[Advanced] Hollywood 1940s Mafia - Game Over

[Amadine]

Random kills suck. It's bad enough at the beginning of a game let alone on Day 4

[Nolder]

IMO random kill is better latter in the game rather than earlier

 

though I'll admit it's still not optimal

[Amadine]

I mean that the activity and spam level on day 4 should have settled down enough that a random doesn't happen.

[Amadine]

No posts in 3.5 hours :/ Hopefully it will be day when i can check back in tomorrow.

[Leelou]

Day dawns on the 5th day. Prodution is far behind and you wake with a vigor to take on the day and find the guilty parties. When everyone is awake, you notice that Jack is being served on a platter.

 

Jack, an Extra (vanilla townie), is dead. It is day with 9 alive it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline is Thursday 11 AM EST.

[Hybrid]

I'm getting a town vibe from the following players, for one reason or another, so I'm not really willing to vote for them without a solid case.

 

1. Amadine -- in her case, I'm not willing to vote for her at all

4. amegakure

5. Sakaea

13. dapianoplay3r

 

That leaves:

 

2. keyholder21

3. Krakalakachkn

12. Lessa - Nolder

16. Ishmael Forsaken

 

If my assumptions are correct, two of these are scum -- though I don't see a key/Nolder team. So the possibilities that I'm considering are key/Krak, key/Ishmael, Krak/Nolder, Krak/Ishmael, Nolder/Ishmael.

 

I plan to reread later today to check on that. In the meantime, I'm back to vote Nolder for previous reasons. Sorry, but I don't have a good enough case on anyone else and we need some voting today.

 

Let's get some activity going.

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Nol (1): Hybrid

 

Not voting: Ama, key, Krak, ameg, Sakaea, Nol, player, Ishy

 

With 9 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline is Thursday at 11 AM EST

[Sakaea]

I am going to VOTE HYBRID because I have been suspicious of him for a while now, and I was going to vote for him last day phase, but missed the DL.

 

Also, Hybrid, this is an advanced game. The symp and one mafia are dead. I would think there are three more mafia left. I might be wrong, tho. Also, I'd like to know why you are getting a town vibe off of Player. He's been pretty inactive...

[Hybrid]

That's definitely a possibility since there aren't any other evil factions.

 

I get a town vibe off of player because he put killuliu at 3 votes. Both kill and I were at 2 votes, so he could easily have gone for me.

 

Also, why are you suspicious of me? Unless I'm mistaken, I've done one pretty pro-town thing as far as you're concerned.

[Sakaea]

As far as I'm concerned, yes. But how hard you were pushing for me, and how easily you backed off actually pinged me. I was expecting suspicion and an argument. There was none. I found that odd. *shrugs*

 

However, you are active. Maybe we should vote Nolder, since he doesn't seem to be too interested in this game. Or somebody else who is inactive.

[Krakalakachkn]

Hybrid had the most to gain from Jack's death.

[Hybrid]

Hybrid had the most to gain from Jack's death.

 

WIFOM. You just pinged me.

[Krakalakachkn]

Could somebody explain to me what WIFOM means? I couldn't find a satisfactory definition online.

[John E. Kelley]

Wine In Front Of Me. From the Princess Bride.

 

"Inconceivable!!"

[Hybrid]

Could somebody explain to me what WIFOM means? I couldn't find a satisfactory definition online.

 

Circular reasoning from trying to figure out someone's actions/motivations.

 

Ex:

Maybe I'm mafia, and I killed Jack to stop my lynch today.

But maybe I'm innocent, and the mafia kill Jack to make you to think the above.

But maybe I'm mafia, and I killed Jack to make you think the above.

And so forth.

[Hybrid]

To add to that, Jack's death doesn't prove or disprove my alignment in any way.

 

If I'm mafia, I gain from killing Jack -- his death could prevent my lynch today.

 

But if I'm innocent, the mafia also gains from killing Jack -- his death could make my lynch easier today.

 

You focus on scenario 1 and ignore scenario 2, which is suspicious.

[Amadine]

I dont have time to re-read right now as I am at work, but my view of Hybrid last night came back as town.

[John E. Kelley]

Vote Hybrid.

[Hybrid]

Unvote, vote Ishamael

[Amadine]

vote Ishamael

 

He's been pinging anyway and he just voted a confirmed innocent.

[keyholder21]

That leaves:

 

2. keyholder21

3. Krakalakachkn

12. Lessa - Nolder

16. Ishmael Forsaken

 

 

Any particular reason you think I'm scum Hybrid?

 

Vote Ishamael. You've been pretty ping-y all game and now you vote for someone that our (uncontested) finder viewed as town? I generally try to give newbie the benefit of the doubt, but sometimes there is just too much to overlook.

 

 

 

BTW, I won't be able to get on much tonight - family stuff. I'll be around tomorrow though - and definitely more than I have been the past two days. Semester is gearing up and I had all day meetings today and yesterday, but they are thankfully over for a few days (Friday is all day too).

[Hybrid]

I don't think you're scum yet. I just think that the scum will be found in that list of 4 names.

[amegakure]

agreed. Ishy you didnt even give a reasoning and You have been off a bit from other games ive seen you play in. so unvote vote ishy

[Sakaea]

Wow. UNVOTE, VOTE ISHY

[Amadine]

Ishy is now at L-1, anything to say Ish?