The Stand Mafia [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN AND NOTBOB WIN!

[Katiora]

Ok. So my thoughts so far. Mostly and i'm going to say this even though most of you will say it is probably scummy but i'm just being honest her, I have no idea what to go on at this point. D1 and we're 41 pages in and honestly I feel more confused than when I first started trying to read yesterday. What a convoluted finger pointing mess... 

 

 

I mean I know it's d1 so all we have is conjecture and votes that may or may not mean anything at all, but man. Ya'll make a thread hard to read. Anyway... onwards. 

 

Honestly I'm having a such a hard time remembering who all is in the game I had to go look. Some people just haven't done anything at all.*whistles* 

 

 

Right now, in the order that Tress has them listed:

 

Eldrick - has been active since they've been here. Almost feels like they are trying to force people into roles regardless of how things actually are. i.e. the thing with "if zander/cory can't read me he must be scum" thoughts. It just appears to be trying to hard to me, though this could be accounted for from his late start and he actually IS trying too hard or he could just be scum. Hard to decide.... 

 

Cory - Has been extremely laid back this game. Not the Cory I'm used to seeing. I haven't really seen him try to push anyone yet and it has me slightly concerned. 

 

Darthe - I want to think he's town so bad. I mean... nothing he's said (even the stuff I really don't agree with) has pinged me as more than just Darthe being himself. I really wanna tinfoil him though

 

AJ - has he been here today?? I honestly can't remember. <.< He's been super quiet to me this game. He had a bit in it where he was fairly vocal but it seems like, since the fluff stopped he has been unusually quiet and not his normal scum hunting self. Not sure if I should be worried. I'll be worried if he's alive past d2 lol 

 

Zander - My eternal tinfoil.... I am 100% horrible at reading Zander. I want him to be town and honestly right now I have no reason to think he's not but.... man... 

 

Hallia - Has been quiet. Normal for last few games and NAI. Pretty sure she's been this quiet for a scum game a while back and the last game, where she did get pretty active towards the end of the game. I would be willing to give her a few (game) days before really worrying. She usually picks up if she's town.

 

DPR - always seems scummy to me. Not sure why. Kinda Null right now

 

Marsh - seems to be involved. I'm not sure I agree with his most recent list, but that doesn't make him not town. I would like to know how firm his reads are at this point?? Just out of curiosity... 

 

Kat - extremely boring and not extremely involved because she hates D1 

 

Leelou - Quiet... says she's busy but has put in some recent effort which I approve of. I probably don't want to vote her today, regardless of Darthe's reasoning unless he were to give me more than "trust me I'm Darthe"... Probably just not going there today. 

 

Krak - I don't buy the "he voted Leelou so he must be scum" thing, or the "he's too active" but I will say he's been slightly defensive. I don't know that I put him and Penguin as W/w if they are then they decided to distance pretty early... 

 

Penguin- ehhh has been a bit over-reactive recently. I think the arguement about his fluff wasn't justified, however, I think it did make him react, so maybe not completely unwarranted. Nothing to judge his play by though so I'm gonna have to trust people that have actually played with him and hope they're not ALL scum. That would mostly be Dice and Eld?? Isn't that right??? >.> 

 

Dice - heh I"m horrible at reading him. One of the past games I was convinced he had to be scum or 3p and was utterly wrong lol. So far this game he's been semi-reasonable and hasn't gone off chasing rabbits. I'll withhold judgement for now and put him as null. 

 

Not Bob - pretty quiet. He's popped in a bit and said something was towny or scummy (and sometimes I haven't been sure if he was serious) but I don't remember any explanations of his reasoning and beyond that I can't think of a whole lot he's posted. Not sure if I just don't remember or if I've missed it or if he's really not posted a lot. 

 

EP - Eh. Usually has decent reads but crazy reasons that make sense to no one else but him. I'm not sure about him yet. 

 

 

So that's my thoughts right now. And looking at them i have NO IDEA who I really would like to see lynched today. Not Zander, Cory, Darthe, AJ, or Hallia for the moment. 

 

My bottom three would probably be Not Bob (from a purely I don't know why point), Krak, and Eld. But not really wanting to vote right now... Is this a Hybrid hammer game?? or a DL game? I don't really want to look... lol 

 

Now someone pick my post apart and tell me why I'm scum *looks pointedly at Cory* 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

2 minutes ago, Eldrick4221 said:

 

I don't care whether or not he has a weapon. I care about the motives behind you guys wanting him to use it on me.

 

Krak clearly has a reason to want to kill me, or he wouldn't have posed the question. I'm curious what it is, which was the primary reason of my questioning.

 

Now that I elaborated, care to share your insight on why you wanted him to do it? Why do you want me dead? Don't just say because you think I'm scum. Why.

 

He shoots you, he likely not scum.  He shoots you and we get your flip, so more intel for town.  Plus, its Day 1.  What's not to like?  From your perspective, obviously...ouch.  From town perspective, upside.

 

[Cory Caboose]

Just now, Katiora said:

Cory - Has been extremely laid back this game. Not the Cory I'm used to seeing. I haven't really seen him try to push anyone yet and it has me slightly concerned. 

 

How was I different last game FYPOV?

[Zander?]

 

2 things: 1st either my reads are good and Marsh is  villager or my reads are bad and Marsh is Scum.

 

2nd if you ever use or mention light salmon to be again i will make it my life's mission to try and  lynch you every game...regardless of both of our alignments...like if we were in a final 3 and you were not confirmed if and the other person admitted being Scum...i will still vote you!!!!!!!

