peace is not a newbie. If I (finally) got that Rand viewed Song then he would have understood it too.

 

As I said I could bring up things about Basel and Ironeyes too but Peace looks scummiest to me.

 

Vote Peace.

[Razen]

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

Arez (2) - Peace, Basel

Basel (1) - Arez

Peace (1) - Tina

 

Not voting (2) - AH, Ironeyes

 

It is now Day 4. With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Your deadline is 7pm CDT (Minneapolis time) on Sunday, July 22nd.

Countdown timer: http://www.timeandda...til Day 4 Ends:

[Niniel]

I said before that I love being in a basic game without tons of spam and I mean it. But a little action would be fun...lol

[peacesells]

After re-reading the thread I´m not going to vote Arez or AH. I don´t think either of them are mafia. I feel really stupid but it was first now, when I read the thread again, that I realised that Rand must have viewed Song. Why would he state so clearly that he had changed his mind about her. I have no idea how a sk would look to a cop. Sometimes mods give town/not town results and sometimes mafia/not mafia. To sum it up - Arez and AH could be the sk but I don´t think they are mafia.

 

Sometimes mods give town results to mafia too if they are Godfathers. More on this later.

 

I agree with Ironeyes that it looks like there are two more mafia since the scene show someone else than Ursula and Queen of Hearts. Someone was protected and I guess it was me protecting AH but the way the scene is written I don´t recognize myself in it. But I don´t know much about this character. Hm...

 

So this leaves me with Basel, Peace and Ironeyes. I could put up cases on all of them but from the eager votes today I would like to say that the remaining mafia is Basel and Peace. I would rather vote Peace than Basel since he has pinged me more. Arez - are you willing to switch to Peace instead?

 

I don't know about Basel, but if I were scum...I'd sit back and let someone else lead a charge at this stage. The game is too important with this few players left.

 

What I have on Peace:

- Iza avoided the Red/Song/Rand argument - voted Peace 1.0 instead

- she hammered Red after my reveal. It´s safe to vote a scum mate when you know they are going down.

- She got two votes early day 2 from Nolder and me. She "defended" herself but never told us who she thought was scummy.

- Peace took over and put all of his energy in lynching Song. He didn´t want to keep a "lurker". Strange when he knew that she had disappeared from another game he is in.

 

Song disappeared after heat was applied with her. It may have nothing to do with the reason she never posted in the other games. She was posting here though. There there was a difference.

 

- He make this awful post in the night where he tells us that he won´t give us his thoughts until day because he often gets nk´d. Isn´t that a good way to show how townie he is.

 

I had just gotten night killed in the the Disney game and I'm pretty sure it came after some things I voiced at night. Many players get quiet at night.

 

- He then votes Nolder.

 

Several of us voted Nolder..that's how he got lynched. If you weren't vetted as the DOC I'd think you were just piling on as a scum player.

 

- And now he is after Song again.

 

Song and Arez is my best read. I can see that Rand may have viewed her but have you considered she may be the God Father? We can't go on viewings completely...especially assumed viewings. Arez is a prolific poster and note afraid to vote someone. Why did that not happen yesterday? Even when he stated he had thoughts on who was scum.

 

Note - Peace is not a newbie. If I (finally) got that Rand viewed Song then he would have understood it too.

 

I've been thinking AH was the cop this game. If you had got that Rand was the cop..why is he dead? Why didn't you protect him?

 

As I said I could bring up things about Basel and Ironeyes too but Peace looks scummiest to me.

 

You should bring up your Basel case. He may be the way to go today. I haven't considered him cause he and Red went hard at it and it looked like he contributed to her melt down. (Although, she just admitted the grievance thread that she sometimes fakes meltdowns. Not sure what to make of that.)

 

Vote Peace.

 

Responses in Blue.

[Ironeyes]

I'm thinking that since we've reached such a crucial phase in the game, it's time for a mass reveal. It may not work, but since our finder is dead and our doc is already outed, there's nothing left for the town to lose by doing it. What do the rest of you say?

[peacesells]

I'm thinking that since we've reached such a crucial phase in the game, it's time for a mass reveal. It may not work, but since our finder is dead and our doc is already outed, there's nothing left for the town to lose by doing it. What do the rest of you say?

 

We can do that..but I'm pretty sure that fake role claims were provided by the Mod. Red claimed Beast and no one countered that claim.

 

I'm Belle. Who are you?

[Basel Gill]

Oh, I'm replacing Song of Fire and Ice? Thought it was Songstress.

 

I don't like how the FIRST post each of you two made had a vote in it for me. Seems like scum rushing a lynch before anyone has a time to argue and think.

And also Basel, You're fence-sitting

 

"Yeah, Arez says valid things and such, but he didn't vote , so he's scum"

 

Now you're just showing signs of skimming my previous post. I explained my reasoning the first time around, but you obviosuly zipped right past it without paying attention, so I'll summarize it for you. You made valid points because you needed some good argument to cover up your lack of explanation as to why you never voted. It took two people voting you (halfway to a hammer) before you gave any defense for this. Most likely because you had no idea what to say, and needed to wait for your scum-partner to show up and give their suggestions. Generally, when I am posting suspicions of the two people I am getting the hardest pings from, I will vote one of those two.

