Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

[Advanced] Ghost in the Shell - MAFIA WIN


Shad_

Recommended Posts

Posted

You did. I got silenced cause of Hastur and then I got shot during the night I was silenced. The silence bought me a free pass and a ton of town cred cause people liked my posts before I got silenced for some reason, but then the 3P decided LETS SHOOT THE SILENCED GUY

  • Replies 3.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:35 PM, Lenlo said:

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:15 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:03 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

I recall Sooh and Nyn (will have to confirm) not having problems with his game, but I don't see this as anywhere near town play.

 

Yeah, his take on the whole cory chatter echoed my own and I specifically liked the post where he explained in length about the fearmongering. But I also asked earlier if he has given any leans so far and top 3 per Zander's request. Via your ISO, I'm guessing no.

 

Did Zander ask? Didnt notice. I know he asked for an "I am town" statement for LD like he always does and if anyone knew the source, which im pretty sure I indicated earlier on that I did.

 

 

yeah he asked for everyone's top three WTL

Posted

ran outa time and its unfinished. sorry if its confusing as hell


ok so onow im looking through eds posts this game. I bolded most of his actual thoughts- i donno maybe i am just expecting to much from ed?

  Reveal hidden contents

 

but this is the nagging feeling im getting from ed

Posted

the rest
 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:00 AM, ed2funy said:

 

  Reveal hidden contents



Tigs has plenty experience playing Mafia in the old days. As for her posts, they don't feel scummy to me. Just...she's not playing the game?

Idk, I think have the most experience playing with her and know her the best and these seemed like jokey posts and ignoring the game. More null for her than anything.

Also, she's from Kentucky, so you already KNOW they're weird people.

 

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:55 AM, ed2funy said:

1. Darthe - idk, Darthe doesn't seem like one to normally disappear, but could be RL stuff
2. Sooh - leaning town. Besides the one question I had for her about the VC, nothing really seemed to ping from her.
3. Dice - null/slight town read, nothing really stood out.
4. seph - probably scum using a failed Scum!DPR tactic from last game. Probably actually Town though. I liked that he, although not at first, tried to steer the convo away from LM.
5. Killashandra - Someone did already point out that she's more confident this game. Even last game where she started scum reading the day I was Lynched, she hedged and hawed somewhat. More something to watch out for. Not null so much as in between.
6. DPR - Generally being DPR: questioning setup, questioning players, questioning why I keep calling him. Why won't you answer? 
7. Niniel - last game she was scum and quickly lynched, but I didn't really see what people saw then. Mostly going off of other people's reads that she's not immediately showing those scum!Nini reads, but some of her posts have felt questioning in a bad way. She was one of the few people I saw actually say she was Town, so that's good.
8. Lenlo - don't remember any sort of meta, but we're bestirs, so D1 pass. (Read: actually pretty null rn)
9. Nynaeve - another one don't remember meta, but she's posting Like the Nyn I know. Game wise, she's questioning. Some people mentioned she wasn't pushing as hard early on as Town!Nyn should be, and hen she changed her style. But she also has mentioned some activity limitations, so that could be the cause.
10. Zander - inquisitive all Zandy. Someone put it best that he's OCD about some things. Wants clarification on everything even if they're minute and have no real bearing on the game. Strongest town read atm.
11. ed2funy - Just in case Seph didn't hear it again: I. Am. Town.
*mutters about old men needing to clean out their ears*
12. Tigraine - Phone still wants to autocorrect her to migraine. Accurate. Wasn't worried about her lack of content until someone pointed out that she posted elsewhere earlier, so now I'm worried. She usually will post a reason for being absent, and if she posted content in the other game, I'd expect her to come here and say she was busy.
13. Adam - NFG no one likes. Wants to Lynch an inactive D1, but that's bad form. Retracted his early vote when questioned on it, but that didn't feel right. Has explained it as just tone, which is a tiresome excuse to be the sole basis for a vote. Temper it with game content.

14. Laughing Man - a good healthy dose of speculation is nice, but I don't think focusing on him too much will do is good until at least D2/when we find out something more concrete.

Basic reads. Feel most comfy with Adam and then Tigs and Nyn. Depending how Seph keeps trying the same tactic scum!DPR used, his Town lean will probably start moving to scum. He reeks of a bad play to push an easy Town Lynch.

