Rebel Mafia - GAME OVER - Congratulations Black Ajah and Wombat!!

[aemonkristen]

I really don't see the point of your question. Alanna unvoted when we asked Amadine for the extension.

 

Okay, that was fun, but UNVOTE. I also think we definitely need an extension; 48 hours is quite short for Day 1.

 

Song was replaced, which means her vote would usually be nullified since she is not playing. It obviously stayed because it is on the vote counts, but that tells us nothing. This happened about an hour after Ama gave us the extension.

 

Also Song has asked to be replaced - i am waiting to hear from Adella.

 

AJ threw a second vote on Talm after we asked the mod to remind him about this game.

 

Hm Unvote Vote Tal, let's see what happens.

 

We had little time and that was the only thing we had to go on. At the time I voted there was nobody with two people on them. This makes me ask you: why are you trying to convince everyone Ed had two votes when he, in fact, had only 1?

[ed2funy]

I find eddie suspicous as well, in either case.

 

*bows*

Thank you.

 

At the beginning of this argument, I was going to say that I don't agree. I've seen Limi play (and she gets a lot of things backwards in her posts a lot....like a silly TARD ), but her insisting is bad light.

Especially when she says I pushed on AJ....I stated my reasons...She kept asking about it and whatnot, so I told her again. And again. lol

 

 

Ummm....not much other comment right now....when is the deadline?

[Tigraine]

I'm going to have to go back and see what really happened, all this back and forth is giving me a headache and since I already have the flu that wouldn't be good. I'm going to bed right now so I'll be back tomorrow with some input.

[Amadine]

Official Vote Count: 52 hours to deadline

 

Ed (0) - Wombat

Talm (1) - Talya

Limi (2) - Aemon, Wombat

Not Voting: KeyHolder, Tigs, Ed, Limi, Arlow, Talmanes, Kat

 

With 10 players, you need 6 to lynch.

[Talmanes]

Ok so here are the day 1 votes.

 

Got a question for you: First day is 48 hours as well? I'll still VOTE TIGS because she can't be town forever.

 

Random Day 1 Vote

Gonna change it up and vote Song; she's more likely to be mafia than town anyways.

 

Random Day 1 Vote

Checking in, and voting for my mintee Arlow.

Random Day 1 Vote

 

Checking in. Gah to you Kat, you beat me this time VOTE KAT

OMGUS Vote

 

Alanna

 

Ahhh ha!

 

Glow fail Tigs!

Random Day 1 Vote

 

Boo to you, Ed, I could've been the first poster in the game thread last night! But I chose not ot be OMGUS Vote Ed, so there :D

 

OMGUS Vote

well shoot, Aemon

it's hard to portray the proper outrage the second time around!

 

OMGUS Vote

Gonna change it up and vote Song; she's more likely to be mafia than town anyways.

 

lol when was the last time I was mafia, DPRs game?

 

 

VOTE ED Lucky number eight XD

 

Random Day 1 Vote, but also gives Ed 2 votes.

>.> Checking in..

 

And I am going to vote Tal since he is sneaky >_> and he plans on eating all the cheeze itz in the world. *nods*

 

Random Day 1 Vote

I'm going to vote MCS, because he's number one and I wanted to be!

 

Random Day 1 Vote

Okay, that was fun, but UNVOTE. I also think we definitely need an extension; 48 hours is quite short for Day 1.

 

Unvotes, saying we need to focus, which is reasonable.

Hm Unvote Vote Tal, let's see what happens.

 

Gives me my second vote without much reason, though explains her plot to get me to show up somehow, later.

Well UNVOTE AEMON because even on Day 1 an OMGUS bandwagon just isn't the way to go :P

 

I completely do not understand the whole I was voting for him to hurry and get him here thing that AJ is trying to pull. If it was a random day 1 vote then say it was a random day 1 vote. The fact that you are trying to make up excuses just seems scummy to me.

 

Votes Aemon deciding to remove her OMGUS vote.

We need to consolidate votes right now. Unfortunately, it looks like no matter who we lynch today we aren't going to get much info. I know this looks bad, but...

UNVOTE

 

VOTE AJ

 

I'd prefer if we didn't go to a random lynch.

 

Aemon tries to get the ball rolling.

Kat, I like your breakdown!

 

AJ, my main issue is that yes, I think it's ok to vote for someone who hasn't checked in, but not so soon. It was about 12 hours after Ama said she he hadn't checked in (not sure the time span or if it was before/after she said she will poke him).

