The Mafia Parable: Basic Game OVER

[Gentled Ben]

Ok, I'm caught up, but my head is congested after 15 pages or however much that was.

 

Who is Marsh? No one named Marsh is posting, but then everyone has a read on Marsh and refer to his responses.

[Clovdyx]

Ok, I'm caught up, but my head is congested after 15 pages or however much that was.

 

Who is Marsh? No one named Marsh is posting, but then everyone has a read on Marsh and refer to his responses.

 

Marsh = Iron.

[Ironeyes]

Ok, I'm caught up, but my head is congested after 15 pages or however much that was.

 

Who is Marsh? No one named Marsh is posting, but then everyone has a read on Marsh and refer to his responses.

That's me. It's a reference to the book I got my handle from (Mistborn)

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

 

 

Comes off a bit defensive. 

 

It's only N1 - town is calm, cool and collected. Not pointing out how people "should have done things". 

 

But that's just me collecting points. 

 

Why did that response form Rand cool your jets? Let's be honest - you had to stick your neck out a bit to say you agreed with me. That implied (to me) that you felt strongly about your view.  His response to your question wasn't strong, and you folded without even following up with him. 

Honestly? I don't know. Maybe I was letting my emotional state affect the game. A lot of my original push on Rand was done all at once, in the heat of the moment. Then I got distracted by Adella's claim and decided to move my vote to make sure she didn't get lynched, and things went from there. 

 

I'm not worried about votes moving around to consolidate, etc, so much as I am a view that just seems to have disappeared for a reason I don't see.

I dunno... I still he's worth a vote or a NK

 

 

 

 

Wut?

I dunno. I just discovered a new webcomic and I've been binging for two hours. At this point my head is so far away from this game that I have no idea what I'm talking about. It's Cardboard Crack's fault 

[Adella]

Ok, now I'm not sure what to do, it seems pretty split on whether people are going to support me for picking my own kill, or for letting the town vote on it... at this point I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to lynch me for one or the other.

 

The paranoia has fully set it.

[Gentled Ben]

 

Ok, I'm caught up, but my head is congested after 15 pages or however much that was.

Who is Marsh? No one named Marsh is posting, but then everyone has a read on Marsh and refer to his responses.

 

That's me. It's a reference to the book I got my handle from (Mistborn)

Gotcha. We can't call you Spike because everyone would think that's a Buffy reference, so old "Ironeyes Marsh" it is, then.

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comes off a bit defensive. 

 

It's only N1 - town is calm, cool and collected. Not pointing out how people "should have done things". 

 

But that's just me collecting points. 

 

Why did that response form Rand cool your jets? Let's be honest - you had to stick your neck out a bit to say you agreed with me. That implied (to me) that you felt strongly about your view.  His response to your question wasn't strong, and you folded without even following up with him. 

Honestly? I don't know. Maybe I was letting my emotional state affect the game. A lot of my original push on Rand was done all at once, in the heat of the moment. Then I got distracted by Adella's claim and decided to move my vote to make sure she didn't get lynched, and things went from there. 

 

I'm not worried about votes moving around to consolidate, etc, so much as I am a view that just seems to have disappeared for a reason I don't see.

I dunno... I still he's worth a vote or a NK

 

 

 

 

Wut?

I dunno. I just discovered a new webcomic and I've been binging for two hours. At this point my head is so far away from this game that I have no idea what I'm talking about. It's Cardboard Crack's fault 

 

 

 

Seems legit.

[Adella]

Also, hey, go me! I managed to actually get on a computer tonight. I will be catching up on my reads. I've been keeping up, but I want to look at everyone individually before I actually submit my kill, however it gets decided.

[DPR]

Ok, now I'm not sure what to do, it seems pretty split on whether people are going to support me for picking my own kill, or for letting the town vote on it... at this point I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to lynch me for one or the other.

 

The paranoia has fully set it.

 

Regardless of what happens, just make sure you leave the town with the most and best info.

[Gentled Ben]

Ok, now I'm not sure what to do, it seems pretty split on whether people are going to support me for picking my own kill, or for letting the town vote on it... at this point I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to lynch me for one or the other.

 

The paranoia has fully set it.

