Beyond the Wall - Game Thread - GAME OVER

[Zander?]

Your picking out literally the weirdest things Z.

 

Ive little to no Meta on some of these players.

 

Wanna see whats what,

[SiRReN]

 

I don't remember Zander bring this clueless in Haunted Mansion, but I never pictured him as the type of person to fake posts like this one.

You are aware that Zander was the wolf ghost in HM, yes?

Oh damn, that's right. I'd forgotten he was the mafia ghost because for nearly the entire game I didn't think it was him haha.

[Shad_]

Meta kinda important imo.

 

I get that you may read people differently but the fact you have no sample would at least make me wary of a read one way or another atp.  But you started this read pretty early.  It sticks out to me.

 

Im not saying its right or wrong, I have no idea on her atp.

AJ's felt pretty consistently villagery to me so far. >_>

[Shad_]

Oh damn, that's right. I'd forgotten he was the mafia ghost because for nearly the entire game I didn't think it was him haha.

Anyway Zander faking confusion as a wolf has been a thing lately.

 

And I don't know why he keeps doing it because I keep calling him out on it.

 

But I kind of feel like he might be doing it again. >_>

 

And I'm not really on the same page with him at all right now when we tend to see eye-to-eye on most things as villagers.

[Andrej]

Agreed.

 

On Hallia for what exactly?

 

Ive no problem with her actual content thus far but not a fan of involvement level atp.

 

She town read Sili earlier.

 

I'm pretty sure you asked her about it.

 

Im saying Sili is null.

 

And yes obv im questioning an easy Town read on a new player from another site.

 

Okay, I could buy null.

 

The issue I have now is that you are making a lot of noise about me pointing out issues I have with Sili when essentially you're saying you don't have an opinion on him.

 

Meta kinda important imo.

 

I get that you may read people differently but the fact you have no sample would at least make me wary of a read one way or another atp.  But you started this read pretty early.  It sticks out to me.

 

Im not saying its right or wrong, I have no idea on her atp.

 

I don't disagree that meta can be important, but without that baseline - how else am I supposed to go about reading new players than taking their posts at face value and evaluating?

 

I feel like I've explained it pretty well atp. Again, you're making an issue of something you apparently don't have your own opinion on.

[Shad_]

way too early for reads reads:

 

towny

 

Andrej

Lenlo

Sirren

Punished Balrog?

 

null

 

Calder

dicetosser1

Hallia

John Snow

Katiora

PrincessBFlea

Sili

Sooh

Wildfire Sedai

 

Concerning

 

Keyholder?

Zander

[Andrej]

I wish I would proof read my posts sometimes.

 

It bothers me to look at them after and see myself using the same word repetitively >_>

[Andrej]

way too early for reads reads:

 

Yes, probably too early for a full list.

 

But finding a couple of gems in the coal isn't necessarily bad.

[SiRReN]

I can say that Princess is a highly analytical player who thrives on ISOing players and pointing out inconsistencies. She's known for walls of text, but has difficulty reading tone. This is true for her town AND scum games. She's also relatively new to mafia in general - this will be her sixth game I believe, whereas I've been playing for a year now.

 

I tried unsuccessfully to tone read her last game, so I'm uncertain what's going to happen when she gets into the thick of this game. When she does show up though, expect a lot of serious analysis from her.

[PrincessBFlea]

Sorry, I fell asleep earlier while re-reading the thread, and then had to go out with my mom =_= Not that I don't like going out with her, it's just been a really long week.

 

So, has anyone answered my question yet? Where is Calder? I still don't think I've seen a post from them?? 

 

Also, at the moment, these are my very base reads, just on the re-read and what I've seen so far:

 

Suspicious

Zander

What Is Going On?

Keyholder

Calder
Dice

SiRReN

Balrog

John Snow
Sili
Sooh
Wildfire Sedai

Trustworthy-ish
 

Hallia

AJ

Lenlo

Kat

Shad

 

These have no evidence to back them up yet, just are how I'm feeling atm based on what I've seen. Gonna try and start some ISO's now that I know how to do them, but I needs a shower, and then I have work and friendship time tomorrow, so not sure how much I'll be able to get done and posted! THIS LIST IS DEFINITELY GOING TO CHANGE THOUGH.... simply because it always does ^_^

[Shad_]

My initial thought was "are you sure you aren't from PerC?"

 

And that was even before any WoTs.

[Shad_]

speak of the devil

[Shad_]

Your list inversion is going to trip me out all game.

[Shad_]

Calder has played a good bit on DM but I wouldn't call him a regular here, and it's entirely possible that he doesn't know the game started yet.

 

Now I'm going to kill some people in Overwatch and go to bed.