This pretty much reminds me of niniel last game imo

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:56 AM, ed2funy said:

Also, didn't order those. Oops/don't care. I'm tired

 
  On 5/1/2017 at 5:00 AM, ed2funy said:

 

  Reveal hidden contents



Tigs has plenty experience playing Mafia in the old days. As for her posts, they don't feel scummy to me. Just...she's not playing the game?

Idk, I think have the most experience playing with her and know her the best and these seemed like jokey posts and ignoring the game. More null for her than anything.

Also, she's from Kentucky, so you already KNOW they're weird people.

 

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:55 AM, ed2funy said:

1. Darthe - idk, Darthe doesn't seem like one to normally disappear, but could be RL stuff
2. Sooh - leaning town. Besides the one question I had for her about the VC, nothing really seemed to ping from her.
3. Dice - null/slight town read, nothing really stood out.
4. seph - probably scum using a failed Scum!DPR tactic from last game. Probably actually Town though. I liked that he, although not at first, tried to steer the convo away from LM.
5. Killashandra - Someone did already point out that she's more confident this game. Even last game where she started scum reading the day I was Lynched, she hedged and hawed somewhat. More something to watch out for. Not null so much as in between.
6. DPR - Generally being DPR: questioning setup, questioning players, questioning why I keep calling him. Why won't you answer? 
7. Niniel - last game she was scum and quickly lynched, but I didn't really see what people saw then. Mostly going off of other people's reads that she's not immediately showing those scum!Nini reads, but some of her posts have felt questioning in a bad way. She was one of the few people I saw actually say she was Town, so that's good.
8. Lenlo - don't remember any sort of meta, but we're bestirs, so D1 pass. (Read: actually pretty null rn)
9. Nynaeve - another one don't remember meta, but she's posting Like the Nyn I know. Game wise, she's questioning. Some people mentioned she wasn't pushing as hard early on as Town!Nyn should be, and hen she changed her style. But she also has mentioned some activity limitations, so that could be the cause.
10. Zander - inquisitive all Zandy. Someone put it best that he's OCD about some things. Wants clarification on everything even if they're minute and have no real bearing on the game. Strongest town read atm.
11. ed2funy - Just in case Seph didn't hear it again: I. Am. Town.
*mutters about old men needing to clean out their ears*
12. Tigraine - Phone still wants to autocorrect her to migraine. Accurate. Wasn't worried about her lack of content until someone pointed out that she posted elsewhere earlier, so now I'm worried. She usually will post a reason for being absent, and if she posted content in the other game, I'd expect her to come here and say she was busy.
13. Adam - NFG no one likes. Wants to Lynch an inactive D1, but that's bad form. Retracted his early vote when questioned on it, but that didn't feel right. Has explained it as just tone, which is a tiresome excuse to be the sole basis for a vote. Temper it with game content.

14. Laughing Man - a good healthy dose of speculation is nice, but I don't think focusing on him too much will do is good until at least D2/when we find out something more concrete.

Basic reads. Feel most comfy with Adam and then Tigs and Nyn. Depending how Seph keeps trying the same tactic scum!DPR used, his Town lean will probably start moving to scum. He reeks of a bad play to push an easy Town Lynch.

This pretty much reminds me of niniel last game imo

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:56 AM, ed2funy said:

Also, didn't order those. Oops/don't care. I'm tired

 
Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:35 PM, Lenlo said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 1:59 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 9:45 AM, Niniel said:

Lenlo - it feels like he voted TLM to have his vote on someone = safe without needing to explain a vote on another player.

 

If I remember right, Lenlo blew himself up once in a game where it was indicated by the mod that saying hastur three times should be done at your own peril. He did it anyhow and went poof xD. So if there's anyone I'd expect to push the envelope irt an unknown factor, it's probably lenlo lol

 

btw, has Lenlo given his top 3? I don't recall it.

 

That only silenced me thank you. Hastur Hastur Hastur.

 

As for top 3, top 3 to lynch or top 3 town? Which ya want?

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 3:16 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 1:43 PM, Lenlo said:

First, on phone.

 

So I wanna point out for DPR, since he is conviently ignoring this fact, I never criticized the TLM spec, I criticized the Cory spec. 2 different things, so don't try to pretend voting TLM is counter to what I've said. It's not.

 

Second, TLM is the/a bad guy in the show Zander. Yeah, he's a less awesome V, but the good guys from this show are in the government (Sector 9 I think) so there's your perspective.

 

I'm trying to block out some time to iso, but until then:

 

This is exactly why my vote is still on you.

 

1. You are not helping to move the game forward - you keep coming back to this point over and over. You need to turn in your reads on everything else in the game.

