Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

[WWWwombat]

Official Final Day 2 Vote Count:

 

Christine(14): 鲍勃不是我的名字, Sakaea, trench, aemonkristen, Crusher, Keyholder, Ape, Meesh, Nolder, Verbal, Leelou, PatsFanTX, Razen, bgrishinko

Ape(3): amegakure, Thorum, Paperblade

Razen(1): Amadine

 

With 27 voting players, it takes 14 to lynch.

[Christine]

No Paper, we learned that I can't die, and that numerous people do not know their fellow faction members.

 

We also learned that there is a number of people in this game that seem to think those that don't know their team mates should die.

 

I believe that we should probably start with Nolder... if he lives through the Night.

[mmeeshal]

Actually, you do lose the day phase.

 

Vote Wombat

 

Making up rules on the fly.

 

Your last vote count didn't say official... or do we need one more vote on her because she's a +1 vote to lynch power?

Well, Player did add a +1 to Christine's train. So your theory was clearly incorrect.

[John E. Kelley]

Sooo....it's Night now?

[Razen]

Sooo....it's Night now?

 

I'm guessing so. We lost our day phase, but no official scene or anything yet, so it's not for sure.

[mmeeshal]

Wombat's probably writing up a scene or something....

[mmeeshal]

Dangflabbit, I have been ninja'd so many times in the past hour.

[WWWwombat]

Someone accused Christine of being a traitor and without any independent thought, the mob gathered around her. She told you your efforts were pointless, but you didn't listen and tried to kill her anyways. And you payed for it. Right as the crowd was collapsing on Christine, something crashed into all of you. When you regained your feet and looked around, Christine was gone.

 

Christine has not been lynched.

 

It is currently Night 2. Night actions are due Wednesday, February 22 at noon EST

[Sakaea]

The BT has disappeared. This is not ok.

[Christine]

The BT has disappeared!

 

 

I wonder if it will reveal my house/character....

[WWWwombat]

Member name Posts

WWWwombat 75

John McClane 63

PatsFanTX 62

Christine 61

Nolder 48

The Crusher 39

鲍勃不是我的名字 29

amegakure 24

keyholder21 21

Leelou 20

Sakaea 19

Thorum 19

aemonkristen 18

Razen 17

Red2111 17

Pac 16

TinaHel 15

Verbal32 14

mmeeshal 14

Ishmael Forsaken 13

bgrishinko 13

Amadine 13

Song of Ice and Fire 12

dapianoplay3r 12

trench 12

Perfexionist 11

Graendals favourite 9

Paperblade 9

Pale Merlot 8

cosmicpanda 8

Vicious89x 6

Mr. Soy Boyo 5

Smash 5

Songstress 4

mcs0083 3

Levity 1

[dapianoplay3r]

No Paper, we learned that I can't die, and that numerous people do not know their fellow faction members.We also learned that there is a number of people in this game that seem to think those that don't know their team mates should die.I believe that we should probably start with Nolder... if he lives through the Night.

 

I just want to comment on this. I think labeling this with something like numerous is dangerous. I accept that there are people like that, but there could be only a few just as likely as there could be many

[Perfexionist]

Sigh at losing day.

[amegakure]

Blah im not going to try with u apeboy.. ur a bully and u can GFY

[John McClane]

Actually, you do lose the day phase.

 

Vote Wombat

 

Making up rules on the fly.

 

Your last vote count didn't say official... or do we need one more vote on her because she's a +1 vote to lynch power?

Well, Player did add a +1 to Christine's train. So your theory was clearly incorrect.

 

 

Good point. So that's something we don't have to worry about either.

[John McClane]

Blah im not going to try with u apeboy.. ur a bully and u can GFY

 

 

Don't try to play the "self pity" card. You already tried to come at me and you failed, BECAUSE your case was based on putting words in people's mouths and lying. I'm not bullying you, or anyone else. I'm setting the record straight, as you try to keep it askew.

 

Now you are recoiling, and hoping people ignore the fact that you were making shit up if you pout enough.

[Paperblade]

No Paper, we learned that I can't die, and that numerous people do not know their fellow faction members.

 

We also learned that there is a number of people in this game that seem to think those that don't know their team mates should die.

 

I believe that we should probably start with Nolder... if he lives through the Night.

Just because you can't be lynched doesn't mean you can't be nightkilled.

 

Numerous people claim they do not know their fellow faction members.

[amegakure]

wow guy you think this is the only game ive seen you in.. your get all egotistical to just about anyone who dosent agree with you. You havent proved squat except that you good at kicking up alot of dust to hid you own faults and a pro and pointing out others. Self pity i laugh...im not pointing out that your a bully or pouting cause i want special attention..just that im done arguing. you get angry if someone dosent agree with you...i hate those kind of people

[Christine]

No, I cannot be killed. I clarified that with Wombat. If I had been killed during the night before I claimed Tree Stump, then my bullet proof vest would have saved me, and I would have then become the Tree Stump. Either way, I make it through this game to the end. Guess you guys are stuck with me!

