[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[Songstress]

Darthe and Seph are dirty.

This is quite possible.

 

If you're town, almost certainly.

[Ironeyes]

Darthe is full of sh*t.

Why didn't you vote him then?

[DPR]

 

Darthe is full of sh*t.

Why didn't you vote him then?

 

 

 

Oh, I did. I was the 1 vote that Cuth asked be removed if it was not a CC. I complied. By this afternoon, it was clear that Cuth was going to swing and now we have our information.

 

I'll present a case come day - I won't  just leave it at a comment.

 

But it did need to be said. 

[DPR]

 

Darthe is full of sh*t.

Pretty sure Nolder knew that already

 

 

 

It's why he gets speedlynched D1.

[DPR]

I will point this out: Darthe has given us no details at regarding his claim. 

 

Coroner is a role that can be used in many different ways.

 

I highly encourage Darthe to give us the details about how his role works. Doing this before night ends is extremely important to prove his claim. 

[seph]

Im Voting myself and dpr tomorrow as should everyone else. I don't even need to use the fact that I'm a f------ pr to get him lynched. I'm just tired of this game, and we need to get on the right track.

 

 

If dpr was town he would have no lynched there instead of letting someone he strongly town read to simply die. Holy cap he even voted for him..... I didn't even see that at first... lol what

 

 

I'm sorry I didn't see eye to eye with you cuth, or see you were a Townie just struggling with the game...

I think we are all are at this point atm.

 

My vote was originally on cuth at the Time of farthest claim, then invited when cuth had his idea about the vote, the revoked when dathe kinda debunked it.

 

What made me no lynch was simple.

1- cuth had 9 freaking 9 votes to 0 at the crucial moment of the fight. There are people who did not think he was mafia, but refused to fight for him and the lynch seemed to be going smoothly.

 

I think darthe has been town and 100% believe his claim, until cced. It makes sense and his posts since his return have not been bad either imo.

 

2- cuths reaction to everything seemed town if the fight when I kept looking over it, and what sold me was his posts about being wrong. This didn't really read as spew, or trying to twist anything but more like, guys I think i screwed up here and I'm sorry. Everything felt genuine to me and I feel bad for not seeing it sooner than as I know I'm a big reason he was in there in the first place.

 

To be honest I feel like this is the best poe.

 

Wifi/nold. I may have been giving Wifi to much of a pass and needs to be reevaluated as nothing strongly suggests she is town here at n2. I need to re look who she voted d1.

 

Tress- give me three names you think are scum with reasons is possible.

 

Ed- upon reread I saw a post at eod that read to me as you thought cuth was scum and you didn't want to move, yet the last few posts at eod were your first towards cuth. You mind telling me why you thought he was scum?

 

Hallia/crush -obviously more inclined to vote Hallia hear

Dpr/seph (if dpr is town, it is going to be very bad for us)

 

Cuth mentioned dice and unless I am terribly wrong here I just don't ever see dice as mafia at the moment. I'll do a reread of him shorty.

 

Eds, eod was extremely poor and random. I thought he was actually reading cuth somewhat town b4 his vote

 

From memory I really want to think.of tress as town but the lack of votes and how she is approaching the game is bugging me.

Prettttty much me and dpr are fighting tomorrow and im going to get him lynched

[Nolder]

I thought Coroner seemed like a strange role for this game but due to jumping in when I did I didn't feel like it was right to vote one way or the other.

[Songstress]

From memory I really want to think.of tress as town but the lack of votes and how she is approaching the game is bugging me.

 

What precisely do you mean by "the lack of votes" here?

[seph]

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

[seph]

You only had one vote yesterday and 0 d1 believe?

[Nolder]

Wifi/nold. I may have been giving Wifi to much of a pass and needs to be reevaluated as nothing strongly suggests she is town here at n2. I need to re look who she voted d1.

If you know who she voted N1 that info would be helpful to me.

[Songstress]

You only had one vote yesterday and 0 d1 believe?

I used both my nomination votes D2, as well as voting during the fight.

 

D1 I didn't vote during the nomination phase, it's true. I was feeling terrible and didn't feel confident with who to vote in the least. You didn't seem to think this was all that out of the ordinary for me at the time, do you now suddenly think it's scummy?

[Nolder]

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

Unless I'm mistaken roles are revealed on death, right?

 

What use would a Coroner be?

 

It also has no flavor significance that I can recall.

[seph]

I haven't thought you to be scummy at all, but I don't have you as town either which is why your in my poe.

 

I didn't remember both your votes, 1 was cut who was the other?

But I think lack of voting and taking a stance could indeed be scummy.

[seph]

 

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

 

Unless I'm mistaken roles are revealed on death, right?

 

What use would a Coroner be?

 

It also has no flavor significance that I can recall.

I had to Google it but coroner targets dead people to get info. If there is a janitor esk role which blocks people being revealed it would seem more likely would it not???

[Songstress]

I haven't thought you to be scummy at all, but I don't have you as town either which is why your in my poe.

 

I didn't remember both your votes, 1 was cut who was the other?

But I think lack of voting and taking a stance could indeed be scummy.

I voted Cuth and Darthe, because I felt they needed to be resolved with how much Cuth was focused on him D1.

 

So you think I might be scum because I felt like crap on Saturday and had no idea who to vote?

[Nolder]

 

 

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

Unless I'm mistaken roles are revealed on death, right?

 

What use would a Coroner be?