2. You say "conveniently ignoring this fact", but I'm the one who drew the distinction between speculation on mechanics vs. your "fear-mongering". It's frustrating that others are not seeing this, but you did criticize the conversation over TLM. Then you agreed that speculation over the mechanics could be useful.

3. To your statement regarding that your vote on TLM is not counter to what you did, I point to your statement below:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 1:49 PM, Lenlo said:

It's possible Shad did his thing and randomized roles between characters so that char claims wouldn't break the game. Also possible he did something similar with TLM and he's a neutral npc role or something.

 

We have no evidence to go off of whether the role is town or wolf or even important

 

4. You did agree with me that mechanics talk was not bad - your point was that fear-mongering was bad. By agreeing that speculation on mechanics is alright, the implication is that TLM/slot#14 does is potentially important to the game.

 

Then you voted it. 

 

That's exactly counter to what you said.

Your misrepping me.

 

1. Im coming back to it because it is the centerpiece to your "case" on me. 

2. You drew the distinction? When asked, I specified what I believed was valid speculation and what was not.

3. Does that statement in any way shape or form say I have a problem lynching the slot? 

4. Once again, your failing to acknowledge the distinction. The discussion as per Cory in the TLM slot was fear mongering. The discussion as to the slots role in the game was speculation. 

 

Your entire spiel is built off of your misrepping the "fear-mongering" conversation/word. TLM is the most interesting/best bet for me atm, though the more you misrep this crap the farther down you go.

 

Darthe - Dudes posted once. Should be posting more, I expect him to be abit of a talker.

Sooh - Classic Sooh. Shes the same as I remember afew months ago, which means I cant read her, but I like the familiarity.

Dice - No bad vibes here

seph - Dudes all over the place, in some posts hes making sense in others I begin to doubt hes reading the same thread I am. Would not fight his lynch, would not push it. Yet.

Killashandra - I have no idea who this even is, but her posts make me believe we are in 2 different games. Every other post confuses me because I dont get how certain ideas get there. I think theres validity in lynching this slot

DPR - Misrepping the hell out of me, but the dudes trying. Depending on how this conversation goes he will either continue to drop or he will become a misguided towny. ATM though I feel hes going for an easy misrep lynch on D1 since ive been gone for months

Niniel - Sheeping DPR? Her entire reason for voting me is that I voted TLM, cause she thinks its a safe slot to avoid voting another player when she herself was not voting up till this point. Her only other suspects are people that arnt here. Shes tagging along for an easy to explain lynch, without any real effort behind the read like DPR. WTL

Lenlo - Hi

Nynaeve - Same wave length. Like her.

Zander - Like him. Dudes loud, doing what I have come to expect.

ed2funy - Catchup made me like him, but hes not really dont much. Besties, but would not fight his lynch.

Tigraine - MIA

Adam - Who?

Laughing Man - A mod slot, could be anything, wanna see what happens if we lynch it.

 

So yeah, im good with TLM, DPR, Niniel or Killa

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:15 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:03 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

I recall Sooh and Nyn (will have to confirm) not having problems with his game, but I don't see this as anywhere near town play.

 

Yeah, his take on the whole cory chatter echoed my own and I specifically liked the post where he explained in length about the fearmongering. But I also asked earlier if he has given any leans so far and top 3 per Zander's request. Via your ISO, I'm guessing no.

 

Did Zander ask? Didnt notice. I know he asked for an "I am town" statement for LD like he always does and if anyone knew the source, which im pretty sure I indicated earlier on that I did.

 

 

Scum shuffle imo.

 

You've talked about fluff and TLM up until that last post. - no other game content at all. There's nothing I can say or do to color that.

 

We disagree on your posts about TLM - talk about feeling like you're playing a different game. We don't have any info on TLM yet and you want to lynch the slot. This does not strike me as townie at all. 

 

I stand by everything I've said. 

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:43 PM, Lenlo said:

You did. I got silenced cause of Hastur and then I got shot during the night I was silenced. The silence bought me a free pass and a ton of town cred cause people liked my posts before I got silenced for some reason, but then the 3P decided LETS SHOOT THE SILENCED GUY

 

LOL

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:29 PM, Killashandra said:

Sorry DPR I havent slept. I stayed up last night to finish some writing jobs and had to just stay up to get on with the usual morning routine. I am going to go take a nap or at least lay down. I am feeling a little loopy from no sleep.

 

 

No worries. 

