Beyond the Wall - Game Thread - GAME OVER

[Shad_]

How you explain your read on AJ is very generic.

Also this.

 

I like the third line more than I dislike the second though.

 

I think.

 

I don't know that the snark is the normal instinctive villager reaction to Dice's comment. Suspicion that he's trying to build a case out of thin air might come first.

 

But the snark in general is more of a town Sooh thing.

 

I dunno. I read her more on tone and I've seen a mixed bag so far.

[SiRReN]

Does everyone need to vote for a lynch to happen?

[Andrej]

I didn't see Darthe being cagey at all. He probably just didn't see your question.

 

Now let's talk about players and not game mechanics that are probably safe to assume as being the same as the status quo at DM.

 

I.E. hybrid hammer.

[Andrej]

Somehow I've read through this whole thread twice and absorbed nothing.

 

Here goes round 3.

 

I'll be blunt enough and say that I don't believe you.

 

To the pile, Snow.

[SiRReN]

*chastised*

[Andrej]

That was more for JS than you, SiRReN.

 

I'm not buying that he's read the game twice and the only thing he wants to talk about is Darthe. If he was that concerned he could've asked in his PM like Darthe said to do several times. I guess he missed that on both read throughs though

 

[SiRReN]

Oh I see. I don't know his meta, does he typically not comment on stuff that happens after it's kind of done? I know some people don't like it when you reopen a closed question by commenting on it hours after the people involved left it behind

[keyholder21]

This kind of threw me off.

 

I mean I agree that it's a good question and probably a good look for AJ to force a follow-through.

 

But your wording feels a little overstated? I mean Sili makes two statements and AJ basically says "ok why?" I don't see where it's oh damn awesome question!, more like ok cool AJ's being kind of towny here.

 

Maybe I just don't like the word "hella". <_<

I think I answered this last night, but I have liked AJ throughout the game so far because he’s asking questions that have come to my mind when I am catching up and is pushing the game along, imo. Makes me feel comfortable in slotting AJ as town for now. As for hella, sometimes I talk “gangsta” for I guess no reason. I don’t know why lol.

 

What do you think of Sili so far? 

 

 

I might just clear you and never look back.

 

I imagine I'll be dead soon anyway.

AJ HAS ASKED FOR LIFE AND SO HE SHALL BE GRANTED IT. NONE SHALL STRIKE YOU SO I DECREE!

 

(tm; Lenlo decrees have no legal binding or game effect. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause)

 

This seems weird to me. Even knowing how much Len jokes around. It feels…awkward.

 

 

Though I would be interested in more scum!SiRReN meta.

With SiRReN, the second she starts seeming scummy, kill her.

She takes risks and gambles as scum but had a good track record of slipping by regardless.

 

Since you know her, what is her meta like for town and for 3p? What do you think of her so far? Do you know PBF? If so, what’s your take on her meta?

 

 

I can understand a gut feeling on a tone read, but since I don't know her I can't really say if its a reasonable read on her. It didn't feel off to me at the time, but I could look at it again.

Dont see why asking who Wifi is, is towny, but I liked these two posts.

 

Isn’t this basically the same thing Shad said literally a page ago? Also, I’m not sure how you can have read the quote I left in and not get a townie vibe.

 

Youre also progressing on someone strangely imo.

Who do you think he’s progressing strangely on?

 

I'm reading but I'm not following. Lots of new people all saying stuff, it's hard for me to process it.

Basically I do my best reading and commenting when I feel it necessary, more so as the game progresses. When people want to get reads out of me before I'm ready I usually tell them, well, I'm not allowed to say it here.

Feel free to ask me about anything and I'll give my two cents, I'm just kind of a airhead tbh.

I understand feeling overwhelmed, but more posts in general would help peeps to read YOU.

 

 

 

 

lucky u can u use onbe to vote zander?? maybe we can lynch himn while HE's sleeping for once.....

Maybe I'll vote him later. Right now I'm welcoming Sirren.

 

This pinged me a bit when I first read it and still kind of does, and it's stupid and trivial but lulz if you're a wolf Sooh.

 

I’ve never played with Sooh, so is there more to the ping other than the sort weird refusal to change her vote?

 

 

SiRReN

,,,,,WHY?

 

This pinged me, but I’m not sure why.

 

Z, what are your thoughts irt to AJ currently? To SiRReN?

 

They started asking questions when I head home for the weekend where I have only a phone and no PC and then want long drawn out answers to something that there are no answers for. I didn't even say anything was scummy. I didn't say I didn't like it. It just seemed weird. Y'all are reading a lot into stuff that I didn't say and I don't like how aj has just jumped on me for something that isn't anything.

 

I got a weird GUT feeling from the lenlos posts. I'm not sure what to think of it. It feels different from the past two games I've played with him and I don't know what the difference is. Honestly from his actions I think he could be town. I think if he were scum he would have jumped the AJ vote on me.

 

Maybe he's VT this game. The other games he was rolled. He just seems more loose this game.

 

And I have was tinfoiling a sili/lenlo team lol but it's just tinfoiling. Right now I'm honestly not sure what to think about Zander he seems very sporadic. Makes me concerned.

 

Bold – who asked for long drawn out answers? And to what question?

Are you still tinfoiling a sili/lenlo team now that you think Len might be town? Does this change your perspective on Sili at all?

[Andrej]

Rehashing issues is one thing.

 

Having zero thoughts/reads/anything is another.

[SiRReN]

True.

[John Snow]

Oh I see. I don't know his meta, does he typically not comment on stuff that happens after it's kind of done? I know some people don't like it when you reopen a closed question by commenting on it hours after the people involved left it behind

 

Actually, the only thing I really consistently do is solve mechanics. I play mafia for solving what roles/interactions there are more so than for scumhunting. My scumhunting is kinda subpar tbh. 

[SiRReN]

But we don't know what the roles are in this game.

[John Snow]

I didn't see Darthe being cagey at all. He probably just didn't see your question.

 

Now let's talk about players and not game mechanics that are probably safe to assume as being the same as the status quo at DM.

 

I.E. hybrid hammer.

 

Considering 

 

 

 

Also, is editing OK?

 

And what happens at DL if we fail to lynch?

Please dont edit. Ive updated the rules to reflect this

 

 

Also, is editing OK?

 

And what happens at DL if we fail to lynch?

Please dont edit. Ive updated the rules to reflect this

 

[John Snow]

But we don't know what the roles are in this game.

 

 

 Not yet, obviously. But, already, there's little things you can suss out if you're watching closely.

[Andrej]

And absorbing.

 

Which by your own admission you failed to do. Which is it?

[Darthe]

 

I didn't see Darthe being cagey at all. He probably just didn't see your question.

 

Now let's talk about players and not game mechanics that are probably safe to assume as being the same as the status quo at DM.

 

I.E. hybrid hammer.

Considering

 

 

Also, is editing OK?

 

And what happens at DL if we fail to lynch?

Please dont edit. Ive updated the rules to reflect this

 

Also, is editing OK?

 

And what happens at DL if we fail to lynch?

Please dont edit. Ive updated the rules to reflect this

Sorry, I missed part two there! This is a hybrid hammer. It goes to the player with the most votes on them

[Darthe]

But we don't know what the roles are in this game.

I do!

[SiRReN]

 

But we don't know what the roles are in this game.

I do!

:0!

[Punished Balrog]

 

This kind of threw me off.

 

I mean I agree that it's a good question and probably a good look for AJ to force a follow-through.

 

But your wording feels a little overstated? I mean Sili makes two statements and AJ basically says "ok why?" I don't see where it's oh damn awesome question!, more like ok cool AJ's being kind of towny here.

 

Maybe I just don't like the word "hella". <_<

I think I answered this last night, but I have liked AJ throughout the game so far because he’s asking questions that have come to my mind when I am catching up and is pushing the game along, imo. Makes me feel comfortable in slotting AJ as town for now. As for hella, sometimes I talk “gangsta” for I guess no reason. I don’t know why lol.

 

What do you think of Sili so far? 

 

 

I might just clear you and never look back.

 

I imagine I'll be dead soon anyway.

AJ HAS ASKED FOR LIFE AND SO HE SHALL BE GRANTED IT. NONE SHALL STRIKE YOU SO I DECREE!

