Ship Wreck Mafia - game thread-

[Talya]

Just a thought I had...what if Kivam made a call for the healer to protect Barm, knowing that by doing that the healer will not follow that order thinking that they were being led into protecting someone they didn't know for definate was an innocent. If Kivam is evil, he may well know who the healer is. Why you ask, becasue we didn't have a kill night one...it could have been that the healer did save the person the evils went for...themselves, so the evils would have a good idea who the evil was...I know its a bit thin. The only other reason for him trying to get the healer to protect Barm, (using the logic that the healer isn't likely to go for someone that looks suspicious's demands). He also announces to the evils that Barm needs to go...mentioning he has a role...so maybe a symp. I prefer the first reason.

 

The others that have caught my eye was Naeann for going with Barm second. At this point my vote on Barm was not bothering anyone... :-\...the same with Wes...Also I have to agree with Leelou about Alys, but I don't feel as strongly.

 

The only reason I don't want to go with Kivam, is because I'm sure he would have been checked out by the finder...except if the finder thinks that the evils know who the healer is and is laying low, which I don't blame them.

 

So I'm still not sure who to go for...so I will go for [glow=red,2,300]Kivam[/glow] for now.

[Kivam]

Hmm . . . two of the more suspicious folks piling onto me.  Am I shocked? No, I am not.

 

This game likely has 3 evil team members.  At the moment, I'm pretty sure Talya is one of them.

 

what if Kivam made a call for the healer to protect Barm, knowing that by doing that the healer will not follow that order thinking that they were being led into protecting someone they didn't know for definate was an innocent.

 

Could someone please explain to me how I could know that the healer would not protect Barm?  Or why I would even think that they would do that?  The only possible reason would be because if the healer blocked the night one night kill, then the evils know who the healer is, and know that the healer has to protect themselves each night.

 

Except, if that were my thought process, I wouldn't need to ask for barm to be protected and hope the healer ignores me.  I'd just nightkill barm, secure in the knowledge that the healer was protecting himself.

 

And, FYI, if I were evil and did ask the healer to protect Barm, I would have aimed the nightkill at [glow=green]the healer[/glow] since that's worth more to me than a dead mason, and the odds of getting blocked would be 50-50 anyway.

 

So . . .

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow] has voted for our only confirmed innocent, after he was confirmed innocent

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow] has repeatedly justified her votes with badly flawed logic

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow] is evil

[Talya]

By saying it Kivam you were trying to make yourself look innocent...like I said my opinion :-\

[bcxanth]

Current Vote Count:

 

Leelou (1): Kison

Talya (1): Kivam

Alys (1): Leelou

Kivam (2): Soyo, Talya

 

Not Voting: Danya, Loki, Alys, Naeann, Wes.

 

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

 

Day 3 ends Today at 9pm MST

[loki redfern]

actually kivam , iiv been thinking kinda along the same lines just i hadnt actually worked out how to say yet.. we know that there was no night kill on night one. on night two there was, so the evil team has night killing aspect to there role, so on night one either they were role-blocked though i cant see that role being used on the first night, or they targeted the person being protected by the healer..and on the first night thats most likely going to be the healer? then the very next day you say , what was it  'the healer must at all costs protect becky' ..which would leave the healer unprotected while the evils know who they are... now without the minor flaw that the evils whent for becky of after you so helpfully pointed him out but the healer didnt notice you would be cert evil in my mind

 

however we dont have a dead healer, unless they are making very ambiguos corener hints here so there are two options

 

1) you are a symping symp who symps and we should basically ignore you the rest of the game, because as some one ,was it you prehaps? , said symps still count as innocents, so for the time being we might as well leave you be

 

2)this is a nice double bluff and your evil as sin and recon  by killing becky you got yourself a bit of rope to cling to

 

(or 2b you are actuallly innocennt and doing a really really bad job of it)

 

though my money is on the first option here so ill leave kivam for the mo i dont know maybe ill change my mind later .. like if i remeber all the time you keep miss quoting me on second day voting :P

 

and  ...   

 

 

 

kivam gets to votes? no fair :P

 

 

now where was i.. oh aye, and .. hmm [glow=red,2,300]alys[/glow] .. your laying lowness scares me a little and er ..what the other person who voted for you said :-*

[Kivam]

Shabbos is starting soon, so I won't be around to find out if I'm dead until Sat. Night.  If I am . . . well, go innocents.  And FTR, if I were a betting man, I'd say some combination of Talya, Boyo, Loki and Danya were our 3 evils, with Leelou also a possibility.

 

Of course I'm probably completely wrong, but that's where I'm currently leaning.  Have fun, y'all

[Alys Kinch]

you are intent on talya, but i'm thinking danya or boyo....

[MsDanya]

??? ??? ??? I posted here!!!

 

blah

 

anyways, I voted [glow=red,2,300]Talya [/glow]

[Talya]

Oky so I've had a think. I might be dead before morning, so just as long as you all know.