And no, I don't think it's quite a huge thing.

But, I don't like random. lol

 

unvote

vote AJ

 

AJ's second vote, Ed saying she is all he has to go on, and wants to avoid randomlynch.

Well, I'm about to go to bed, deadline is 5amish my time and I won't be up that early. In hopes of a controlled lynch I have to UNVOTE and VOTE AJ as she is currently the one with the most votes.

 

Kat gives AJ her third vote, saying she just wants a controlled lynch.

I still think Ed and Aemons jumping on this was weird.

 

However in interest of a controled lynch :/ unvote vote aj

 

Limi, also voicing the need for a controlled lynch, gives another AJ vote.

I guess if we don't want a random lynch that I need to vote AJ. Don't really feel all that good about it :/.

 

Key votes in the interest of a lynch, but mentions she isn't comfortable with the lynch.

Oops, Vote AEMON

 

AJ gets some retribution.

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Says she believes AJ is town, but is voting anyway, though she gives a fairly good explanation.

 

FULL ANALYSIS COMING SOON

[Talya]

My apologies, Aemon, I missed her unvote somehow.

[Talmanes]

>.> Checking in..

 

And I am going to vote Tal since he is sneaky >_> and he plans on eating all the cheeze itz in the world. *nods*

 

Just realized this is a total metagaming move lol.

 

Well, I'm torn between just voting an inactive, or voting AJ, who has pinged me a little. The thing is, I don't want to vote her if she's pinged me just because she's, well, actually posting a lot. I just thought it was weird, the whole thing with voting Talmanes to get him here when he obviously hadn't seen the thread. *shrugs* I think I'm more in favor of voting an inactive, though.

 

Just pointing out here, that Alanna had suspicions of AJ.

Well UNVOTE AEMON because even on Day 1 an OMGUS bandwagon just isn't the way to go :P

 

I completely do not understand the whole I was voting for him to hurry and get him here thing that AJ is trying to pull. If it was a random day 1 vote then say it was a random day 1 vote. The fact that you are trying to make up excuses just seems scummy to me.

 

Here Tigs voices suspicions as well. I'm just pointing these out, because it seems there is an effort to pin the lynch on certain people.

I find that really curious of you to say Tigs because I don't feel she has been defensive on this at all aside from explaining... and as to not undstanding it.. did you read everything? Thigs where pretty clear cut to me at least. Kathleen's post summed it up nicely. ^^

 

This post doesn't make the most sense, as Limi mentions things that aren't actually in Tigs' post.

I agree with you Laine. And I know Tigs, Aemon and Ed are going to need to be looked at

 

Here you are implying suspicion on everyone who voiced suspicion on AJ, which seems odd, as no one had even voted for her yet. Yes I know she ended up being town, But there was no way of knowing that until later. It appears those just talking about suspicions were targeted.

She isn't going to vote for herself :P

 

The reason I find YOU suspicious Aemon is because YOU were the second vote when there where several other people with one vote a well. I can't help but feel that since you voted second and put her the closest to being lynched that people soon followed.

 

Talk about an overly easy way to lead town and mafia to an easy lynch.

 

Now here, this is what really pinged me. Limi is saying that Aemon looks suspicious, because he voted for someone he had found suspicious, INSTEAD of adding his vote to one of the random Day 1 votes. That seriously makes no sense.

I am suspcous of Aemon because Tigs wasn't the second to vote on AJ.

 

Aemon was, and at that point Aemon could have put his vote on any number of other players at that point but by doing thus and with such a short deadline left, next time I checked in others had voted as well to "consolidate" votes as well.

 

The reason I find Tigs suspicous is because I felt Aj and Kat had fully explained what happen right there and voted on her anyways.

 

Eddie also seemed to be harrying Aj from the begining while almost working in tandem with Aemon. He brought all attention on herand didn't really let up.

 

I didn't really get that much persistence from Eddie, as he wasn't going after her very hard, and wasn't even the first to vote AJ.

So you wanted to consolidate your vote Aemon, why didn't you put it on Ed, he had two votes! I can't say why song voted Ed, but she didn't come on to do anything after that. So you started to cpnsolidate on someone who only had one vote, like so many others. That sounds a bit fishy to me.

Yeah Aemon points out this well enough in the next post, but it is a about the same as with Limi. Talya is saying that it is 'fishy' that Aemon votes for someone he found suspicious instead of voting someone who, although not even at the time, had previously had 2 random Day 1 votes.

