Mafia - A Christmas Tale - Mafia Won

[WWWwombat]

[pre]This game is so confusing.[/pre]

[LilyElizabeth]

Nothing to be confused about. We're sinking, and we need to start bailing fast!

 

 

[WWWwombat]

My bucket has a hole in it =S

[LilyElizabeth]

Well, I'm going to patch mine, and see if we can win this thing!

 

 

[WWWwombat]

You make good points Meesh, but I'm still unsure of you.  If you are mafia, my hat is off to you.  If you are town you have still played a damn good game.

[WWWwombat]

Hey Meesh what are your thoughts on Pale?

[mmeeshal]

Honestly?

 

Honestly and truly the only people I'm absolutely certain of one way or another are myself and the dead folks.  All I have right now are suspicions of pretty much everyone.  Some are stronger than others, but I have NO idea who to trust.

 

Like, I have no reason to mistrust Lily, but she's just pinging me, honestly.  If I can't even be sure our uncontested Finder is who she says she is, and can't really make myself trust Rey and Al Jenn, is it really surprising that I'm not terribly sure of anyone at this point? :D

 

My thoughts on Pale--he could be the Godfather, but again I'm not even sure I trust that Lily's the Finder.  And honestly, if I had to pick one opinion and stand by it, I'd probably say that I think Pale's innocent.  At least, I'm not getting any sort of scum reading of him, because everything he ever says makes sense to me.  However, I don't think I ever HAVE gotten scum vibes from him when he WAS scum.  So while I am kind of banking on his innocence, I have a 50% chance of being completely and utterly wrong.

 

Bah...  All I know is that I can find reasons to suspect each and every one of you of being mafia, legitimately.  What I think, simplified, about Pale is that he's a wild card for me but if I had to choose Pale or Lily as being innocent I'd probably choose Pale right now.

 

If he's mafia, he's probably laughing his head off at me.  But that's just the way it goes.  People look plenty stupid in hindsight, in a mafia game.

[LilyElizabeth]

You'd choose Pale as innocent over me? Wow! That's a surprise. Again, let's see what, if anything, I find tonight. But if you all aren't going to believe me, wow! Just wow! We're dead.

 

 

[mmeeshal]

Well, like I said, I really don't know who or what to believe, honestly.  Locke flipping innocent shook me.  I wasn't chomping at the bit to lynch him, and I wanted to make sure he really was scum so as not to make a mistake, but I was also fairly certain that if anyone was scum, it would be him.  Being so wrong about that scared me, and right now I'm kind of going through a crisis of doubting everything everyone says to the point where if it turned out ALL of you were mafia I wouldn't be surprised.

 

Which I shouldn't be doing; I need to get my act together ASAP, for the Town's sake.

[LilyElizabeth]

I know the feeling. I feel like a switch just flipped, and I'm seeing things more clearly. I feel like I can maybe, just maybe, help save us now. As you know, my confidence took a beating earlier, but I'm over that. Yes, we may lose, and yes, it may be due mostly to me, but I WILL go down fighting!

 

 

[mmeeshal]

Well, hopefully I can get over this and finish off this game strong.  I don't want to be one of the leading reasons for losing the game for the Town either. >.<

[WWWwombat]

What stinks is that we're pretty much at game over with the mafia only using two night kills.  This game sucks -.-

[WWWwombat]

Meesh:  What would/should Fezzick do?

[LilyElizabeth]

What's a Fezzick?

 

 

[Talya]

Again another night. Again the noises and whispering. You wake to find Al Jenn lying on a pool of his own blood. A Snowflake decoration sticking out of his chest where the glitter bended with the blood. It was a shame you knew, but as you look around you realise one person is still missing. There sat by a mirror, looking like she was doing her makeup was Elli. The lipsick was poisoned. No wonder she had been so quiet, she looked like she had been there a while!

 

Al Jenn - an Innocent Mason is Nightkilled

Ellie - A Mafia Roleblocker is Modkilled

 

There are now 8 left, it takes 5 to lynch. I will not set a deadline, just yet!

