Mafia - A Christmas Tale - Mafia Won

[a pale tanned lover]

Lets not rush into a lynch yet. Reyoru if you are innocent why are you telling people to lynch you and find out? at this stage we can't afford too get the wrong person.

[WWWwombat]

If you get lynched with information you haven't told us it's on you.  All you're giving me are subtle hints to make yourself seem valuable.  It's pretty hard not to think you're scum right now.

[mmeeshal]

Well that's a defeatist attitude.  Just because I don't agree with you (me, just one person), and because you have 2 votes on you, you're going to just stop?  That's not pro-town behavior.  If you're honestly town, you'll go down kicking and screaming, this late in the game.

 

Plus, Day just barely started.  We have till Thursday.  No reason to "give up" so early on in the Day phase.  If you really are Town, you're definitely not acting like it.

 

Since you don't want to carry on with your own argument, I'll do it for you so that if people want to agree with you they'll have a fair chance.

If Lily is lying and is scum, then for one thing there's probably no roleblocker either, which makes it more likely that we're at LYLO (lynch right or lose).  Also, that means Pallet is probably scum too.

 

Honestly, the main problem I have with Rey's scenario is just that if there really is a watcher and/or tracker, with all the suspicion that's been flying around they have to have gained SOME info of value at this point.  And if so, they should have shared it.  They haven't, so I tend to disagree with Rey.

[Reyoru]

I dunno man, just a bit down atm. Got exams in 3 weeks, and have spent a lot of the day doing papers. Its my fault really, I try not to let it affect the game.

 

If there are two people right now I wouldn't vote for, it me and Al Jenn. And that statement may have got me modkilled. Ill say no more on that.

[Reyoru]

In my opinion, Ellianora and Locke are scum. Lurking out of sight, with Locke acting like he doesn't have a clue when he does post in.

[WWWwombat]

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[meercatman]

But would it be smart for a tracker just to reveal himself? wouldn't he just get lynched the next night?

[Reyoru]

I did mention that in my post meercatman

[WWWwombat]

I still suspect you Reyoru, but I'm unvoting just in case.  Saying who you would/wouldn't vote for is something any role can do unless there's a PR.

[mmeeshal]

For someone who is dropping heavy hints of pro-townness, though, you really have been acting scummy.  Although, in light of what you may be hinting at, some things that looked scummy before COULD be seen in a different light.

 

So, if you think Elli and Locke are scum...what do you think of Lily and Pale then?

 

**edit for new posts**

Guys, did you not see what I said?  If a tracker/watcher has information that contradicts Lily's claim, then when all is said and done the Healer can simply protect the tracker/watcher instead of Lily.

 

Simples. (once people have figured out who to believe, of course)

[Locke]

Well, I'm inclined to believe Lily at this point, because that last viewing seemed too obviously suspicious to be anything but truth.  But it's not like we'll be lynching her anyway I guess.

 

I also find it interesting at how little Rey is defending himself.  

 

 

[WWWwombat]

I will continue believing Lily unless there is a counterclaim.

[mmeeshal]

Actually, Eebs, he's defending himself pretty heavily, in a roundabout way.

 

I'm almost starting to believe Rey here.

[Reyoru]

I apologise if I acted scummy.

 

I don't know about Pale - I think he's innocent though. When I put him on the spot a few pages back, he had a good answer.

 

Lily has not been very active. And she is VERY hard to read. She may have been busy with Yule, or not. Dunno.

[Reyoru]

Really Locke?

 

Or are you saying that cos I mentioned you as possible scum?

[Locke]

Well yeah, by not defending himself...

 

lol Rey.  I forgive you for acting scummy :P :D

[Locke]

What in the world are you talking about Rey? ???  Honestly, I wrote that before I read your post of suspicion on me, but I still don't see any correlation anyway.

[Reyoru]

Lol ;)

[Reyoru]

if you did then fair enough, I apologise.

If not, its a simple corelation. I mentioned you as possible Mafia, you then give a reason you think I'm scum.

[WWWwombat]

  Quote

Actually, Eebs, he's defending himself pretty heavily, in a roundabout way.

 

I'm almost starting to believe Rey here.

 

Why?  He still hasn't said anything convincing imo.

[a pale tanned lover]

Remember Crusher?

[WWWwombat]

Yeah, what about him?

[Reyoru]

And I won't. I've told my suspicions, my motives and probably will be modkilled as a result of one of my statements. Kill me if you want - I already think this game is beyond our winning. Which is a shame as there are some good active players who could save the game if we worked together. Unfortunately, I look scummy and so this post will simply be treated as a bluff.

 

You can't say I haven't tried.

[mmeeshal]

Okay, guys, now that the discussion has moved on from what it was when I started typing, I just wasted a few minutes of my life.  Thanks guys.

 

Crusher was a Mason, Wombat.

[Locke]

  Quote

if you did then fair enough, I apologise.

If not, its a simple corelation. I mentioned you as possible Mafia, you then give a reason you think I'm scum.

 

I wasn't giving a reason I suspect you.  What I said was actually something that made you less suspicious in my mind.

 

I'm actually inclined to believe you, because I've thought to do the same thing you just did.