[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[Darthe]

 

I.. Agree?

I'm basically saying your play has been bad/nonexistent until this page and need you to keep this intensity so I can actually formulate a read on you. Plz :)

Words hurt. I pretty much said what I wanted to, but im gonna be around now. My busy time is passed.

[Ironeyes]

Yall did stuff while I was in physics. 

 

 

 

Talk about pushing a narrative...

 

No one can really feel one way or the other about Sooh because we have no info, now do we?

 

Could've been a 3P kill. Could've been a punishment to the scum team for the day ending without a lynch. 

 

One question I see that nobody is discussing is "why would the scum team waste a janitor role on D1?" Janitor roles are typically 1x as multi-x really throws the game balance. It's possible to overcome - sure - but it would require a lot of power on the town's side.

 

Guess I'll throw my two cents in here. I thought about it for two or three minutes and I think the janitor becomes most useful when there are 3rd party roles proven to be in the game cause then you can janitor a kill to make people uncertain about how many scum are left. Granted, we don't know how many there are in the first place but we can guess. So I have no idea why scum would use it so early unless a) they have more than one to use or b) they know there are 3rd parties and wanted to sow WIFOM. Or else it wasn't them who made the kill. It doesn't make sense in the end. 

 

 

One question I see that nobody is discussing is "why would the scum team waste a janitor role on D1?" Janitor roles are typically 1x as multi-x really throws the game balance. It's possible to overcome - sure - but it would require a lot of power on the town's side.

Why wouldn't they use it on N1? There's no guarantee whoever had the janitor role lives through D2. Most 1x roles tend to get used N1 for just that reason.

This is also a good point, and it kind of rings a bell for me. That basically points to the janitor being someone who looked like a likely D2 lynch, so someone who was under the gun D1. Which would be Darthe, DPR, or Cuth, depending on how you look at it. But obviously this is relying on a lot of conjecture and shaky logic. 

 

 

 

One question I see that nobody is discussing is "why would the scum team waste a janitor role on D1?" Janitor roles are typically 1x as multi-x really throws the game balance. It's possible to overcome - sure - but it would require a lot of power on the town's side.

Why wouldn't they use it on N1? There's no guarantee whoever had the janitor role lives through D2. Most 1x roles tend to get used N1 for just that reason.

 

 

Erroneous.

 

No scum team worth its salt is going to blow power roles on N1 for no reason. They take time to set up and use to their max potential. Only a complete newb would panic waste a tool like that. 

Throw shade much? All of us here have played a fair number of games, even if not all of us are particularly good at the game. 

 

[V] dpr [/v]
[V] darthe [/v]

If you think im a wolf then match me DPR

Um, why isn't anyone noticing that the guy just self-voted? Every other time I've ever seen someone do that the thread proceeded to blow up

[Darthe]

 

Im back and just finished a read up.

 

Heres everything I see:

 

Tress and seph both look townie to me. Yesterday Tress drew votes for basically nothing and today is the same with seph, its Cuth making a statement and half the thread following because he seems more involved. In particular, I thought seph showed up hard over the last couple of pages though it would have been good to see him respond more to DPR.

 

Which brings me to DPR. He is the bottom of my list rn, reason being that he yesterday mirrored cuth on me, and has continued to do so, along with a few wolfy posts and his reaction to my early joke vote.

 

Cuth himself, ive still got no idea where the red is coming from. We're he not so earnest about it and still spending time in other things id be very sus of him. Its a townie tunnel imo.

 

Rn, im cool with duking it out. I dont think that I want to with seph though. Id rather DPR.

 

 

Oh, and for reads in general,

 

 

Seph - whole package this game

Dice - the aussie is aggressive in the right way and is being weird in the right way, not quiet.

Bfg - strong presence, good questions, no pushiness that ive seen.

Marsh - your soul lays itself bare to me bruh, sorry. On the real though, his recent questions about votes and confusion should be telling.

Ed - I hesitate to put this above cuth, he could prob be lower, bit I think the sooh kill spews him and I dont have much else on him.

Cuth - tinfoil drops him, but he is playing strong.

Tress- dont really have much ti say here, she has been aight, but shouldnt have gained the traction she did yesterday imo.

Crush - whered the bacon king even go? I dont like him being quiet like this

Hally - same as above, she hasnt done anything.

Wifi - hasnt sussed me this game. Thats a big deal, because she does every other game and she hasnt been absent here.

Dpr - dudes a wolf, and there are a bunch of reasons, part mentioned above, but also I'll grab a quote above and mention that the no lynch swap once we found out we all could was telling. Cuth was never gonna die there.

Do you have more on DPR?

In a sense. I saw stuff that contributed to my read, but pointing it out would take reading back and quoting things piece by piece.

[seph]

Well I didn't hate your catch up, and I would rather not vote you into a fight if your town.

You pretty heavy in the me/dpr/cuth circle atm.

 

The problem is we can't really vote hallia or crusher into a fight as its useless for info. Unless of course we just want to lynch them.

[DPR]

 

Do you try to be annoying as shit?

Where do you think Darthe learned it from?

