[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Nynaeve]

The thing there is again why would Thane claim cop if he is third party. There are lot other PRs to go with that could easily pass :)

 

Exactly. But why would he do it as scum. Who in their right mind come in with a THIRD cop claim and expect people just to swallow it over? Come on.

[Nynaeve]

I refuse to believe in a world where Than does something like that as scum.

[Nynaeve]

Something doesn't feel right here. 

[Nynaeve]

yolo lynch Lily first imo. 

[BFG]

Do you believe Eldricks confusion over the no death?

[Nynaeve]

What scummate walks in seeing his own scummate failing badly at countering lily and then figures... hey I KNOW... I'm gonna try too!! 

[Nynaeve]

AFTER we get confirmation on her guilty.

[Nynaeve]

I mean seriously. Think about it. Let it sink in. Put yourself in Thane's shoes..... if he's scum? He'd be mindnumbingly..... [insert bad word].... if he's the cop? Obviously he'd come forward. 

[Nynaeve]

Do you believe Eldricks confusion over the no death?

 

Not confusion. He posted at the SAME TIME as the scene. imo had it typed up and basically pushed post right as the scene was posted. Look at his post. Unless he's a REALLY fast typer.... he just rushed in. 4 mins later Lily is countering him.

[BFG]

IF it was 4 mafia they'd have expected to win start Day 3 at 4v4 so why bother with the fake claim thing?

[LilyElizabeth]

 

 

Hi Zander. I'm studying for a test that I have in 8 hours. This is horrible

Alanna......The North Remembers......

OH my god, Zander, I'm not mafia this game, okay? I'M NOT MAFIA. I don't know what I need to do to prove it to you, but you're probably just gonna have to lynch me to solve me, okay?

 

 

Not if I'm still alive. I'll view you tomorrow night. 

[Nynaeve]

Breadcrumbing could be a cop leaving his reads behind. It could also be done to screw with a doc too. Think about that. 

 

 

I am terrible at noticing breadcrumbing. So if I noticed it? It was noticable. Lily should have been shot N1. She wasn't. BG casually mentions that Turin is his kryptonite.... Turin dies.... Lily uses it to push BG.  It all feels...... almost too tidy.

[LilyElizabeth]

 

So, I was completely serious about wanting a mentor. Anyone want to tackle this train wreck?

I would but this is my last game and I'm probably not going to stick around DM

 

 

Nooooooooooooooo

[Nynaeve]

IF it was 4 mafia they'd have expected to win start Day 3 at 4v4 so why bother with the fake claim thing?

 

I dunno. I'm trying to brainstorm. But something doesn't make sense here. If we have a spare lynch, like we assumed we do, then why bother false claiming at all? It doesn't lead to a win.... weather it's Lily lying or Thane.

[BFG]

 

IF it was 4 mafia they'd have expected to win start Day 3 at 4v4 so why bother with the fake claim thing?

I dunno. I'm trying to brainstorm. But something doesn't make sense here. If we have a spare lynch, like we assumed we do, then why bother false claiming at all? It doesn't lead to a win.... weather it's Lily lying or Thane.

I don't know.

 

Keep it simple, lynch Eldrick?

[BFG]

Hi Lily :)

[Nynaeve]

 

 

IF it was 4 mafia they'd have expected to win start Day 3 at 4v4 so why bother with the fake claim thing?

I dunno. I'm trying to brainstorm. But something doesn't make sense here. If we have a spare lynch, like we assumed we do, then why bother false claiming at all? It doesn't lead to a win.... weather it's Lily lying or Thane.

I don't know.

 

Keep it simple, lynch Eldrick?

 

 

Eldrick is next for sure. That's not the problem. 

[Nynaeve]

Eventually we are gonna have to settle the cop dispute, is all. 

[Zander?]

I really dont think theres 4 Scum in a 12 player game.

[Pralaya]

Breadcrumbing could be a cop leaving his reads behind. It could also be done to screw with a doc too. Think about that. 

 

 

I am terrible at noticing breadcrumbing. So if I noticed it? It was noticable. Lily should have been shot N1. She wasn't. BG casually mentions that Turin is his kryptonite.... Turin dies.... Lily uses it to push BG.  It all feels...... almost too tidy.

 

She didn't breadcrumb N1. How could she have? :)

[Zander?]

Were lynching Eld today no matter what.

 

Gives us more time to think

[Zander?]

 

Breadcrumbing could be a cop leaving his reads behind. It could also be done to screw with a doc too. Think about that. 

 

 

I am terrible at noticing breadcrumbing. So if I noticed it? It was noticable. Lily should have been shot N1. She wasn't. BG casually mentions that Turin is his kryptonite.... Turin dies.... Lily uses it to push BG.  It all feels...... almost too tidy.

 

She didn't breadcrumb N1. How could she have? :)

 

 

^^^^^^

[Nynaeve]

My take? Content wise Lily is townier than Thane. Peeking choices wise? I think Lily made a choice that makes sense to me more. 

 

Timing wise? Don't like Lily's timing compared to Eldrick's. Thane's claim, timing wise, makes me feel like it could be legit. 

 

 

As far as connections to BG and Eldrick? That I'm gonna have to research.

[Nynaeve]

 

Breadcrumbing could be a cop leaving his reads behind. It could also be done to screw with a doc too. Think about that. 

 

 

I am terrible at noticing breadcrumbing. So if I noticed it? It was noticable. Lily should have been shot N1. She wasn't. BG casually mentions that Turin is his kryptonite.... Turin dies.... Lily uses it to push BG.  It all feels...... almost too tidy.

 

She didn't breadcrumb N1. How could she have? :)

 

 

Not breadcrumbing per say. But when she flipped out at BFG and Turin 1.0 "guessing" she was cop?  I thought it was a dead give away that she could be the cop.

[LilyElizabeth]

Lily, for curiosity purposes, what is your character?

John Winchester