[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[Hallia]

Everyone on here is salty and practically chomping at the bit to cause fights.

Its my fault. I'm so sweet we need a lot of salt for contrast.

[Zander?]

how do you all epect me to read 14 pages.... there are pokemon to catch!!

 

hey brother

 

wtf is pokemon....

 

lolololol

[SiRReN]

 

Everyone on here is salty and practically chomping at the bit to cause fights.

Its my fault. I'm so sweet we need a lot of salt for contrast.

 

Well gosh dangit Hallia! 

[Clovdyx]

Zander, what is AJ's scum range?

[Clovdyx]

 

Everyone on here is salty and practically chomping at the bit to cause fights.

Its my fault. I'm so sweet we need a lot of salt for contrast.

 

 

Please always be wonderful.

[Regy Rusty]

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

 

Sorry whose statement are you referring to here, Alanna or Kat

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I think Sili is just over estimating the value of what I'm assuming was an intentional conversation starter.

 

Intent is probably ~villagery but execution was poor.

 

Good point and post from AJ imo.

 

This isn't necessarily directed at you, but do I need to point out that the only road bumps were sirren and regy's interpretation of my vote?

[Hallia]

 

I'M WHY WE CAN'T HAVE NICE THINGS

[Zander?]

 

 

I am only on page 6 but I feel extremely uncomfortable with the hydra [v] zalanna[/v]

I really feel like the back and fourth betweeen hallia/alanna isn't t/t and I fell pretty damn good early about hallia. Hopefully she can be my town buddy again :)

 

Hmmmm lets suss the slot most sussed....

 

What in particular are you uncomfortable with?

[Clovdyx]

 

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

 

Sorry whose statement are you referring to here, Alanna or Kat

 

 

What the hell?  That's not even what I wanted to write.  That's literally the exact OPPOSITE of what I wanted to write.

 

It was in regards to Alanna's, though I can see why you didn't get that.  

[Zander?]

zander is framing his posts a little funny, and laine's read list struck me as - meh.

 

meh.

 

Framing?

 

How so, can you show the quotes as well?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

zander is framing his posts a little funny, and laine's read list struck me as - meh.

 

meh.

 

Framing?

 

How so, can you show the quotes as well?

 

probably not worth it. i wasn't about to push you over said posts anyway.

[Regy Rusty]

 

 

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

 

Sorry whose statement are you referring to here, Alanna or Kat

 

 

What the hell?  That's not even what I wanted to write.  That's literally the exact OPPOSITE of what I wanted to write.

 

It was in regards to Alanna's, though I can see why you didn't get that.  

 

 

So you meant you DON'T have a problem with her calling Kat out on not contributing? :P

[Cory Caboose]

Thank god for Hallia

 

Sili either don't sub out or stop posting

 

I reccomend the former, but if you are committed to it then you have no right to be in the thread period

[Zander?]

Did you all decide to be as awkward as possible deliberately?  I read the first ten pages and want my fifteen minutes back.

 

I could almost lynch Cory today.  I realize that it's not going to go anywhere, and he's probably going to dismiss it as paranoia or being weird, but he's sounded legitimately bad.  Him saying he's trying something new means literally nothing to me (positive or negative).

 

I like Hallia's early effort and willingness to get involved but her phrasing is rubbing me the wrong way.

 

 

 

 

I never see Cory doing anything that makes him less than who he is naturally at this game, and that's involved and passionate.

 

 

Why the need to include Zander?  You're hydra, no?

 

 

 

What was wrong about me making a dig at corys changed meta? Seems fair game to mention with how often ppl use that as an excuse snd then flip wolf. Not sure cory would use that excuse but I liked his response. That last post was a little stilted, not gonna quote bc it's too long on mobile

 

What meta change?  The one that was pretty much a joke?  What was stilted about my post? I don't quite know what you mean by it being stilted.

 

 

 

 

 

Content wise, everything looks okay, and I don't mind either post to Alanna.  But something strikes me as off.

 

Zander/Alanna both look all right to me.   Zander's early approach to Cory is probably more likely to come from him as town than mafia, and this seems like a really natural response to Cory's advice (which is probably good advice, regardless of Cory's alignment)

 

 

 

Zander earnest advice: if you are a villager, take a little time off and let other people get comfortable in the thread before pushing in any given direction unless you think it has a great deal of merit

 

There's no need to start off the thread with 10+ pages of arguments between four people in a thirteen player game with 48 hours to go. Let the discussion open up a little

 

I am Town

 

And Im gonna call out what I see.

 

No arguments man just asking questions and commenting.

 

 

Regy I'd guess as town, just because of his approach to Sili, and his explanation to Zander about Sili's voting/reasoning seemed plausible enough.  

 

Chris is either Scum and Im worried about my reads or Clov is Town.

 

Imma roll with the latter for now. Slight Town lean on Chris.

 

Seeing eye to eye on things here.

[Clovdyx]

 

 

 

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

 

Sorry whose statement are you referring to here, Alanna or Kat

 

 

What the hell?  That's not even what I wanted to write.  That's literally the exact OPPOSITE of what I wanted to write.

 

It was in regards to Alanna's, though I can see why you didn't get that.  

 

 

So you meant you DON'T have a problem with her calling Kat out on not contributing? :P

 

 

Yeah.  What I intended to write was "I really have no problem with her statement".  

[Zander?]

 

 

 

s

But it's soooo much easier to blame Zander... i mean it's his fault you've posted so much... 

 

Hahaha!  That is true, and more fun.

PSA: Let's make the start of this game a little less     and a little more     and then later when we see real things that make us go     when can   the 

Thank you

I love that idea.  Won't be hard with you here.

 

Defensive

I'll say more when my WiFi works but you're coming off strange, maybe it's something we need to step back from and try again

Meta change as in change of playstyle, I joked/made a dig at cory about him being a wolf bc he said that he was gonna play difreeently, what's bugging you particularly about what I said?

 

Defensive?  Of...myself? I don't get it, I haven't defended myself this game that I can recall.

 

 

I just find i hard to believe you got Scum or bad vibes from BOTH me and Alanna thus far

 

 

Well, considering I've shown where I got them, I don't see how you can't believe it.

 

Kat is awks- town who doesent know how to approach or wolf?

 

This I do agree with you on.

 

 

I like your involvement fwiw.

 

Youre reasoning is thin imo but Ill see how you progress with it.

 

So a question before i forget it.

what exactly are you referring to because hallia hasn't cased anyone that i remember in these 6 pages.

imo it looks like you just added the last part to add it, with no real reasoning.

 

 

She sussed me.

[Regy Rusty]

I understand. I really don't think I can wring any useful info out of their conversation so I'm just going to drop it unless further posts from the two of them allow me to recontextualize it to give a better idea of their alignments.

 

I look forward to when Zander is actually caught up rather than quoting and responding as he goes along. :V

[Sili Quirrels]

Thank god for Hallia

 

Sili either don't sub out or stop posting

 

I reccomend the former, but if you are committed to it then you have no right to be in the thread period

Fwiw requesting a sub out is different from quitting. You have to confirm with the mod that you can sub out first. And so I continued posting.

 

It in my mind makes ethical sense.

 

Unfortunately there would be no point in subbing out now. So it's the former.

[Sili Quirrels]

Though I'm still not entirely sure I'm cut out for this. Alas.

[Katiora]

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

^ This... Clov gets me. I wasn't trying to contribute. At the time I posted there was some kinda thing going on that I didn't really get anything out of. Lainey called my posts fluff and me "trying to look like i'm contributing" I was letting everyone know i was here... that was all. It was in fact fluff and me not trying to contribute and maybe a little bit trying to diffuse the situation. Then I got annoyed lol... I wasn't "as wordy as I  usually am" because I didn't have anything to be wordy about? I mean... really. it was one thing I was harping on... I'm not going to write 5 paragraphs on it. When I actually get into the game and can make some good reads I'll be wordy lol... but until I have data there's nothing to talk about. 

 

Speaking of reads ya'll are a bunch of abrasive argumentative people this game aren't you.... how annoying is that... And btw being argumentative on D1 is not towny. it's just annoying and skews reads, so unless you are mafia and TRYING to skew reads by picking fights maybe you shouldn't (especially on D1) because normally it just moves everyone from honestly trying to figure people out to being defensive and shutting down and making it hard to read anyone. Also it will give mafia a good excuse to not say anything and then when you say "well why aren't you posting" they'll just say they weren't wanting to get in the middle of the fight and it gives them a perfect excuse to just sit back and watch and not implicate themselves in anyway.... it also discourages Town from posting and getting pulled into it and being implicated as well. So in other words it makes OTHER people not post and doesn't really serve a whole lot of purpose... so for the time being can't we all just pretend to be friendly if not friends?? lol 

[Cory Caboose]

All you can do is your best

 

It's not too late to restore order to this circus

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

i read 5 pages like  hours ago. and halfway through 6 or 7.

though i think i may have been a bit hasty on my vote. 

 

I don't know where your vote is, but I know your post to Zander just now is pretty bad.

 

how so? I am trying to figure out where he is coming from because it didn't make sense to me.... posts like this really grind my gears lol....

well you will be happy to know my vote is there as well

 

 

Because the stance he was presumably referencing for having bad reasoning was her saying she was uneasy about THEM.  And given that in the nested quotes Hallia basically says "I've explained why I feel bad about you", it's kind of hard to say she hadn't done so.

 

It isn't like she voted them, or cased them as i said. she says she is uneasy about them, and Tbh I don't think she even gave specific info. so i disagree

so he is basically calling her reasoning thin when she hasn't really offered anything besides she felt uneasy??

 

 

She mentioned Laine as well.

[Regy Rusty]

 

 

Well I'm still as confused about the Alanna and Kat exchange as I was yesterday. The point Alanna seemed to be making about Kat trying to get by with trying to appear contributive while not actually contributing doesn't seem accurate to me, but it's not a smoking gun.

Neither came out smelling like roses tbh and I just need to see more points.

 

In conclusion: idk, I could lynch the Hydra I guess.

 

I'd like to hear specifics on why others are suspicious of them.

 

Depending on how you're interpreting contributing, I really have a big problem with her statement.  I definitely don't think Kat contributed anything early on, but still made an effort to make it known she was following along.  

 

^ This... Clov gets me. I wasn't trying to contribute. At the time I posted there was some kinda thing going on that I didn't really get anything out of. Lainey called my posts fluff and me "trying to look like i'm contributing" I was letting everyone know i was here... that was all. It was in fact fluff and me not trying to contribute and maybe a little bit trying to diffuse the situation. Then I got annoyed lol... I wasn't "as wordy as I  usually am" because I didn't have anything to be wordy about? I mean... really. it was one thing I was harping on... I'm not going to write 5 paragraphs on it. When I actually get into the game and can make some good reads I'll be wordy lol... but until I have data there's nothing to talk about. 

 

Well this is awkward...

 

(Clov in fact agrees more with Alanna and missed a word in that post)

[Cory Caboose]

AORN i am going to focus on finding people I trust

 

I have a short list of Hallia and Sili

 

Get on this list while it's HOT