Shadow over Fiddlesmouth Game Thread [GAME OVER, TOWN WINS]

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I want something.

[DPR]

 

[mcs0083]

Yikes

[Kivam]

Night is over.

 

Day scene coming up, along with results of night actions and thief plays - but it will take a while for me to go through the thief plays and get the scene up.  Call this "Dawn" - no voting, but Day 1 thief plays are done and cleared as pf right now

[Alys Kinch]

i have not finished catching up from the day, but i wanted to say in regards to the aemon/nae argument, nae has a point. you used pointless info (that is both right annd wrong) to back up a vote you feel was neither good or bad during a period when you can't vote after a vote that only revealed several questions- all of which you just blatently ignore.  i am not saying scummy, but a definate ping.

[Barmacral]

Bah, Alys, catch up! I've already posted the only pertinant post on the whole topic.

[Alys Kinch]

stoping to respond again. the bandwagon witch hunt is best used, and really only effective, at end game when you can compare and draw more than speculation.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I find it is pretty effective during the first couple of game days also.

[DPR]

 

Yes, we knew that one... :P

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I gathered that.

 

 

:P X 2

 

[DPR]

 

Yes, we knew you gathered that... :P :P :P

 

okay, I'll stop now.  :-*

[ed2funy]

Wow....

So, I got that there was a lot of .

A lot of snarky posts.

And we decided that using the vote count isn't good (with a few exceptions *eyes Pete* :D).....

 

 

Hmmm.....did anything good happen?

[Kivam]

OK, power's flickering in and out, so no elaborate morning scene.  Just some info:

 

1) WOMBAT, an innocent, has been murdered

 

2) Al Jenn has been resurrected

 

Day 2 has begun.  With 23 players alive, it takes 12 votes to lynch.  Happy hunting

 

 

[ed2funy]

:o

Al is back. Whoo.

 

Awww...Wombat is dead.

[mcs0083]

Okay. Let's think about this. Resurrection does not necessarily mean Al Jenn has come back with the same role he had. I could be wrong about this, but I really think it's something to mull over. It also might be possible that a certain relic or whatever was used to bring him back, and not necessarily by the mod directly. So if this is the case, an innocent used it to bring back a fallen innocent, in place of one that would possibly be killed during the night. Or the cultists brought him back as one of them to turn their numbers even more to their favor. It may even be that the person who used it, no matter what their alignment, used it on Al not knowing who or what he would come back as. For the record these are just random thoughts that bounced around in my head right after I saw the post of the nights events. I really believe it's something to think about though.

[Al Jenn Mael]

Well I can't say that I thought this would happen in the slightest. However after my... untimely demise yesterday I think I will stay away from the line of reasoning that lead to that death like Alys suggest. Just to jib some people though... I am still innocent *Laughs*

 

It feels good to be back. Alys you're right nothing worthwhile has been talked about really, I will double check a few... interesting posts I saw and post my thoughts on the win/lose conditions shortly. *Smiles*

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

[glow=red,2,300]Nae[/glow] Wombat was the only person to vote Aemon, and Aemon and Nae had that whole back-and-forth. It looks like there may be a set up in the works.

[Barmacral]

[glow=red,2,300]Vote: Anox[/glow]

 

The reason for this is as I stated in an earlier post made during the night phase.

[Pookie]

Al's back!

 

Welcome back, we always could spot a friend  ::)

Welcome back, and I smile when I think how you must have been (when you found out you were resurrected)

And I know what a scene you were learning in

Was there something that made you come back again (would be interesting to know if it was a relic or a role)

 

No vote for me yet.  My note cards are at the other end of the house.  :P

[Hybrid]

OK. 

 

Clean slate for Al, then.  We don't know what his alignment is or how resurrection works. 

 

I'm going to reread in the meantime.

[Lavinya]

Go with your instincts! We almost had Thorum on the ropes during day one, why was that? Why did we back off? Who was most vocal in defending Thorum? There we will find our scum, people!

 

[glow=red,2,300]VOTE THORUM[/glow]

 

And welcome back Al. Sorry bout the whole lynch thing, hope there's no hard feelings and all that. Heh.

[Al Jenn Mael]

I'm looking for at least 20 people in this game.  There will be relics.  There will be thief plays.  And there will be (at least) one very special twist: the mafia may win if you kill them all.

 

There will be a Vessel, randomly selected from among all the players in the game (including the mafia).  If the Vessel is still alive when the final mafioso dies, and certain other conditions (which I will only reveal to the mafia) are met, the mafia will win (obviously, if the randomly selected player is mafia, this option is off the table).  The Vessel will not know who they are, and they may or may not have another role.  Should make for an interesting game.

WIN CONDITIONS:

 

The win conditions for the scum in this game are unusual.  Yes, they will win if they can kill you all.  But they will also win if they all die - as long as: 1) the Vessel is alive; and 2) another condition (that only they know) has been met.

 

Remember that.

 

Also, be aware that, at the start of the game, nobody knows who the Vessel is. 

 

Have fun.

 

Well I think it is safe to assume that the vessel isn't mafia and so they have that win condition. So let us speculate. Can the finder identify the Vessel? If so they're an equal threat staying alive as the mafia is. I am going to assume the second condition has to do with the relics. Either they need a certain relic or a set of relics. I am going to assume some relics are expendable and others aren't. Now...

 

2) You MAY NOT post any information about a relic on the thread.  That means no claiming to have one, and it means no publication of any information you got via PM from me when you obtained your relics. You can speculate about whether other people have relics, but that's it.

 

I'm not sure how much we can talk about relics, however I think it only refers to any that we might have.

 

I don't know how or under what conditions I came back, but I would like to assume it was a relic and not a persons role. That being said, I don't think this was a one time use relic. Or that the person who had it was way to scared of getting it stolen. The reason I say this is because I think I would be a terrible person to resurrect. You should all agree: I'm new, play weird, and wasn't very valuable to the town being vanilla. I also don't think many people think I have much in the way when it comes to skill with this game *Shrugs* That and the lynch there are no hard feelings for. Like others have said clean slate right?

 

Relics are unique and an important aspect to this game. The mafia are going to try and confuse us about their alternate win condition. I would guess a set of 3 relics. I'm not that familiar with this theme so if anyone has some clues as to what they would be please help.

 

*****************************************************************

 

[glow=red,2,300]Nae[/glow] Wombat was the only person to vote Aemon, and Aemon and Nae had that whole back-and-forth. It looks like there may be a set up in the works.

 

I did a re-read through of last nights events and although it seemed harmless I would agree I think they were/are attempting a gambit.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Nae[/glow]

[Pookie]

I had a thought about the known-only-to-mafia win condition too.  It goes a little something like this:

 

I've had enough of having nothing, I won't take just anything

I got my mind set on something, all I want is everything

It's my life Mr., I ain't running, I'm no puppet on a string

I want more than I see coming

All I want is everything, all I want is everything

 

Meaning I think they need all the relics for that second win condition.

[ed2funy]

:o

That is either really hard, or doable, depending on how many there are.

 

Also...I will be gone later today for Explorers again. Be back later tonight. :)

[Thorum]

Go with your instincts! We almost had Thorum on the ropes during day one, why was that? Why did we back off? Who was most vocal in defending Thorum? There we will find our scum, people!

 

[glow=red,2,300]VOTE THORUM[/glow]

 

Nice post. Sounds like one I would make. However, I would vote the person defending me too much. And no, I'm not gonna reread 50 pp. right now to find out who that is...

 

For now, I'm voting [glow=red,2,300]aemon[/glow]. For having me scroll through 4 nighttime pages without any real content.