[ADVANCED/KITCHEN SINK] The Axe or the Hammer - GAME OVER

[SBoydW]

Isn't this only Corrosive's second game or so? Just saying, maybe he/she is still learning. If not, lemme know, we can pressure him/her if need be.

 

Yeah his first game was Amega's Naruto game... so this is his second...

[mmeeshal]

1) Corrosive is a guy

2) Amega's Naruto game was his first game online, though I am pretty sure he said he'd played mafia in person before, which is fun and gives you the general idea, but is still vastly different.

3) He's Hoof's friend, purty sure.

4) Alakazam.

5) No, but really, I dunno. This is probably either his second game online, like Ishy thinks, or one of his first 5.

 

But I dunno if we can really afford to give someone a full pass for noobness.

[mmeeshal]

6) Ninjer'd. H8.

[Turin Turambar]

ok. I never played in person. How do the mafia talk if everyone is in a room I suppose.

[SBoydW]

ok. I never played in person. How do the mafia talk if everyone is in a room I suppose.

 

A lot of head nodding and glancing...

[mmeeshal]

ok. I never played in person. How do the mafia talk if everyone is in a room I suppose.

 

A lot of head nodding and glancing...

This. Everyone closes their eyes and in some cases (like the Darkfriend Hunts at D*Con) everyone starts the rhythmic patting of their thighs to create some noise.... And then the mod gets one NA at a time, basically. "Mafia, open your eyes. Who do you want to kill?" etc.... They all nod heads or shake them, look meaningfully, and keep doing so until they agree on someone and the mod points at them too....

 

It's fun.

[Turin Turambar]

interesting. sounds like it would be fun. being able to look each other in the eye makes a difference I bet too.

[Sakaea]

Never done mafia in person, but it sounds hella fun.

 

Just because Corrosive is a n00b doesn't really give him a pass, IMHO. If this was his first game, he'd get a D1 pass from me. After your first game, you're fair game. That's how I've played it in the past, and I think it's fair. Does anyone disagree?

[John E. Kelley]

Nope, I agree completely. I may need more scummy behavior than just one action to hammer or something drastic, but merely casting a FoS or a pressure vote is totally justified after your first game. Lemme reread his posts real quick, I don't see any problem pressuring him.

[SBoydW]

Never done mafia in person, but it sounds hella fun.

 

Just because Corrosive is a n00b doesn't really give him a pass, IMHO. If this was his first game, he'd get a D1 pass from me. After your first game, you're fair game. That's how I've played it in the past, and I think it's fair. Does anyone disagree?

 

Yeah definitely no newb passes in an advanced game.

[SBoydW]

To be honest I think he skated through the Naruto game because he was new... I don't think he's ever been under any pressure and has been fairly quiet... Let's see how he reacts to some pressure....

 

Corrosive

[Turin Turambar]

I looked up his posts. there were 8. to paraphrase:

 

1. hello, vote Levity

2. welcome Turin. (thanks btw)

3. FoS at Nolder.

4. "fair enough. still suspicious" to Nolder

5. Unvote vote Ledinna.

6. not much mostly that he was keeping up but had nothing to add.

7. " *8 pages" (I guess this was how much he needed to read.)

8. votes Kae.

 

I'm okay seeing where this goes.

 

VOTE Corrosive

[bgrishinko]

Couldn't you have just quoted him using the multiquote?

 

I'd feel better about trusting your analysis then.

[Turin Turambar]

I can't use it properly on this machine. If you wish to check. do the advance search. Click on the gear at the top right. Select corrosive as author, select DM mafia games. select view as posts. hit search. they will all pop up most recent to least.

[Sakaea]

I'm off to bed, but before I do, I'll Vote Corrosive for reasons already stated.

 

So what say you, Corrosive?

[mmeeshal]

Hope I'm not ninja'd while doing this...

 

**edit to make sure they're in chronological order**

 

Checking in and and and Vote: Levity just because

 

 

Welcome Turin, enjoy the game :)

 

Sorry guys, I haven't felt my input was needed so far. I feel I need to at least contribute a post though to let everyone know I'm not dead. I would just like to say though, with Nodlers' last post, he seems rushed to get the argument over, either he wants D1 over so that he can get to the NK someone stage, or I'm just interpreting his post wrong. It seems slightly scummy? FoS at Nodler...

