[Advanced] Monty Python and the Holy Grail Mafia (Game Over)

[Krakalakachkn]

Wow, my bad guys, I totally didn't even realize how incomplete my end of night 2 scene was.

 

 

It should have said:

 

 

Csarmi, Sir Robin the Tracker, has been nightkilled

[Sakaea]

Christine's Unofficial Vote Count

 

Min (1) - Red

Moon (5) - Tina, Sak, GF, Wombat, Min

Red (8) - Berf, Moon, Tiinker, Trench, Kill, Key, Piano, BG

 

23 Alive, 12 to Lynch, 14 Voting

 

 

That being said, over half of the current people alive are voting, and our votes are pretty evenly split. People keep going back and forth between Red and Moon, whether because of band wagoning or trying to have a controlled lynch today, I don't know.

 

Someone mentioned that one of the two is most likely scum, and I have to agree. More than likely, if we lynch one and they flip town, the people that voted for them are mafia. If they flip mafia, then the votes on the other person is the mafia. But of course, this means that there is probably innocents mixed in.

 

 

With this reasoning, at this point it makes me think that Red is the innocent, since there is more people on her, as more than likely that's the mafia team and a few innocents. It is probably the people that haven't been flipping too. Going to guess the flippers are the innocents.

 

Combining that reasoning with the fact that I really just don't see there being two silencers, and that only one person has turned up silenced today, I am going to say Vote Moon.

 

 

So, 6 Moon, 8 Red

 

Isn´t this a strange post? What does the first part mean? If we lynch Red and she is town then all who voted for her are mafia, except for some of them who are town? And the same goes if we lynch Moon and she is town then all who voted for her are mafia, except for some of them who are town. lol.

 

And it get´s even funnier when you say you vote Moon cos Red has most votes and thereby the mafia team is on her lynch. So by this logic, if Moon will have more votes on her than Red you will then change your vote to Red?

 

Your second last post was also very weired. Big FOS on you, Christine.

 

 

I thought Berf made a good case and I see why some follow him. I can see a possibility that both Red and Jack could be town though. Mafia silence Jack. Everyone blame Red. She turns up town and then everyone goes after Jack again and lynch him too. But as Berf said it would probably be easier for mafia just to step back and let them continue the argument wich would in the end lead to the same thing. First a lynch on one and when she/he turns up town then lynch the other one.

 

We have some claims today. Red say she is Dennis the Digger. Well she is Dennis today anyway if we should go by her posting. It did look like she was King Arthur day one and the Black Knight day 2. Why does her roll change every day? How could we trust her? Min says she has figured out who Red is and hint on a PR since she says we shouldn´t vote Red. I may be a bit stupid but I don´t get it at all. And I don´t know what roll Min might have. The only things that seems clear is that they have to vote one another certain days.

 

(Sakaea suddenly changed her vote to Moon after Red said she was vanilla. It seems like she and Christine is out to rescue Red.)

And Moon makes a half reviel hinting she is "servant of the Knights". So we have two players who has majority of votes on them and we got hints about their rolls.

 

Moons only "defens" so far is the half reviel so I´m sticking to my vote on her. I´m more then willing to listen to the rest of you though. My head is just spinning...

 

 

In answer to the bolded part, I'd just like to point out that my vote was originally on Moon last day phase anyway. And now she's revealed her role (under pressure, I might add). As I said last night, I'm gonna be gone most of today (job hunting again), but I'm not going to unvote or change my vote. Moon's reveal seems a bit too forced/reluctant to me.

 

And in answer to Tina, yes, I think it's bad to lose vanilla town, and I have misgivings about voting for Moon, but I think I explained that already^^. Obviously power roles are more important, but ATM we have no clue as to who those might be. Therefore, losing vanilla town is bad, because we lose a vote we may need later.

 

Ciao everyone. Wish me luck.

[Charis alAslan]

I'm ducking in here for a sec as I run around today because I know if I leave it, I'll be reading 50pgs of text later!

 

I was about to vote in favor of whatever would get us a controlled lynch - yes, a controlled lynch and not a bandwagon, as some have suggested. Really? Way to FoS yourselves, Moon and Christine.

 

Anyway, that controlled lynch seemed to be moving towards Red. I do think these CHARACTER reveals/plays by her are interesting. (Yes, I'm emphasizing the word CHARACTER, because her role has nothing to do with her character. She could be freakin King Arthur and Krak could see fit to make her mafia or an SK. Character reveals are NOT role reveals.) The many characters I've seen come out of her make me wonder why Min is so confident she knows who Red is. There was an exchange between them that I clearly missed.

