[Basic] JLM's Ad Icons Mafia - Game Over!

[Myndrunner]

  On 5/16/2011 at 2:23 AM, trench said:

I dont know why anyone would vote for Mynd. I have only played one game with the guy but I have never seen a line of complete bull delivered so smoothly. I am still in awe about it.

 

Best quote of the game! *bows*

[killuliu]

  On 5/16/2011 at 5:44 PM, Myndrunner said:

  On 5/16/2011 at 2:23 AM, trench said:

I dont know why anyone would vote for Mynd. I have only played one game with the guy but I have never seen a line of complete bull delivered so smoothly. I am still in awe about it.

 

Best quote of the game! *bows*

 

And it's pretty much true :D

[GMaster479]

mhmm. So...this is why I HATE Day 1 lynches without a Night 1 coming first. Can we get a vote count?

[LilyElizabeth]

  On 5/16/2011 at 6:41 AM, TinaHel said:

  On 5/15/2011 at 10:39 PM, Deadlyfreind said:

hmmmm looks like i have some bad rep...

 

 

VOTE:Tina

 

 

lets even things out a bit

 

 

even things out... So your vote for me doesn´t have anything to do with me voteing you?

 

 

 

  On 5/15/2011 at 7:07 PM, LilyElizabeth said:

I need to get back in the habit of posting more in games.

 

I'm surprised that nobody said anything to Christine for blatantly bandwagoning. I didn't because I know it's her first game, but I'm surprised nobody else did.

 

 

 

  On 5/15/2011 at 11:05 PM, LilyElizabeth said:

I was actually giving Christine's excuse for her. I guess that got misinterpreted. She's just learning the game, so I, for one, am going to cut her some slack for this.

 

This is highly supspicious. Looking like you´re defending Christine and painting her as a target at the same time.

 

I already said I didn't mean to paint her as a target.

[Niniel]

Unofficial votecount

 

Deadly (2): TinaHel, Pruthvish

TinaHel (2): Mynd, Deadly

Mynd (2): Leelou, GMaster

Moon (1): Lily

Killu (1): Moon

Christine (1): Quibby

Alanna (1): Key

Lily (1): Christine

 

Hope I got it right!

[danneric]

So right now we have a three way tie with no evidence to back any of the votes...awesome!

[trench]

  On 5/16/2011 at 8:58 PM, Deadlyfreind said:

So right now we have a three way tie with no evidence to back any of the votes...awesome!

 

Sounds like day 1 to me.

 

Personally I had no real problem with the Mynd bandwagon vote, 1) because its early still 2) from what I gather Mynd's play style woould get him random votes on D1

 

What has me scratching my head is Lily's pointing out of the bandwagon vote, but not wanting to call attention to it at the same time? that reads as a scum setup ploy to me and then there is Chrsitine's switch vote to Lily. Its early still and were not under any deadline, so I can wait awhile before I start voting with any confidence. I would definetly like to hear more options then what we have so far.

[JenLenaMom]

vote count:

 

Deadly(2): TinaHel, Pruthvish

TinaHel(2): Mynd, Deadly

Mynd (2): Leelou, Gmaster

Moon (1): Lilly

Killu (1): Moon

Christine (1): Quibby

Alanna (1): Keyholder

Lily (1): Christine

 

Yep you were right Tina.

Majority is 10. If you don't reach a majority there will be a random death.

 

 

So by my count fifteen of you have checked in. If anyone has outside DM access to Mav, Csarmi, or Tynaal give them a poke; they are in danger of ModKill. Since that's enough active to get a good conversation going (clearly, lol) Let's set a deadline of Wednesday, May 18th, at 8:30pm Central Time. If you don't live in CST you're going to have to do the conversion yourself because I'm pretty sure I failed time zone math, lol.

[Christine]

*sits herself in the corner quietly*

 

I voted for Lily because she dragged me here. And it's Day 1. I can do that kind of stuffs.

[JenLenaMom]

I just realized that I sort of buried that in a wall of text.

 

Just to be clear:

 

The deadline is now Wednesday at 8:30pm Central time.

 

Anyone not checked in or on approved LOA will be Modkilled at that point.

[danneric]

havent seen CS posting in awhile and i dont have contact with him :(

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm not sure how many times I need to explain this. I was explaining that Christine was new - no more, no less. I wasn't trying to call attention to her, although I now realize that was exactly what I did. Sorry, Christine. I should have waited to defend you until somebody said something.

[killuliu]

JLM: it could be good if you would edit those DLs to the first post, so they would be easy to check :)

[Red2111]

  On 5/17/2011 at 12:44 AM, Christine said:

*sits herself in the corner quietly*

 

I voted for Lily because she dragged me here. And it's Day 1. I can do that kind of stuffs.

 

see that explination would cut it if Lily had been your first vote. yes Day 1 normally has silly votes, thats what i'm assuming your Mynd vote was; but the events surrounding Lily as well as your vote on her and now your flimsy reason you give for voting her make me suspect you even more.

 

 

 

now that we have a deadline, we need to start figuring out what we're going to do. that we likely have 3 MKs on the way makes me less in clined to actually want to lynch someone, the chances are too likely we'd hit more townies than scum with both.