[WWWwombat]

Ok so I think we lucked out there.  I think if Elli hadn't been modkilled we would've lost.  I take it Lily was unblocked last night and will have a finding for us.  It's LyLo imo so I think if Lily gets a guilty find we all know what to do.

[a pale tanned lover]

Totally agree with you there wombat, hopefully Lily got a guilty viewing, then we're right back in the game.

[mmeeshal]

Heh...can anyone say we got REALLY lucky?

 

Well, Elli being the mafia roleblocker and Al Jenn being an innocent mason helps me with my suspicion list quite a lot, so I'm certainly grateful that those particular people/roles ended up dead (even though it would've been preferable not to lose an innocent at all, things went better than they could've).

 

So now I believe Rey, at least.  And I'm very certain of Lily, too, although, again, I can't rule anything out.  We'll see what she Found for us last night; at this point she has a pretty good chance of having found scum.

 

Oh, about Elli being the roleblocker...she's been inactive for a while, so I guess we know why Lily was roleblocked only the first Night and not the next one.

 

My suspect list (OH and TALYA, there are only 7 of us left, so that's 4 to lynch)...

 

1. Meercat

2. Wombat

3. Pale

4. Zep

5. Lily

6. Rey

7. Meesh

 

I say we go after Meercat; pretty sure we CAN'T go wrong with him.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Meercat[/glow]

[WWWwombat]

Meercatman tops my list too but I'm going to wait for Lily.

[mmeeshal]

Okay, here's the deal.  I'm going to my grandparents' house with my family to visit the extended family for Christmas, and we're coming back tomorrow I believe.

They don't have wi-fi and don't let people use their computer that often, which sucks.  Last time I was up there I found other people's wi-fi networks that weren't secure, so I managed to get internet access with my laptop, but there's no guarantee that I'll be able to do the same this time (since the time before that I wasn't able to find any wi-fi networks at all).

 

Basically, I may possibly not have internet access till tomorrow night...  And my phone's a no-go because it hasn't let me log into DM at all lately. ::)

 

Just a warning.  And it irritates the heck out of me; this isn't a good time for anyone to be missing, when most of us are under equal amounts of suspicion.

 

**edit for Wombat**

*shrugs*

Works for me, but I'm kind of sure you're mafia too, so convenient excuse. ;) :P

[Reyoru]

[glow=red,2,300]meercatman[/glow]

[WWWwombat]

I just don't want to lynch an innocent again.  I think we would lose, before the nk even, if we did that this time around.

[Reyoru]

  Quote

I just don't want to lynch an innocent again.  I think we would lose, before the nk even, if we did that this time around.

 

Scum if I ever saw it. Trying to stop a lynch on a mafia buddy. And its quite interesting how the nk is quite foremost on your mind - been discussing it with your mafia pals on your QT board?

 

Wombat and Meercat are scum.

[mmeeshal]

Might as well do this before I'm dragged out the door...

 

  Quote

Vote Count

 

Meercat (2): Meesh, Rey

 

Not voting: Meercat, Wombat, Pale, Zep, Lily

 

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.  No deadline has currently been set.

 

It makes sense, although I'm quite positive (yes, again) that Meercat is scum; I've been wondering about him for a while.  Hopefully Lily will come on and give us her results, though, so we know what we're looking at here.

 

(oh, you know what would be awful? If Lily viewed Elli. >.<)

 

**edit Rey**

That's pretty much the line of thought I have, although since we still don't know if there are 3 or 2 mafia left, there is still a slim chance that Meercat could be innocent (unlikely, but a possibility).  So I can accept his reasoning although if Meercat flips scum Wombat's next on my list.

[WWWwombat]

It's not unreasonable or scummy to want as much information as is reasonably possible before acting.  Provided Lily doesn't give us another target, I'm totally down with lynching meercatman.  I don't see why him flipping scum would say anything about me seeing as I have been saying I think he's scum for a while now.  Also, I'd be stupid not to think about the nk.