[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Eldrick4221]

On the plus side, lily is probably checking Thane tonight. That buys us another night.

[Eldrick4221]

 

It was loads of fun watching nyn, laine, and. Run Nolder and Turin up, though.

It was funner to see you get told by your own mommy.

Hehe yeah

[BFG]

 

BFG

 

Pretty sure BFG was casing him since D1

 

Um, yes?

[Zander?]

Now for a vote that counts.

 

[V]Thane [/v]

 

Cuz he's #1 on the list :D

 

 

I meant [unvote]

 

[V]Turin [/v]

 

T names....

 

 

If Thane is your teammate Ill never stop laughing at this

[BFG]

 

 

I am not talking about D2. I am talking about N2.

 

Who was casing Thane aside from me?  I don't follow.

 

BFG

 

Srs?

 

Lol

[Pralaya]

 

 

 

 

 

BG, Eldrick and Zander. Need to get this done

Im not Scum dude.

 

I agree 100% on BG and Eld tho

 

If you are actually town, then tell me this.

 

BG and Eld made a counter train on Thane against Turin. Does this look like distancing to you?

 

If not, who is the deep-wolf. Was Eld the only scum in Nolder train? Other than me and Thane, that leaves Alanna, Nyn, BFG and Lily. Who is it?

 

there were probably a maximum of 4 votes possible on Thane, it was a low risk train of actually being lynched.

 

True. But, if distancing was what the scum team was planning, why Thane? Why not go with someone who people suspected - like Eld himself?

 

I am not saying that it is impossible, but it is kind of unlikely.

 

Of course, if you are thinking outside BG/Eld, then the whole thing changes

 

Pretty much. I'm not convinced Eldrick is mafia, and I'm not overly confident in the POE and we probably have no ML left.

 

I think you, Nyn, Lily are all likely town. but that still leaves a fairly hefty POE.

 

Laine is tricky. Her reads have been fairly fluid and easy to observe, but for Laine hasnt engaged her suspects very much. She has spent a fair bit of time defending herself but that could be a function of having people sussing her early. Out of the group that's left I'd probably say most likely town, for the transparency.

 

Zanders reads don't seem as fluid, I really don't like the immediate agreement with Thane that it should be Eldrick today, he's been soft defending Thane all game, he doesn't appear to be re-evaluating after mislynches. He has engaged Sooh, Nolder - but I disagreed with his early case on Sooh, although he came out of it looking better. He's also stopped poking everywhere. how much is due to change in style I don't know. He has gone complete tunnel vision as town before, so I can't rule the possibility out.

 

It's tricky, my thoughts/confidence in the game have been very different to all of Nyn/Zander/Laine all game, so I do find it difficult to relax.

 

Eldrick is a difficult read and one we can't get wrong now. I was feeling ok Day1, but his decreased involvement doesn't look good.

 

Thane has been covered.

 

BG pending ISO still :(

 

I would really like a mafia flip before I start piecing together possible teams :/

 

That's why I specifically asked her if she wanted to throw both BG and Eldrick out of the scum list. And, she was positive neither BG nor Eldrick were scum.

 

I mean, pretty much everyone saw BG as scum at that time.

[Pralaya]

 

BFG

 

Pretty sure BFG was casing him since D1

 

So? She ramped it up on N2.

[Zander?]

Incoming...

 

 

From Mars?

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

 

 

BG, Eldrick and Zander. Need to get this done

Im not Scum dude.

 

I agree 100% on BG and Eld tho

 

If you are actually town, then tell me this.

 

BG and Eld made a counter train on Thane against Turin. Does this look like distancing to you?

 

If not, who is the deep-wolf. Was Eld the only scum in Nolder train? Other than me and Thane, that leaves Alanna, Nyn, BFG and Lily. Who is it?

 

there were probably a maximum of 4 votes possible on Thane, it was a low risk train of actually being lynched.

 

True. But, if distancing was what the scum team was planning, why Thane? Why not go with someone who people suspected - like Eld himself?

 

I am not saying that it is impossible, but it is kind of unlikely.

 

Of course, if you are thinking outside BG/Eld, then the whole thing changes

 

Pretty much. I'm not convinced Eldrick is mafia, and I'm not overly confident in the POE and we probably have no ML left.

 

I think you, Nyn, Lily are all likely town. but that still leaves a fairly hefty POE.

 

Laine is tricky. Her reads have been fairly fluid and easy to observe, but for Laine hasnt engaged her suspects very much. She has spent a fair bit of time defending herself but that could be a function of having people sussing her early. Out of the group that's left I'd probably say most likely town, for the transparency.