 

Ok, I dont have time for this. Moon has just revealed and Red has also revealed - both alleged Townies. Jack is silenced and there's no heat on Min today.

 

One thing, Red -- I've been a symp in mafia games before and I never shared a QT with the mafia, so while Jack (if he is the symp) may know who the mafia is, they would not know who he is. That's how I've known the symp role to be, anyway. So, his silencing could be real unless self-inflicted. Just wanted to point that out.

 

Therefore, I will check in later. Gotta go back now!

[Charis alAslan]

BTW - My blood test came out normal and my pregnancy is progressing along well!

[Red2111]

*Red continues to build up a bigger mud pie for her cart* I mean, if i went round sayin i was an emperor just because some moistened bink had lobbed a symitar at me, they'd put me away!

 

Sakaea good luck with the job hunt!

 

One thing, Red -- I've been a symp in mafia games before and I never shared a QT with the mafia, so while Jack (if he is the symp) may know who the mafia is, they would not know who he is. That's how I've known the symp role to be, anyway. So, his silencing could be real unless self-inflicted. Just wanted to point that out.

 

Therefore, I will check in later. Gotta go back now!

 

typically with a Symp your allowed to veiw the Mafia's QT board but you can't post anything on it. so you can read their convo and know what their plans are (by default can include yourself in on their plans) but you just can't communicate with them directly. each Mod has their own way of hadnling the symp role but thats how i've personally modded the role as well as played it the one time i was a symp; so its purely up to how Krak decided to mod the role if he is a symp.

 

 

also, glad the blood tests came back good!!

[WWWwombat]

In my experience, typically symps are NOT given access to the mafia QT as it would make finding the symp too easy for the mafia.

[Krakalakachkn]

Vote Count

 

 

Min(1): Red

Moon(8): Tina, Sak, GF, Wombat, Min, Christine, Ama, Key

Red(7): Berf, Moon, Tiinker, trench, Kil, Player, BG

 

 

With 23 alive it takes 12 to lynch. Day 3 will end on Saturday, 2pm EST.

[Alanna]

Well, I will go ahead and put my vote down for Moon.

[bgrishinko]

This is a flip floppy day for me. I had my heart set on Moon, but then along came Berf with his awesome arguments, but then crap happened, and now Moon is taking the lead in the votes. Well, either one will do, so I'm going to keep my vote where ever it is most useful. And today that seems to be Moon. I'm done flipping and will be settling once and for all on Moon.

 

I know you have your heart set on Red, Berf, but I implore you to let us move on and finish off Moon and we can focus on Red tomorrow.

 

Unvote: Vote Moon.

[Krakalakachkn]

Vote Count

 

 

Min(1): Red

Moon(10): Tina, Sak, GF, Wombat, Min, Christine, Ama, Key, Alanna, BG [L-2]

Red(6): Berf, Moon, Tiinker, trench, Kil, Player

 

 

With 23 alive it takes 12 to lynch. Day 3 will end on Saturday, 2pm EST.

[trench]

I am willing to move my vote to Moon. I think Red has defended herself more convincingly then Moon. Unvote Vote Moon

[Krakalakachkn]

That's L-1

[Charis alAslan]

Um, I really hate to be the hammer, (never hammered anyone before), but this is the only time I can log in tonite.

 

Vote MOON

[Christine]

Blah, I am gonna go back to keeping my thoughts to myself...

[Krakalakachkn]

And that's a lynch. Scene coming up shortly...

[Moon Sedai]

Bah.

[Krakalakachkn]

Concorde was settling down with the rest of the camp, preparing for dinner when she walked by a tree with unusually strong limbs. One caught her sleeve, and instead of breaking, it ripped the sleeve off - revealing her dreaded secret.

 

"She's got a wart!" Dingo screamed.

 

Before she knew what was happening, the camp was in an uproar and people were carrying her towards Sir Bedivere.

 

"Now, how do we know she's a witch?" asked Sir Bedivere.

 

"She's got a wart!" screamed the townspeople.

 

"So tell me, what do we do with witches?" asked Bedivere.

 

"Burn them!" screamed the townspeople.

 

"Wait, wait" said Bedivere, "and what do we burn apart from witches?"

 

"MORE WITCHES!" screamed one overzealous townsperson (quickly shushed by his peers).