 

(tm; Lenlo decrees have no legal binding or game effect. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause)

 

This seems weird to me. Even knowing how much Len jokes around. It feels…awkward.

 

 

Though I would be interested in more scum!SiRReN meta.

With SiRReN, the second she starts seeming scummy, kill her.

She takes risks and gambles as scum but had a good track record of slipping by regardless.

 

Since you know her, what is her meta like for town and for 3p? What do you think of her so far? Do you know PBF? If so, what’s your take on her meta?

 

I'm reading but I'm not following. Lots of new people all saying stuff, it's hard for me to process it.

Basically I do my best reading and commenting when I feel it necessary, more so as the game progresses. When people want to get reads out of me before I'm ready I usually tell them, well, I'm not allowed to say it here.

Feel free to ask me about anything and I'll give my two cents, I'm just kind of a airhead tbh.

I understand feeling overwhelmed, but more posts in general would help peeps to read YOU.

Sorry, I've been busy basically all day and haven't gotten a chance to check in here. 

 

I've gotta go back and read from where I left off, but as for this;

 

For town, SiRReN is a helpful and engaging player. Someone I'd feel confident in following, basically what I'd call a AAA player. 

As far as I can remember I don't think she's ever been a 3rd party so I'm not sure what I'd expect from her. Her philosophy as mafia is that it's their job to give the town something to chase, so she feels really strongly about playing a strong Scum-game but I dunno if that would apply to being 3rd party. She might act the same and make a bunch of ballsy moves though. 

 

As for BF, I really can't say. I would have thought I could nail her scum game after she previously flipped scum but since then I've also seen her flip town in a very similar manor (and very different than previous town games) so for her I'd say all bets are off.

When she was scum, she was very abrasive and got upset when people didn't see eye-to-eye with her and didn't work well with other players who ultimately flipped town. She was also blatant about town-reading her scum mate (which worked out well for her as they never flipped). Unfortunately, I can't really call any of this her scum-tell because her game has really fluctuated.  

 

--

 

I've always been a strong advocate of doing what I do and not caring how I look. On VS people recognise my town game and leave me to it, for the most part. I know this is a different forum with different players and I can't expect the same results here, but I don't up my post count just because I'm asked to. 

[Punished Balrog]

Whoops. I quoted more than I meant to. 

[Shad_]

What do you think of Sili so far?

I couldn't care less about the name confusion. If he's a villager I think it will be pretty obvious soon enough. I've seen him 3P beautifully, but content level is still a major tell for him w vs v. So far null and on the clock; he'll step it up if he's town.

[Andrej]

on the clock is a good way to put it. Every time he comes in for a couple of pot shots and is gone again I get a little more worried.

[Andrej]

Shad I'm kind of bothered you didn't slam Snow when he came in.

 

Or is that still my job in the good cop/bad cop routine?

[Shad_]

 

 

 

lucky u can u use onbe to vote zander?? maybe we can lynch himn while HE's sleeping for once.....

Maybe I'll vote him later. Right now I'm welcoming Sirren.

 

This pinged me a bit when I first read it and still kind of does, and it's stupid and trivial but lulz if you're a wolf Sooh.

 

I’ve never played with Sooh, so is there more to the ping other than the sort weird refusal to change her vote?

 

Refusal to change the vote is an odd way of looking at it when Dice was joking around.

 

It's the formality of it, which I'm now starting to think might be non-existent and I missed a bit of dry humor here. Sooh has some differences in her manner of stating things that I can't really articulate but tend to pick up on, and it makes a difference based on the degree to which that post was joking vs obligatory responding, and it's subtle and not very substantive in a single instance and blah blah I'm not really interested in making reads on p3 content but reserve the right to gloat excessively if proven correct.

[Katiora]

@key Aj was giving me a hard time for not "properly" replying to lenlo being annoyed at me saying his interactions with sili were a bit weird for me.

 

Not really tinfoiling any more either. Usually once I sleep on it and come back and retook over stuff I get over it lol. Right now I'm more worried about Zander. I just haven't seen his town game yet. Makes me sadface.gif