Belichick - Mafia Eternal Night

[Andrej]

Vote Rand?

[Yates]

Can you respond to post 842, Hally? These are actual and real thoughts and questions I have. From my brain. That requires response. From you.

[Yates]

Vote Rand?

Is Hally Town?

[Andrej]

You say that's OMGSUS-y, but nothing to Thane's vote on me after I posted my reasoning and voted him?

 

Noted.

I did comment on this actually. I went back to check Thane since your main point for him being scum was his mentioning of Pral/Verb - did you not see the post?

 

I liked his reaction.

[Andrej]

 

Vote Rand?

Is Hally Town?

Idk. I've never really seen her fight this strongly so I'm not sure what to make of it.

[Yates]

@Hally

 

Look - if AJ and Zander both tell me they are Town reading you for acceptable reasons that I just don't agree with? I'll compromise on a Rand lynch and go to sleep. But barring that, I still need your help.

[Shad_]

I have about 10 tabs open right now and I swear to god if Thane and Hallia don't start using quotes more I will lynch them on principle.  -_-

 

@Zander you're not 1000 really bro.  Remember your wtl Salami crusade?  Not trying to burst your bubble just saying I'm not seeing the Talya thing and while I think you make epic reads we all slip sometimes.  I'll keep your scum view of Talya in the back of my mind as the game progresses but I'm not lynching her today.

 

And regarding Thane, I'm piecing this together yet but I don't think the whole calling him out for repeating the Pral/Verbal line is as unfounded as it seems.  He was responding to people, yes, but at least with BFG he resurrected the question out of nowhere after having already answered it.  Meh.  Quotes will follow.

[Zander?]

this has just really took the wind out of my sails...i feel like a jerk now...im sorry Hallia....i really am.

[Yates]

And regarding Thane, I'm piecing this together yet but I don't think the whole calling him out for repeating the Pral/Verbal line is as unfounded as it seems.

Founded or not - is it even scummy?

[Hallia]

 

Zander has taken the fun  out of playing right now, frankly.

 

I'll sit here and wait for someone else to talk to that can be at least semi-civil.

 

Are you being serious Hallia cause if so Im sorry.  you just said you weren't rustled and then this.  I sincerely apologize if you felt i was being rude.  that was absolutely not my intent with our back and forth. i was asking to help clear you then all of a sudden you came at me.  i responded to you with what i thought was within the spirit of the game trying to get my thoughts/points across.

 

If I offended you Im truly sorry!!!!  you know i love ya!!! and i think your awesome!!!!

 

 

It's ok Zander, I needed a moment.  I'm an excitable, passionate person and I got too caught up and let myself get upset when I shouldn't have.

 

<3

[Andrej]

 

 

I'm not lynching outside of the following tonight:

 

Hally, Rand, BFG.

Why BFG?

Do you need specifics? There was some kind of disconnect between what she was thinking and what I thought she would be thinking in more than one spot. I'd have to go back over her in ISO but it was enough for me to at least not be Town reading her and to have some concerns.

Specifics would be cool when you have time, sure. Tbh I've never been very good at reading her. She's tricked me as scum and I've vigged her when she was town.

 

TLDR though - Fair enough. I have her as a light town lean for now.

[Yates]

this has just really took the wind out of my sails...i feel like a jerk now...im sorry Hallia....i really am.

Don't feel too sorry. She's probably scum running an AtE on you.

[Hallia]

Shaddap, pooper

 

[Andrej]

 

this has just really took the wind out of my sails...i feel like a jerk now...im sorry Hallia....i really am.

Don't feel too sorry. She's probably scum running an AtE on you.

lol

 

Could be though

[Shad_]

 

And regarding Thane, I'm piecing this together yet but I don't think the whole calling him out for repeating the Pral/Verbal line is as unfounded as it seems.

Founded or not - is it even scummy?

 

 

I don't know that it's terribly scummy but I can understand someone pointing it out with honest intentions.

[Hallia]

 

/snip

goodmorning all *has coffee and distributes where necessary*

 

Alanna: i tend to ping all the time, it has gotten me mislynched quite a few times. But it's how i play. If someone townreads me D1, that player is suspicious to me.

 

BFG: Happy to see you! Very nice entrance. I noticed you saw me mentioning Verb and Pral and me not wanting to lynch them. I don't, they need to play first. As far as lynching goes: the prime suspect would give most information, and personally i don't feel like there's a lot of diffirence between lynching a likely wolf and an infolynch. After all: you lynch suspects to get to a wolf, all the time.

 

Dice: wow, didn't think you would be in. and some post it is.... interesting.

:( I am still noting this continual posting on the same thing.

 

 

Whatcha thinking Andrej?

Like I said, mostly a hunch. I don't really understand his progression on BFG or the explanation he provided.

 

It also seems that he's more off topic than not (he isn't the only guilty one of this) but there have been places in the game where I feel like opportunities were there to make observations and he didn't. For instance, the Yates test and the Thane posts a few of us have commented on. I don't remember him saying anything about these and instead he's telling us about his house. Which is great and all but doesn't catch wolves.

 

 

Chatty because football and awesome explosions outside and I know some of you now.

 

Wolf Thane in Star Wars literally repeated the same four observations he made in the first 24 hours up until the moment he was lynched, while taking every opportunity to push things off topic.  He's already put out as much meaningful content as he did that entire game, and that's pretty promising.  I think if he's town it will become pretty obvious with time.

