[Basic C9++] Murder Mystery Mafia D5

[DPR]

 

 

Kronos at this point is LHF - doesn't really effect his alignment, but he's clearly peaced for some reason or another - and will eventually have to be resolved.

 

The question is - do we do that today, or do we try something more spicy?

w/w with kronos and hard bussing confirmed

Regardless of Kronos flip we will not get reliable info regarding him imo. But it's true we will have to resolve him sometime.

 

 

 

Agreed that he doesn't give much info, but I also do think that his avoiding the thread is a bad sign. 

[seph]

Cory it's eod on day 1 and you want me to follow you and shad onto a inactive. I'm going to need something in terms of other reads.

 

I'm not going to follow just because. It's literally a coin toss at the moment and I wanna feel 100% in my decision to go there over people I want to resolve with content I dislike.

[seph]

 

 

 

Kronos at this point is LHF - doesn't really effect his alignment, but he's clearly peaced for some reason or another - and will eventually have to be resolved.

 

The question is - do we do that today, or do we try something more spicy?

 

w/w with kronos and hard bussing confirmed

Regardless of Kronos flip we will not get reliable info regarding him imo. But it's true we will have to resolve him sometime.

 

 

Agreed that he doesn't give much info, but I also do think that his avoiding the thread is a bad sign.

I'm going to personally check myself before deciding what to do.

I just have had a bad taste in my mouth from a similar situation and it's bugging me lol

[Cory Caboose]

Cory it's eod on day 1 and you want me to follow you and shad onto a inactive. I'm going to need something in terms of other reads.

 

I'm not going to follow just because. It's literally a coin toss at the moment and I wanna feel 100% in my decision to go there over people I want to resolve with content I dislike.

 

I didn't ask you to follow me in any way, I'm not even sure if I wanna lynch WBK atm

 

I also have a ton of reads in the thread. What are you reading?

[Sooh]

Okay, I'm finally up to the minute here.

 

It's been a while since I've played mafia and I haven't played with all of you so here's what I've got so far....

 

I'm not going to quote anyone in this because it's based on the first 14 pages or so. The harmless "you're cool, you're cool, you're scum" banter doesn't really mean much however in particular these four stood out to me manbat, shad, Steph and sooh. In the beginning they were the ones posting the most but it was always two against two. One would say specifically point out two others and say 1 is scum 2 is cool. I seem to recall all 4 doing that at one point. (I started my read last night and fell asleep). Yes I know others have pointed fingers but there's was in a consistent, pointed manner.

 

Ed has always been a hard read for me, especially with his drunk drama queen self. It's a toss of the coin with him.

 

killasandra being new giver her quite an advantage in that anything that is slipped up on or that someone attacks her for can be attributed to that. As far as newbies usually being town the first time, while the statistics and odds may favor that, I say it's crap to use as a reason in your own defense. I also tend to lean towards scummy on ones that specifically go for the "kill me or don't, I don't care" line. Because she's new? Or because she thinks it will help portray the persona?

 

DPR to me, has always been a good one to keep around in the beginning because he always had good casings on everyone, be they scum or not. That's a valuable asset but until late game it's hard to tell if his casings are for the good or bad of the town.

 

Day 1 has never told me much until after it has ended. On the off chance that mafia is lynched today, I would look to those that chased then the hardest as the remaining scum. Only because I believe that to be a good strategy in looking vanilla.

I don't think I've called neither of Manbat, Shad or Seph scum, so not sure what you're referring to specifically with this read, and while this is a bunch of text I think I'm going to depend on some real time interaction to read you better, because none of this is too far fetched for scum to come up with tbh.

[Cory Caboose]

It's also not EOD for like another 8 hours, which is a lot of time considering we haven't really started wagons yet

[Shad_]

I'm going to be out most of the day, but our lovely mod created a game that finally sets a deadline during hours I can actively play.     Will be back and probably undistracted 1-2 hours prior through to the flip.

[seph]

It's also not EOD for like another 8 hours, which is a lot of time considering we haven't really started wagons yet

Na uh

Not in mafia time

[Sooh]

Sooh: I could vote Ed, Shad or Darthe. Maybe Kronos but it's possible that something has happened to him.

 

 

Not Shad. It should say Seph.

Ok, I'm not sure I follow your reasoning, but I'll wait and see what you do I guess.

 

Ftr I don't have you as towny yet, so if you're town you might want to help me??

[Kaylee]

I try to accommodate as many as I can for deadline. It's close to when I put my kiddos down.

[Cory Caboose]

Who do you wanna lynch Seph?

[seph]

Gimme a minute to look over things.

 

Looking at vote counts I would bet money on there being 1 mafia in niniel, Darthe, ed

 

I guess that is assuming my strong town reads are correct.

But being a villagery game imo I think the mafia are going to have limited people to push imo

[Cory Caboose]

1 mafia in 3 people? that's right you don't have an answer u punk

 

people are so quick to throw stones at those who are trying their best to fill the game's inherent leadership vacuum, but they don't know nothin' themelves and couldn't handle the WEIGHT of RESPONSIBILITY if it fell into their laps

 

the south lost, get over it

[Cory Caboose]

(fwiw niniel & darthe are in my bottom four :thumbsup:)

[Cory Caboose]

but you sassed me so you don't get an explanation

 

get off my lawn

[seph]

1 mafia in 3 people? that's right you don't have an answer u punk

 

 

people are so quick to throw stones at those who are trying their best to fill the game's inherent leadership vacuum, but they don't know nothin' themelves and couldn't handle the WEIGHT of RESPONSIBILITY if it fell into their laps

 

the south lost, get over it

Rofl all these flavors and you choose salty...