 

Lolololololol 

[Katiora]

Oh look!! Not Bob!! 

 

And your logic could be flawed not bob... If he were doc it would definitely be detrimental to town. 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

6 minutes ago, Eldrick4221 said:

 

Um..what suss on Cory?

 

Why you suss Cory?

[Katiora]

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

 

How was I different last game FYPOV?

You came out immediately pushing lynches if I remember correctly. Really before you had anything solid to go on (and you were wrong ) This game you just seem much  more cautious and maybe slightly less confident? Idk... 

[Eldrick4221]

2 minutes ago, 鲍勃不是我的名字 said:

 

He shoots you, he likely not scum.  He shoots you and we get your flip, so more intel for town.  Plus, its Day 1.  What's not to like?  From your perspective, obviously...ouch.  From town perspective, upside.

 

Fair enough. It's not that you think I'm scum. It's that you want a flip.

[Zander?]

10 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

 

 

Cory promise me you're a Towny?!?!?!

[Cory Caboose]

its hybrid hammer @Katiora

[Katiora]

You don't like this color Zander?? 

[Cory Caboose]

Just now, Katiora said:

You came out immediately pushing lynches if I remember correctly. Really before you had anything solid to go on (and you were wrong ) This game you just seem much  more cautious and maybe slightly less confident? Idk... 

 

Did I? Because I pushed your wagon about, idk, 8-9 hours before EOD1 and didn't really push anyone before that

This game is... 2 days from EOD1....

[Katiora]

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

its hybrid hammer @Katiora

Thank you.. that is what I thought. For that I (probably) won't vote you today... maybe tomorrow lol

[Cory Caboose]

Starting to think you didn't read the game at all. Feel justified in lynching you there ;)

[Katiora]

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

Starting to think you didn't read the game at all. Feel justified in lynching you there ;)

Honestly it started right before the weekend and I didn't read it a lot after I found out I was lynched over the weekend so you're maybe slightly justified in feeling justified

[Cory Caboose]

lol

<3

[Eldrick4221]

2 minutes ago, 鲍勃不是我的名字 said:

 

Why you suss Cory?

 

I didn't suss Cory. I said that like Zander, he should be able to read me, and if he continues to scum read me it would be telling.

 

For the record, because it's been mentioned a few times, I didn't suss Zander either.

 

Zander, and I though Cory, are good at reading me. That they are reading me wrong is worrying. That's a scenario that usually means scum push.

 

Time will tell if they keep on me, if I survive the day, ofc.

[Darthe]

4 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

Cory promise me you're a Towny?!?!?!

giphy (1).webp

[Cory Caboose]

sure i can promise im a townie

 

im a townie i promise

 

if i were mafia, i would obviously have to lie to you about this

 

luckily for you random.org has kept me from being a liar thru the power of probabilistic coincidence

[Darthe]

2 minutes ago, Darthe said:

giphy (1).webp

[Cory Caboose]

Just now, Darthe said:

[Zander?]

2 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

sure i can promise im a townie

 

im a townie i promise

 

if i were mafia, i would obviously have to lie to you about this

 

luckily for you random.org has kept me from being a liar thru the power of probabilistic coincidence

 

Cory a Wolf....sadface.gif

[Cory Caboose]

Just now, Zanatron said:

 

Cory a Wolf....sadface.gif

 

lol

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

4 minutes ago, Katiora said:

Darthe - I want to think he's town so bad. I mean... nothing he's said (even the stuff I really don't agree with) has pinged me as more than just Darthe being himself. I really wanna tinfoil him though

 

AJ - has he been here today?? I honestly can't remember. <.< He's been super quiet to me this game. He had a bit in it where he was fairly vocal but it seems like, since the fluff stopped he has been unusually quiet and not his normal scum hunting self. Not sure if I should be worried. I'll be worried if he's alive past d2 lol 

 

Hallia - Has been quiet. Normal for last few games and NAI. Pretty sure she's been this quiet for a scum game a while back and the last game, where she did get pretty active towards the end of the game. I would be willing to give her a few (game) days before really worrying. She usually picks up if she's town.

 

DPR - always seems scummy to me. Not sure why. Kinda Null right now

 

Marsh - seems to be involved. I'm not sure I agree with his most recent list, but that doesn't make him not town. I would like to know how firm his reads are at this point?? Just out of curiosity... 

 

Not Bob - pretty quiet. He's popped in a bit and said something was towny or scummy (and sometimes I haven't been sure if he was serious) but I don't remember any explanations of his reasoning and beyond that I can't think of a whole lot he's posted. Not sure if I just don't remember or if I've missed it or if he's really not posted a lot. 

 

My bottom three would probably be Not Bob (from a purely I don't know why point), Krak, and Eld. But not really wanting to vote right now... Is this a Hybrid hammer game?? or a DL game? I don't really want to look... lol 

 

Feedback:

 

Darthe:  trust your feelings Luke (I mean Kat), tinfoli on him already, you know it's true.

AJ:  Gone but not forgotten.  Good observation as I had almost forgotten he was in this game.

Hallia:  Another good point.  A quiet Hallia is usually a scummy Hallia.

DPR:  this dude always seems uber scummy to me early then kind of picks up his game later.  He usually has better reads once there is blood in the water.  I trust him more late game.

Marsh:  I'm kind of mixed on him because he usually a low-volume poster but I did like his list.  Useful kind of Day 1 for him.

NotBob:  You say he's pretty quiet, doubt his sincerity, can't recall any of his posts and yet you put him in your bottom three.  Are you new to mafia?  Is this your first game as scum?

[Zander?]

Ok supper time back in a bit.