Camp Dreadfall Mafia Game -- GAME OVER -- MAFIA WIN!

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

5 minutes ago, DPR said:

Sin did flip Goon. I’m not understanding what you’re saying here

Not at EoD. By flipping Darthe it made it look like SD had the better role so was more likely to be blocked/whatever at night. 

5 minutes ago, DPR said:

 

 

This is the 4th or 5th time you’ve made a point to imply I’m not telling the truth, which is fine, but you also keep pushing the “mafia holstered” scenario. 
 

You just keep driving away from the most obvious conclusions. Why?

I'm trying to look at all the possibilities. We can say mafia must have tried to kill DPR or Ed, so they must be one or the two blocked players. But that is making an assumption and if that assumption is wrong it gets very close to the end of the game. 

[DPR]

4 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

If DPR is lying. He was pushing for people to claim roles so he would know who to "block". I'd still get no result. DPR holsters or tries to kill Turin. He doesn't kill Ed as as long as DPR is core town Ed just helps thin the herd out quicker. He choses Turin as he is the one most after Dice. Is the interaction with Darthe "no Wes doesn't make those mistakes" distancing. It felt a bit forced to me. 

 

But again, no way of resolving outside of checking the pockets of a dead pirate. 

 

Sighs. It really looks like anyone lying has no impact on anything else. Except for Ed where we need another explanation of Teph's death. 

This is really something. 
 

I’m surprised Turin hasn’t already jumped into this mud puddle with you to splash around 🤣
 

 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

1 minute ago, DPR said:

This is really something. 
 

I’m surprised Turin hasn’t already jumped into this mud puddle with you to splash around 🤣
 

 

Such a forced smiley! So it was you in the Ballroom with the Candlestick! I knew it! 

[DPR]

2 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Not at EoD. By flipping Darthe it made it look like SD had the better role so was more likely to be blocked/whatever at night. 

I'm trying to look at all the possibilities. We can say mafia must have tried to kill DPR or Ed, so they must be one or the two blocked players. But that is making an assumption and if that assumption is wrong it gets very close to the end of the game. 

SD has been the most suspected player the entire game - ed was most likely to solve SD. Not a big stretch there 

[DPR]

3 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Such a forced smiley! So it was you in the Ballroom with the Candlestick! I knew it! 

Whatever you say 🤣

[dicetosser1]

3 hours ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

I think Key had changed the order of the players so the top voted player was on top each time. But still kind of panicky not to see that. Or you still had sleep in your eyes, lol. 

 

On that note I'm getting coffee. It would be really great if we could find someone that could clear more than one person with their flip.

panicky works.  I was worried she missed my vote.

 

 

25 minutes ago, Tigraine said:

I have a zoom meeting at 8:30 for my kid to enroll in summer blind camp (i didn't know that was a thing).  

 

I'll be back after.  

 

yep they are a thing.  Even been shown in movies like Mask.

 

hope your kids ready for sports! They’re liable to end up playing blind cricket or baseball .  There probably others.  My dad went to a blind school and played blind cricket and the same principles apply fairly easily to baseball
 

22 minutes ago, DPR said:

dice jumped from SD (goon) to Darthe (Bus Driver), so it’s the opposite of what you said I think lol

nah she said it right. Former was referring to SD.  
 

 

@Turin Turambar  I thought I quoted you question but apparently not

 

i wasn’t not voting SD because I town read him.  I hadn’t minded his play and was leaning town but he hadn’t done anything that made me snap my fingers and go he’s town!  I didn’t mind his kickstart to the game. The tarot thing jogged a memory of someone doing that like that before so that seemed like consistent meta, considering I think I’ve only played with him once and I only realised that with the tarot jogging my memory

 

in fact that what I voted Ed about at the start. I was going to vote sd cause we’d been around so long yet never played together.

 

anyways. I thought he handled the pressure well.

 

but why I wouldn’t vote him was more about how his train happened. Not that it was quick or anything but there just didn’t seem to be any resistance to it yet it wasn’t like everyone was in consensus about “let’s lynch sd!”