I get your point though.

Can you tell me who is at the bottom of your list at least?

[seph]

but you sassed me so you don't get an explanation

 

get off my lawn

Ninjad.

I'm only being sassy because I believe in you <3

[Cory Caboose]

you have 3 of my 4, that'll have to sate you for now

 

a true man does not gloat about the spoils of the journey when he has not finished the hunt 

[Cory Caboose]

 

but you sassed me so you don't get an explanation

 

get off my lawn

Ninjad.

I'm only being sassy because I believe in you <3

 

 

<3

[Cory Caboose]

first rule of bro club is don't talk about bro club

[seph]

first rule of bro club is don't talk about bro club

But I brought the bbq

[Sooh]

My current bottom:

 

WBK, Niniel, Darthe, Tigraine

 

Feeling a bit better about Tress.

 

[v]Niniel[/v]

[Tigraine]

hello tigraine i am monstrmanbat

 

what do you think of seph/shad/manbat/sooh in regards to their alignments (v/w)?

I honestly can't say more that I think 2 of the 4 are scum. As to which two.....I have no idea. I think it's a good strategy to back and forth with a couple you know are town to later refer to as "this looks suspicious"

Tigrane. What do you think of me shad sooh and manbat. You didn't really go into any detail

See above. I can't pinpoint which, but my best guess is that two are scum.

[Tigraine]

 

Okay, I'm finally up to the minute here.

 

It's been a while since I've played mafia and I haven't played with all of you so here's what I've got so far....

 

I'm not going to quote anyone in this because it's based on the first 14 pages or so. The harmless "you're cool, you're cool, you're scum" banter doesn't really mean much however in particular these four stood out to me manbat, shad, Steph and sooh. In the beginning they were the ones posting the most but it was always two against two. One would say specifically point out two others and say 1 is scum 2 is cool. I seem to recall all 4 doing that at one point. (I started my read last night and fell asleep). Yes I know others have pointed fingers but there's was in a consistent, pointed manner.

 

Ed has always been a hard read for me, especially with his drunk drama queen self. It's a toss of the coin with him.

 

killasandra being new giver her quite an advantage in that anything that is slipped up on or that someone attacks her for can be attributed to that. As far as newbies usually being town the first time, while the statistics and odds may favor that, I say it's crap to use as a reason in your own defense. I also tend to lean towards scummy on ones that specifically go for the "kill me or don't, I don't care" line. Because she's new? Or because she thinks it will help portray the persona?

 

DPR to me, has always been a good one to keep around in the beginning because he always had good casings on everyone, be they scum or not. That's a valuable asset but until late game it's hard to tell if his casings are for the good or bad of the town.

 

Day 1 has never told me much until after it has ended. On the off chance that mafia is lynched today, I would look to those that chased then the hardest as the remaining scum. Only because I believe that to be a good strategy in looking vanilla.

I don't think I've called neither of Manbat, Shad or Seph scum, so not sure what you're referring to specifically with this read, and while this is a bunch of text I think I'm going to depend on some real time interaction to read you better, because none of this is too far fetched for scum to come up with tbh.

I plan to address this but am having a hard time navigating the pages on a mobile device. Anyone know how to quickly switch pages on a mobile?

[Tigraine]

 

Okay, I'm finally up to the minute here.

 

It's been a while since I've played mafia and I haven't played with all of you so here's what I've got so far....

 

I'm not going to quote anyone in this because it's based on the first 14 pages or so. The harmless "you're cool, you're cool, you're scum" banter doesn't really mean much however in particular these four stood out to me manbat, shad, Steph and sooh. In the beginning they were the ones posting the most but it was always two against two. One would say specifically point out two others and say 1 is scum 2 is cool. I seem to recall all 4 doing that at one point. (I started my read last night and fell asleep). Yes I know others have pointed fingers but there's was in a consistent, pointed manner.

 

Ed has always been a hard read for me, especially with his drunk drama queen self. It's a toss of the coin with him.

 

killasandra being new giver her quite an advantage in that anything that is slipped up on or that someone attacks her for can be attributed to that. As far as newbies usually being town the first time, while the statistics and odds may favor that, I say it's crap to use as a reason in your own defense. I also tend to lean towards scummy on ones that specifically go for the "kill me or don't, I don't care" line. Because she's new? Or because she thinks it will help portray the persona?

 

DPR to me, has always been a good one to keep around in the beginning because he always had good casings on everyone, be they scum or not. That's a valuable asset but until late game it's hard to tell if his casings are for the good or bad of the town.

 

Day 1 has never told me much until after it has ended. On the off chance that mafia is lynched today, I would look to those that chased then the hardest as the remaining scum. Only because I believe that to be a good strategy in looking vanilla.

I don't think I've called neither of Manbat, Shad or Seph scum, so not sure what you're referring to specifically with this read, and while this is a bunch of text I think I'm going to depend on some real time interaction to read you better, because none of this is too far fetched for scum to come up with tbh.

I plan to address this but am having a hard time navigating the pages on a mobile device. Anyone know how to quickly switch pages on a mobile?