Newbie Mafia Game Over!

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Peace, that is weak. And reeks of scum.

 

Wasn't you the one who stated that the "real" doctor should not reveal.

 

Way to pull a rabbit out of your hat.

[peacesells]

Peace, that is weak. And reeks of scum.

 

Wasn't you the one who stated that the "real" doctor should not reveal.

 

Way to pull a rabbit out of your hat.

 

Yeah, it was me..I'm playing 4 games right now and I forgot I was the doctor in this game.  No matter...either way you are lynched today or tommorrow...althoug if I get lynched the real doctor is gone.

[LilyElizabeth]

Well, I'm officially confused. I guess it's time to go with my gut, and since I'm already pretty sure who three mafia are, I'm going with it for now. Hope I'm right. I don't think any of you more experienced players answered my question about how many mafia we likely have in a game this size. Or maybe I just forgot. So, what's it likely to be?

 

 

 

 

[peacesells]

I think you guys need to to sit back and think..."what if you were the doctor and there was a doctor claim on day one." 

 

Would you want to counter claim day or would you try and find a way to get the scum/liar lynched without claiming?  This is what I did...but seeing how I am at L-1 I was forced to claim. 

 

Tayla..I'm hoping you can see this at least.

[LilyElizabeth]

Peace, I think you waited too long. Even if you are telling the truth, there are only 7 hours left, and that's probably not long enough for enough people to change their votes. The one with the highest votes get lynched, whether or not it's a majority, remember?

 

I would love to see what Talya and Dae have to say, but I don't know if they'll check in in time.

 

 

[peacesells]

You are probably right..doesn't help that there hasn't been much other activity today..just about 4 of us actually participating.

 

My only hope is that the Dragon lynch went through..otherwise your doctor is bye bye.

 

Also...If I get lynched I'll bet a million bucks I know who gets NK'd tonight.  It won't be LZP, Lilly or Tayla.

[LedZepMan]

I am utterly confused now.

 

I don't know what to do.

 

Bamboozeled 0_o

[LedZepMan]

Also...If I get lynched I'll bet a million bucks I know who gets NK'd tonight.  It won't be LZP, Lilly or Tayla.

 

Is that a referance to me being a mafioso?

 

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Oh, wow! I missed that completely. Did he just call us mafia? *laughs*

 

If I was mafia, I wouldn't be so worried about whether or not we made a mistake. I'd know. lol

 

 

[a pale tanned lover]

Yeah Peace you left the reveal too long unless Cosmicpanda does an automatic lynch.

 

I left my vote on Dragon anyway so didn't have anything to say before, and i was in bed when you revealed.

 

Like Talya said earlier whoever has left their vote on Dragon should be looked at closely! Well if Peace is the doctor then those with votes on him should be looked at more closely.

 

 

[Talya]

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

 

I'm sure we still have time.

 

Okay, now the problem is. Is Peace telling the truth that he is Healer and he forgot this. It would explain why he first told everyone to unvote Dragon, then suddenly U turned. I can understand where he is coming from when you are in more than 1 mafia game, but it is also a good place to hide your actions.

 

He did right in only revealing now though. When he was one lynch away, before would have looked too much like mafia.

 

I think I strongly moving towards Dragon as being Mafia, but at this stage I'm not goin to vote for either. I'm not sure what the vote count is at present, and I don't know who else will see this to change but I'm going to go with [glow=red,2,300]APTL[/glow] purely because he last had most points (sorry sweetie :-*)

 

I don't like to tell the finder who to check, but you certainly have two good candidates tonight. Which ever one you choose you are either going to come up with a mafia or healer. Which ever one is the other will be the other. (hopefully, unless they are both mafia, but I don't want to go down that road).

 

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Talya, I will do the same. That leaves Pale, Peace, and Dragon all tied with 3 votes, though, if I'm right. I don't see how that helps. *shrug* I'm following your lead, because I don't want to lynch the healer, and hopefully, it's one of those two....lol. Maybe someone else will come on in time and change their vote, too.

[glow=red,2,300]

Unvote Peace

Vote Pale or APTL[/glow]

(nothing personal, sweetie. You're just the only one who could possibly be sacrificed instead of one of those two.)