 

 

VOTE: NO LYNCH

 

until something better presents itself.

[Niniel]

Mav dissapeard in the other game I´m in and was md´d, so I´m not sure he will show up. I miss CS. Where are you?

 

I can see your point here Red but what would we learn from a no lynch? Tomorrow would be like starting on day one again. On the other hand - can we get ten players out of 15 to vote for the same player?

 

There have been some things to notice today.

 

1. Christine. I don´t think it´s strange to start the first bandwagon. Someone has to do it sooner or later. Moving her vote when being accused of it could be a new player reaction. Her reason for voteing Lily was very weired. Lily hasn´t been silent - actually the opposit,

 

2. Lily. I haven´t played with you before but I guess you are na experienced player. I don´t think you just happen to blame Christine for bandwagoning at the same time as you try to defend her. What to think of your excuses now - I don´t know.

 

3. Pruthvish. Voted Deadly and then dissapeared.

 

4. Red overreacted a bit to Deadlys post in my oppinion. And I can´t see the connection Quibby - Lily. (Could of course be one but I don´t see it.)

 

5. Mynd is very quiet. That is strange.

 

Even though I think it´s hard to get a controlled lynch today I will make a "serious vote". Unvote. Vote Lily.

[Alanna]

Tina, we would still need a majority to vote for a no-lynch (I think?), so it's no good doing that just because we might think we can't get a majority. If we simply don't lynch anyone at all, a random player will be killed, which would be bad, of course.

 

Actually, I went back to reread what Lily said and I understand what she was saying now. I don't think it was scummy.

 

As for Mynd, if I recall correctly from the WOT mafia game, he was pretty quiet the first day or two, I think.

[csarmi]

checking in

vote Deadly

[csarmi]

  On 5/18/2011 at 1:36 AM, DEADLINE said:

This is the deadline, if I got it right. Does it appear alright?

[csarmi]

  On 5/19/2011 at 1:40 AM, DEADLINE said:

 

Sorry, off by a day and an hour. Should be good now?

 

[Niniel]

Hi Csarmi! I´m so glad you are here.

 

Alanna - I don´t think I got the idea with a no lynch. So if we all should vote no lynch then noone will be modkilled? (I mean exept the inactive onces.)

[trench]

On the whole Lily subject, I think there is not to much left to discuss, you either buy her Line or you dont. She has replied as to her reasons for her actions, so its just a judgement call there.

 

Same with Christine, not much left to discuss.

 

Tina brought up a point about Pruthvish, Im not sold on scum by it, but its always been my oppionion that Mafia just want to survive day 1, so they do some random voting and fade into the background, but then Csarmi shows up and drops one on him as well? First votes really mean nothing to me but it did peek my intrests, and has me wondering why Deadly keeps getting attention. With Pruthvish voting and walking away, Tina and Deadly voted each other, then Csari drops one on Deadly when he shows up. This has me thinking Mafia are envolved some how.

 

The Quibby/Lilly conection doesn't hold water IMO. I'll just file that away for later.

 

I personally am not one for a No Lynch Day 1, the Random Hammer falls hard and could cause us to lose a PR. Not a good option IMO

 

I wont Vote right now but I could get behind a Lily/Christine lynch if the group wants to go that way, and to keep a random from occuring but right now I really want to figure out why Deadly keeps getting attention.

[LilyElizabeth]

I don't think a no lynch is a good idea today, Red. We need a lynch ballot to analyze. I know the lynchee will probably be town, but we still need that.

[Christine]

Just because, Happy Birthday Lily! <3

[JenLenaMom]

vote count:

 

Deadly(2): Pruthvish, Csarmi

TinaHel(2): Mynd, Deadly

Mynd (2): Leelou, Gmaster

Moon (1): Lilly

Killu (1): Moon

Christine (1): Quibby

Alanna (1): Keyholder

Lily (2): Christine, Tina

No Lynch (1): Red

 

 

Majority is 10. If you don't reach a majority there will be a random death.

 

Deadline is Wednesday May 18th 8:30pm CST, right now it is 4:15pm CST just so you guys can figure it all out.

[Myndrunner]

  On 5/17/2011 at 12:21 PM, Red2111 said:

  On 5/17/2011 at 12:44 AM, Christine said:

*sits herself in the corner quietly*

 

I voted for Lily because she dragged me here. And it's Day 1. I can do that kind of stuffs.

 

see that explination would cut it if Lily had been your first vote. yes Day 1 normally has silly votes, thats what i'm assuming your Mynd vote was; but the events surrounding Lily as well as your vote on her and now your flimsy reason you give for voting her make me suspect you even more.

 

 

 

now that we have a deadline, we need to start figuring out what we're going to do. that we likely have 3 MKs on the way makes me less in clined to actually want to lynch someone, the chances are too likely we'd hit more townies than scum with both.

 

 

VOTE: NO LYNCH

 

until something better presents itself.

 

HOLD THE PHONE!!!! NO LYNCH?! Are you SERIOUS!?!

 

Nothing and I repeat N O T H I N G good comes out of a No Lynch, especially on Day 1! This only helps the mafia, as if we might as well have started on Night 1!

unvote

 

vote Red

 

She is obviously mafia!