Posted

Tell me DPR, how is wanting to lynch a slot we have no evidence for either way, that is purely a creation of the mod and is named after the VILLIAN of the series this game is based on, wolfy? Sure, maybe its not towny, thats your opinion, but how is it wolfy?

 

Once again btw, you avoid having to talk about the distinction between Cory and TLM, something you have omitted in every one of your posts about me.

 

Finally, humor me. What other thing has occurred in this game of note? Of the same level as there being an extra slot from the mod? Has someone slipped? Someone claimed? There been some massive big case reveal? Its D1 dude. Theres very rarely anything of note until we get the first flip and can begin to connect some dots. I always wait for the first flip before I pull out the marker.

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:46 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:43 PM, Lenlo said:

You did. I got silenced cause of Hastur and then I got shot during the night I was silenced. The silence bought me a free pass and a ton of town cred cause people liked my posts before I got silenced for some reason, but then the 3P decided LETS SHOOT THE SILENCED GUY

 

LOL

 

Wait a minute... Shad... were you the one who shot me? Or was it Sili? I think it was an S name.

Posted

think im honestly more comfortable with the adam lynch atm 

@lenlo how exactly am I all over the place?

Posted

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Lenlo (2) - DPR, Niniel

 

Adam (3) - seph, Dice, Killashandra

 

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

Laughing Man (1) - Lenlo

 

Tigraine (1) - Adam

 

Ed (1) - Zander

 

Not Voting: Darthe, Nynaeve, Tigraine, Ed

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

bla_1493683200.png

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:56 PM, Lenlo said:

Tell me DPR, how is wanting to lynch a slot we have no evidence for either way, that is purely a creation of the mod and is named after the VILLIAN of the series this game is based on, wolfy? Sure, maybe its not towny, thats your opinion, but how is it wolfy?

 

Because it might kill a townie. Or because it might help the town in some way.

 

Because we have 13 other players that need solving and you are exclusively focused on the one account we have no way to know anything about.

 

This is just common sense.

 

Once again btw, you avoid having to talk about the distinction between Cory and TLM, something you have omitted in every one of your posts about me.

 

I don't think anyone else is going to accuse me of avoiding talking about it...

 

I was extremely clear that I brought up Cory because he was signed up and then mysteriously dropped. The purpose of my pointing that out was to introduce evidence that we might be dealing with an account manned by an actual player.

 

You are the one that introduced the idea that Cory is scary and made it fear-mongering. 

 

I just played with Cory. Cory isn't scary. Nobody is afraid of TLM if it is Cory. Nobody cares who it is. That's all bunk you made up.

 

Finally, humor me. What other thing has occurred in this game of note? Of the same level as there being an extra slot from the mod? Has someone slipped? Someone claimed? There been some massive big case reveal? Its D1 dude. Theres very rarely anything of note until we get the first flip and can begin to connect some dots. I always wait for the first flip before I pull out the marker.

 

There are 43 pages of posts and reads. Seems like we oughta be able to find something in there, no? Just like every other game. 

 

Honestly, your logic is so bad here that I don't know what to make of it. 

 

 

Blue.

Posted

Alright peeps im back and see theres a lot of posts

 

You guys need to stop spamming so much so i can catch up ffs....

 

tumblr_inline_onbwgbeanI1s9xkmb_500.gif

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:57 PM, Lenlo said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:46 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:43 PM, Lenlo said:

You did. I got silenced cause of Hastur and then I got shot during the night I was silenced. The silence bought me a free pass and a ton of town cred cause people liked my posts before I got silenced for some reason, but then the 3P decided LETS SHOOT THE SILENCED GUY

 

LOL

 

Wait a minute... Shad... were you the one who shot me? Or was it Sili? I think it was an S name.

 

 

 

You realize that you're talking more about that game than this one, right?

 

Imma sorta flip your earlier question to me about you not acting townie...

 

Given your low level of participation and willingness to lynch an unknown slot, why shouldn't we lynch you?

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 4:57 PM, Lenlo said:

Wait a minute... Shad... were you the one who shot me? Or was it Sili? I think it was an S name.

I'm not familiar with that game.

 

Only person I ever shot who didn't flip wolf was monstr.  :wink:

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 5:17 PM, Shad_ said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:57 PM, Lenlo said:

Wait a minute... Shad... were you the one who shot me? Or was it Sili? I think it was an S name.

I'm not familiar with that game.

 

Only person I ever shot who didn't flip wolf was monstr.  :wink:

 

 

Liar im sure youve NK Townies as Scum......

