[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[ed2funy]

Pretty much. I think most people will vote hallia.

I'm a big? And I know that, if I don't prove myself town will most likely lose.

[unvote]dpr

 

[V]seph [/v]

Are you seriously trying to say that by having people vote you into the ring know most of us will vote Hallia over you that it will somehow prove you're Town?

 

Seriously? HOW SWAY?!

[seph]

Then vote for me then?

[seph]

It's your choice at that point. I know what I need to.do, and I want have as much time the next 3 days

[dicetosser1]

*sigh*

 

lol take that ninja monkey!!

 

[ed2funy]

Explain yourself on why you think Iron or I is scum and why you thinking voting you makes sense.

[seph]

1. If for is town I said you or iron.

 

I'm in everyone's poe, and won't have as much time later

[ed2funy]

 

*sigh*

lol take that ninja monkey!!

*grumbles*

Tit for tat

[ed2funy]

1. If for is town I said you or iron.

 

I'm in everyone's poe, and won't have as much time later

Doesn't explain how you got to that reasoning.

 

More WoW?

[Zander?]

 

- You still were the main driver of Nol's train and were CERTAIN he was Scum

- You sussed Tress who flipped Town PR

- Youre sussing me or were sussing me and Im a Town PR

 

So all of your bravado, slimy, side stepping and placing the blame on others besides yourself only validates my point about pot meet kettle.

 

 

Nolder made no sense whatsoever. He wouldn't read the game! He didn't answer questions and he got all carried away attacking me with nothing except meta.

 

I don't control him - he acted like a flake and the crowd voted for him. I really did think he was scum.

 

Tress had a pr - the only pr that had actually helped us - and instead of playing it cool, decided to let her freak flag fly and got insane with her #3waygambit tinfoil theory. Who TF does that? Of course i sussed her! Especially when she slipped with her weird comment...

 

But back up... if I remember correctly, and I do, it was your stupid a$$ that joined in and kept her going on the tinfoil.

 

Oh, and then you completely failed to protect her. Because you have tunnel vision and can't help yourself. Then she died.

 

Then you ask everyone to reveal, even though you were the only one who had been caught with a pr. And you cried about it when players questioned you...

 

Dude, seriously, you are screwing this up for the town. Get a hold of yourself. 

 

 

If you think picking at me, insulting me etc is somehow gonna make me think your Town, its wont fyi.

 

Red- This is basically you to me.

 

I answered what was asked of me, I wanted a reveal, I wasnt the only one to suggest it iirc.  I didnt make anyone else claim, I didnt hold a gun to their heads.  I asked, most did, if thats an issue for you take it up with them, 

 

And man also gfy, you sit there and call me stupid and basically the same with Tress.  Get off your f'ing high horse, if youre Town you'll have no one to blame but yourself if you get ML'd.  Going around and insulting people, blaming everyone else for stupid plays when youve been as bad or worse and sowing WIFOM, not taking any responsibility for your mistakes  avoiding and sidestepping direct questions and using stuff to fit your own narrative is not Town play, so on the slight chance Im off on you, play better and only blame yourself.

 

And with that, Ill say no more on that matter.

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 7 - Ed2funy, Dicetosser1, BFG, Songstress, Ironeyes, Hallia, DreadPirateRoberts
• No lynch - 2 - Seph, Cuth

Cuth has been lynched!  Write-up incoming...!

 

 

This has been bugging me all game.

 

I don't have time to do a re-read and case right now, but I will later. For now though, I wanted to start to back up my vote on Seph.

What's bugging you about it? Cuth was obviously town in that fight and I did not want him to die. He had 8 votes at one point, Iran hell Gallia got on to vote him when he was her only read in the damn game. She even town read him for nothing when others were actually pushing.

 

Dpr if your town I need you to start working with me because I have been going back and fourth on tour slot and it would mean that last scum is likely in iron/ed.

 

To be honest I'm most likely voting Gallia as I feel she has a much better chance to flip scum, and I don't want her here when it gets down to a important decision as she is going to be a sus at this point regardless.

 

I'm trying to re read and look at how d1 panned out. But the three trains d1 all had Townies voting them besides darthe. If you know you are town what do you think scum would do? Probably not vote or throw down a wasted one imo.

 

 

It bugs me that the "no lynch" was a safe vote that also protected Darthe. But, from a town pov, there really wasn't a choice but to protect the infomrative role. Which is why you stand out.

 

Early in the game you pushed for my lynch about as hard as Darthe. Now you've dedicated your life to WoW, and that's fine but people are going to think what they think.

 

If it helps, I don't want you to be scum. I liked your observations in the last game we were in and would rather have you on townside, but when you evaporate, it doesn't look so good.

 

The thing with Hally is, you have to resolve her early in the game before it matters - otherwise the risk is too high. She disappears frequently. She's known for it. She does it as both town and scum. At this point, you either have to commit to resolving her or decide to ride it through... you don't want to have her slot distracting you when it comes to endgame because she's not even around to talk to.

 

If you'll play, i think it will help the town. At this point, everybody has paid so much attention to me that the scum team seems to be pretty well hidden. 

 

It's tempting to say just resolve my slot, but I know that I'm town and that puts tomorrow at endgame. 

 

If we can't reason out who is likely to be scum, then Hally is the best pick to lynch. But out of 7 pairs of eyes, I'm hoping that someone spots something that is more definitive. 

 

Why is it that every time you pop in to the thread your WTL list changes? I don't like this variability. The game's gone on long enough for you to have solidified your reads. 

 

 

 

Because I look at new content, go back through old content and look for anything that gives me a sense of what is actually going on.

 

I can't speak for everybody, but we're at the stymied point in the game, no?

 

If ed and Zander are to be trusted, they're town.

 

You and dice seem to be town.

 

I know I'm town.

 

That leave Hally & Seph. But Seph is here and seems to be doing alright, so that leaves us with an inactive...

 

Things are fluid. 

 

What is your view of the game and who are your top suspects?

I get what you're saying, but that post was @ Seph. 

 

My view of the game... I believe both Zander and Ed, which makes them town. My view of Dice hasn't changed hardly at all this whole game, which might be cause for tinfoil later but for now I'm willing to keep him as town. Then there's you, who have seemed somewhat townier this phase, and Seph, who is trending slowly downward. And I haven't a clue what to do with Hallia but I'm pretty sure if she were town she'd have more of a presence. 

 

Pretty much. I think most people will vote hallia.

I'm a big? And I know that, if I don't prove myself town will most likely lose.

[unvote]dpr

 

[V]seph [/v]

You know, I can live with this. Unvote DPR, and vote Seph

[ed2funy]

Zander, I literally told you right after you said you wanted a reveal that I was about to push for one.

It's like you don't even read my posts.

[Ironeyes]

Oh lol, sorry DPR. I just realized why you reacted to my post. I accidentally quoted you when I meant to quote seph. Lemme go back and find the one I meant to quote... 

[ed2funy]

 

 

 

Corrected Vote Count!

 

• DeadPirateRoberts - 3 - Zander, ed2funy, Dice
• Hallia - 5 - Ironeyes, ed2funy, Seph, DeadPirateRoberts, Dice
• Seph - 3 - DeadPirateRoberts, Seph, IronEyes
• Dice -1 - Zander

 

Day Five nomination phase ends at 11pm Eastern Friday, March 31

 

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 7 - Ed2funy, Dicetosser1, BFG, Songstress, Ironeyes, Hallia, DreadPirateRoberts
• No lynch - 2 - Seph, Cuth

Cuth has been lynched!  Write-up incoming...!

 

 

This has been bugging me all game.

 

I don't have time to do a re-read and case right now, but I will later. For now though, I wanted to start to back up my vote on Seph.

What's bugging you about it? Cuth was obviously town in that fight and I did not want him to die. He had 8 votes at one point, Iran hell Gallia got on to vote him when he was her only read in the damn game. She even town read him for nothing when others were actually pushing.

 

Dpr if your town I need you to start working with me because I have been going back and fourth on tour slot and it would mean that last scum is likely in iron/ed.

 

To be honest I'm most likely voting Gallia as I feel she has a much better chance to flip scum, and I don't want her here when it gets down to a important decision as she is going to be a sus at this point regardless.

 

I'm trying to re read and look at how d1 panned out. But the three trains d1 all had Townies voting them besides darthe. If you know you are town what do you think scum would do? Probably not vote or throw down a wasted one imo.

 

 

This  vvv  was in response to that  ^^^

Why is it that every time you pop in to the thread your WTL list changes? I don't like this variability. The game's gone on long enough for you to have solidified your reads. 

 

 

[DPR]

 

 

- You still were the main driver of Nol's train and were CERTAIN he was Scum

- You sussed Tress who flipped Town PR

- Youre sussing me or were sussing me and Im a Town PR

 

So all of your bravado, slimy, side stepping and placing the blame on others besides yourself only validates my point about pot meet kettle.

 

 

Nolder made no sense whatsoever. He wouldn't read the game! He didn't answer questions and he got all carried away attacking me with nothing except meta.

 

I don't control him - he acted like a flake and the crowd voted for him. I really did think he was scum.

 

Tress had a pr - the only pr that had actually helped us - and instead of playing it cool, decided to let her freak flag fly and got insane with her #3waygambit tinfoil theory. Who TF does that? Of course i sussed her! Especially when she slipped with her weird comment...

 

But back up... if I remember correctly, and I do, it was your stupid a$$ that joined in and kept her going on the tinfoil.

 

Oh, and then you completely failed to protect her. Because you have tunnel vision and can't help yourself. Then she died.

 

Then you ask everyone to reveal, even though you were the only one who had been caught with a pr. And you cried about it when players questioned you...

 

Dude, seriously, you are screwing this up for the town. Get a hold of yourself. 

 

 

If you think picking at me, insulting me etc is somehow gonna make me think your Town, its wont fyi.

 

Red- This is basically you to me.

 

I answered what was asked of me, I wanted a reveal, I wasnt the only one to suggest it iirc.  I didnt make anyone else claim, I didnt hold a gun to their heads.  I asked, most did, if thats an issue for you take it up with them, 

 

And man also gfy, you sit there and call me stupid and basically the same with Tress.  Get off your f'ing high horse, if youre Town you'll have no one to blame but yourself if you get ML'd.  Going around and insulting people, blaming everyone else for stupid plays when youve been as bad or worse and sowing WIFOM, not taking any responsibility for your mistakes  avoiding and sidestepping direct questions and using stuff to fit your own narrative is not Town play, so on the slight chance Im off on you, play better and only blame yourself.

 

And with that, Ill say no more on that matter.

 

 

 

I think somebody needs a timeout in the harmony hut.

[ed2funy]

DPR, besides self preserverance, what do you think of the sudden move to Seph by both himself and Iron?

 

Everyone else?

[Ironeyes]

DPR, besides self preserverance, what do you think of the sudden move to Seph by both himself and Iron?

 

Everyone else?

If it helps, DPR's posts in this phase seem towny to me. And TBH I'm kind of done with him being in the ring every night. 

[Zander?]

 

 

@ Mods: Being serious here - would you consider instituting the 1 question option? During the fight, each player can ask 1 question to each fighter?

*assumes Clov-tone*

 

No.

 

 

Awwwwww mannnnn...

 

Gonna be a looooong fight. 

 

 

lololol

 

 

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 7 - Ed2funy, Dicetosser1, BFG, Songstress, Ironeyes, Hallia, DreadPirateRoberts
• No lynch - 2 - Seph, Cuth

Cuth has been lynched!  Write-up incoming...!

 

 

This has been bugging me all game.

 

I don't have time to do a re-read and case right now, but I will later. For now though, I wanted to start to back up my vote on Seph.

What's bugging you about it? Cuth was obviously town in that fight and I did not want him to die. He had 8 votes at one point, Iran hell Gallia got on to vote him when he was her only read in the damn game. She even town read him for nothing when others were actually pushing.

 

Dpr if your town I need you to start working with me because I have been going back and fourth on tour slot and it would mean that last scum is likely in iron/ed.

 

To be honest I'm most likely voting Gallia as I feel she has a much better chance to flip scum, and I don't want her here when it gets down to a important decision as she is going to be a sus at this point regardless.

 

I'm trying to re read and look at how d1 panned out. But the three trains d1 all had Townies voting them besides darthe. If you know you are town what do you think scum would do? Probably not vote or throw down a wasted one imo.

 

 

Red- Can you show me Hallia's Cuth progression youre talking about here man?

[seph]

I mean I can in a min. If you is her, she says.it d1, and again before he goes in the ring I think

[ed2funy]

 

DPR, besides self preserverance, what do you think of the sudden move to Seph by both himself and Iron?

 

Everyone else?

If it helps, DPR's posts in this phase seem towny to me. And TBH I'm kind of done with him being in the ring every night.

I agree he's been more Towny this phase, but overall trend is still there and he's been jumping back and forth.

Having Hallia and Seph is dumb cause they're both more non-entities this game. Hallia obviously more than Seph. Dice would be better against Hallia even just because he's been here more and still isn't feeling super Towny

[Zander?]

 

 

- You still were the main driver of Nol's train and were CERTAIN he was Scum

- You sussed Tress who flipped Town PR

- Youre sussing me or were sussing me and Im a Town PR

 

So all of your bravado, slimy, side stepping and placing the blame on others besides yourself only validates my point about pot meet kettle.

 

 

Nolder made no sense whatsoever. He wouldn't read the game! He didn't answer questions and he got all carried away attacking me with nothing except meta.

 

I don't control him - he acted like a flake and the crowd voted for him. I really did think he was scum.

 

Tress had a pr - the only pr that had actually helped us - and instead of playing it cool, decided to let her freak flag fly and got insane with her #3waygambit tinfoil theory. Who TF does that? Of course i sussed her! Especially when she slipped with her weird comment...

 

But back up... if I remember correctly, and I do, it was your stupid a$$ that joined in and kept her going on the tinfoil.

 

Oh, and then you completely failed to protect her. Because you have tunnel vision and can't help yourself. Then she died.