[Niniel]

After re-reading the thread I´m not going to vote Arez or AH. I don´t think either of them are mafia. I feel really stupid but it was first now, when I read the thread again, that I realised that Rand must have viewed Song. Why would he state so clearly that he had changed his mind about her. I have no idea how a sk would look to a cop. Sometimes mods give town/not town results and sometimes mafia/not mafia. To sum it up - Arez and AH could be the sk but I don´t think they are mafia.

 

Sometimes mods give town results to mafia too if they are Godfathers. More on this later.

 

I agree with Ironeyes that it looks like there are two more mafia since the scene show someone else than Ursula and Queen of Hearts. Someone was protected and I guess it was me protecting AH but the way the scene is written I don´t recognize myself in it. But I don´t know much about this character. Hm...

 

So this leaves me with Basel, Peace and Ironeyes. I could put up cases on all of them but from the eager votes today I would like to say that the remaining mafia is Basel and Peace. I would rather vote Peace than Basel since he has pinged me more. Arez - are you willing to switch to Peace instead?

 

I don't know about Basel, but if I were scum...I'd sit back and let someone else lead a charge at this stage. The game is too important with this few players left.

 

 

What I have on Peace:

- Iza avoided the Red/Song/Rand argument - voted Peace 1.0 instead

- she hammered Red after my reveal. It´s safe to vote a scum mate when you know they are going down.

- She got two votes early day 2 from Nolder and me. She "defended" herself but never told us who she thought was scummy.

- Peace took over and put all of his energy in lynching Song. He didn´t want to keep a "lurker". Strange when he knew that she had disappeared from another game he is in.

 

Song disappeared after heat was applied with her. It may have nothing to do with the reason she never posted in the other games. She was posting here though. There there was a difference.

 

- He make this awful post in the night where he tells us that he won´t give us his thoughts until day because he often gets nk´d. Isn´t that a good way to show how townie he is.

 

I had just gotten night killed in the the Disney game and I'm pretty sure it came after some things I voiced at night. Many players get quiet at night.

 

- He then votes Nolder.

 

Several of us voted Nolder..that's how he got lynched. If you weren't vetted as the DOC I'd think you were just piling on as a scum player.

 

- And now he is after Song again.

 

Song and Arez is my best read. I can see that Rand may have viewed her but have you considered she may be the God Father? We can't go on viewings completely...especially assumed viewings. Arez is a prolific poster and note afraid to vote someone. Why did that not happen yesterday? Even when he stated he had thoughts on who was scum.

 

Note - Peace is not a newbie. If I (finally) got that Rand viewed Song then he would have understood it too.

 

I've been thinking AH was the cop this game. If you had got that Rand was the cop..why is he dead? Why didn't you protect him?

 

As I said I could bring up things about Basel and Ironeyes too but Peace looks scummiest to me.

 

You should bring up your Basel case. He may be the way to go today. I haven't considered him cause he and Red went hard at it and it looked like he contributed to her melt down. (Although, she just admitted the grievance thread that she sometimes fakes meltdowns. Not sure what to make of that.)

 

Vote Peace.

 

Responses in Blue.

 

Have taken a sleeping pill so it will be a short answer. Mafia can play it many ways. You say that they would sit back. I say they might throw themselves on one player and hope that others will follow. There is not only one way for scum to play.

 

Yes, Song/Arez might be GF but I really hope we don´t have both a sk and a gf in a basic game. But let me ask you - do you think there are 2 mafia left? Who do you think is the second?

 

You have been thinking AH is cop although Rand´s coroner says he is cop? Ehm? As I said I was just too stupid to realised it before I did my re-read, otherwise I would have protected him of course.

[Ironeyes]

I'm thinking that since we've reached such a crucial phase in the game, it's time for a mass reveal. It may not work, but since our finder is dead and our doc is already outed, there's nothing left for the town to lose by doing it. What do the rest of you say?

 

We can do that..but I'm pretty sure that fake role claims were provided by the Mod. Red claimed Beast and no one countered that claim.

 

I'm Belle. Who are you?

 

There's always the risk of that. I'm Cinderella.

[peacesells]

Tina..I had been thinking AH was cop before Rand flipped.

 

As for a second..its either Basel or Marsh.

[Arez Al'Loke]

I definatly have no objections to voting either Peace or Basel.

[peacesells]

I definatly have no objections to voting either Peace or Basel.

 

Lol..of course you dont scum.

[peacesells]

This game is coming to a stand still.

 

Let look at Arez even closer. His meta as town is zany. Always saying crazing things, no afraid to put himself out there. Since joining this game he hasn't done any of that. He's been too careful. Overly careful players are scum.

[Basel Gill]

This game is coming to a stand still.

 

Well, it is the weekend.

[peacesells]

meh..it's been dead before that.

[Razen]

Provided for your viewing pleasure, even though absolutely nothing has changed since the last I posted a vote count. I'm heading off to bed now - I've not been feeling well today.

 

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

Arez (2) - Peace, Basel

Basel (1) - Arez

Peace (1) - Tina

 

Not voting (2) - AH, Ironeyes

 

It is now Day 4. With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Your deadline is 7pm CDT (Minneapolis time) on Sunday, July 22nd.

Countdown timer: http://www.timeandda...til Day 4 Ends: