[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[dyachei]

Also I don't think they should have extended deadline for me. AFAICT, no one was really pushing a nego lynch and I will have the night cycle to finish catching up.

 

Hopefully will be more useful on the next day cycle.

[Guest]

Ok so this is a new community to me.

 

But on several communities, village can't chat at night and hammering removes opportunities to discuss cases and also to some extent read votes. Pretty easy for wolves to bus.

 

I didn't say random was better. Not sure where that comment was coming from. Do you have to hammer on this site?

 

Depends on the mod, entirely. Some lock the threads at night. Some are hammer games. Some are not. 

 

Each game is slightly different. I like that it's like that. 

[dyachei]

 

Ok so this is a new community to me.

 

But on several communities, village can't chat at night and hammering removes opportunities to discuss cases and also to some extent read votes. Pretty easy for wolves to bus.

 

I didn't say random was better. Not sure where that comment was coming from. Do you have to hammer on this site?

 

Depends on the mod, entirely. Some lock the threads at night. Some are hammer games. Some are not. 

 

Each game is slightly different. I like that it's like that. 

 

Same, but wasn't sure for this specific case.

 

I just got to tiinker's read list and I really don't like it.

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

Nolder just went from scummy to townie in my book...

 

For what exactly......

 

 

For the bolded below.  He could have run off on his townie points and like taken all the credit, but he didn't.  He even wondered why he got credit.  Though, I do wonder at that. I am pretty sure he knows that a person will get townie points for claiming tracker.  Unless he's the one that is returning from a long hiatus and forgot...?? I can't remember who that was in a past game?? 

 

 

 

 

 

wut?

 

WiFi exactly what townie points does claiming Tracker get me?

Wait what? If you didn't think it would gain you townie points you wouldn't have claimed.

My reason for claiming was not dying with the information I had.

Without a doc I could easily be killed N2 for any number of reasons so there's no point in not coming forward.

I mean yeah sure I could stay silent go for the hero track but I prefer playing it safe.

I don't completely understand your reasoning. You do know that claiming tracker is also claiming town PR, right? It gives you alllllllllll the towny points.

 

What? Why?

I mean I would understand that if I was confirmed, I will be when mafia kill me because it's too dangerous to leave me alive.

But you have absolutely no reason to believe my claim right now.

It shouldn't give me any towny points at all...

 

[Nolder]

 

 

 

 

 

 

wut?

 

WiFi exactly what townie points does claiming Tracker get me?

Wait what? If you didn't think it would gain you townie points you wouldn't have claimed.

My reason for claiming was not dying with the information I had.

Without a doc I could easily be killed N2 for any number of reasons so there's no point in not coming forward.

I mean yeah sure I could stay silent go for the hero track but I prefer playing it safe.

 

I don't completely understand your reasoning. You do know that claiming tracker is also claiming town PR, right? It gives you alllllllllll the towny points.

 

What? Why?

I mean I would understand that if I was confirmed, I will be when mafia kill me because it's too dangerous to leave me alive.

But you have absolutely no reason to believe my claim right now.

It shouldn't give me any towny points at all...

 

 

I understand where you're coming from, but from what I've experienced it is generally accepted that a claim is taken as true unless someone CC's. I've been lynched/mislynched in the past for not accepting someone's claim as true.

 

I guess it's different when it's tracker vs. doc (for example), but yeah. I see what you mean. Circumstances are important.

 

You have to see that it can be seen as town to claim, right? Considering my first sentence? 

 

Wow I just lost my whole post...sigh.

 

Ugh.

 

I'll post again in regards to this later.

Remind me.

[Nolder]

 

 

 

 

 

wut?

 

WiFi exactly what townie points does claiming Tracker get me?

Wait what? If you didn't think it would gain you townie points you wouldn't have claimed.

My reason for claiming was not dying with the information I had.

Without a doc I could easily be killed N2 for any number of reasons so there's no point in not coming forward.

I mean yeah sure I could stay silent go for the hero track but I prefer playing it safe.

I don't completely understand your reasoning. You do know that claiming tracker is also claiming town PR, right? It gives you alllllllllll the towny points.

 

What? Why?

I mean I would understand that if I was confirmed, I will be when mafia kill me because it's too dangerous to leave me alive.

But you have absolutely no reason to believe my claim right now.

It shouldn't give me any towny points at all...

