[Basic C9++] Murder Mystery Mafia D5

[monstrman]

i know what i felt

 

i felt a wolf

 

and smelt it

 

tigraine smells like wolf

 

she probably has a whole pack in her living room

 

plotting

[ed2funy]

 

 

 

 

Ed, who are you most suspicious of right now?

Tigs and WBK.

Talk to me about them?

I went more town on Tigs at first, but the back and forth with Seph and manmeat was disconcerting. Tigs can articulate herself better than that and should have cleared it up quicker.

 

WBK because of how flippant he was with Nin and his stance on her. Very few people post about feelings on someone or tone reads and have that as confirmation either way. They can usually back it up with more of a why. Then his responses, which I quoted a couple of, didn't sit right.

Unless you're talking about a different back and forth with Manbat, I don't think she was very vague or ambiguous at all. Assuming you're talking about the mixup regarding her answers to the question (Manbat thinking she was confusing him and Seph), I thought it was pretty straight forward.

The mixup after.

Although, I totally misread her at first too.

[Cory Caboose]

Cory... Monstr town? Y/N

Very likely imo

[Clovdyx]

 

 

it evolved far beyond that

but nobody read it

at this point i need to stick to my guns or I'll never be able to respect my village game again, whether I'm right or wrong

 

I know you think that.

i don't think it

 

I am positive of it

 

 

What I mean is, I'm fully aware of your POV.  And you can be as positive as you want - I really don't care that much, because I'm pretty content with your slot.  You being right would make me feel better, but it's like going from an A to an A+.  Yeah, it's an improvement, but it really doesn't matter.  You being wrong isn't going to make me feel any worse about you; I'm damn near positive you believe what you're saying, so if she's town, I'm a hell of a lot more inclined to think of it as a bad read than a deliberate effort to mislynch her.

 

That being said...I'm nowhere near that comfortable with Ed, so I'd be really happy if he discussed exactly what HIS thoughts on it are.  Was he talking about that, or something else (or something more specific?)  What was she leaving confusing/unclear?

[Songstress]

 

Cory... Monstr town? Y/N

Very likely imo

 

 

Kthx 

 

[ed2funy]

There's a cat on my porch with a collar and no tags. I want it.

 

[Cory Caboose]

Inb4 i die and its tress monstr

[Songstress]

There's a cat on my porch with a collar and no tags. I want it.

 

IMG_4281.JPG

 

Ed has a StrangerKitty!!

[Songstress]

Inb4 i die and its tress monstr

 

[Darthe]

 

The circumstance does help clear me though. Thats my only vote in this game and I left it on a teammate even when I was calling wbk a wolf and had a good spot to switch and he was lead train? Unless we are both wolves its a tough sell, usually.

Yes and Darthe. I mean we've all played with you before, most of us have probably been scum with you before at some point or another, and we're generally aware that you'll do a lot of unorthodox things with a plan in mind in order to manufacture a winning scenario. It looked to all the world like WBK was never coming back and would eat the D1 lynch without much fuss for it, and you're not the sort to panic that you were contributing to your team mate being the distant second option. Once Cory bit he bit hard, and you're not going to panic at that either. You play to the field and you're only going to get wiggly about it when the people who you think would call you out on it are dead or else your game is on the line. You're a good wolf, generally, and one that will pull a sufficiently wide array of punches that it prevents you from skating by as a middling villager without drawing negative attention. I think it's entirely possible you're a villager in this game, but you're not exactly easy to pin down and there's little you can do by way of vote placement and well timed pressure on the right people to earn yourself a solid clear. The only times I've felt you were a pretty obvious villager were when you showed a clear and persistent investment in wanting town to win. Namely, Dragon Reborn and Lost that I can recall.

 

I recognize you can't give 110% in every game you play and I don't really demand that of anyone (though I've learned to expect it from some), but if you were a bit more aware of why villagers in general struggle to clear you for things they would clear others for, perhaps you could find a more effective way to show it when you really are town?

That is way too rational and thought out for me man. Id rather you just say "oh yeah derf is town" for nebulous reasons and roll with it.

[Songstress]

#FULLDARTHE

[Shad_]

[Shad_]

Cory and I generally agree on who the suspects are but disagree on the order (I think).

[Darthe]

Wow it's still night?

[Darthe]

#FULLDARTHE

I mean I have a reputation at stake here. What do you people want from me?

[Songstress]

Wow it's still night?

 

Mod's gonna hurtjuu

[Cory Caboose]

Trying to stay up for phase change but I am exhausted

 

Zzz

[ed2funy]

 

There's a cat on my porch with a collar and no tags. I want it.

 

IMG_4281.JPG

Ed has a StrangerKitty!!

Giving her tuna and water.

Named her George.

[Darthe]

 

Wow it's still night?

Mod's gonna hurtjuu

What is love for a thousand, Alex.

[Shad_]

Trying to stay up for phase change but I am exhausted

 

Zzz

 

Vig shot one wolf SK shot one wolf wolves shot SK Kaylee's busy writing the post-game.

 

Obviously.

[Clovdyx]

Goodnight, all.

[Clovdyx]

Goodnight, all.

 

 

Trying to stay up for phase change but I am exhausted

Zzz

 

Vig shot one wolf SK shot one wolf wolves shot SK Kaylee's busy writing the post-game.

 

Obviously.

 

 

I'd laugh my ass off.

[ed2funy]

I gave George tuna and water. Never seen it around the neibothood.

[ed2funy]

Oh god.

Neighborhood.

[Songstress]

George is cute

 

Here's my StrangerKitty.  He doesn't live here, actually, but he hangs out at my house pretty regularly because I have a pet door and Bagheera puts up with him.