 

Zanders reads don't seem as fluid, I really don't like the immediate agreement with Thane that it should be Eldrick today, he's been soft defending Thane all game, he doesn't appear to be re-evaluating after mislynches. He has engaged Sooh, Nolder - but I disagreed with his early case on Sooh, although he came out of it looking better. He's also stopped poking everywhere. how much is due to change in style I don't know. He has gone complete tunnel vision as town before, so I can't rule the possibility out.

 

It's tricky, my thoughts/confidence in the game have been very different to all of Nyn/Zander/Laine all game, so I do find it difficult to relax.

 

Eldrick is a difficult read and one we can't get wrong now. I was feeling ok Day1, but his decreased involvement doesn't look good.

 

Thane has been covered.

 

BG pending ISO still :(

 

I would really like a mafia flip before I start piecing together possible teams :/

 

That's why I specifically asked her if she wanted to throw both BG and Eldrick out of the scum list. And, she was positive neither BG nor Eldrick were scum.

 

I mean, pretty much everyone saw BG as scum at that time.

 

No?

 

I was unsure on Eldrick. BGs bottom of the list.

 

 

 

BFG

 

Pretty sure BFG was casing him since D1

 

So? She ramped it up on N2.

 

Not really, I spent Day/Night 1 asking Laine/Zander/Nyn to review Thane, I spent Night 2 asking Zander/you/Nyn to look at Thane because I think he's mafia.

[Nynaeve]

 

 

BFG

 

Pretty sure BFG was casing him since D1

 

So? She ramped it up on N2.

 

 

So she did that while they were expecting it to be LYLO and cooked up a counter claim to Lily?   Eh.  

[Hallia]

I got pulled into work, will be out in just a few moments -.-

[Zander?]

I got pulled into work, will be out in just a few moments -.-

 

yes ma'am!!!!

 

<3 <3 <3

[Nynaeve]

I think BFG is town. At best she was right on Thane all along. At worst she was just wrong.

[Nynaeve]

I think last scum is prolly Thane. If not, time to look at Laine. Pral seems so involved that I'm getting a good feeling there, even though I don't necessarily agree with him on some things.

[Zander?]

I think last scum is prolly Thane. If not, time to look at Laine. Pral seems so involved that I'm getting a good feeling there, even though I don't necessarily agree with him on some things.

 

 

Nyn, does it hurt being GOAT??

[Nynaeve]

 

I think last scum is prolly Thane. If not, time to look at Laine. Pral seems so involved that I'm getting a good feeling there, even though I don't necessarily agree with him on some things.

 

 

Nyn, does it hurt being GOAT??

 

 

I wouldn't know. I've been kinda lame this game in case you haven't noticed lol   But gotta pick yourself up.

[BFG]

I think last scum is prolly Thane. If not, time to look at Laine. Pral seems so involved that I'm getting a good feeling there, even though I don't necessarily agree with him on some things.

Agreed

[BFG]

 

 

Eld

 

Then

 

 

Last wolf in here

 

Thane Alanna Pral

Dude, seriously? Mafia needed one lynch to win (they assumed they would have a NK). They spent the entire N2 trying to drive the mislynch on Thane to. ALl they needed was two votes and bam, they would have got the win.

 

 

 

Dude we have 2/3 the scum team.

 

its 6 -3

 

after today its 6-2

 

after nk, tomorrow starts

 

5-2

 

we lynch eld

 

5-1

 

Thats 3 mislynches if my maths right?

 

NK:

4-1

 

ML/NK

 

2-1

 

Pretty sure it's 1 mislynch before lylo barring a doc protect.

[Hallia]

Ok.  Back at desktop; VC and PC coming now.

[Nynaeve]

D3 - 9 players (3 scum, 6 town).  scum lynch

D4 - 7 players (2 scum, 5 town).  scum lynch

D5 - 5 players (1 scum, 4 town). 1 mislynch

D6 - 3 players (1 scum, 2 town) - LYLO

[Eldrick4221]

D3 - 9 players (3 scum, 6 town). scum lynch

D4 - 7 players (2 scum, 5 town). scum lynch

D5 - 5 players (1 scum, 4 town). 1 mislynch

D6 - 3 players (1 scum, 2 town) - LYLO

I approve of this plan.

[Nynaeve]

In case anyone cares I'm gonna stop reading the thread for obvious reasons.

 

I liked this plan

[Hallia]

Final Vote Count:

 

Lily(1): BG

BG(5): Lily, Nyn, Zander, Pral, Eldrick

 

The good guys finally had a solid lead.  And although this demon was a smooth talking son of a gun, he was no match for the united band of unlikely heroes.

 

BGrishinko - Crowley - Mafia Roleblocker has been lynched!

 

 

It is now Night!  You have 24 Hours for Night Actions.

[Nynaeve]

A roleblocker in a basic game?  That's OUTRAGOUS

[Hallia]

Scenes can be longer after today as well.  Vacation is over!