[Advanced] Nightmare Before Christmas - Town Wins!

[Lenlo]

Talk

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Vote AJ

 

I can also vote Tab.

[Leelou]

Vote Count 
 
Nol (1) - Lenlo
Lenlo (1) - Nol 
BFG (1) - Pizza

AJ (1) - NotBob
 
It is now day. With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. 
 

[Shad_]

Shad, you said you think this is wrong based on your understanding of her meta, or the meta on this site, iirc.

 

You think she's a townie, and so forth.

 

I have noted that, but I have to ask you if you are sure. Because if there's a scumbag in your list of townies, it's going to be BFG here, I feel.

 

Zander asked me a while ago to name my first and second town reads most likely to be wrong.  I said NotBob then BFG.  Point being I've said as much as I care to in her defense and the ball is in her court to offer an explanation and continue to consistently produce content I like.  I can't imagine voting her as things stand but I'm not going to lock her in as unlynchable at this stage.  (I think the only player as good as mod confirmed in my mind right now is Dice.)

[Shad_]

Going to be out for a while today.  My D2 priority is still figuring out AJ.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Going to be out for a while today.  My D2 priority is still figuring out AJ.

 

Voting AJ helps to figure him out.  Just saying...

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

[v]Andrej[/v] get in here son.

 

I am totally cool with lynching Tab today fwiw.

Also cool. Zanders last wish was that Tab get lynched, I aim to see that through for him.

 

 

i dont think im lynching Tab today. Too obvious and im not real keen on shads post here

 

 

How about AJ?  

[Nolder]

@ nolder

 

ok lets talk bro.

 

so im fairly clear you think len is scum. can you trell me ure thoughts on other players?  theres been so much too and fro with u len and shad that im a bit lost where ure standing.

 

I also want to know why I shouldnt lynch you especially because of the timing of ure show up just after DL. BE CLEAR i am not asking role info. I am asking for you to try and convince me. I saidf it about snow. He didnt do it. I voted him and screwed the pooch. I have no interest in doing that again.

Ok well I'm not sure much has changed but let me try to keep it simple and I'll give you my best guess between town/scum.

 

1. AJ - town

2. Zander - Jack Skellington - Vanilla Town - NK N1

3. Nolder - town

4. Lenlo - scum

5. Laine Shad - town

6. NotBob - town

7. Lord Commander - Sally - Town Voyeur - Lynched D1

8. Taborline - scum

9. Dice - town

10. Pizza -  town

11. BFG - town

12. Thane - scum

 

Gun against my head that's what I'd guess.

 

Ok next question...

Why you shouldn't lynch me because I showed up after deadline.

I don't see why it's a problem but iirc the deadline was 4PM right?

I have a bad sleep schedule which I've been struggling to change this month.

I think I finally did it since I'm up at 8:45 AM right now but I also don't feel like I slept much last night so I may just crash later.

Anyway that day I went to sleep at like 7AM and woke up right around deadline.

You don't have to believe me if you don't want to since it's RL and shouldn't be relevant to the game but you asked so I answered.

[Nolder]

If I have anything to say about it Nolder or Tab will be today's lynch. To many times have I seen town have a day like D1 then decide not to lynch the scummiest player in the game, thinking the slot will resolve itself before F3.

 

Yeah tall about who and what you want but I am not moving from Tab and Nolder.

Here's a question, do you think we're both scum?

[Andrej]

[v]Taborline[/v]

 

I think she's the way to go today.

[Andrej]

Like 9/10 times she needs to get lynched in this situation.

 

@Pizza - do you share those sentiments regarding Tab as you do Thane?

[Andrej]

Shad is my secret wolf after reading last night.

 

Also part of the reason I think it's important we kill Tab today. Lots of shady action around her and a lot of preemptive linking I noted.