 

I am the Healer, I'm not sure if the evils have been pushing me to claim this, but I have thought abot it. If I do survive I only have one night for the finder, which isn't good news for them. So I don't think they should reveal under any circumstances. The evils already know who I am because they tried to kill me night one. And mostly a healer will save themselves night one as they have no idea who maybe innocent and guilty.

 

The other reason I bring it up is because, I really couldn't see how they were saying Barm was innocent...sorry I didn't know what the Masons were...so if they knew someone was innocent I assumed they must have been evil..I was totally wrong.

 

Now the intereting thing is, is that Kivam called for the healer to heal Barm...If he is guilty then he would have known I wouldn't go for him, becasue I was sure Barmy was evil. I thought they may have been trying to get me to choose Barm, so that they could kill me, and I would be no us to the finder at all. They have known who I am and now you all do, either way...claiming or not I will have just one night to save the finder when they reveal..hence don't do it until you have some evils. (to the finder).

 

I think Kivam is either a symp or an evil and I can't make my mind up which he is...at the moment I'm not sure what to do and time is running out. But I leave it up to you, I have no way to prove who I am...

[bcxanth]

The sun begins to descend from it's mid-day peak as evening slowly approaches. Suddenly darkness descends upon the whole campsite. You freeze, afraid to move. You look wildly about you but cannot see anything except blackness.  Suddenly a feeling of being completely carefree fills you. Nothing else matters except maintaining that happy feeling. Then just as suddenly it stops. The feeling is gone, and day is returned. Everyone stares with open-mouthed astonsishment at what just happened.

[Alys Kinch]

Current Vote Count:

 

Leelou (1): Kison

Talya (1): Kivam, Danya

Alys (1): Leelou Loki

Kivam (2): Soyo, Talya

 

Not Voting: Alys, Naeann, Wes.

 

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

 

Day 3 ends Today at 9pm MST

 

which means we are going to end up with a random unless someone jumps in here. i am not since my vote won't help the goings on and i'd prefer not hinder. also, i am contested. i don't dispute that i should be from the outside pov.

[MsDanya]

hey BCX or Nephi, could you add how many hours left when you write when days start and end and stuff? cause i'm lazy  :P

[loki redfern]

er yeh that would help the stupid people (i.e. like me)

[DPR]

Why are my posts not making it through?

[SBoydW]

Day ends in a little more than 5 hours

[DPR]

OK - I think I have it fixed now. I'm on the road and access has been hard to find. I posted earlier, but it did not show. It was before Talya revealed and I have not have time to go through everything thoroughly. I'm doing a read through now, but I have an biz dinner tonight. I'll be back as soon as I can.

[Alys Kinch]

good luck, wes. and yep. nearly 5 hours.

[MsDanya]

ok, forgot to [glow=red,2,300]unvote [/glow].  i'm still not going to vote for Kivam tho, not convinced he's evil.

[bcxanth]

Current Vote Count:

Leelou (1): Kison

Talya (1): Kivam

Alys (1): Leelou Loki

Kivam (2): Soyo, Talya

 

Not Voting: Alys, Naeann, Wes, Danya.

 

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

 

Day 3 ends Today at 9pm MST, in approx 1 hr 15 mins

[Guest nephitess]

okie...i'll try and remember to do that for you guys. *nods*

 

well well...we have some progress here don't we BCX?? *weg*

[Kison]

If it is not too late,

 

[glow=red,2,300]Alys Kinch[/glow]

 

Because,

 

1) Kivam's time has not yet come

 

2) I dislike no-lynches, especially caused by tied votes

 

3) She was a little odd earlier in the game

[bcxanth]

Bah. Sorry guys, realized I estimated the time wrong earlier. Forgot I'm 2 hours ahead of nephi, not 1. :P

 

Game ends at 9pm MST/11pm EST, approx 1 hr 20 mins from now.

[Guest nephitess]

Current Vote Count:

 

Leelou (1): Kison

Talya (1): Kivam

Alys (3): Leelou, Loki, Kison

Kivam (2): Soyo, Talya

 

Not Voting: Alys, Naeann, Wes, Danya.

 

[glow=green,2,300]ONE HOUR TWENTY MINUTES.[/glow] Any last minute votes...*looks at the non voters*

[bcxanth]

About 15 mins left folks.

[Guest nephitess]

there has been a lot of debate today. Many veiled threats and musings. A few quiet members of your group speak up and make their voices heard. Three people though want to make their point known. Loki, Leelou and Kison surround Alys and take the rope that was used to kill Barm. They put it around her neck. Alys is silent and and the look in her eyes says "you'll be sorry"

 

A minute later Alys is swinging in the breeze. You let her down when you are sure she is dead. you find nothing on her to implicate her as a killer.

 

[glow=pink,2,300]Alys an Innocent[/glow] has been lynched. It is now night.

 

Night will end at 6pm MST. 21 hours aprox. 

 

[glow=red,2,300]Night actions please.[/glow]