It's your shot to take, and it doesn't look like anyone has a strong town read on Sooh, and that's who you said you're going to shoot, so unless there is a reason not to (and "Yeah guys, don't shoot me" IS a great reason, ), then I say go ahead and shoot her.

[Gentled Ben]

Also, sorry for missing deadline. I thought I could pop on around lunch, but it rained here this morning, so I bailed and went to the Great Sand Dunes instead, where it was also about to rain, so I took some quick pictures and came back, and the DL came while I was driving.

[Gentled Ben]

I'm going to go to bed within an hour or so, then I'll drive most of the day tomorrow, then unpack and get caught up again. I should be fully functional on Sunday. Catching up from a ton of pages like I did just now really only befuddles me. I mean, I read everything, but it's a big jumble inside of my head.

[Ironeyes]

Ok, now I'm not sure what to do, it seems pretty split on whether people are going to support me for picking my own kill, or for letting the town vote on it... at this point I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to lynch me for one or the other.

 

The paranoia has fully set it.

Well technically the mafia can't lynch you without help from the town. Since being able to lynch people without help is their wincon... But they can shoot you, unfortunately. 

I say just pick your shot thoughtfully and then tell who it was right before the deadline or something.

[Adella]

 

Ok, now I'm not sure what to do, it seems pretty split on whether people are going to support me for picking my own kill, or for letting the town vote on it... at this point I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to lynch me for one or the other.

 

The paranoia has fully set it.

Well technically the mafia can't lynch you without help from the town. Since being able to lynch people without help is their wincon... But they can shoot you, unfortunately. 

I say just pick your shot thoughtfully and then tell who it was right before the deadline or something.

 

Depends on how convincing of a case they can make, and I'm feeling that they're laying the groundwork for it. But you're right, if I would be basically confirmed town D2 (which is why I really really didn't want to reveal) then I'm a perfect target for night.

[LedZepMan]

I say the other two vigs holster tonight, and if there aren't two kills tonight we kill Adella tomorrow

[Ironeyes]

I say the other two vigs holster tonight, and if there aren't two kills tonight we kill Adella tomorrow

And what happens if she's town and mafia holster so they can get an easy mislynch?

[LedZepMan]

I doubt they'll holster

[Shitsure Kamimashita]

I'll be on again in an hour.

[Adella]

I doubt they'll holster

Uh, they might if they think they can mislynch a townie that will be all but confirmed when the kill goes through as I say it will.

[Adella]

I say the other two vigs holster tonight, and if there aren't two kills tonight we kill Adella tomorrow

This actually has me thinking. I see huge potential for LZM to be scum here. If he is mafia and said this, he could easily convince his teammates to holster so they could Lynch me.

 

The worst part is that he doesn't even consider I may hit mafia, which is really a point in Sooh's favor. Anyone else think this may be a scum slip? He accidentally pointed out that Sooh has no possibility of flipping scum, while trying to set up a mislynch for D2?

[LedZepMan]

Now you're fighting. Where did I say Sooh has no possibility of flipping scum?

 

I'm actually giving you the benefit of the doubt here.

 

Kill who you want, claim it come morning. If scum holsters I'll be shocked.

[LedZepMan]

I hope you kill scum.

[Adella]

Your scenario said nothing about the possibility of Sooh being scum. Most people would have said something along the lines of:

 

I say the other 2 vigs holster tonight, and if Sooh flips town and there is only one kill...

 

OR

 

Other 2 vigs should holster and if Sooh flips town and is the only kill...

 

Or even say your exact statement with the caveat that if Sooh is mafia then clearly I am cleared as town...

 

You failed to even mention the possibility that she could flip scum and clear me as town, which is a huge slip to me. Someone else come talk to me about this!

[LedZepMan]

I said what I meant. Kill who you want. Claim it in the am.

 

Hell, shoot me if you want. Just claim it. If scum don't send in a nk, I'll be a monkeys uncle.

 

The last thing I said about Sooh was that she wasn't null to me, but I couldn't place what was bugging me about her.

 

So, fire away. Smite Sooh if you want. If I don't die tonight, and there's two nk's, I will believe you.

[LedZepMan]

Also, you never got back to me with proof of why I should believe you, like you said you would.