 

It also has no flavor significance that I can recall.

I had to Google it but coroner targets dead people to get info. If there is a janitor esk role which blocks people being revealed it would seem more likely would it not???

 

Oh...well I guess there could be a 1 time Janitor role and a Coroner to even it out.

The only time I have ever seen such a thing was when I tried to include the role in one of my own games a few years ago though so it's not something I would expect to see.

Then again I don't really know Clov as a mod so maybe it's a mistake to try to game him.

 

Either way though I don't see it as thematic or flavorful so I'm still inclined to find it weird.

[seph]

 

I haven't thought you to be scummy at all, but I don't have you as town either which is why your in my poe.

I didn't remember both your votes, 1 was cut who was the other?

But I think lack of voting and taking a stance could indeed be scummy.

I voted Cuth and Darthe, because I felt they needed to be resolved with how much Cuth was focused on him D1.

So you think I might be scum because I felt like crap on Saturday and had no idea who to vote?

Feels bad :(

But no I'm not certain you are scum at all. I think ed has a higher likely hood of being scum than you atm, as does Halla and possibly crusher.

 

Out of everyone in my poe you, and ed depending on what he does when he comes back would be the last ones I would want to lynch.

 

I'm just simply at the point where everyone not in my poe I feel comfortable with. I need to reread a decent amount of people

[ed2funy]

@Seph, what posts are you referring to about my thoughts on Cuth? I believe I actually said I was going to go back and reread on the Cuth/DPR/Darthe/Seph back and forth and provide some thoughts.

 

I was literally trying to post thoughts quoting post by post right up to the deadline. There's a Word doc on my laptop with another post; I'll have to get back onto it and post it. So, they weren't random, they were quick thoughts as I was rereading before Fight time.

[ed2funy]

How many times have you said you were comfy with me as Town, Seph? I'd have to look back, but I swear you put me as Town a couple of times. Why the sudden flip?

[ed2funy]

 

^^^

Ha!

 

 

Also, Songtress

[v] Cuth [/v]

 

 

Gonna hop on my laptop to dissect and make sure what I'm feeling is a strong opinion.

 

All this DPR, Darthe, Cuth, Seph stuff is what I'll focus on primarily. Still comfy with my vote on Seph atm

Why doesn't [ u ] work to unvote? *grumbles*

 

Unvote Song, Vote Cuth

Seph, I kept my one vote on you cause I think you're scummy and moved my other from Tress (I was the only vote on her) to Cuth and the proceeded to go back and see if I was comfy with leaving my vote on him, which I said I was comfy with right before deadline.

[ed2funy]

 

ok.

 

i think i know why she said it but id like to see her respond to you first.

Dice, any thoughts on mine and Tress's back and forth?

Dice, yes you said you were gonna give input.

[seph]

Why move your vote off tress who you thought was the most scummy? And I DID have you as town, but I didn't really like your eod and your a spot i really want to resolve along with tress.

 

Why do you think I'm scummy exactly?

 

What made you think Cuth was scum?

[seph]

I don't think you and tress are m/m possible but not likely

[DPR]

Im Voting myself and dpr tomorrow as should everyone else. I don't even need to use the fact that I'm a f------ pr to get him lynched. I'm just tired of this game, and we need to get on the right track.

 

 

If dpr was town he would have no lynched there instead of letting someone he strongly town read to simply die. Holy cap he even voted for him..... I didn't even see that at first... lol what

 

 

I'm sorry I didn't see eye to eye with you cuth, or see you were a Townie just struggling with the game...

I think we are all are at this point atm.

 

My vote was originally on cuth at the Time of farthest claim, then invited when cuth had his idea about the vote, the revoked when dathe kinda debunked it.

 

What made me no lynch was simple.

1- cuth had 9 freaking 9 votes to 0 at the crucial moment of the fight. There are people who did not think he was mafia, but refused to fight for him and the lynch seemed to be going smoothly.

 

I think darthe has been town and 100% believe his claim, until cced. It makes sense and his posts since his return have not been bad either imo.

 

2- cuths reaction to everything seemed town if the fight when I kept looking over it, and what sold me was his posts about being wrong. This didn't really read as spew, or trying to twist anything but more like, guys I think i screwed up here and I'm sorry. Everything felt genuine to me and I feel bad for not seeing it sooner than as I know I'm a big reason he was in there in the first place.

 

To be honest I feel like this is the best poe.

 

Wifi/nold. I may have been giving Wifi to much of a pass and needs to be reevaluated as nothing strongly suggests she is town here at n2. I need to re look who she voted d1.

 

Tress- give me three names you think are scum with reasons is possible.

 

Ed- upon reread I saw a post at eod that read to me as you thought cuth was scum and you didn't want to move, yet the last few posts at eod were your first towards cuth. You mind telling me why you thought he was scum?

 

Hallia/crush -obviously more inclined to vote Hallia hear

Dpr/seph (if dpr is town, it is going to be very bad for us)

 

Cuth mentioned dice and unless I am terribly wrong here I just don't ever see dice as mafia at the moment. I'll do a reread of him shorty.

 

Eds, eod was extremely poor and random. I thought he was actually reading cuth somewhat town b4 his vote

 

From memory I really want to think.of tress as town but the lack of votes and how she is approaching the game is bugging me.

Prettttty much me and dpr are fighting tomorrow and im going to get him lynched

 

 

What a joke.

 

You don't even know who's in the game. Because you're not paying attention. Because you're scum.