 

 

 

 

 

 

Look at Tress gettin' in on the action! #piratenodofapproval

[Ironeyes]

Well I didn't hate your catch up, and I would rather not vote you into a fight if your town.

You pretty heavy in the me/dpr/cuth circle atm.

 

The problem is we can't really vote hallia or crusher into a fight as its useless for info. Unless of course we just want to lynch them.

Looks like Chris is trying to get at least one of them subbed, so I'm willing to wait for that. Let's get some people in the fight who will help us crack this game open

[seph]

Who would that be iron? And do u have a updated reads list?

[BFG]

@Marsh - meet Darthe... wrt thread not blowing up

[Ironeyes]

Who would that be iron? And do u have a updated reads list?

Basically one of the four already being discussed, namely you, DPR, Cuth, and Darthe. Of the four I have you as the towniest, and the other three pretty much tied in the null section. 

 

I'll go grab my read list from earlier today and see what changes I want to make in it. 

[DPR]

I get annoyed easily just ask darthe...

 

Dpr why do you think me and darthe would provide useful info in a fight?

 

Both of you were engaged on D1 and pushed my lynch for no apparent reason. You will either avoid talking and both look terrible for it, or you will engage and explain yourselves. Then we will have our info.

[BFG]

Cuth you around?

[Cuth]

@cuth why do you want me to respond to DPR about?

what?

[Ironeyes]

@Marsh - meet Darthe... wrt thread not blowing up

[BFG]

Seph, why do you have such a strong town read on WiFi?

[Cuth]

Cuth you around?

yes miss BFG

[seph]

I have explained my reasons for voting you d1, I don't have anything else to explain unless you have a specific question?

 

If I engaged darthe wtf would I say tht i havent abouy him lol. I literally have stated my reasons for disliking darthe, and would

1. Continue to solve the game while posting 1000 gifs.

2. Argue any point he had because I know I'm town, and I don't plan on dying while posting 1000 gifs. We can move it down to 200 that way I can be a over achiever.

 

3. I don't need a fight to talk about darthe. So if you want some answers would it not be better to ask me here? Instead of hoping to get them??

[seph]

 

@cuth why do you want me to respond to DPR about?

 

what?

I thought you had a post saying you wish I would have responded to dpr more, and I don't remember what I missed.

[Cuth]

 

 

@cuth why do you want me to respond to DPR about?

what?

I thought you had a post saying you wish I would have responded to dpr more, and I don't remember what I missed.

 

...

 

i don't think so?

[Ironeyes]

That moment when you ISO yourself to find your read list... #lazy

Also I know Zander isn't here but I can't resist putting my scum leans in #lightsalmon

So we got

 

Lock town:

Ironeyes--I checked his role PM  

 

Likely town:

Sooh--I know she's dead but since we didn't get a flip I think it's worth stating that I'm pretty sure she was town.

Ed--Good analysis, strong WIM. Even though I don't necessarily agree with his reads, I see clearly where he's coming from. 

Dice--Tone mostly. 

 

Lean town: 

BFG--Normally one of those people who becomes obv town pretty quickly, but hasn't posted quite enough to get there yet. I'm pretty shaky on this read. 

DPR--I liked his posts during the fight. 

Wifi--Basically just guessing here. She's really hard to read, but I don't sense the kind of nervousness that I felt from her last time she played scum. 

Seph--Vague tone read, as well as reads that make sense to me. I'm shaky on this read as well. 

 

IDK: 

Darthe--Who even knows... I can't read darthe to save my life, which is hilarious since he reads me like an open book. 

Cuth--I liked how he was during the fight, which is why he's up here instead of in the scum catagory. I'm half-and-half on him. 

Tress--Just null for now. 

Crusher--Same as above. 

 

Lean scum: 

Hallia--Where the heck is she? This isn't normal for her at all.

 

Def scum: 

IDK yet

Based on more recent content, I think I'll switch the order just a little. So it will look like this now: 

 

Ironeyes

Dice

Ed

BFG

Seph

Cuth

Tress

Wifi

Crush

Hallia

DPR

Darthe

[seph]

Seph, why do you have such a strong town read on WiFi?

Hard to explain. It's a pretty big gut/tone read. I'm pretty sure there was a post d1 I really liked. Also I liked her list more then you did apparently lol, seemed like a normal WiFi list imo.

[seph]

I don't hate irons list and I feel a lot better towards him. Can move up to town for me

[Ironeyes]

I don't hate irons list and I feel a lot better towards him. Can move up to town for me

[Ironeyes]

Guyzzzzzz I'm addicted to Kronk gifs now

[seph]

OK now I have to vote you even if you are town... you trying to play me iron??????

[Lizabeth]

Vote count!

• Darthe - 6 - Cuth, DreadPirateRoberts, Seph, Songstress, Dicetosser1, Darthe
• Seph - 2 - DreadPirateRoberts, Ed2funy
• Songstress - 1 - Ed2funy
• Cuth - 3 - Seph, Songstress, Dicetosser1
• DeadPirateRoberts - 1 - Darthe

Day Two nomination phase ends at 11pm Eastern