[Ithillian Turambar]

Official Vote Count

 

Heavy (1) - Dice

 

Not Voting (5): Heavy, Tig, Turin, Eddie, DPR

 

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

 

Day 3 Deadline

[dicetosser1]

32 minutes ago, DPR said:

Why are you a WIFOM machine this morning?? Lol, you’ve made multiple posts that have cut through the clutter but now you want to explore all the angles? 

because he’s freaking out and getting desperate.  There was a post early that showed that

 

 

30 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

If Sinister had flipped goon, would not make it much more likely that he had "misunderstood the rules" to save a better role? So Dice getting Darthe to flip increases the WIFOM and makes it more likely SD would be blocked. Which may be why the other mafia handed in the NK. Which aligns with Dice. Or me, but in that case you can eliminate one and shoot the other. 

what?

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

I feel bad about DPR. 

 

So much feels wrong, especially his role claim. I'd say it isn't a worry as even if we lose three this D/N cycle he then has to show his double vote. Unless he has a mafia double vote or an assassination like Gud had. Then either he will appear lock clear on the last day or we'll likely lose 4 townies and not make it to the last day. 

 

Because the last mafia role must something. Maybe not hugely overpowered, but constant commuter and constant Vig are pretty powerful even if they can get in the way of Town as well. 

 

So maybe DPR is worth clearing first, maybe that will resolve things quicker 

[Turin Turambar]

Thanks Dice, I'm not sure if I believe but I can see a world where you are town.

 

Thanks Tig for the claim and the clarification a out claiming town. I had thought you were referring to me, but I'm an attention seeker so it's always about me, lol.

 

Thanks Heavy, I don't follow your logic so much but I guess?!? 

 

DPR,  I still would like to see where you documented that you had SD as town.

 

I've been reading Darthe and got thru EoD 1. I'll be posting my thoughts shortly. 

 

My current PoE is:

Heavy

DPR 

Dice

 

Not sure of any of them. If Eddie fake claimed vig and then shot SD, I tip my cap. If Tig slid by in the shadows I'm gonna be mad but fair enough.

[DPR]

4 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

because he’s freaking out and getting desperate.  There was a post early that showed that

Yes there was lol

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

1 minute ago, DPR said:

6 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

because he’s freaking out and getting desperate.  There was a post early that showed that

Yes there was lol

How am I freaking out, lol. I think you guys should know when I'm freaking out. 

[DPR]

6 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

I feel bad about DPR. 

 

So much feels wrong, especially his role claim. I'd say it isn't a worry as even if we lose three this D/N cycle he then has to show his double vote. Unless he has a mafia double vote or an assassination like Gud had. Then either he will appear lock clear on the last day or we'll likely lose 4 townies and not make it to the last day. 

 

Because the last mafia role must something. Maybe not hugely overpowered, but constant commuter and constant Vig are pretty powerful even if they can get in the way of Town as well. 

 

So maybe DPR is worth clearing first, maybe that will resolve things quicker 

 

[DPR]

7 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

Thanks Dice, I'm not sure if I believe but I can see a world where you are town.

 

Thanks Tig for the claim and the clarification a out claiming town. I had thought you were referring to me, but I'm an attention seeker so it's always about me, lol.

 

Thanks Heavy, I don't follow your logic so much but I guess?!? 

 

DPR,  I still would like to see where you documented that you had SD as town.

 

I've been reading Darthe and got thru EoD 1. I'll be posting my thoughts shortly. 

 

My current PoE is:

Heavy

DPR 

Dice

 

Not sure of any of them. If Eddie fake claimed vig and then shot SD, I tip my cap. If Tig slid by in the shadows I'm gonna be mad but fair enough.

I had SD as Town all game - everybody knows that. Remember the multiple TWTBAW convos? 
 

You’re not even trying to solve the game

 

Enough f’n around. Did you catch the slip or not?

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

If Turin is lying, then he must have holstered or tried to kill me. Seems pretty unlikely. Not impossible. 

 

His role claim seems a bit OP but could also limit towns information. 

 

Slight concern that he was on board with SD elimination (goon) but not Darthe (PR). 

 

Think on balance, Turin is likely town. 

 

So I think my PoE is Dice and DPR. 

[DPR]

3 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

If Turin is lying, then he must have holstered or tried to kill me. Seems pretty unlikely. Not impossible. 

 

His role claim seems a bit OP but could also limit towns information. 

 

Slight concern that he was on board with SD elimination (goon) but not Darthe (PR). 

 

Think on balance, Turin is likely town. 

 

So I think my PoE is Dice and DPR. 

I dunno… Seems kinda counterproductive to kill me after I’ve been so helpful and can prove my double vote tomorrow lol

 

Hmmm. Why would someone want me gone? 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

Just now, DPR said:

I dunno… Seems kinda counterproductive to kill me after I’ve been so helpful and can prove my double vote tomorrow lol

 

Hmmm. Why would someone want me gone? 