 

Wolfy AF liar imo

 

LAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Posted

Also I see Tigs been on posting in the other thread but not in here when I check my notifications list.....

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 1:49 PM, Lenlo said:

It's possible Shad did his thing and randomized roles between characters so that char claims wouldn't break the game. Also possible he did something similar with TLM and he's a neutral npc role or something.

 

We have no evidence to go off of whether the role is town or wolf or even important

 

Need to see some reads brah.

 

If you already posted some as im catching up please disregard this part.

 

Need a 3 person WTL list please with some reasoning brother.

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 1:52 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 6:16 AM, Zander said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:05 AM, ed2funy said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:00 AM, Zander said:

@Ed

 

If you wanna see me and Lenlo fight read the Matrix game....fyi- Were both Minority Villas in that game....lololololol

 

I thought youd like the dream reference....that was straight up for you my little buttercup.

 

Can you explained the contrived part irt to me and Killa please? Who do you take issue with there me or here or both?!?!?

 

And again these play by plays are pointless without you giving reads man.

 

Just straight up post a reads list with reasoning please!!!!

 

And like I get you may not have a read on everyone but you should have some at least.

More wanted like hello fights. I don't read old games for meta purposes.

 

If you responded about the Dream reference, good. You've been reading. Spoiler tags are just to make scrolling easier.

 

I took issue with you both. It felt fake.

 

Still. Stching up before reads list. #shrugemoji

 

 

 

Ya lets see thats reads list with some reasoning brah

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:05 AM, Killashandra said:

I was waiting on him to make an actual post with reads. I cant tell with him right at first but I had him pinned mafia day 2 of our last game. He made a big mistake though so unless he does something like that... But there is something he did in that game that he did not do as much in murder mystery as town. I was watching to see if he did it again. He has not yet. I need to go look at another of his scum games to be sure it is an actual tell and not my imagination.

 

Let me know what you come back with irt Ed

 

 

Did she come back to this after ed posted his read list?

 

 

Not atp but she does below...lolololol

 

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 1:55 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 9:45 AM, Niniel said:

Killa - her entusiasm does indicate town. I think it´s hard to do that as a first time mafia. But if I should go by what she has written then I would say she is mafia. 

 

Depends on what alignment she favors, really.

 

 

Ya this is extremely assumptive, and she should personally know this is not a general rule of thumb type thing because Nini was Scum with Besie in Worlds End and those whove played with her know she LOVES Wolfing it up.

 

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 2:05 PM, Killashandra said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 1:52 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 6:16 AM, Zander said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:05 AM, ed2funy said:

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 4:00 AM, Zander said:

@Ed

If you wanna see me and Lenlo fight read the Matrix game....fyi- Were both Minority Villas in that game....lololololol

I thought youd like the dream reference....that was straight up for you my little buttercup.

Can you explained the contrived part irt to me and Killa please? Who do you take issue with there me or here or both?!?!?

And again these play by plays are pointless without you giving reads man.

Just straight up post a reads list with reasoning please!!!!

And like I get you may not have a read on everyone but you should have some at least.

More wanted like hello fights. I don't read old games for meta purposes.

If you responded about the Dream reference, good. You've been reading. Spoiler tags are just to make scrolling easier.

I took issue with you both. It felt fake.

Still. Stching up before reads list. #shrugemoji

 

 

Ya lets see thats reads list with some reasoning brah

 

 

  On 5/1/2017 at 5:05 AM, Killashandra said:

I was waiting on him to make an actual post with reads. I cant tell with him right at first but I had him pinned mafia day 2 of our last game. He made a big mistake though so unless he does something like that... But there is something he did in that game that he did not do as much in murder mystery as town. I was watching to see if he did it again. He has not yet. I need to go look at another of his scum games to be sure it is an actual tell and not my imagination.

 

Let me know what you come back with irt Ed

 

Did she come back to this after ed posted his read list?

I am now. I thought I may have noticed something about ed while he was scum vs town. But when I went into the data base and tried to check my thought against other scum games of his I found he had taken a break from DM mafia for a long time. So I took a look anyway and I got nothing because his game style for town or scum is very different before his absence and after. So meta from old games is probably pretty useless for him and I could not answer my own theory. Maybe I will keep it in mind though for future games.

 

 

 

Ummmm he just flipped Scum in current game.  You could check his ISO there.

Posted
  On 5/1/2017 at 5:22 PM, Shad_ said:

Minority village shots always kill wolves.

 

This is why I fing love you soooooo much boo

 

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...