Kae's [BASIC] X-Men Mafia GAME OVER! TOWN WINS!!!

[Nolder]

I'm about to go to sleep so I barely skimmed the new posts, will reply to them more thoroughly in the morning

 

I just wanted to say that I wasn't making fun of Red

not really sure what gave you that idea

[Blackhoof]

well, the way you phrased that last bit was more extreme than your past badgering of red, and you never called for her lynch before. i thought you might be using sarcasm, but you just basically said you werent, so now i am confused.....

[Amadine]

Mynd's uncharacteristic behaviour here only confirms the vote i have already placed on him.

[Myndrunner]

Mynd's uncharacteristic behaviour here only confirms the vote i have already placed on him.

 

Im sorry, but what exactly is "uncaracteristic" of my "behaviour"? Mind you I have uncontestedly all but revealed my character, who would be an X-men town character in this game....yet you feel confirmed in your vote.

[Blackhoof]

do not assume that just becaue you have revealed that we will believe you unconditionally.

[Amadine]

Your hints mean nothing to me Mynd - i am not interested in X-men at all and i wasn't able to work out who you were from the wiki *shrugs*

[Myndrunner]

Your hints mean nothing to me Mynd - i am not interested in X-men at all and i wasn't able to work out who you were from the wiki *shrugs*

 

Have you heard of a game called Mafia? You should try playing it. I cannot believe you are too lazy to take the time to get even a brief understanding of the theme of the game you signed up for.

 

Rogue is one of the X-men, played in the films by Anna Paquin, aka. Sookie Stackhouse or the little girl in the Piano, take your pick. If you feel an uncontested X-men like myself would be worthy of the D1 lynch, then by all means proceed....but I ask you to please make sure you are the hammer.

[Amadine]

Thank you for pointing that out to me Mynd. I so appreciate the time it took you to instruct me in the finer points of mafia

 

what part of

 

and i wasn't able to work out who you were from the wiki

did you not understand?

Does that not tell you that i have been reading up on the game? Take your holier than thou attitude and go beat the grass somewhere else.

[Myndrunner]

Thank you for pointing that out to me Mynd. I so appreciate the time it took you to instruct me in the finer points of mafia

 

what part of

 

and i wasn't able to work out who you were from the wiki

did you not understand?

Does that not tell you that i have been reading up on the game? Take your holier than thou attitude and go beat the grass somewhere else.

I assumed that was a joke or a lie since Rogue is a primary X-men character.

[Amadine]

So? I didn't catch your hinting, and since when does hinting confirm you are telling the truth anyway?

[Myndrunner]

So? I didn't catch your hinting, and since when does hinting confirm you are telling the truth anyway?

 

When nobody counters.

[Levity]

This is rather interesting...

 

I'm still feeling Mynd as town after all of this, but since I've been easily convinced in the past I'm still going to be a little wary of everyone arguing vehemently right now (except for Ama, as I'm not getting any particular scum or town reads on her at the moment, just Wiki frustration)

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT (probably the only one you'll get today)

 

Red (1) -- Nolder

 

BG (5) -- Turin, Song, Basel, Mynd, Hoof

 

Mynd (2) -- Ama, Red

 

Hoof (1) -- Aemon

 

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Not Voting: Ishy, BG, Amega

 

That is L-2

[Nolder]

what is with DM people and replying in someone else's quotes?

 

but Hoofs vote was opportunistic and screams of rushing to get the day over with and securing a lynch on a very good player

what does it matter if he is good? he is either an asset or a threat, and if he is acting scummy, the chances of him actually beign a threat increase.

if you are mafia and you know BG isn't on your team you know he is a threat

 

I will be watching closely to see who votes BG after Hoof

 

I'm not going to change my vote as of yet because even if Hoof is her partner I believe Red is the more dangerous player here and it'd be much better if we got rid of her early as she's generally more capable of smooth talking her way out of a lynch than Hoof

I'm also giving Hoof the day to get his act together just in case this is one of those moments where he's incredibly scummy even though he's actually town

so your argument to defend BG is "no no hes a good player" and your argument agaisnt red is "yes, kill her, she is a good player!"....

 

seems like you are either distancing from an ally or trying to get a townie lynched.... either one is bad.

no my argument to defend BG, as you put it, is that his actions aren't necessarily scummy

however it's since been pointed out that it was his words that were scummy not the PM

I can agree with that I suppose although I don't find it condemning yet

and as I said I prefer Red over anyone, yourself included

I prefer her because she's capable of quick talking herself out of a lynch

the fact that I prefer her has nothing to do with why I want to lynch her in the first place as anyone who bothered to read my case on her would know

 

way to boil things down to make them look like something they're not Hoof

 

 

...

who is the third player?

the three players involved in that scenario were Mynd, Red, and BG

 

although there should be no future for Red because we should lynch her today

let's get off BG and do that ok guys? ok cool

you seem to be sarcastic..... but you might be serious..... very strange and scummy behavious, nolder.

sarcastic? no not at all

I was serious although I was also trying to be slightly humorous so perhaps that came across

regardless I don't see what's scummy about it

you seem fond of dropping the S word without really explaining yourself

THAT is scummy

[Nolder]

well, the way you phrased that last bit was more extreme than your past badgering of red, and you never called for her lynch before. i thought you might be using sarcasm, but you just basically said you werent, so now i am confused.....

I was replying to Amega there

but yeah uhhh I'm not trying to badger Red

I'm just trying to get YOU PEOPLE to lynch her because I believe she needs lynching

[Nolder]

So? I didn't catch your hinting, and since when does hinting confirm you are telling the truth anyway?

 

When nobody counters.

to be fair there are tons of XMen

we don't really know that the town players will be "good guys" from the movies yet do we?

just because you are uncountered doesn't necessarily make you town

[Basel Gill]

although there should be no future for Red because we should lynch her today

let's get off BG and do that ok guys? ok cool

 

Except that BG is scum for reasons which have been well-explained already, so I don't feel like bothering with an explanation which would be redundant (lest someone accuse me of dropping the S-word without an explanation), and we alreayd have a good train going for him. If we break down the BG train with just two votes to go. we'd have to take the time to build a whole new one for Red, and then get the BG train going all over again after Day 2 starts. I'd sooner lynch BG now, and worry about Red later.

[Basel Gill]

*alreayd = already

[Levity]

bleh, my laptop's out of commission at the moment. Posting from my phone.

 

I'm getting a feeling Nolder is town, too. It's rare that scum ever tunnels /this/ hard unless you're a few players I've seen...

I know this is something Nolder regularly does, but I'm getting town feeling from his behavior regardless. I could be horribly wrong.

[Nolder]

that's nice for a change

 

most people are convinced I'm scum by page 2 in almost every game I play

[amegakure]

@ basel so I've seen some of the cases on BG. Did you have any opinions of your own, you seem very eager for this lynch.

[Levity]

Well, you just seem to be acting particularly townish this game from what I've seen. Again, I could be wrong.

[John E. Kelley]

Nol IS acting townish this game. Ergo, he's scum.

[Nolder]

:sad:

[Nolder]

in all seriousness I'm not scum this game

most games I haven't got a clue why people seem to think I am although I do sometimes make some pretty big slip ups when I'm townie

I remember I was extremely frustrated in Lily's game (the one before Mall Madness 2) but that mostly my own fault