Does your double vote, should we live to see it, prove you are town or only that your role gives you a double vote? 

[Tigraine]

59 minutes ago, DPR said:

dice jumped from SD (goon) to Darthe (Bus Driver), so it’s the opposite of what you said I think lol

 

No that's my point.  If he's scum,  why jump to the person with at least some of a role instead of staying put and not making yourself stand out.

[Turin Turambar]

I was reading Darthe for info but looked at othe things happening along the way. This post by SD I think is worth looking at in depth.

On 5/14/2025 at 5:14 AM, SinisterDeath said:

It's Day 1, my guess after a multi-year hiatus, he's pivoting his play style a little from the last game that only happened a few weeks ago to not get burned out. I wouldn't stress too much on this read. 

 

🤣

 

I'm looking at it as more like, Heavy just doesn't like getting rolled up on. It's also D1.

 

Here's the quote.

Being wary of someone new isn't a bad thing, specially if they have a pro over their shoulder.

 

Darthe clearly flubbed on the unprompted reads.

Was Darthe lying? Or did he just not see DPRs request? I dunno.

Or is this indicative of a DPR x Typh wolf team with coaching as we can clearly see those two going back and forth and asking for a read specifically from Typh?

 

Speaking of.

 

 

I always find it interesting that DPR isn't actually giveing an opinion, but is prompting others for their opinion. 😁

 

Anyways, back to GK...

 

Not rum, but an Extra large Margarita.

Margaritas have Tequila.

I suspect that even though Tequila isn't rum, it'll likely get him even drunker... I just hope he keeps his pants on, we don't need to see Papa Roach.

 

For sure.

The only thing I have from him is, he loved without a Paddle, and he voted Ed because Ed voted for me first. Lol

 

My thoughts?

 

Dice loved Without a Paddle, and Tigraine enjoyed the bear scene.

 

Turin choose Addams Family Values, where Wednesday sets the Camp Staff on Fire, because they tried to get her group of campers to play the Native Americans in the Thanksgiving Play with the Pilgrims. (Clearly she had valid reasons for doing so)

 

Heavy Choose Hateful Eight / The Abominable Dr. Phibes, two movies I'm not familiar with.

 

DPR choose Friday the 13th (on today, the 13th). The movie about the mother who takes revenge on the Campers who stay at the Camp, because she feels they are all responsible for killing her son.

 

Darthe choose Cabin in the woods, and if you go with GK's interpretation of the events that have unfolded, then Darthe has infact, Chris Hemsworthed it into that wall. Lmao

 

Everyone else either hasn't choose a movie, or refused to choose one because they don't watch "horror movies", even though I gave everyone an out by picking any movie of any genre that takes place at a camp, or the woods.

 

IMO not answering participating says more then participating.

 

Participating, may or may not give me some indication about what your surface thoughts are regarding the game.. It may mean nothing at all.

 

It is day 1 after all. Aside from Claims, and some other random stuff, who people vote for, is probably going to get us more information for D2 then anything else.

 

Also, I haven't read any other post since my last one, so I'm sure I have some more I need to read.

The first part is him replying about DPR. I asked this before but I don't think there were replies. Does this look more like TMI or more like defending a teammate?

He follows up by defending? Heavy. He doesn't  go as far as implying Heavy was town (although I think Heavy said he thought it did). My question is based on these statements which of DPR or Heavy is more likely  SD'S teammate??

 

The rest is meh imo. 

[DPR]

10 minutes ago, Tigraine said:

 

No that's my point.  If he's scum,  why jump to the person with at least some of a role instead of staying put and not making yourself stand out.

Now I see, you’re saying you see Town!dice making the move he did - not Mafia!dice. 

[Tigraine]

16 hours ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Could DPR have holstered his NK to make it look like... No someone blocked me or protected Turin. 

 

Why did you think he had a NK? 

 

 

[DPR]

@Turin Turambar yes or no - did you catch the slip? 

[Tigraine]

1 minute ago, DPR said:

Now I see, you’re saying you see Town!dice making the move he did - not Mafia!dice. 

Yeah, I probably should've clarified it lol

[DPR]

If you did, I don’t want to mess up anything you have going.

[DPR]

1 minute ago, Tigraine said:

Yeah, I probably should've clarified it lol

No worries, I’m trying to get work done in between dragging Turin to the win OMG