 

Talya's reaction to the no vote argument was promising.  She seemed to take it seriously and hop on board.  I can't give Zander a pass for it.  I think there's a decent chance he thought it was an obvious joke just like I did and played along.  I mean even if the rules did permit Yates' approach, it's not like we'd be granted a free win.  They'd be modified accordingly.  I think if Zander took it seriously he'd have investigated and seen that it was wrong, so null on his reply.

 

Yates test looks great for Talya because I think she sincerely bought it.

 

Shad is seeing the same thing.

 

I'm unsure what you're saying here, Hally, can you explain better? I read this post from Shad in a more positive manner for Thane, as in he's exceeding expectations after his scum game in SW, yet you're saying that Thane is being scummy from this same post.

 

Also, to Thane on the Dice/me situation: thoughts? You were there when it happened, I just want your thoughts on us from the encounter.

 

 

 

He sees that Thane has a tendency to do that for the first part.

 

I think the difference here is that Shad thinks he's posting about more topics in this game, whereas in my opinion he is already doing that very thing, with regards to continually mentioning only Verb/Pral until I called him out.

 

 

 

He sees that Thane has a tendency to do that for the first part.

 

I think the difference here is that Shad thinks he's posting about more topics in this game, whereas in my opinion he is already doing that very thing, with regards to continually mentioning only Verb/Pral until I called him out.

I see what you mean. Did he really mention Verb/Pral that many times though? I remember calling him out for it the first time and he responded (when he got me and BFG mixed up) but I don't remember seeing it sense. So idk.

 

 

 

For Yates

[Shad_]

 

I was catching up in clumps, and responding to what stood out to me.  I was merely agreeing that you had posted this.

Ok. I know that. But why? In all the stuff you were reading, what made THAT important for you to agree with?

 

I also JUST saw you do this in my star wars game with your 'mason' gambit, don't act like you only do them as town.

Are you saying fake claims are the same thing as a gambit? I mean, I don't deny that I have also pulled off scum gambits but Town couldn't know it was a gambit until after I flipped. So they don't look like this. Regardless, you didn't claim you saw me do SCUM gambits. So you see why I would wonder?

 

Below this Alanna questioned the same thing and I cleared it up.

Okay. Can you link for me? Because that's not part of the page 22 stuff that bothered me initially, which is what this post was about.

 

Also, NONE of the things you pointed out took anything you said out of context or misrepresented you in anyway. And that's the accusation you made when you voted for me. So... are you going to support that allegation or was that all hyperbole for effect?

 

 

 

He sees that Thane has a tendency to do that for the first part.

 

I think the difference here is that Shad thinks he's posting about more topics in this game, whereas in my opinion he is already doing that very thing, with regards to continually mentioning only Verb/Pral until I called him out.

[Hallia]

 

 

this has just really took the wind out of my sails...i feel like a jerk now...im sorry Hallia....i really am.

Don't feel too sorry. She's probably scum running an AtE on you.

lol

 

Could be though

 

 

I never ever do AtE.  I don't really like it.

[Shad_]

Oh hey Hallia beat me to that.  :P

 

Not sure it jives with me and Hallia "seeing the same thing" though.

[Zander?]

I have about 10 tabs open right now and I swear to god if Thane and Hallia don't start using quotes more I will lynch them on principle.  -_-

 

@Zander you're not 1000 really bro.  Remember your wtl Salami crusade?  Not trying to burst your bubble just saying I'm not seeing the Talya thing and while I think you make epic reads we all slip sometimes.  I'll keep your scum view of Talya in the back of my mind as the game progresses but I'm not lynching her today.

 

And regarding Thane, I'm piecing this together yet but I don't think the whole calling him out for repeating the Pral/Verbal line is as unfounded as it seems.  He was responding to people, yes, but at least with BFG he resurrected the question out of nowhere after having already answered it.  Meh.  Quotes will follow.

 

fair enough but i had not meta with him and seriously his play was erratic to say the least,  i also backed off of him.  i was also on seph and backed off to.  im not perfect but i do lunch wolves.

[Andrej]

AtE is sort of a natural thing - people do it all the time even if they don't mean to, or have the intent of doing so.

 

Saying stuff like "I'm not having fun" or "I don't care anymore" etc are manipulative even if you weren't meaning them to be.

[Hallia]

Well then, I never ever intentionally do it.

[Zander?]

 

this has just really took the wind out of my sails...i feel like a jerk now...im sorry Hallia....i really am.

Don't feel too sorry. She's probably scum running an AtE on you.

 

do you believe that cause i was reading her town.  if she did that id just be honestly disappointed.

[Yates]

Specifics would be cool when you have time, sure. Tbh I've never been very good at reading her. She's tricked me as scum and I've vigged her when she was town.

Just one that I found on the first page of her ISO real quick... it's kind of lulzy but:

I feel like I'm nitpicking, which isn't my favourite way to play, which makes me feel grumpy :/

Afaict and iirc, "nitpicking" [or really what I would better characterize as paying attention to details] is her specialty. So that felt weird. I mean, what is this post if not "nitpicking" as an example?

[Yates]

Oh hey Hallia beat me to that.  :P

 

Not sure it jives with me and Hallia "seeing the same thing" though.

Agreed.