 

"Uhhhh....wood?" asked one mediocrely smart townsperson.

 

"Good!" said Bedivere "and why do witches burn?"

 

"Because they're made of....wood?"

 

"Excellent. So how do we tell if she's made of wood?" asked Bedivere.

 

"Build a bridge out of 'er!"

 

"No. Tell me, does wood sink in water?" asked Bedivere (a little PO'd at this point).

 

"It floats! It floats! Throw her into the pond!" screamed the townsfolk.

 

"What also floats in water?" asked Bedivere.

 

"Bread!"

 

"Apples!"

 

"Very small rocks!"

 

"Churches!"

 

"A duck!" came a mysterious voice from beyond the crowd.

 

"Excellent" said Bedivere, "So...logically..."

 

"If she...weighs the same as a...duck, then she's made of....wood?" said one townsperson.

 

"Good!" said Bedivere, "We shall use my largest scales."

 

 

The townspeople carried Concorde to the scales and placed a duck on the opposite scale. They then removed the supports and a great shout went up as the scales evenly balanced.

 

 

Concorde had nothing to say except, "It's a fair cop."

 

 

 

 

Ahmoondah, Concorde, Mafia Symp, has been lynched. It is now Night 3.

 

 

Night will end Saturday at 2pm EST.

[bgrishinko]

Works for me!

[Red2111]

*Red stands up and claps her hands, mud dripping off her hands* And that is why ruling by the masses is most effective.

 

 

i knew she was scum! yes, Min is right when she says i was forced to vote her. the thing is, since Jack obviously isn't the symp then he'd be on a QT board. unless he's a cultist or God Father.

 

a God Father veiws innocent when cop veiws them, but there are other roles that can catch God Father role. i also wonder why the scum would freeze him but have me vote for Min.

 

 

 

Moon's "silencing" and newt excuse are the fake claim. someone else pointed this out earlier but

 

I think since we're all aware of Red, she is less of a potential threat. We can always lynch her. Also, the apparent newting of Jack rang to me as a 90% confirmation she was innocent, though I do have beer in front of me. Still, I bet either the red or moon voters feature mafia members for sure this time.

 

major FoS for the usage of the word "Newting".

[Red2111]

*Red hums happily as she picks up the mud pie and tosses it into the cart*

 

 

actually i take that back, Alanna is the one that pointed it out about the vote forcing.

 

 

i'm very interested to hear fromt he people who were quiet today and to hear what Jack has to say as well.

 

 

and Krak, excellent scene writing dude!!

[bgrishinko]

I feel like there is a lot to be learned from this lynch and I need to go back and analyze what Moon has done, but not at night. I'll look into it and post my thoughts on it at the end of the night.

[Sedai]

Hah I was correct on moons sympness from the start

 

***super long post coming up****

 

Btw red ;p there goes your symp theory

[Sedai]

I have to many quoted blocks so I can't just copy and paste

Everything I've written. It'll be direct and no editing so if you see conflicting thoughts or etc that's why.

 

Charis is a #1 ATM for scum. People has to give me some love for making that connection

[Sedai]

First or all that was an amateur hour set up. Please killing csarmi, the one player who I believe just generally dislikes me was cheap. Next of all I believe wombat's silence more because I wasn't turned into a newt

 

On another note. If I were mafia then I'd know I was silenced by the mafia silencer. I wouldn't have posted and then deleted my posts. Just saying. 

 

.

 

 

.

 

 

.

 

 

Phone messing up Jack?

 

*Csarmi moves his left foot.

 

lol, nice.  Adios Sir Robin.

 

Key. Don't remember saying I was on my phone. I told the mod via pm but I don't think I ever stated it. That's interesting that you would know that. 

[Sedai]

Tracker is someone who sees if a person has a NA right? 

 

This is the end of my lunch break but when I get home ill do a case on someone (not sure who yet but probably moon or chris)

Im of the opinion the Moon is being scummy but it jsut doesnt feel right for the lynch. I think that the Jack and Chris interaction was distracting and to me I dont think its something they would do just because they are childish. So that leads me to want to take a look at one of them as they are likely scum. I still think jack is a good candidate but I want to look at chris first to give a weighed opinion. 

 

Oh and jack, what happened with all those posts? Glitch or something?

 

So Charis and my interaction was scummy and distracting, but mine and Red's wasn't? Interesting. He then says he wants Charis's weighted oppinion first, and not mine. He must of knew I was silenced. 

 

Then throws in the glitch post to try and cover it up.