Create-Your-Own-Role Mafia II - Game Over

[Jeran]

Cat, I'd definitely like to hear more about your vote on FDM.

[Myndrunner]

Keep trying to build that case, CUBA, but you see....dragonsworn's role was pretty much confirmed, whereas everyone else except the messenger were as of yet unidentified.  If I had any protective capabilities, I would have protected him more than ANYONE. 

 

And here is my second thought.  I think its well established that I have a notorious reputation in these games.  Wouldn't you all agree?  Everyone typically suspects me of being mafia on Day one....except the Mafia themselves because they know who is and who isn't mafia.

 

So I ask you....why protect me if, in the eyes of innocent players, I'm likely mafia?

[Naeann]

This is the craziest thing I've seen you do yet Mynd.  You are majorly attacking someone who protected you because he thought you were innocent.  Are you just peeved that you couldn't use your role because of it?

[Thorum]

[glow=red,2,300]Cuba[/glow].

 

Because Mynd makes sense for once  :P

 

Carwyn ... Can you elaborate a bit more please?

Merci beaucoup.

[Verbal32]

[glow=red,2,300]CUBA[/glow]

 

I'm going more with the retaliation (OMGUS) vote rather than agreeing with Mynd.  I already said that once, and I'm afraid the world might spontaneously end if I say it again. O_O

[Thorum]

We all mustn't forget that there's a second and a possible third healer.

 

Too bad cuba hasn't mentioned that as a reasoning for not protecting that important role ;D

[Blig Blog]

Well I for one do not agree with Mynd, I still think that something is up with MN. If you pay attention to her then you might see what I see. Although I don't think that the tide will turn enough from CUBA to get enough people on MN I'm going to vote on who I think is Mafia: [glow=red,2,300]MN[/glow].

[Thorum]

Why mn? She was almost my random vote, before I read Mynd's thought thoroughly.

 

Without giving reasoning, that vote will certainly never overtake cuba's

[Blig Blog]

Take a look at how she's playing this game and how she played the last game that she was in. She didn't defend herself or even say a thing about my post after I first voted for her and she just kind of stayed back, lurking if you ask me.

 

CUBA, I think just made an honest mistake. I'm just saying: take a closer look at MN.

[mnwhiterose]

You always seem to think that I am mafia.  Very interesting. And, you seem more interested in metagaming than finding mafia. The last game we played has nothing to do with this game.

 

Now, if you will bring proof as to why you think I am mafia, I am certainly more than willing to discuss my defense with you.  But, you seem to be more interested in playing the different games and game styles against each other rather than play just this game.

 

You smell rather fishy to me.

[CUBAREY]

Well looks like I am headed for the gallows, Mynd yet again bamboozos the townies into killing one of their own. But a couple of things that players should keep in mind.

 

I believed Dragonswordn suspicous and most likely mafia, since Mynyou were his main accuser I protected Mynd (Its highly unlikely that the Mafia would have killed their own man especially when there are multiple finders and doctors in the game). Again why is Mynd so upset that I protected him since he would have been the obvious target for the Mafia if Dragonsworn had been Mafia himself. Now I protected Mynd while forgetting Dragonsworn's role as a Finder but ask yourselfs why Mynd is so hot and bothered by my choice since frankly the Doctors should have assured that Dragonsworn was protected if his role was that important in this particular game.

 

In fact a suggestion for townies to think about, does more then one Mafia player have the ability to appear innocent even when targeted by a Finder (usually only  the Godfather is, but if its restricted only to one Mafia player then the multiple Finer roles in the game would seem to unfairly and seriously tip the odds of the game towards the Town).

 

Oh, Mynd you and your Mafia buddies should know something about the role I submitted (you know the one entitled CENSORED). You not only have a Mafia buddy with the ability to kill seperately, he also is a Solo win player with some rather interesting powers that can be used against other Mafia. So protect your back, one of you is a fink besides being Mafia.

