DPR Mafia - The Dark Monocle - Game Thread

[Niniel]

One of the reasons that I have been suspicious of Verbal the whole game is that I knew from the start that he and Leelou were on a team. Since I didn´t know my guild members I thought that everyone started out that way. I thought that people that started up together should be mafia. Unvote. Verbal might still be mafia but not on by the reasons I thought of. Verbal has anything happened to you recently? If so, could you tell me because it would prove that someone else has been right/wrong.

 

I did not find Verbal until N1, what do you mean you knew from the start?

 

 

Maybe I should rephrase that. I didn´t know, I suspected.

[mmeeshal]

@Aemon--do you mind if I share your plan/idea out here for everyone to weigh in on? I have thoughts concerning it myself, but I figured I'd ask, first.

[mmeeshal]

How do we go from here? Should we wait and see if everyone get in touch with their guilds tonight? Maybe everyone except Meesh belong to a guild.

Right, that's why I've proposed a no-lynch...first, we don't want to take the wrong step today...second, we can solve the mystery of if anyone is lying about their guild membership...third, we'll have more information based on who dies in the night.

[DPR]

A No-Lynch vote is fine if that is what you want to do.

[mmeeshal]

Sweet, thanks for letting us know, Wes!

[Niniel]

How do we go from here? Should we wait and see if everyone get in touch with their guilds tonight? Maybe everyone except Meesh belong to a guild.

Right, that's why I've proposed a no-lynch...first, we don't want to take the wrong step today...second, we can solve the mystery of if anyone is lying about their guild membership...third, we'll have more information based on who dies in the night.

 

At the same time we need to find the automations and if nothing stops it we will likely have a new one tomorrow.

[mmeeshal]

To those of you expressing worry over my recruitment... I dare the mafia to try it. If I was worried about it I wouldn't have revealed so easily--I would have tried to fly under the radar as much as possible. XD Because you're right, this would be a lot of power to hand to the mafia.

 

ALTHOUGH, if you think about it, if the mafia are in the QTs already, then they already know what everyone's saying.

 

Still...I'm not worried about it. They can just try to catch me. I haz mad ninja skills.

[Razen]

@ Meesh: I think we did have a mutual misunderstanding - no worries about how you sounded though. We all get frustrated sometimes because we approach the game from different angles.

 

I don't know if I agree with the no-lynch idea. I understand that we don't want to mislynch anyone today for fear of killing the wrong person but as Tina pointed out, I don't like the idea that we probably get stuck with another automaton.

 

I find it interesting that Ishy immediately took off on my QT suggestion that Meesh might be the arsonist. I brought that up before Meesh had revealed her role and I didn't know what other reasons there could have been for her to not have been in a guild. I asked what Ithi, Kae, and Aemon might have thought and was waiting for them to answer when Meesh revealed. And now Ishy takes off on that mindset like a speeding bullet - and when confronted about it, says that his role is exactly opposite of the arsonist.

 

Meesh said that someone tried to waste a shot on here since she had revealed. There's no point in hiding it-I was the one who tried to kill Meesh after she revealed because I didn't trust what she was saying. But after the failed result and her confidence about not being able to be converted, I'm beginning to believe her. Unvote.

[Niniel]

I hope people find their way back to this game once the weekend is over.

[LilyElizabeth]

Crusher is a glassmaker.

 

I like the no lynch idea. It will give us a chance to get the people organized into groups, and see if anyone lied about which group they belong to. (We should be so lucky...)

[Christine]

I concur with the No Lynch idea. In fact.

 

 

Vote: No Lynch

 

 

JLM, I am going to search you out tonight. One of y'all hit me, in case there is a bastard role blocker out there?

 

 

Sorry I have been inactive. Jon got home on Friday. We spent yesterday in bed. Today, we are doing stuffs, so I am off and on DM.

[mmeeshal]

I know, right?

 

Bwah, that nap was too long, and not long enough. I'm all cold and shaky. XD

 

Ithi, I'm sorry to hear about Max! I hope everything is all right and that he gets well soon!

 

 

 

Okay, so I'm gonna go ahead and share Aemon's plan/idea/thingy.

 

Aemon proposed that we test the theory of there being at least one original mafia in each guild. Obviously we all want to do that, but Aemon came up with a pretty good suggestion of how to go about doing that.

 

There is one guild that has been almost completely decimated. The Machinists have 4 dead and only 2 (claimed, not yet united) living. One of the dead was a recruit, but not an original mafia, so, as a perfect way to test our theory, we can clean up the Machinists. Sounds heartless, but effective at testing that theory, at least. If we lynch Tina or Player and she/he isn't mafia, I can shoot the other one tonight--eliminates the slightly randomness my kill can have, since I don't always really know who's a good target, and helps us determine if there's any merit to the idea that every guild has a scummy in it.

 

So...what do you think?

 

If we take this route, I'd personally suggest lynching Player today, first, because I have reason to believe Tina is town, or at least not original mafia.

[mmeeshal]

I hope people find their way back to this game once the weekend is over.

Lol ninja'd...I got company when I started typing my PM. My original comment was in response to this quote.

[mmeeshal]

Oh, and as far as Hoof goes, I suspect he was a Chemist. The chemists were told they had found and united all of their members the same night I sent in the kill on Hoof, a couple of hours afterward.

[Razen]

If we go with Meesh's idea about lynching the Machinists, our team can actually help you guys out there. We lie detected Tina on Night 2. The exact post that we LD'd was this one: (bolding added-I copied the statement from our QT)

 

TinaHel, on 05 March 2012 - 09:28 AM, said:

 

I don't know if Basil is town or not but I do know how irritating it is when you get vote after vote and when you try to defend yourself and go after someone else and all you get is more votes because of "over reaction". I see people that are trying to blend in by being sheep on his train.

 

My internet isn't working. I have to use my phone and rely on people keeping their networks open. It will take at least two days before it works again. I hope I can get on but can't be sure. I might be able to do a re-read on my work later today. Holding my vote until then.

 

 

We were told that since Tina would have known whether Basel was town or not if she was Mafia, that she was town at that point. Therefore, she would have had to have been converted after that point to become an automaton and she cannot be an original mafia. So if we do take the lynch the machinists road, I would agree with going after Piano first. That doesn't mean that Tina should get a free pass, but if we are looking for original mafia, every piece of information helps.

[Leelou]

I agree with the informational lynch and believe that Player is a good place to start.

 

unvote, vote Player

[mmeeshal]

unvote

vote Player

[hotpocket2006]

I can dig it. VOTE PLAYER

[LilyElizabeth]

My vote is already on Player, so I just won't switch it.

[Razen]

The informational lynch is good with me. Vote Player.

[WWWwombat]

I don't like all this making lists of who is in what guild and fishing for my guild. Meesh knows who is in the guilds. Let's leave it at that. I think it only serves the scum to publicly out guild alliances since the guilds function as neighbor groups rather than mason groups.

[Christine]

I do not see DPR repeating something he has done in the past.

[Christine]

Also, just to remind. in the Vampire one, there was one group that started as Vamps, and someone else that could become a Werewolf. Then there was the Weres recruiting. I think Vamps could recruit too?

 

What group has not lost anyone? THAT would be the place to start.

[Leelou]

All of the guilds have lost someone.

 

And in the Vamps game all the Vamps started in one guild. I think there could be recruits on both sides - don't 100% remember about recruits. Why do you keep bringing back up the vampire game? Wes has run many different types of games over the years here.

[Christine]

BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT YA'LL KEEP BRINGING UP.

 

 

Lynch the Same team as Nolder? Seems silly.