 

 

 

 

[a pale tanned lover]

Well i am innocent but Talya is right i have the second most votes so if you have time then vote for me to save who i believe as the doctor, better for the town that way.

[LilyElizabeth]

Less than an hour to go, and we still have a three-way tie, unless my calculations are off. This is a real cliffhanger!

 

Goodnight all. I'm not waiting up to see how it turns out. Betcha I dream about it, though....lol

 

 

[cosmicpanda]

Vote Count!

 

APTL (3) Green Shirt, Talya, Lily

Talya (1) Rose

DS (3) APTL, LZM, Peace

Peace (3) DS, Midori, Dae

 

Not Voting: Meesh

 

Deadline

 

Back from my trip now! Hope everyone had a good time.

 

My rules state that in the event of a tie, nobody dies. As there is a three-way tie, there is therefore no lynch.

 

It is now Night! Send in night actions ASAP.

 

Normally in my games I don't allow days to proceed after the majority; however, as was pointed out, I failed to include that in my rules this time. That was a major slip on my part. I decided that I couldn't enforce a rule I hadn't included, so I allowed the unvotes. However, this rule is now included and is in full effect. In the future, once the hammer vote is cast, the game enters twilight. I will edit this into the first post. Sleep well!

[LedZepMan]

ok, so its night now. Lets see who gets nk'd

[mnwhiterose]

Oh my.....votes, unvotes....It's enough to make my head spin. And we have 2 doctor claims?

 

Sorry I haven't been around this round, folks. I work the State Fair in MN and I've been working 16 hour days and haven't really had a chance to get online.

[Daetirion]

Dammit, i don't pay attention for a day and that happens?

 

So much for newbies games being easy folks. Trust me, day 1 is not normally like that.

[peacesells]

Dragon..who are you killing tonight?  I need to know whether to protect myself of APTL?

[peacesells]

Everyone, look really close to who voted for APTL..(dragon was the first) they should be high on everyone's suspicion list.  Dragon tried to get something going on APTL when it looked like his false claim was going through...pretty much confirms an innocent in my mind.

 

So..Tayla..have anything to say about that?

 

If APTL is night killed tonight...it's the scum taken care of their scum slip and getting rid of a confirmed innocent.

[Talya]

I can't see how you get a confirmed innocent from that. Unless I get the coroners report on death I won't believe anything. That inculdes you, Dragon and aptl. And anyone else for that matter.

 

I went with aptl, to prevent either you or Dragon from being lynched. Not becaue I thought he was guilty, but I would rather save a roled player than a nonroled player.

 

Why should those who voted for aptl be on everyone's suspicion list. you seem to be so pushing eyes away from yourself, just assuming everyone thinks that you are the healer.

 

I still think that both of you (dragon and you) claimed in odd ways, so you are both looking suspicious. Dragon was looking more suspicious before, but you seem to be pushing stuff that is just starting to ring as too pushy!

[peacesells]

Who would you know that the vote would end in a tie?  But..if that is the case..TYVM.  :)

 

BTW...from my perspective (and obviously you can't see it) dragon is absolutely scum and he tried to get APTL lynched after his role claim.  Once everything comes out (either my death or his) this will be very apparent.  I wanted to make sure this was known so that if I get lynched tommorrow then at least it won't be in vain..I'll have contributed to the scum hunt.

 

 

[Talya]

Well you may well be right, but I won't know untill I see that cornoners as I said before.

 

What does TYVM mean, I don't like acronyms!

[Talya]

As for knowing that it would be a tie, I didn't. But all I knew was that aptl did have votes on him. but with all the voting and unvoting I wasn't sure and didn't have time to check. I hoped someone else might come in and do something too.

 

I didn't want the healer (whoever it maybe to die) so did all I could in the time that was available. I wasn't sure if it would have worked at all, but it looks like it did!

 

If I had left my vote on you, or not voted you would be gone! So if Dragon is mafia as you have said, I haven't helped him at all by trying to save you

[peacesells]

TYVM = thank you very much.

 

And...that makes sense...sorry I didn't see it before.