[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Turin Turambar]

My take on BG. He will always make sense in what he says. He will always look reasonable in thread. He will fake claim as either alignment. It will generally have something in it that sounds too off to be made up. As town he will accept a lynch if he thinks it will forward the town solving and winning the game. I have never seen him use the fake "lynch me if you must" as mafia.

 

End of BG thoughts for those that may not have played with him before.

 

P.s. I.may be biased cause he killed.me twice in one day when I was just starting to play.

[BFG]

Loving the avis for this game

[BFG]

Turin, thoughts on Pral?

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

 

this conversation feels very familiar

 

I'm not sure I completely buy Sooh's earlier response either

Buy which response?

 

Oh, and before I forget. Zander, you're not at all Zander this game. You seem hostile, defensive, FOSing everyone (at least until recalibrating with Cory), and I don't see at all the townie Zander that I've come to expect. This has nothing to do with volume. It has to do with tone. You're using vocabulary that seems un-Zander and that is why I'll

 

[unvote]

[v]Zander[/v]

Regarding the BG tunnel

 

I dunno, I need to muse a bit

I may have explained it in a bad way. Like, I was thinking that IF BG is that type of scum when he is scum he might latch on to that and just never let it go, no matter what I said or did to explain myself. It's possible that tunnel is the wrong word, but sustained suspicion maybe?

 

 

Ok thoughts on Eldrick?

 

Nothing further as of yet. I haven't had the energy to go back and reread. For now I have scummier options. I feel like Zander is just off like I said. I also find Pral's vote on me strange, and I would love for him to explain further what it is about me that is so terribly scummy. 

[Eldrick4221]

Lol @ Sooh's avi. Almost went with that one.

[BFG]

You're sounding more like you today :)

[Sooh]

You're sounding more like you today :)

Is "you" myself or Eldrick?

[Sooh]

I like the C-clef because it's obscure. It's not much used. That being said the only clef I truly know is the G-clef. Every other clef is translated into G-clef before I can comprehend.

[Turin Turambar]

Turin, thoughts on Pral?

Only 3 posts that I sort of just glossed over. Looking back at the content I am a little concerned. He named nearly half the game saying there was a baddie in the group. Random says that most.likely correct. I disagree with the vote on Sooh. I think from what he posted Nol or Lily would be a more appropriate vote. He seems to.be voting Sooh for bad play rather than mafia play.

 

Maybe I am reading that wrong but it leads me to see a possible Nolder, Alanna, Pral team. Which would mean I am wrong about Thane.

[BFG]

 

You're sounding more like you today :)

Is "you" myself or Eldrick?

You :)

[Sooh]

 

 

You're sounding more like you today :)

Is "you" myself or Eldrick?

You :)

 

May be due to that my fever is pretty much gone today. I had like 38.5 yesterday when I was posting. Possibly not good for the clarity of my posts

[BFG]

Something about the whole Lily exchange with Zander, Nolder voting Lily for it and unvoting her with just an explanation from her. And, Alanna being dragged into it by Sooh. There is definitely a bad one in this exchange,

Can you explain this?

[BFG]

 

 

 

You're sounding more like you today :)

Is "you" myself or Eldrick?

You :)

May be due to that my fever is pretty much gone today. I had like 38.5 yesterday when I was posting. Possibly not good for the clarity of my posts

Glad you're feeling better.

 

At the moment I'm mixed on Zander, our conversation yesterday about my "reads" felt similar to the conversation last game about votes. He's looking at lots of people and Zander is naturally defensive...

 

But his reads list is so SO different to what I'm thinking it has me concerned. Admittedly some of my positions have clarified in the past couple of hours so it's not fair to judge him on that

[BFG]

/meh maybe that's an exaggeration :/

 

I don't really have strong reads on people, but I disagree with Sooh as a mafia read (although this read doesn't surprise me from Zander) and am surprised that Thane and Laine are so high.

 

The rest is probably more tweaking than outright disagreement

[Turin Turambar]

BFG, did you find it unusual for Z to even make a full list at that time?