 

I think Nolder is likely town and just getting drug into pointless conflicts. He does play the confusion/semantic game as scum but usually it's more artificial on the surface. Here he reads like he's actually getting pissed. I believe Lenlo's frustration to be genuine as well

[Andrej]

I also saw that you guys want me to lay out the case on Snow, which I will do later. If you want a preview then just ISO him in Kaylee's Avatar (Air Bender?) game and watch his a) poor reasoned vote on Seph and b) his lack of progression on that read despite remaining there thru the entirety of the Day.

 

Quotes will come later when I'm off my phone but that is basically the gist of it. I felt the parallels were very similar and perhaps got a little selfish towards EOD thinking my read was correct and wanting to push it through

[Andrej]

Wow I guess I froze the thread

[Lenlo]

Im still ok with a Tab lynch to, [unvote][v]Tab[/v]

 

One of those two needs to die today.

[Andrej]

Pretty much if Tab is a wolf that'll lock Shad in for me.

 

He clears quite a few people he's been toying with like Nolder/NotBob

 

The last one should be Thane or one of Pizza/BFG

[Lenlo]

Pretty much if Tab is a wolf that'll lock Shad in for me.

 

He clears quite a few people he's been toying with like Nolder/NotBob

 

The last one should be Thane or one of Pizza/BFG

Tab flipping Wolf locks Shad in as wolf as well?

 

Please explain, because while he was my choice for Deep Wolf in Zanders question and I had issue with his EoD, he would not be my next immediate choice. As much as I refuse to believe Nolders actions are those of a townie, if Shad flipped scum then yeah that would look good for Nolder. I would be very disappointed if Nolder flipped town though.

[Andrej]

His EOD should honestly be the most obvious indicator. He played a pretty big role in making sure that I stayed put on Snow when it seemed the momentum was about to finally swing into Taborline. He stated that he'd take Nolder or Snow over Tab. Snow is now confirmed and with how Nolder and Shad have been interacting I don't think that dynamic is w/w. Basically I think he put up two townies to cover his partner

 

The really bad part is the fact he wasn't voting anyone when the timer passed. He made a little show of voting Tab for "reactions" but if he was legit why not actually move it there? The important part of that sequence is that this took place once Snow was ahead. I know Shad understands how crucial it is to be voting at EOD and he did a lot of pussy footing around the wagons to end up on none when the dust settles.

 

There was also some linkage he was doing irt me and Tab when Zander started to point it out. It's odd to me that he went from "null/don't wanna lynch her" to "she could be scum with AJ"

[Lenlo]

Uuuuuugh it pains me to say this, but I suppose if he clears Nolder but Nolder doesnt clear him we should resolve him first. That hurts to type though.

 

For now Tab first though.

[dicetosser1]

Shad is my secret wolf after reading last night.

 

Also part of the reason I think it's important we kill Tab today. Lots of shady action around her and a lot of preemptive linking I noted.

 

I think Nolder is likely town and just getting drug into pointless conflicts. He does play the confusion/semantic game as scum but usually it's more artificial on the surface. Here he reads like he's actually getting pissed. I believe Lenlo's frustration to be genuine as well

 

this

 

and im leaning towards the first sentence.

[dicetosser1]

@NB   I think    emphasis on think  AJ is Town but i need to see a lot more form him. he and pizza are my deepwolf candidates

[dicetosser1]

vote shad

[Nolder]

I don't like my interactions with Shad, in fact I got quite mad at him before, but I don't think he's mafia.

If it's between him and me I choose me but if it's not...then I'd rather lynch almost anyone else.

 

Speaking of which D2 is supposed to be when Thane had the time to catch up with us more.

I'd really like to hear more from him.

[Andrej]

Yes Thane is certainly on my radar for toDay too

[Leelou]

Vote Count 
 
Tab (2) - AJ, Lenlo
Lenlo (1) - Nol 
BFG (1) - Pizza
AJ (1) - NotBob

Shad (1) - Dice
 
It is now day. With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.