Actually Aemon, go back to the first page, Both Alanna and Song voted Ed. Before you had even voted. It was there from the start and didn't change because song wasn't really on after that, she'd asked to be replaced. Ed had 2 votes from the start

 

She is keeping to her defense here apparently not realizing her error.

I really don't see the point of your question. Alanna unvoted when we asked Amadine for the extension.

 

Okay, that was fun, but UNVOTE. I also think we definitely need an extension; 48 hours is quite short for Day 1.

 

Song was replaced, which means her vote would usually be nullified since she is not playing. It obviously stayed because it is on the vote counts, but that tells us nothing. This happened about an hour after Ama gave us the extension.

 

Also Song has asked to be replaced - i am waiting to hear from Adella.

 

AJ threw a second vote on Talm after we asked the mod to remind him about this game.

 

Hm Unvote Vote Tal, let's see what happens.

 

We had little time and that was the only thing we had to go on. At the time I voted there was nobody with two people on them. This makes me ask you: why are you trying to convince everyone Ed had two votes when he, in fact, had only 1?

Aemon sums this up well, though I'm a little inclined to think it was more an accident of miscounting at least to some extent.

 

From the votes, the only person that really stuck out to me was Key, who voted, yet tried to back away from it, saying that she was not comfortable with it. Trying to appear separate from a lynch, is in my experience, often a scum tactic.

(Oh and I totally just realized Tigs was first, thought she was third, so my info may be slightly off in the votes post)

So my suspects are as follows: Limi was focusing on pretty much everyone who was voting based on suspicion instead of randomness. Talya, was doing somewhat the same thing. Key, just looks bad to me based on her vote, and trying to not be attached to the lynch.

 

I want to see how people react, and will vote tomorrow, when I can actually think straight.

[keyholder21]

Talm, I really don't see how my being unhappy about it is any different from some of the other voters.

 

I still think Ed and Aemons jumping on this was weird.

 

However in interest of a controled lynch :/ unvote vote aj

 

Limi has a :/ face here which means she's not happy about it, she just said in a face instead of what I said.

 

 

I guess if we don't want a random lynch that I need to vote AJ. Don't really feel all that good about it :/.

 

I voted for her because I didn't want a random lynch, I don't have to feel good about voting for someone who SAID she was town.

 

I've already explained how I came to my vote....I may not be ecstatic about my vote, but there really is no where else to go.

I'd rather vote for that small oddity.

*shrugs*

 

Ed mentions that he's not happy about it either, so why pointing me out and not him?

 

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Alanna also mentions that she's sorry and that the vote "sucks." So again, I don't understand how my statement "looks bad."

[WWWwombat]

Let's get some posts and votes.

[ed2funy]

Let's....

 

Talm, can you reply to Key? I think she has a valid question.

 

I see many who say they didn't like their vote (yes me too, though I look at the people who waited so long to do anything....and as long as I waited, they cut it close, imo).

 

I would vote Talm to be lazy and let you all decide which way to swing, but I don't want to do that. It's bad because the next vote could be a scum on either of them pushing the town one way. (Between Limi and Talm, I'm still concerned with her, and as I skim through again, well, I'm way more comfortable with Limi than I was with AJ. LMAO >_<)

 

*posts all over Wombat*

ehhhh, sorry.

[WWWwombat]

ewww

[Talya]

That was...too much information...ewww!!!

[aemonkristen]

I'm still happy voting for Limi and I think my reasons are pretty clear. I can also see how Talya could have miscounted. I myself thought I was the third vote on AJ at the moment i voted because of Alanna being in the game as well. An understandable mistake.

[Tigraine]

I think that I might be to blame for everyone getting off on the vote count, right after I voted, I stated that I was the second vote. I reread everything and have no idea how I came up with that other than Aemon having voted right before my post.

 

I stated my reasons for voting AJ, and if it had been Day 4 then I wouldn't have voted her. As it stood, it was Day 1, and she was just trying to justify a random vote and to me, that looked scummy. Maybe my mistake about being the second vote was what got everyone else started on voting her too, maybe they thought it was odd that she was making excuses for a random vote...I don't really know.

[ed2funy]

Well, waiting for my damm chinese food, I realize Limi is scum!

 

*is bored* But seriously. We need some activity. Where are you all?!

 

Little Miss NEFARIOUS

[Little Miss]

Right now for me it's a tie for the same people who have been pinging me.