[BFG]

BFG, did you find it unusual for Z to even make a full list at that time?

Yes/No/Maybe?

 

It's not something I've seen him do this early before, again as either alignment (i won't pretend a photographic memory of his games though)

 

I think he's trying to be more concise with his thoughts and reads lists are one way to do that. I don't want to judge him on the presentation of thoughts over the thoughts themselves. If it wasn't for placement of some of his reads I'd probably have him as cautious town at this point

[BFG]

BFG, did you find it unusual for Z to even make a full list at that time?

Yes/No/Maybe?

 

It's not something I've seen him do this early before, again as either alignment (i won't pretend a photographic memory of his games though)

 

I think he's trying to be more concise with his thoughts and reads lists are one way to do that. I don't want to judge him on the presentation of thoughts over the thoughts themselves. If it wasn't for placement of some of his reads I'd probably have him as cautious town at this point

[BFG]

BFG, did you find it unusual for Z to even make a full list at that time?

Yes/No/Maybe?

 

It's not something I've seen him do this early before, again as either alignment (i won't pretend a photographic memory of his games though)

 

I think he's trying to be more concise with his thoughts and reads lists are one way to do that. I don't want to judge him on the presentation of thoughts over the thoughts themselves. If it wasn't for placement of some of his reads I'd probably have him as cautious town at this point

[BFG]

Sorry for CF

[Eldrick4221]

One of the things that has bugged me so far was Lily's vote changes. I went back and ISO'd her. They do seem more fluid and towny in that light.

[Clovdyx]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT


Nolder(1): Turin
Sooh(2): Pralaya, Zander

Zander(2): bgrishinko, Sooh 

Not Voting: alannalynn, BFG, Thane, Lily, Nolder, Nynaeve, Eldrick

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Nolder]

@Nolder, I didn't read it that way. Noted. So back to your vote on Alanna, did you vote her for in essence "nudging' at Z (or whoever it was)?

 

Z, what did you learn from your effort to gauge reactions? I personally don't see the sense in doing such a thing in a game that has been confirmed to have fake claims for mafia.

I said as much, yes.

I voted her because I didn't like that she didn't drop a vote with her post.

As far as day 1 goes what she was saying was as good a reason as any to vote someone but she held off.

[Nolder]

 

Turin, thoughts on Pral?

Only 3 posts that I sort of just glossed over. Looking back at the content I am a little concerned. He named nearly half the game saying there was a baddie in the group. Random says that most.likely correct. I disagree with the vote on Sooh. I think from what he posted Nol or Lily would be a more appropriate vote. He seems to.be voting Sooh for bad play rather than mafia play.

 

Maybe I am reading that wrong but it leads me to see a possible Nolder, Alanna, Pral team. Which would mean I am wrong about Thane.

 

Can you expand on what you're seeing connects Pral to myself and Lily? I'm not understanding that.

[Nolder]

I propose the next person to change their avatar is lynched with extreme prejudice.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

Turin, thoughts on Pral?

Only 3 posts that I sort of just glossed over. Looking back at the content I am a little concerned. He named nearly half the game saying there was a baddie in the group. Random says that most.likely correct. I disagree with the vote on Sooh. I think from what he posted Nol or Lily would be a more appropriate vote. He seems to.be voting Sooh for bad play rather than mafia play.

 

Maybe I am reading that wrong but it leads me to see a possible Nolder, Alanna, Pral team. Which would mean I am wrong about Thane.

Can you expand on what you're seeing connects Pral to myself and Lily? I'm not understanding that.

It was Alanna I see you and Pral possibly working with. You both seem to have mentioned some things about her and/or put her in your wtl pile but are pointing away from her.

 

It gives me the feel of soft distancing While defending. Nolder, you went for Lily once she voted Alanna but removed your vote from her directly after she unvoted Alanna. Pral voted Sooh (wrongly IMO) for "dragging Alanna into the thing with Z, lily and you". I don't recall that happening. Maybe Pral can explain and/or show where that happened.