[Basic] I <3 the 90's Mafia: Music Edition - TOWN WINS!

[Katiora]

I will only have a short time now but will be her in 30 minutes.

 

Hallia - I knew but I didn't know how to signal it without outing us both. We'll now it's done and Mafia will have a hard time.

 

This is important! Wish thought my post about Hallia was me signaling cop but still she voted me. Try to talk yourself out of that before I get back.

THANK YOU NIN!!!! 

 

Besie and Wish for the SCUM!!! 

[wish-tree]

Wish what did you mean by 'Nin has reason to think Hallia town, but a doc save doesn't mean town...'?

I didn't want to vote Nin yesterday because I thought she was the cop with a green on Hallia, but that would have been impossible b/c DM doesn't use N0 checks afaik... so yeah

 

then I reread Nin's posts after her claim today, some before the claim that said Nin said that Hallia was town for reasons and wouldn't explain them, which seemed to me to be a cop soft but that wouldn't make sense, b/c she claimed doc. Hallia claiming that she was Nin's other half - Nin saying she's a limited doc, means that Hallia is probably also a limited doc. Therefore I'm not confused anymore, I think.

[Katiora]

[unvote]

 

I need to think about this and decide, I think I was too hasty jumping on Besie.

Don't think... just do it trust your gut! 

[Hallia]

I will only have a short time now but will be her in 30 minutes.

 

Hallia - I knew but I didn't know how to signal it without outing us both. We'll now it's done and Mafia will have a hard time.

 

This is important! Wish thought my post about Hallia was me signaling cop but still she voted me. Try to talk yourself out of that before I get back.

O.O oh my. Get it Ninners

[wish-tree]

well, you ninja'd me

 

I thought you had a n0 on Hallia, which makes no sense in this setup

[Guest]

I was town last game, and I'm town this game. In both, people claimed. Granted, both then and the one now (seph) has been true. But if people just believe claims so easily, then why don't scum claim more often? It just doesn't make sense to me.

[BFG]

I'm still mixed on Laine

 

On the one hand her observation along the lines of 'didn't like my argument with Zander, frustration/something else?' was incredibly observant that I don't know if mafia notice or bother pushing

 

On the other I don't get her 'Zander 'post delay' thing' although I think she tried to observe it and I don't know if she ever addressed Hallia's point about whether telling 2 people to shut up is something she'd do.

 

At the moment I'd go with slight town because of the 'something else' thing, but I definitely need to reread

[wish-tree]

I PMed the mod and she said it would have been written in the setup if there was a n0

[Katiora]

I PMed the mod and she said it would have been written in the setup if there was a n0

What does this even mean?? 

[Guest]

Hallia, will you please still tell me why you voted me?

[Hallia]

I...did?

[BFG]

I was town last game, and I'm town this game. In both, people claimed. Granted, both then and the one now (seph) has been true. But if people just believe claims so easily, then why don't scum claim more often? It just doesn't make sense to me.

Mafia do claim

 

Despo (older player) used to believe VT claims, because mafia claim cop to out them

[Hallia]

[wish-tree]

 

I PMed the mod and she said it would have been written in the setup if there was a n0

What does this even mean?? 

 

On the site I play mafia the most, there are night 0 actions. Every cop gets randomized a night 0 check on a random townie. I wasn't sure if this was the case, but I thought that's what was being softed yesterday. 

 

Then I asked the mod if there were night 0 actions, and she said if there were, the setup would have said. That's why I didn't believe Nin's hint. 

[wish-tree]

And until Hallia came out and verified it, I thought Nin was lying.

[Clovdyx]

 

Wish what did you mean by 'Nin has reason to think Hallia town, but a doc save doesn't mean town...'?

 

I didn't want to vote Nin yesterday because I thought she was the cop with a green on Hallia, but that would have been impossible b/c DM doesn't use N0 checks afaik... so yeah

 

then I reread Nin's posts after her claim today, some before the claim that said Nin said that Hallia was town for reasons and wouldn't explain them, which seemed to me to be a cop soft but that wouldn't make sense, b/c she claimed doc. Hallia claiming that she was Nin's other half - Nin saying she's a limited doc, means that Hallia is probably also a limited doc. Therefore I'm not confused anymore, I think.

Weren't you on Niniel for pretty much all of today?

[BFG]

Besie's reaction was poor, but I don't know it makes her mafia.

 

She's pretty astute as mafia, does she out herself to push a lynch on a claimed PR when she knows she'll look awful after a flip?

[wish-tree]

 

 

Wish what did you mean by 'Nin has reason to think Hallia town, but a doc save doesn't mean town...'?

I didn't want to vote Nin yesterday because I thought she was the cop with a green on Hallia, but that would have been impossible b/c DM doesn't use N0 checks afaik... so yeah

 

then I reread Nin's posts after her claim today, some before the claim that said Nin said that Hallia was town for reasons and wouldn't explain them, which seemed to me to be a cop soft but that wouldn't make sense, b/c she claimed doc. Hallia claiming that she was Nin's other half - Nin saying she's a limited doc, means that Hallia is probably also a limited doc. Therefore I'm not confused anymore, I think.

Weren't you on Niniel for pretty much all of today?

 

I asked the mod last night. Thought that Nin was scummy outside of her "do you want me to claim", but I thought that was a role soft so I tried to protect her.

[wish-tree]

If you check my ISO, I'd been scum reading nin until she said "do you want me to claim"

[Guest]

 

I was town last game, and I'm town this game. In both, people claimed. Granted, both then and the one now (seph) has been true. But if people just believe claims so easily, then why don't scum claim more often? It just doesn't make sense to me.

Mafia do claim

 

Despo (older player) used to believe VT claims, because mafia claim cop to out them

 

 

... I see the sense in that. So the maf would claim cop and "out" the actual claim. So that when the vt is lynched, the fake cop is lynched the next day. Right?

[Guest]

 

 

... can I offer hugs?

[Katiora]

Besie's reaction was poor, but I don't know it makes her mafia.

 

She's pretty astute as mafia, does she out herself to push a lynch on a claimed PR when she knows she'll look awful after a flip?

She does if she thinks she can get away with it and say "i thought it was fake, how would I know?"

[wish-tree]

I have this thing where I read scummy people as either mafia or PR, because both of those roles have something to hide, I can't tell the difference. I don't try to push the ones I think could be PR because I don't want to endanger them, but if their claim is proven to be false, then I will push them. 

 

So nin's gut reads - I feel x is town - seemed like a good way to soft a n0, but when I found out there were no n0 checks in this setup, that made me go after her really hard at the start of today.

[Guest]

Besie's reaction was poor, but I don't know it makes her mafia.

 

She's pretty astute as mafia, does she out herself to push a lynch on a claimed PR when she knows she'll look awful after a flip?

 

2 things:

 

1. sounds like WIFOM

2. after searching for the definition of "astute" - awww

[Lenlo]

[unvote][v]Dice [/v]

 

Easy choice.