 

 

[Blig Blog]

I "always" seem to think that you are mafia? Ha! I thought you were mafia last game, yes but that was because we had REAL good evidence against you. And this is the second game I've ever played with you, I think that you're mafia this time just based on a real strong feeling and the way you're playing the field right now. I might be metagaming but I'm sure as heck sure on this one. I'll find some evidence on you somehow and bring you down...or find out that you're really innocent and leave you alone, which I doubt will happen.

 

Oh and the last game has nothing to do with this game? True. But you didn't say anything of the sort when people were talking about the game you were in before that, how you weren't playing the "I'm just a noob who made a mistake" thing that you did last game that you and I were in. I'll stop talking about other games, all I was saying was that I wanted people to see how your play style has changed.

 

Plus, now you're defending yourself after I said something about you not doing so...and, to me, you were obviously lurking...and you're defending quite strongly now.

[cosmicpanda]

Votecount:

 

Cubarey (4) - Mynd, Rose, Thorum, Verbal

Far (1) - Gus

Mynd (1) - Cubarey

Rose (1) - Blig Blog

 

Not voting: Lia, FDM, Jeran, Nae

 

With 11 alive, it takes six to lynch.

 

deadline

[Myndrunner]

Again why is Mynd so upset that I protected him since he would have been the obvious target for the Mafia if Dragonsworn had been Mafia himself.

 

Ah, but I wasn't the target!  Perhaps I was supposed to be the target for lynching today in hopes that a DS kill would lead people to suspect me.  FAIL!  I think that your mafia plan is crumbling apart and a lynch on you will prove this.  I am surprised that Nae is refusing to vote you.

 

And Blig and Rose? is it?  "Kivam's Gambit - U R DOING IT WRONG!"  ;D

[Far Dareis Mai]

Cuba you have to admit that it is suspect that it completely slipped your mind to protect DS when he spent the entire night phase railing against how the mafia were going to kill him because he was a Finder. It is entirely possible it did slip your mind; and I would absolutely allow for that possibility if it were Day 5 and there was so much information being swirled around that it can sometimes make your head spin...but on Night 1? Unlikely. Therefore, I vote [glow=red,2,300]Cuba[/glow].

[Jeran]

I'm almost ready to vote Cuba for the same reasons that others have stated, but I'm still hoping to hear from Cat.  I'm not in a hurry since there is almost a full day to go.

[Myndrunner]

 

After putting a couple of pieces together I and definitely stand by my original vote. >_<

 

[glow=red,2,300]FDM[/glow]

 

Yeah, this post does disturb me.  Carywn? Did you get a finder role and some info to go with it? 

[Naeann]

I'm not refusing to vote him... I just know how you work and am not entirely sold on YOUR innocence.

[Myndrunner]

I'm not refusing to vote him... I just know how you work and am not entirely sold on YOUR innocence.

 

Good, you are not sold on my innocence.  So you do see why CUBA choosing to protect me was quite odd, right?

[Naeann]

So are you saying you are mafia?

[Myndrunner]

Nope, I am saying that for someone who suspects me as mafia, it is odd that you do NOT find Cuba's poor choice in protection a bit....scummish.  I think you are defending him because it was your plan all along to set me up for DS's demise, and now it is backfiring.

[Naeann]

I just dont understand why you are mad that you were protected.  There are other finder roles out there... I had one last night.

 

 

So.. if I think YOU scummy... I should think Cub scummy because he DIDN'T think you scummy last night and therefore protected you?  YOU thought DS was scummy last night.. perhaps, in a moment of weakness, Cub agreed with you that DS was scummy.. and didn't even think about the fact that we would lose the role DS had.  He was solely looking out for NOT protecting who he thought was scum.  Makes logical sense to me [glow=red,2,300]Mynd[/glow].

[Liathiana]

I"m not sure when I"ll be back tomorrow, so I'll have to vote tonight. Mynd is definitely on my suspicious list but I'm not finding him as scummy as [glow=red,2,300]Cuba[/glow].

[cosmicpanda]

That's a lynch!

 

Cubarey, a townie, is lynched.

 

Send in night actions.

[Jeran]

Okay I'm confused.  If Cuba was the Hooker on Day/Night 1 then how come he died as the Illusionist?  Did he skip over CENSORED?