 

Then you ask everyone to reveal, even though you were the only one who had been caught with a pr. And you cried about it when players questioned you...

 

Dude, seriously, you are screwing this up for the town. Get a hold of yourself. 

 

 

Ima cool off that tone a bit. But I mean it.

 

I'm headed to the fight - got it. That ain't gonna change now.

 

I have no idea what people will decide to do. From a personal pov, I'm fine with getting zilched - I mean, damn.

 

But from a town pov, I know we'll only be down another townie. So I have an obligation to not crap out.

 

So try, try to see this thing like you've had goggles on...

 

Rethink your picks. Blank sheet it. I did.

 

Seph is my top pick for scum - If Hally ain't scum, then I think someone got recruited. 

 

 

Why seph over Hallia?

 

Lay out your thinking irt bold, and since you like to keep saying how stupid I am, explain this to me like I'm 5.

[seph]

So because I'm not posting 100 times a phase I'm a non-entitie lol.

 

If that's the case you should want to resolve me. If I can show you all I'm town we have a better shot at this because I clearly have 0 idea wtf I'm doin

[ed2funy]

*sigh*

I feel a thus coming on soon.

 

How would two big ole question marks, one of which probably won't even post, bring any info and prove your townness?

You don't have to post a lot, but you can post more reasoning behind things and hit some of the smaller issues with the big

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 7 - Ed2funy, Dicetosser1, BFG, Songstress, Ironeyes, Hallia, DreadPirateRoberts
• No lynch - 2 - Seph, Cuth

Cuth has been lynched!  Write-up incoming...!

 

 

This has been bugging me all game.

 

I don't have time to do a re-read and case right now, but I will later. For now though, I wanted to start to back up my vote on Seph.

What's bugging you about it? Cuth was obviously town in that fight and I did not want him to die. He had 8 votes at one point, Iran hell Gallia got on to vote him when he was her only read in the damn game. She even town read him for nothing when others were actually pushing.

 

Dpr if your town I need you to start working with me because I have been going back and fourth on tour slot and it would mean that last scum is likely in iron/ed.

 

To be honest I'm most likely voting Gallia as I feel she has a much better chance to flip scum, and I don't want her here when it gets down to a important decision as she is going to be a sus at this point regardless.

 

I'm trying to re read and look at how d1 panned out. But the three trains d1 all had Townies voting them besides darthe. If you know you are town what do you think scum would do? Probably not vote or throw down a wasted one imo.

 

 

It bugs me that the "no lynch" was a safe vote that also protected Darthe. But, from a town pov, there really wasn't a choice but to protect the infomrative role. Which is why you stand out.

 

Early in the game you pushed for my lynch about as hard as Darthe. Now you've dedicated your life to WoW, and that's fine but people are going to think what they think.

 

If it helps, I don't want you to be scum. I liked your observations in the last game we were in and would rather have you on townside, but when you evaporate, it doesn't look so good.

 

The thing with Hally is, you have to resolve her early in the game before it matters - otherwise the risk is too high. She disappears frequently. She's known for it. She does it as both town and scum. At this point, you either have to commit to resolving her or decide to ride it through... you don't want to have her slot distracting you when it comes to endgame because she's not even around to talk to.

 

If you'll play, i think it will help the town. At this point, everybody has paid so much attention to me that the scum team seems to be pretty well hidden. 

 

It's tempting to say just resolve my slot, but I know that I'm town and that puts tomorrow at endgame. 

 

If we can't reason out who is likely to be scum, then Hally is the best pick to lynch. But out of 7 pairs of eyes, I'm hoping that someone spots something that is more definitive. 

 

 

Who and what are you referring to with the informative role part? 

 

Red- I know this is prolly another lolzander thing, but the way DPR says this coupled with the post makes me think that like hes talked more bout with seph if that makes sense,  It's basically like in DPR's world there no way scum!seph would be lying about it if that makes more sense.

 

Green- Spot on about Hallia, she was never high volume unless a PR but more recently its way less active as normal for her as BOTH alignments.  FML

Like shes not even here to at least claim and if shes voted in were not even sure she'll show at all.

 

sadface.gif

[Ironeyes]

 

 

DPR, besides self preserverance, what do you think of the sudden move to Seph by both himself and Iron?

 

Everyone else?

If it helps, DPR's posts in this phase seem towny to me. And TBH I'm kind of done with him being in the ring every night.

I agree he's been more Towny this phase, but overall trend is still there and he's been jumping back and forth.

Having Hallia and Seph is dumb cause they're both more non-entities this game. Hallia obviously more than Seph. Dice would be better against Hallia even just because he's been here more and still isn't feeling super Towny

Wouldn't putting two non entities in the ring encourage them to become entities?