[amegakure]

This is the record btw:

 

 

Christine did her little reveal:

Christine said she was in a faction but didnt know who she was with. (is it impossible shes by herself)

Ape boy votes christine

I vote ape boy

Ape boy quickly defends.

Ape boy decides she dosent have any teamates

I noticed that apeboy has made contridictory post.

Apeboy gets mad....lashes out..calls people names

ape gets defensive and says the whole point is about converting and getting a kill

ape boy then says im twisting his words and christines.. (not true) merely made an assumtion that she didnt have any...

ape boy then says that the point now is that im twisting words.. i got one thing messed up..

end result.. Ape was still wrong about christine.. a lynch that he sooo pushed for.

[John McClane]

wow guy you think this is the only game ive seen you in.. your get all egotistical to just about anyone who dosent agree with you. You havent proved squat except that you good at kicking up alot of dust to hid you own faults and a pro and pointing out others. Self pity i laugh...im not pointing out that your a bully or pouting cause i want special attention..just that im done arguing. you get angry if someone dosent agree with you...i hate those kind of people

 

This conversation hasn't been about you and I agreeing. What are you talking about? You made a case on me, based it on putting words in my mouth and you were lying about what Christine had said - so I stuck up for myself, and pointed out where you were spinning and lying. End of story.

 

If you were done arguing then you'd shut up already. Now you are just taking personal shots at my personality and indirectly insinuating you hate me. All I've done is play mafia... and I'm not angry guy. You are the one insinuating you hate me now, because I pointed out the holes in your case in a game.

 

Oh, and I've definitely "proved squat".

 

I proved that you don't know the difference between having NO teammates and having teammates and not knowing who they are.

 

I proved that Christine said she has team mates. Even though YOU said she said she doesn't. A lie.

 

I proved that the case you built on me, was based on that lie.

[amegakure]

not lies an assumption...

 

can you prove she has team mates....can she confirm that she has team mates.

 

i know the difference guy.. i just made an assumption

 

the rest your quite right...as of now theres not much to like

[amegakure]

u keep saying i put words in your mouth...in everything else you might me right. But i never made up what you said. I mearly assummed that she didnt have any team mates. which isnt to far off of what you said.

[John McClane]

This is the record btw:

 

 

Christine did her little reveal:

Christine said she was in a faction but didnt know who she was with. (is it impossible shes by herself)

Ape boy votes christine

I vote ape boy

Ape boy quickly defends.

Ape boy decides she dosent have any teamates

I noticed that apeboy has made contridictory post.

Apeboy gets mad....lashes out..calls people names

ape gets defensive and says the whole point is about converting and getting a kill

ape boy then says im twisting his words and christines.. (not true) merely made an assumtion that she didnt have any...

ape boy then says that the point now is that im twisting words.. i got one thing messed up..

end result.. Ape was still wrong about christine.. a lynch that he sooo pushed for.

 

I thought you were done? Who is contradicting themselves now?

 

Good recap. Obviously skewed by the fact you are trying to manipulate people into seeing something that isn't there, but whatever... why should the details matter. You left out the part where you lied about Christine saying she had no team mates. Kind of an important part of the timeline... given the fact that the so-called contradiction you are accusing me of only exists in your point of view when you leave out that wrinkle.

 

What is your friggin point already? I voted her because she begged for another day, and said she had a team - and I said I felt she might be trying to eek out another conversion or kill, and wasn't acting like someone with teammates, despite whatever she said.

 

Then you lied and said she said she had no team, and used this lie to manufacture this contradiction story (I've already proven that this NEVER HAPPENED, and Christine has vouched for it multiple times. She never said she had no team. You are the ONLY PERSON who feels that "no team" and "I have a team, but don't know who they are" is the same thing. Which is ridiculous.)

 

So, because I didn't contradict myself as you've tried to prove - I'd like you to explain what your point is. As of right now, you haven't got one. I think you are arguing for the sake of arguing now.

 

Also, I wasn't wrong for wanting to vet Christine's reveal now, rather than later. Its the right play. Don't want an unvetted, unkillable claim in endgame where you can't do much about it. Its a common sense play to vet her now.

[John McClane]

u keep saying i put words in your mouth...in everything else you might me right. But i never made up what you said. I mearly assummed that she didnt have any team mates. which isnt to far off of what you said.

 

No, you made up what Christine said. The used that to change the meaning of my statement and call it a contradiction.