[Advanced] Hollywood 1940s Mafia - Game Over

[Christine]

Or... Wombat is trying to kill some of us. My mind = blown.

 

 

Wombat, what's up?

[keyholder21]

I'm equally confused, though it did make me giggle a lot.

[Krakalakachkn]

I am going to UNVOTE

After reading through this thread a couple of times, the one who is pinging me as being the scummiest so far is Jack_D

When someone tries to steer a topic of discussion away from one player onto someone else, that leads me to believe that a mafia scum is trying to help protect one of his team mates. I could be wrong about that, and I reserve the right to change my mind before this lynch is complete.

But right now, I VOTE Jack_D

 

 

Oh Vambram, you were so close to making that sound convincing.

[keyholder21]

Maybe he confused it with another game?

[Krakalakachkn]

Vote Jack

 

 

D'oh!

[Krakalakachkn]

I must be taking stupid pills or something.

 

Unvote

Vote Vambram

[Krakalakachkn]

I'm going to cry.

 

Unvote

Vote Vambram

[Amadine]

So why the vote on me Womby?

 

So far Hybrid, Red and Jack are pinging my scumdar - for Red and Jack that is normal, and Hybrid i haven't played enough games with to be be sure my scumdar is accurate.

[WWWwombat]

So why the vote on me Womby?

 

So far Hybrid, Red and Jack are pinging my scumdar - for Red and Jack that is normal, and Hybrid i haven't played enough games with to be be sure my scumdar is accurate.

 

 

Sorry.

 

unvote

 

Vote: Christine

[amegakure]

yes this is totally a PR.

[Red2111]

If you flip innocent, how in the world does it clear Lia or Alanna of being mafia?

 

by the same logic your using by climaing if i flip scum then that means Lia & Alanna are scum.

 

 

yes this is totally a PR.

 

a PR on the first day though?? generally those are handed out as a NA. so either Womby is faking it or it's part of his character/role imo

[WWWwombat]

If you flip innocent, how in the world does it clear Lia or Alanna of being mafia?

 

by the same logic your using by climaing if i flip scum then that means Lia & Alanna are scum.

 

 

 

 

No.

[Red2111]

how is it not the same when its using the same logic Womby?

 

 

if one person implicates another, then by logic the same person should clear said person depending on the alignment.

[WWWwombat]

That's not the same logic. Mafia know other players' alignments. Innocents do not. Teamwork can implicate but it cannot vindicate.

[Red2111]

exactly. but what hybrid is saying is that if i'm scum then so are Alanna & Lia. how is this not the same as saying if i'm innocent then so are Alanna & Lia.

 

 

to simplify it, Hybrid is suggeting the Black = White, but refuses to acknowledge that by saying this, he's also implying that White = Black. which just isn't true. thats all i'm getting at, and that all i'm trying to prove by making such a fuss out of this. and why i say linking players like this only helps the scum and does nothing for the town.

[Red2111]

and also that i don't want my town alignement to be used to help clear another player, which is what will happen on a subtle level if Hybrid is able to convince people opf what he's assuming.

[Hybrid]

If you flip innocent, how in the world does it clear Lia or Alanna of being mafia?

 

by the same logic your using by climaing if i flip scum then that means Lia & Alanna are scum.

 

No, it's not the same.

 

P.S. I like how you managed to evade my question, misrepresent my words, and throw in a little WIFOM to boot, all in the same post.

[Red2111]

and what question is that Hybrid? all i've seen you do is try to clear two peopel with my town alignement when i flip.

 

and it's not WIFOM. if your saying White = Black, then the reverse of Black = White is equally true. it's simply logic.

[Hybrid]

but what hybrid is saying is that if i'm scum then so are Alanna & Lia.

Misrepresenting my words.

 

and also that i don't want my town alignement to be used to help clear another player, which is what will happen on a subtle level if Hybrid is able to convince people opf what he's assuming.

And bashing us on the head with "I'm innocent"

[WWWwombat]

A logical statement does not imply its converse, Red.

[Christine]

Wow, Krak, struggling with those codings, huh? Still no idea what's up with Wombat, but ok.

[Hybrid]

and what question is that Hybrid?

 

I can make it easy for you. In my last four posts, I've only posted one question. Here's an even bigger hint: in one of my posts, it was the only thing I posted.

 

all i've seen you do is try to clear two peopel with my town alignement when i flip.

 

Actually, I think I've been crystal clear in saying that if you flip town, it doesn't in any way clear Alanna or Lia of being scum. I can quote this if anyone not named Red is interested.

[Krakalakachkn]

Hey Wombat, why the vote?

[Red2111]

but what hybrid is saying is that if i'm scum then so are Alanna & Lia.

Misrepresenting my words.

 

no i'm not,. only pointing out the revese implication for when i flip innocent.

 

and also that i don't want my town alignement to be used to help clear another player, which is what will happen on a subtle level if Hybrid is able to convince people opf what he's assuming.

And bashing us on the head with "I'm innocent"

 

and i'll continue to state it because it's the truth

 

 

 

A logical statement does not imply its converse, Red.

 

yes it does. if you say Black = White, then you're also implying White = Black. which i'm saying Hybrid is doing.

 

 

and what question is that Hybrid?

 

I can make it easy for you. In my last four posts, I've only posted one question. Here's an even bigger hint: in one of my posts, it was the only thing I posted.

 

i'm at work. i'm not going to dig through 10 pages to hunt down a quote. just ask the question again since you claim i've not answered it.

 

all i've seen you do is try to clear two peopel with my town alignement when i flip.

 

Actually, I think I've been crystal clear in saying that if you flip town, it doesn't in any way clear Alanna or Lia of being scum. I can quote this if anyone not named Red is interested.

 

yet the revese implications of what your claiming is still there. you're denying this implication exists and i'm calling you out on it. since i know i'll flip innocent because i know what my alignment is, i'm not goign to stand by and let you link me with players so it could clear them in any way shape or form.

besides, you have yet to explain exaclty how my alignment woudl implicate Alanna or Lia. especially when Lia hasn't posted much at all. i can see Alanna, as we were arguing the same thing concerning the inactives/lurkers, but so were alot of other people too.

[Alanna]

yes this is totally a PR.

 

Or it's just funny.