Ship Wreck Mafia - game thread-

[Kivam]

Sorry Tigs - but at least you were roleless.  About as much as we could hope for day 1

[Barmacral]

Told you so.

 

*le sigh* Well, we're over a 100 posts into the game now.

[bcxanth]

Holy crap, we are. You people are spamming machines.  I love you all. :D

[DPR]

 

Jeez, now I feel bad for Tigs. Sorry bout that whole "cocoanut" thing (technically, cocoa nuts would be seeds and very small though. Kind of a weird choice, but then, that's just how I roll, evidently).

Good thing I didn't wonk him with a coconut! Gotta save those to fill up with rum! *raises a toast to Tigs*

[bcxanth]

I have no idea what you're talking about Wes...

 

*whistles innocently*

[DPR]

 

*flicks a seed at bcx*  ::)

[Guest nephitess]

*twaps DPR* No abusing the mod. TISK TISK....

[Alys Kinch]

'tis night. shhhhhh! i'm trying to sleep off the bad choice.

[Naeann]

Nephi and Bcx... I'm going to be on a short LOA.. They finally got my apartment ready so tommorow I am moving and I will get the computer hooked up and hopefully back online asap but i use a dial up connection so it will be when they get that setup.. Im just posting this in case it isnt a quick fix.

[Guest nephitess]

NP hun!

 

For Every one else *coughnightactionscough*  ;)

[Kivam]

Nephi - here:

 

*edit - damn, it was an image of a Ricola*

[Alys Kinch]

link do not workses.

[bcxanth]

Hey guys. Sorry I'm running late. work has been killer today. We'll be sending out night actions and getting the scene posted soon.

[bcxanth]

You wake up with a worried feeling deep in your gut. In one day you'd gone from cruising on a luxury boat to stranded on a tropical island, two of your fellow castaways have ended up dead, and there was a murderer somewhere amongst you.  Not even knowing what to expect you rise from your spot on the ground and see the others doing the same.  Everyone looks around, scared at what might be found.  Slowly though everyone relaxes. Nobody else has died... yet.

 

It is now Day 2.  The day will last until 8pm MST on Monday 1/14.

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[Barmacral]

Well, thats a good sign. Or a bad one, either way, it tells us nothing.

[Vemynal]

so either we have a good healer or an evil group that likes to play head games, if the later then we likely have an advanced evil on the evil team, but with to little evidence voting an experienced player on such is irresponsible.

 

*BUT* since I still think kivam was acting weird on day 1 and was planning to vote him anyways off the bat its simply an added bonus.

 

[glow=red,2,300]kivam[/glow]

[Talya]

It is a shame about Tigs. Sorry :-[

 

However, no kill last night cannot be anything but good for us. I don't why the evil team would hold out for a night kill. So we have a good/lucky healer. That or there is something else at work that prevented a kill, but that will give me a headache this early in the morning to think about it.

 

 

Will have to give some more thought to who I think may be evil.

:-\

[MsDanya]

I hate nights who tell us nothing.

[Leelou]

It's worse since it is the first night.  :-\

[DPR]

Well, thats a good sign. Or a bad one, either way, it tells us nothing.

 

Not exactly nothing - Vemy's theory is one way to look at things, and it could be the start of an elaborate plan put forth by experienced players. It could also be a sign that we have a number of complex roles like in the last few games (It did not escape my notice that two mods can much more effectively handle an elaborate setup than just one). At least we did not lose anyone, so the night wasn't a total loss. We just have to be careful now and try to hit a mafia with the next lynch. There something in one of the last few posts that pinged me, so I'm going back for another look....

[Alys Kinch]

my son's birthday is today, so i won't likely make another appearance until late, if I even get back.

 

I think we have both an experienced team and complex roles...

[Kison]

*BUT* since I still think kivam was acting weird on day 1 and was planning to vote him anyways off the bat its simply an added bonus.

 

[glow=red,2,300]kivam[/glow]

 

Do you mind going into detail on why you believe Kivam was acting out of the ordinary?

 

i really don't want to kill kivam; i want to play with him. and barm is too much fun to lose early

 

Do not lose this quote if any of those three come up scum.

 

Day One suspicions usually are misled. Unfortunate we had no kill last night.

 

My vote will be based upon the response I get from Vemynal.

 

That is all.

[Vemynal]

kivam is an intelligent player, and he knows my play style as well. i've never been afraid to put a vote on someone to get things started in this game and to be quite honest thats all my vote on him was at first. it put the votes at 2 for kivam, 2 for barm and 1 for DPR, nothing threatening.

 

But he came out very hard from the get go, launching into how i always follow at his heels and agree with him, for some reason he had a vested interest in seeing me dead for a rather frivilious vote, very unlike how I've seen him play in any of the games I've played (and I've yet to see him as evil).

 

In any event thats my reason, he acted out of the ordinary for himself

 

maybe not the best reason, but I haven't seen any other.

[Barmacral]

Its good in the respect that we have a little more time to figure out who's evil, however, it is bad because after the first night, it doesn't tell us enough. We've got essentially nothing to go on, and the results of the night have kept it that way.

[Kivam]

so either we have a good healer or an evil group that likes to play head games, if the later then we likely have an advanced evil on the evil team, but with to little evidence voting an experienced player on such is irresponsible.

 

*BUT* since I still think kivam was acting weird on day 1 and was planning to vote him anyways off the bat its simply an added bonus.

 

[glow=red,2,300]kivam[/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vemy[/glow] is again gunning for me, which is very out of character for him.  In fact, Vemy's typical first day is flitting around spamming the thread and generally not "moving the game along as quickly as possible" (which is his explanation for the vote.

 

Definitely not narrowing down the kill zone to two, which is pretty much what happened once he named me (and made me equal to Barm, which is why I'm seeing links there).

 

Also, the idea that an evil team would deliberately choose not to kill to play headgames makes no sense.  As an evil, you want to narrow the field quickly, hopefully killing the finder before he can reveal and provide information, and at the very least moving closer to end-game.  Doing nothing at night literally does nothing for the evil team.  And the fact that Vemy is posting such an obviously illogical theory this early really has my antennae up.

 

All in all - sorry, Vem, but right now you're the most suspicious guy on the island, by my count.

 

Anyone have a better candidate?