[Pick Your Poison] Pulp Fiction Mafia - Game Over

[alannalynn]

Sooh who do you think is mafia

[dicetosser1]

sigh

 

im really tempted to lynch sooh anyways

[alannalynn]

My reads have been so backwards lately. Logically I should reverse my reads right

 

Idk

[dicetosser1]

laine thoughts on shad? and talya?

[Sooh]

last hunch is to look in Dice/Darthe... they could make sense together and as Kiv partners

[alannalynn]

Shad I'm still mildly suspicious of. Can you look back and see if Kiv ever pushed a lunch that way? There's something that's bothering me but I can place it.

 

And Talya. I'd probably vote Talya if I knew people would follow. I've been town reading her all game and thats not normal.

 

I think Darthe is town. I think thane could go either way. Dice maybe town.

 

Sooh??

 

I'm driving to work so I don't have many thoughts. I can check in on break before DL though

[Sooh]

To me Kiv seemed defensive of Shad. 

 

And I'm also suspicious of Shad town reading me with such certainty the whole game. 

 

I'm not sure about Talya, but if I am to move my vote I have to do so before going to sleep, which will be in half an hour.

[Shad_]

ffs [unvote]

 

Why?

[Darthe]

[unvote] [v] alannalynn [/v]

[Shad_]

I think Darthe is thinking what I'm thinking.

[Shad_]

Yeah, I'll go there.  [v]alannalynn[/v]

[keyholder21]

Vote Count 4.6
 
Darthe (2) - Thane Vakarian, Sooh
Sooh (1) - Talya
AlannaLynn (2) - Darthe, Shad

Not Voting (2) - AlannaLynn, dicetosser1,

 
4 to lynch.
 
Deadline: 9pm PST Monday, August 17th

[Darthe]

ffs [unvote]

Shad I'm still mildly suspicious of. Can you look back and see if Kiv ever pushed a lunch that way? There's something that's bothering me but I can place it.

 

And Talya. I'd probably vote Talya if I knew people would follow. I've been town reading her all game and thats not normal.

 

I think Darthe is town. I think thane could go either way. Dice maybe town.

 

Sooh??

 

I'm driving to work so I don't have many thoughts. I can check in on break before DL though

I don't fault you for being confused but I don't abide you not thinking.  Just vote Thane ffs

 

I think Darthe is thinking what I'm thinking.

That this town is going to derp right into a loss to you and Talya?  Yeah, I'm thinking that but don't worry, I'll never act on it.

[Darthe]

Yeah, I'll go there.  [v]alannalynn[/v]

Fascinating.

 

Do you think Talya is one of those who plays overly clean when she is a wolf?  I honestly can't recall my meta of her.

[Shad_]

I am sorry I couldn't fight harder.

 

Sorry town.

Basically there is no mafia player in this game who is not capable of making this statement.

 

ffs [unvote]

Which makes this look like pretty blatant PR hunting.

[Darthe]

I don't think so.  But I do think that wolves have more/better reasons to unvote there than townies do.  

 

Which leads to the question of dumb play or scum play?  

[Shad_]

 

Yeah, I'll go there.  [v]alannalynn[/v]

Fascinating.

 

Do you think Talya is one of those who plays overly clean when she is a wolf?  I honestly can't recall my meta of her.

 

I read Talya town the whole way through Belichick until DT was spoiled. I really don't see a distinct difference in her town and scum games. But the one thing I keep going back to is how she put Kivam at L-1 over Dice.

[Darthe]

I really want to say hell with it, we're killing one of Thane or Sooh.  Parked votes, daily whining about me, lack of conviction and failure to generally perform from both.  The only difference is Thane has managed to be louder about it, they likely have a wolf between them.  

 

But that's likely me not grasping this game all that well.

[Darthe]

 

 

Yeah, I'll go there.  [v]alannalynn[/v]

Fascinating.

 

Do you think Talya is one of those who plays overly clean when she is a wolf?  I honestly can't recall my meta of her.

 

I read Talya town the whole way through Belichick until DT was spoiled. I really don't see a distinct difference in her town and scum games. But the one thing I keep going back to is how she put Kivam at L-1 over Dice.

 

Yeah that's a big deal.

[Shad_]

I really want to say hell with it, we're killing one of Thane or Sooh.  Parked votes, daily whining about me, lack of conviction and failure to generally perform from both.  The only difference is Thane has managed to be louder about it, they likely have a wolf between them.  

 

But that's likely me not grasping this game all that well.

 

I saw Thane in Star Wars.  He was not the Thane I'm seeing here.  Maybe huge layers of post spam that were impossible to crawl through had something to do with it, I don't know, but he's been really bold here.  Fake claims, picking fights with you, begging people to switch their vote from Kivam to Dice.  His scum game mostly involved picking a few town and scum reads out the door and talking about coffee while passively repeating his reads any time someone asked.

[Shad_]

No one else seems to think Dice is scum here and I'm not really concerned with Darthe unless he is.  I'm not going to toss out everything I've been thinking today and lynch Laine on a single post that I might be misinterpreting.  [v]Sooh[/v] makes the most sense.

[dicetosser1]

why does sooh make the moast sense shad??

[Shad_]

why does sooh make the moast sense shad??

 

She's near the bottom of most people's POEs, including mine, and only two of you can be scum.  No lynch is not an option and I don't see four of us resolving on anything else in the next four hours unless someone shows up and decides to scum tell really hard.  For me, I have two competing theories.  One says scum are between Sooh, Laine, and Thane, and I think Sooh is the most likely of those three so I'd start with her.  The other says when Kivam couldn't get a lynch moving on me he took a gamble at two competing scum trains, meaning you and either Darthe, Talya, or Thane.  The way Darthe's been today I'm starting to think Talya is more likely scum than he is in that scenario. 

[alannalynn]

I have a few minutes break before my lunch break later (which is before DL), I'm more willing to go thane over sooh because I think he's more likely mafia. Sooh's reaction threw me off and I need to reevaluate that slot before making a decision there.

 

I guess I'm trusting Darthe here though

[alannalynn]

 

 

Yeah, I'll go there. [v]alannalynn[/v]

Fascinating.

 

Do you think Talya is one of those who plays overly clean when she is a wolf? I honestly can't recall my meta of her.

when I wolfed with her I though she was a lot cleaner and more careful as opposed to her getting things mixed up as town, I'm not sure how far that meta holds though