 

Eddie, Tigs, and Aemon.

 

Tigs for her confusion on AJ, and then voting.

 

Aemon FOR being the Second vote on AJ, When there were a number of other players he could have voted on.

 

Eddie - Because of the way he harried AJ but claimed he didn't want a random vote.

 

I would bet for sure that at least one of these are mafia and easily got the ball rolling on AJ.

 

Right now I am going to vote Ed for the pressure he put on AJ

[ed2funy]

Right now for me it's a tie for the same people who have been pinging me.

 

Eddie, Tigs, and Aemon.

 

Tigs for her confusion on AJ, and then voting.

 

Aemon FOR being the Second vote on AJ, When there were a number of other players he could have voted on.

 

Eddie - Because of the way he harried AJ but claimed he didn't want a random vote.

 

I would bet for sure that at least one of these are mafia and easily got the ball rolling on AJ.

 

Right now I am going to vote Ed for the pressure he put on AJ

Can you say OMGUS?

 

*goes to get his food and comes back*

 

Well, since you insist this was extreme pressure, I am fine with my vote on you.

 

just in case there were more posts....

 

No new posts I see

[Talmanes]

Talm, I really don't see how my being unhappy about it is any different from some of the other voters.

 

I still think Ed and Aemons jumping on this was weird.

 

However in interest of a controled lynch :/ unvote vote aj

 

Limi has a :/ face here which means she's not happy about it, she just said in a face instead of what I said.

 

 

I guess if we don't want a random lynch that I need to vote AJ. Don't really feel all that good about it :/.

 

I voted for her because I didn't want a random lynch, I don't have to feel good about voting for someone who SAID she was town.

 

I've already explained how I came to my vote....I may not be ecstatic about my vote, but there really is no where else to go.

I'd rather vote for that small oddity.

*shrugs*

 

Ed mentions that he's not happy about it either, so why pointing me out and not him?

 

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Alanna also mentions that she's sorry and that the vote "sucks." So again, I don't understand how my statement "looks bad."

Well Limi in that particular post merely said she thought it was weird, not really distancing herself that much. Ed, as shown by his 'shrug', just didn't seem to care much, as he was already slightly suspicious. Quite honestly, as I did my post at like three in the morning, I missed Alanna, but I'll be looking at her for the same reason I am you.

 

The reason you stuck out, is because you seemed to be, more so than anyone else, trying to convey not wanting to vote. I know you weren't the only one, you just stuck out more to me. Alanna did do it a bit more later too, though, so she is almost equal with you. You are still pinging me a bit more.

[Amadine]

Hello my pets....

 

Arlow has asked to be replaced as he is going away so we are welcoming Alanna back into the game.....

 

 

Official Vote Count: 29 hours to deadline

 

Ed (0) - Wombat

Talm (1) - Talya

Limi (3) - Aemon, Wombat, Ed

Ed (1) - Limi

 

Not Voting: KeyHolder, Tigs, ArlowAlanna, Talmanes, Kat

 

With 10 players, you need 6 to lynch.

[ed2funy]

hahaha...Talm...you can look at Alanna now...but I don't think it'd matter.

[Talmanes]

Yeah I realized that after I posted that. Now I know why I never mentioned her last night lol.

[Alanna]

Hello :) Need to do a reread though I have sort of kept up with the posts since Alanna 1.0 died I'm not really sure I get where you're coming from with key, Tal. Her sentiments when she voted AJ just don't seem very different from the others' to me; all I see there is a difference in personalities, and therefore, a difference in the way everyone expressed their reluctance to vote AJ. I don't think many of the people on her lynch were happy about lynching her, but most everyone seemed to think it was too late to do anything about it.

 

That's all for now, will be back tomorrow sometime with more definite thoughts...

[Talmanes]

Well you see, ever since using the strategy of backing away from a lynch, while still supporting it, and seeing how well it worked, I've become much more suspicious of people who do this, or appear to do this. That is all really, though it has served me well before.

 

Now, as I'm not going to be on much longer, and probably won't be on much tomorrow, I will vote Limi for now. I think I and others have given ample reasoning for my vote.

[Little Miss]

Honestly Every one? I am not going to let it get this far with out revealing when there is only have 26 hours in the game left, I am Theodrin Dabei - And I walk in the Light.

 

So merely because I didn't "express" myself on voting for AJ, I am being persecuted.

[WWWwombat]

What about throwing suspicion on Aemon for no reason?