The Mafia Parable: Basic Game OVER

[LedZepMan]

No, that's make you a toddler

[LedZepMan]

Along with your attitude

[LedZepMan]

Did you graduate preschool yet?

[Ironeyes]

It's in direct response to talking about vig shots. If it walks like a duck......it's a damn duck

Problem is that with the open setup, fake claims are easier than pie. I think we're much better off judging people based on their gameplay

[DPR]

Speaking of, DPR - you said you thought SK stsrted strong. What did you like? I can't remember seeing more than a couple of his posts and don't recall any of his content.

 

The rest of your list seemed pretty fair to me

I'm on phone, so this is short and sweet, but I remember SK being the first one to move past the joke phase and into actual game-related questions. It struck me as being a bit early for that, but that's just my taste.

 

His content didn't move me one way or the other, just the fact that he jumped in playing.

 

Then he stopped, which I found strange for the level of interest he had displayed.

 

Again, not a scumtell. Just a D1 note.

[Nynaeve]

Im not going to ignore her pinging all over the place cause she hinted at a vig role in an open setup.

[LedZepMan]

So you all are gonna lynch the only person who has claimed vig? I'm supposed to be the one without a brain.

[Nynaeve]

Did you graduate preschool yet?

Well lets not lynch her then. She said she might be vig so it must be true! Hell it doesnt matter that she's making shit up. Nah lets just take her word for it

 

Good plan! You rock at mafia!

[Nynaeve]

If she wants to step forward and make an actual claim, bring it on.

[LedZepMan]

And I'm gonna be outta cell service till after DL. Have fun

[Ironeyes]

Another benefit to a Hallia lynch that I just realized is that it gives us a better look at Nyn's alignment. If Hally flips town, I'd be more willing to lynch Nyn tomorrow. 

[Nynaeve]

Fact is it's 50 mins to dl and she's tied... you'd think she'd claim by now. No?

[Ironeyes]

Another benefit to a Hallia lynch that I just realized is that it gives us a better look at Nyn's alignment. If Hally flips town, I'd be more willing to lynch Nyn tomorrow. 

This is probably my brain activating the "justification-o-matic" in reaction to my decision... or maybe I've just been reading too many of Scott Adams's blog posts about cognitive dissonance. 

[Nynaeve]

Another benefit to a Hallia lynch that I just realized is that it gives us a better look at Nyn's alignment. If Hally flips town, I'd be more willing to lynch Nyn tomorrow.

Lol sure

 

Im not arrogant enough not to admit that i could be wrong. I just dont think i am.

 

I'll remember this little tidbit if she does by miracle flip town.

[Ironeyes]

 

Another benefit to a Hallia lynch that I just realized is that it gives us a better look at Nyn's alignment. If Hally flips town, I'd be more willing to lynch Nyn tomorrow.

Lol sure

 

Im not arrogant enough not to admit that i could be wrong. I just dont think i am.

 

I'll remember this little tidbit if she does by miracle flip town.

I don't think you're wrong either, as I've demonstrated with my vote. I'm just spitballing here, posting my thoughts as they come. 

[Adella]

I didn't see that as a claim, but maybe it was. I'm not inclined to ignore the rest of her play this phase though. Especially is she were a vig, it's her responsibility with that role to be more engaged and try to figure out where a good place to use her shot is. I don't think she has been doing that at all, which is why the chance that it's a fake claim to either set herself up to make a solid claim later, or to distract from a real big getting killed by mafia sort of like how we cover for cop in some games.

[Adella]

As far as why you shouldn't Lynch me... That feels like a weird question to answer, like in a job interview when they ask why they should hire you lol.

 

Most importantly is because I am town.

 

Next would be because I feel that I have contributed to this game more than Hallia has, I am working harder to understand people and their reasonings, and have contributed more to the game as a whole. I need to find scum, it's my job and I'm taking it seriously.

[Nynaeve]

If she's a vig she should be here claiming right now. And then she'd have to back it up. Should be self resolving. It's as simple as that.

 

Im not backing off over some lame breadcrumb early game.

[Ironeyes]

I didn't see that as a claim, but maybe it was. I'm not inclined to ignore the rest of her play this phase though. Especially is she were a vig, it's her responsibility with that role to be more engaged and try to figure out where a good place to use her shot is. I don't think she has been doing that at all, which is why the chance that it's a fake claim to either set herself up to make a solid claim later, or to distract from a real big getting killed by mafia sort of like how we cover for cop in some games.

@Bold: Is this intended to say you think she might be trying to draw the night kill? Your wording tripped me up here. 

[Nynaeve]

I also dont like that sooh hasnt been around today. Really dont like it.

[Nynaeve]

I think sooh/hallia should be the trains today.

[Ironeyes]

I think sooh/hallia should be the trains today.

I wouldn't complain about that. But with like half an hour left and only a few people in thread I don't think it'll happen. Especially since pretty much everyone on Adella's train has checked out. 

[Sooh]

I think sooh/hallia should be the trains today.

I'm cool with the trains the way they are actually.

[Nynaeve]

 

I think sooh/hallia should be the trains today.

 

I'm cool with the trains the way they are actually.

Lol

 

Stop doing that:-p

[Ironeyes]

 

I think sooh/hallia should be the trains today.

I'm cool with the trains the way they are actually.