 

 

blue is true  

 

red is wrong and u should know that nol   A claim like that WILL automatically give u townie points to some and will   like i did    automatically unvote you for it.  thats kinda giving townie points too really

 

 

can you answer my wquestion to you please?

 

To be frank, that's because I think you're all playing the game wrong.

Like I said DM just ate my post and I don't have the energy to retype it, will do so later.

Also I didn't understand your question.

[Tiinker]

NK me plz and save me from this place.

[Guest]

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

[dicetosser1]

i rephrased nol

[Nolder]

 

 

@ nol

 

thoughts on calling ure action?

I don't know what this means.

 

Rephrase?

 

 

nol the ninja lol

 

im thinking perhaps you should call ure action.   maybe very late into the night phase    what do u think?

 

and please do NOT give any indications of whether u are odc/even nights ort 1 shot or anything like that. just play it as you have a track every night even if you dont.

 

I don't see any harm in this.

 

I'll call my shot later.

Internet is acting up right now.

[dicetosser1]

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

[Nolder]

Also I don't think they should have extended deadline for me. AFAICT, no one was really pushing a nego lynch and I will have the night cycle to finish catching up.

 

Hopefully will be more useful on the next day cycle.

I'm just annoyed I misread the deadline don't mind me.

 

I wasn't even going to be awake at this time I've only had 5 hours sleep but my fan turned off and I was hot and I was like I wonder what these guys are saying I'll make a couple posts and then go back to sleep and next thing I know the hammer is falling.

[Guest]

 

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

 

 

Ah. lightbulb

[dyachei]

 

Also I don't think they should have extended deadline for me. AFAICT, no one was really pushing a nego lynch and I will have the night cycle to finish catching up.

 

Hopefully will be more useful on the next day cycle.

I'm just annoyed I misread the deadline don't mind me.

 

I wasn't even going to be awake at this time I've only had 5 hours sleep but my fan turned off and I was hot and I was like I wonder what these guys are saying I'll make a couple posts and then go back to sleep and next thing I know the hammer is falling.

 

Oh I get it. I'm annoyed I didn't realize it was this early. would have liked to have gotten a vote in

[Nolder]

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

Basically yes, but it goes further than that with regards to vanillas and stuff.

[Nolder]

 

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

 

I like it because if I track a mafia it stops them from doing anything and absolutely forces them to kill me if they haven't submitted their kill yet.

[Tiinker]

 

 

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

 

I like it because if I track a mafia it stops them from doing anything and absolutely forces them to kill me if they haven't submitted their kill yet.

 

 

Or someone else on their team just submits. lol.

[dyachei]

I'm not a fan of calling it. I'm assuming wolves get to choose who does the kill in this game? if yes, calling the action just makes it so that 1 wolf can't do the kill.

[Guest]

 

 

 

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

 

I like it because if I track a mafia it stops them from doing anything and absolutely forces them to kill me if they haven't submitted their kill yet.

 

 

Or someone else on their team just submits. lol.

 

 

this ^

[Darthe]

We are a pretty diverse forum di, we use a lot of styles, integrated terminology, and game formats change from game to game. Its a good forum for mafia.

[Darthe]

I dont think the tracker convo matters much, as im willing to lynch nol anyhow based on the last few pages.

[Darthe]

Definitely, if believer flips wolf. Nol looks mad about the lynch.

[Nolder]

 

 

 

It's okay, Nolder. I understand what you mean entirely. Just because someone claims doesn't mean it's true and shouldn't be accepted that easily; and iyo it shouldn't make someone towny just for claiming.

 

Dice is asking you to specify your claim.

Dice, iirc he said he tracked Darthe and Darthe didn't go anywhere.

 

No dice is asking if he thinks CALLING his ACTION tonight is a good idea.  ie saying ITT BEFORE morning who he is going to track

 

I like it because if I track a mafia it stops them from doing anything and absolutely forces them to kill me if they haven't submitted their kill yet.

 

 

Or someone else on their team just submits. lol.

 

MAYBE THEY CANT OK TIINK?

 

GOD WHY DO YOU HAVE TO BUZZKILL EVERYTHING?! /s

[dicetosser1]

the whole point is so that if/when he dies we know who he targetted.

 

It also allows other roles if there are any to not double up.

[Nolder]

I'm just waiting to see the flip and then I'm going back to sleep.