[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Zander?]

Nyn, If you're right and this is LYLO, there's a fourth one, isn't there?

 

And yes, Thane. 

 

Who's your deep wolf candidate, Zander?

 

 

Wait WHat???

 

4 Scum in a 12er is pretty bastard imo.

[Eldrick4221]

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

[Nynaeve]

Nyn, If you're right and this is LYLO, there's a fourth one, isn't there?

 

And yes, Thane. 

 

Who's your deep wolf candidate, Zander?

 

3 scum:

D1-12 players (3 scum, 9 town)  - mislynch and NK

D2-10 - players (3 scum, 7 town) - mislynch and no NK

D3- 8 players (3 scum, 6 town) - IF there's a mislynch and NK

D4- 6 players (3 scum, 4 town) - LYLO

 

 

4 scum:

D1-12 players (4 scum, 8 town)  - mislynch and NK

D2-10 - players (4 scum, 6 town) - mislynch and no NK

D3- 8 players (4 scum, 5 town) - LYLO

[Zander?]

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

 

 

Wasnt WoW basic?  Or am I wrong?

[Nynaeve]

The default ratio is 1:4 but I have seen mods who deviated from it. So there's no telling. But it's not something I'm gonna be worrying about anyhow. If the game doesn't end after we lynch a third scum? Then I'll worry.

[Nynaeve]

 

Nyn, If you're right and this is LYLO, there's a fourth one, isn't there?

 

And yes, Thane. 

 

Who's your deep wolf candidate, Zander?

 

3 scum:

D1-12 players (3 scum, 9 town)  - mislynch and NK

D2-10 - players (3 scum, 7 town) - mislynch and no NK

D3- 8 players (3 scum, 6 town) - IF there's a mislynch and NK

D4- 6 players (3 scum, 4 town) - LYLO

 

 

4 scum:

D1-12 players (4 scum, 8 town)  - mislynch and NK

D2-10 - players (4 scum, 6 town) - mislynch and no NK

D3- 8 players (4 scum, 5 town) - LYLO

 

 

I made a misake. In D3 it should say 9 players, not 8. Apparently math is lost on me.

[Nynaeve]

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

 

Wifom

[LilyElizabeth]

I agree with you Zander, on the deep wolf candidate, and that there should only be 3 scum. I've seen a lot of games in my time, and they aren't always perfectly balanced. I don't know Hallia's level of experience. (No offense, hon.)

[Nynaeve]

 

So... while we wait for BG to be run up.

 

 

Zander and Lily..... who do you think the third one is? Thane?

 

 

Maybe but I have a Deep Wolf Candidate....

 

 

Which is?

[Eldrick4221]

 

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

 

Wasnt WoW basic? Or am I wrong?

I didn't play WoW. But giving scum extra powers throws off the balance. Basic is balanced because it's simple. Just those 2-3 roles.

 

Unless they've changed that over the years. That's how it was.

[Nynaeve]

Wait WHat???

 

4 Scum in a 12er is pretty bastard imo.

 

 

I've seen it done in JN. But again, not something I think we should worry about. 

[Zander?]

 

 

So... while we wait for BG to be run up.

 

 

Zander and Lily..... who do you think the third one is? Thane?

 

 

Maybe but I have a Deep Wolf Candidate....

 

 

Which is?

 

 

 

 

Nyn, If you're right and this is LYLO, there's a fourth one, isn't there?

 

And yes, Thane. 

 

Who's your deep wolf candidate, Zander?

 

 

Alanna if there is one imo

 

 

[Nynaeve]

 

Nyn, If you're right and this is LYLO, there's a fourth one, isn't there?

 

And yes, Thane. 

 

Who's your deep wolf candidate, Zander?

 

 

Alanna if there is one imo

 

 

 

 

That's fair.

[Zander?]

 

 

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

 

Wasnt WoW basic? Or am I wrong?

I didn't play WoW. But giving scum extra powers throws off the balance. Basic is balanced because it's simple. Just those 2-3 roles.

 

Unless they've changed that over the years. That's how it was.

 

 

 

if WoW was basis it was 1 RB 2 goons in a 13er.

[LilyElizabeth]

Today is BG. Tomorrow Eldrick. By then maybe I'll have a view on Thane. 

[Nynaeve]

Or Alanna >.>

[LilyElizabeth]

Or both

[bgrishinko]

[v]Vote Lily[/v]

 

So Lily's explanation:

She claims to have guilty on me. Instead of just telling people this, she "hints" it in such a way that (as Nyn said) you'd have to be blind not to notice. So what's the difference in not just claiming cop right then? Why not just knock me out right then and there if I were mafia? I can understand the need for a cop to keep their cover, but Lily didn't even try so it has the same result. Mafia would know who you are. Only town might not get that if they are focused on following other leads.  Town!Lily would have to know for certain that mafia would pick up on that. Instead, she encourages the Turin line from behind hoping to get another townie lynch out of it before having to release her fake claim. This also is protecting Thane as the winds of war were definitely going to lynch him.

 

I had hoped you weren't really going to do that and you were town with some misguided reason to vote me, but this makes way more sense. Setup the fake cop claim early on so that you can line up the lynches one after another. You vote me with no real reason all of day 2, don't even bother coming up with a reason to hide it like a good town cop should do. You take a backseat opinion on the Turin bandwagon and try and connect me with everything he does ensuring all the people voting for Turin will vote for me the next day.

 

I am Town.

 

I was wrong about Eld it seems but Thane I was not. Lily, Thane, and Laine.

[Nynaeve]

I finally read Lily correctly, I'm so proud.

[LilyElizabeth]

I finally read Lily correctly, I'm so proud.

 

I'm proud of you, too. 

[Zander?]

[v]Vote Lily[/v]

 

So Lily's explanation:

She claims to have guilty on me. Instead of just telling people this, she "hints" it in such a way that (as Nyn said) you'd have to be blind not to notice. So what's the difference in not just claiming cop right then? Why not just knock me out right then and there if I were mafia? I can understand the need for a cop to keep their cover, but Lily didn't even try so it has the same result. Mafia would know who you are. Only town might not get that if they are focused on following other leads.  Town!Lily would have to know for certain that mafia would pick up on that. Instead, she encourages the Turin line from behind hoping to get another townie lynch out of it before having to release her fake claim. This also is protecting Thane as the winds of war were definitely going to lynch him.

 

I had hoped you weren't really going to do that and you were town with some misguided reason to vote me, but this makes way more sense. Setup the fake cop claim early on so that you can line up the lynches one after another. You vote me with no real reason all of day 2, don't even bother coming up with a reason to hide it like a good town cop should do. You take a backseat opinion on the Turin bandwagon and try and connect me with everything he does ensuring all the people voting for Turin will vote for me the next day.

 

I am Town.

 

I was wrong about Eld it seems but Thane I was not. Lily, Thane, and Laine.

Goodbye

[Nynaeve]

Lily is not great at breadcrumbing. We should totally lynch her for that.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

I don't see how you guys are buying this roleblocker bit. Basic games have cop and doc. Maybe vig.

Wasnt WoW basic? Or am I wrong?

I didn't play WoW. But giving scum extra powers throws off the balance. Basic is balanced because it's simple. Just those 2-3 roles.

 

Unless they've changed that over the years. That's how it was.

 

if WoW was basis it was 1 RB 2 goons in a 13er.

Ok so rb is allowed in basic now. I didn't know that.

 

But even still that game was balanced by having a 10th townie. This game is 12. Rb doesn't fit.

[Nynaeve]

lmfao

[Nynaeve]

I am overjoyed right now