 

 

I see your point Nodler, but still, it seems suspicious :|

 

 

Challenging observations there Maw... It made me re-analyze my vote, Ledinna's vote was sus, but when questioned she doesn't respond, that just settles it for me! I don't need any more evidence on this one, it's a no-brainer. UNVOTE... VOTE: Ledinna

 

 

I do not have any valuable input as of yet, just letting you know I'm still here. I am up to date on the posts (I was about 4 pages behind) and I must say, about time Ledinna decided to post ;)

 

 

8 pages***

 

 

 

I'd like to hear from Verb, Corrosive, and Panda, too. What do you guys think?

Mmkay, you're hearing from me :) Vote: Kae

[Turin Turambar]

Thanks Mmmmmmeesh.

[mmeeshal]

No problem, Turin! Seems like your summary was pretty spot-on.

[John E. Kelley]

Hope I'm not ninja'd while doing this...

 

**edit to make sure they're in chronological order**

 

Checking in and and and Vote: Levity just because

 

 

Welcome Turin, enjoy the game :)

 

Sorry guys, I haven't felt my input was needed so far. I feel I need to at least contribute a post though to let everyone know I'm not dead. I would just like to say though, with Nodlers' last post, he seems rushed to get the argument over, either he wants D1 over so that he can get to the NK someone stage, or I'm just interpreting his post wrong. It seems slightly scummy? FoS at Nodler...

 

 

I see your point Nodler, but still, it seems suspicious :|

 

 

Challenging observations there Maw... It made me re-analyze my vote, Ledinna's vote was sus, but when questioned she doesn't respond, that just settles it for me! I don't need any more evidence on this one, it's a no-brainer. UNVOTE... VOTE: Ledinna

 

 

I do not have any valuable input as of yet, just letting you know I'm still here. I am up to date on the posts (I was about 4 pages behind) and I must say, about time Ledinna decided to post ;)

 

 

8 pages***

 

 

 

I'd like to hear from Verb, Corrosive, and Panda, too. What do you guys think?

Mmkay, you're hearing from me :) Vote: Kae

 

Vote Corrosive.

 

I was right in the middle of my reread of his posts when this showed up, I should have just waited on you Meesh, thanks.

 

To be completely honest, the vote on Kae really looks like the only scummy post, but he can feel a little pressure. What say you CS?

[Spirit1025]

Well, I don't know. I'm still not trusting BG too much, I'm with meesh on that one. Corrosive has been awfully quiet, and that's often a suspicious thing...but then again, I'm pretty quiet too, and for me it's just my nature, so I think I'd want more to go on than lack of speaking up. I would like to hear him defend himself though. For now, I'm going to put my vote back on BG. Vote:BG

[Niniel]

You are voting BG now? Hm...

[Turin Turambar]

At least you are consistent spirit. Care to share your thoughts for hanging tough on BG?

[SBoydW]

Well, I don't know. I'm still not trusting BG too much, I'm with meesh on that one. Corrosive has been awfully quiet, and that's often a suspicious thing...but then again, I'm pretty quiet too, and for me it's just my nature, so I think I'd want more to go on than lack of speaking up. I would like to hear him defend himself though. For now, I'm going to put my vote back on BG. Vote:BG

 

While I'm anything but trusting of BG, I think there have been enough indirect evidence to warrant caution in lynching BG. That also seems to be the consensus of most everyone else so it seems a bit.... off that after everyone unvotes him... then you vote him.

[Amadine]

Vote Count

Meesh (3) - Ed, Red, Ishy

Turin (1) - Womby

Ed (1) - Tina

Kae (4) - BG, Key, Loki, Corrosive

Corrosive (2) - Soy, Turin, Kae

BG (1) - Spirit

Not Voting: Nolder, Verb, Pandy, Des, Ledinna 2.0, Levity, Maw, Nyn, Meesh

22 players = 12 to lynch

[Amadine]

Dapianoplay3r will be replacing Pandy.... welcome to the game Player!