[PrincessBFlea]

As to SiRReN's comment, so far that has been my meta~ but I'm still settling into my skin, and having to adapt as I go, especially when my schedule doesn't allow for me to post as often as I'd like to! ^_^

 

However I am a fan of WoT, and I WILL be heavily analytical either way... but my accuracy rate on catching scum is pretty decent! If I don't flat out call them on it, I've at least been heavily sus of them! 

 

:D Which makes me proud of myself, as this will be my 5th game actually ^_^

[PrincessBFlea]

Calder has played a good bit on DM but I wouldn't call him a regular here, and it's entirely possible that he doesn't know the game started yet.

 

Now I'm going to kill some people in Overwatch and go to bed.

 

Okay, thanks! :3 I'd still like to see something from him, but that's more of a "How can I read what doesn't exist" thing, and having even one missing element can effect how everyone else interacts and behaves, so I'm looking forward to when he pops in!

 

Okay, to shower~~~!

[Andrej]

I can say that Princess is a highly analytical player who thrives on ISOing players and pointing out inconsistencies. She's known for walls of text, but has difficulty reading tone. This is true for her town AND scum games. She's also relatively new to mafia in general - this will be her sixth game I believe, whereas I've been playing for a year now.

 

I tried unsuccessfully to tone read her last game, so I'm uncertain what's going to happen when she gets into the thick of this game. When she does show up though, expect a lot of serious analysis from her.

 

Shad said something earlier that I think was important irt Balrog.

 

Do you agree/disagree?

[Hallia]

 

 

 

Voted z cause tone. Didnt seem to care about my alignmeny. I retract that. He sounds better now.

What gave you that impression and where did it change?

 

AJ again with a hella good q.

 

This kind of threw me off.

 

I mean I agree that it's a good question and probably a good look for AJ to force a follow-through.

 

But your wording feels a little overstated? I mean Sili makes two statements and AJ basically says "ok why?" I don't see where it's oh damn awesome question!, more like ok cool AJ's being kind of towny here.

 

Maybe I just don't like the word "hella". <_<

 

Also find it odd because I had just used a similar phrase, saying that something was a good question.  SHE'S JACKING MY STYLE.

 

 

Len, if you're catching up you should see.

It's a light read, but I feel okay about it for pg 15 and on someone I've never played with before.

I'd put you up there too, I think.

I don't mind the town read of Sirren, she sounds townish to me.

 

 

Agreed.

 

On Hallia for what exactly?

 

Ive no problem with her actual content thus far but not a fan of involvement level atp.

 

She town read Sili earlier.

 

I'm pretty sure you asked her about it.

 

And if you look back, I answered him too.

[Andrej]

speak of the devil

 

Amusingly in tuned with my exact reaction.

[Andrej]

I know you did, Hallia. And I believe I responded in kind.

 

I was asking for Zander's thoughts on it

[Andrej]

@Princess - it would help me a lot if you could provide some thoughts about your town/suspect reads. I can understand the huge cluster of nulls, because I'm in a similar spot, but a few words on the others would be nice.

 

Thanks!

[PrincessBFlea]

 

I can say that Princess is a highly analytical player who thrives on ISOing players and pointing out inconsistencies. She's known for walls of text, but has difficulty reading tone. This is true for her town AND scum games. She's also relatively new to mafia in general - this will be her sixth game I believe, whereas I've been playing for a year now.

 

I tried unsuccessfully to tone read her last game, so I'm uncertain what's going to happen when she gets into the thick of this game. When she does show up though, expect a lot of serious analysis from her.

 

Shad said something earlier that I think was important irt Balrog.

 

Do you agree/disagree?

 

 

PB is playing pretty much exactly how I've seen him play as town twice before.

 

I don't know if his wolf game looks any different, but I'm certainly not bothered.

 

 

Are you talking about this?? Balrog is consistently difficult for me to read, but I would say so far this feels townie for him. Last time he felt off for me, I noticed it pretty quickly... Wolf Him is more accomodating and apologetic and trying too hard to seem townie, without actually putting in more effort to post more often or even more period.

 

 

PB is playiDoDng pretty much exactly how I've seen him play as town twice before.

 

I don't know if his wolf game looks any different, but I'm certainly not bothered.

 

[PrincessBFlea]

I really hate the post box for this site =_= it isn't responding to my commands and I'm having trouble making it bigger and arg!

[Andrej]

I wasn't kidding about clearing Shad earlier, either.

 

I understand that his scum game is pretty solid, and I don't doubt that he could fool me, but we've never had issues linking up as townies in the past and I'm almost purely going to rely on my intuition here.

 

Shad

Lenlo

SiRReN

 

WiFI (this is for silly reasons, though I would be amused if someone tried to tell me why)

 

Other than that, I'll be out for the night soon whenever my wife gets home from work. Until then I'll be hanging around trying to resist posting too much

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Zander[/v]

[Lenlo]

I am ok with my joke vote on Zander becoming a real one.