[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

 

 

notbob who else would you think scum besides thaneballs?

 

Maybe Sili...maybe Salami...not sure...what you think?

 

 

Lunch menu is Yates and Thaneballs.  Preferably Yates, because I'm not convinced Verbal and Leelou were w/w.

 

possibly this combo as well...that vote on leelou was too clever by half.

 

I realize that brevity is sort of your thing, but it would help a lot if you'd actually explain these reads.

 

 

OK.  I'll try since you asked nicely.  

 

Sili because he was on Laine at EOD.  At the time it struck me as a momentum vote towards Laine.  Almost got me to vote there when he went that way.  Have to think one scum was trying to get cover for Leelou and Clov obviously wasn't it.

 

Salami cause of his role + his mock outrage.

 

Thaneballs because their ISOs are the worse of the entire town.  Very little interaction, both took the path of trying not piss anyone off.  Plus, I have zero history with Thane and the guy offered me a cup of coffee.  

 

The combo mainly due to Wombat's pile on vote at the buzzer.  Leelou was the lynch for sure.  Just seemed unnecessary at the time.  Not the strongest cases but its what I got.

 

Whats in your wallet? 

 

 

 

this made me laugh like really laugh...lololol

 

 

Mafia is a funny game...lol

[Andrej]

I laughed too, though I've seen Thane do that a lot lately in games. Thanks for clarifying NB

 

I don't think Thaneballs is a bad direction to go in today.

 

I think Sili's D1 looks a lot more like him as a villager but it does seem he's lost steam after the Leelou lynch which doesn't make sense to me seeing as how the GF died D1

 

Csarmi is a reluctant villager read. Don't like the claim or his attitude in some places but neither make him scum an overwhelming percent of the time.

 

The apple of my eye for today is Yates. He looked to be doing some unwarranted buddying/defending that could be TMI and generally there aren't many productive things I've seen from him.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I laughed too, though I've seen Thane do that a lot lately in games. Thanks for clarifying NB

 

I don't think Thaneballs is a bad direction to go in today.

 

I think Sili's D1 looks a lot more like him as a villager but it does seem he's lost steam after the Leelou lynch which doesn't make sense to me seeing as how the GF died D1

 

Csarmi is a reluctant villager read. Don't like the claim or his attitude in some places but neither make him scum an overwhelming percent of the time.

 

The apple of my eye for today is Yates. He looked to be doing some unwarranted buddying/defending that could be TMI and generally there aren't many productive things I've seen from him.

 

Yes, I know some have Yates in their sights...he's stays off my radar for some reason.  Let me ISO.

[Shad_]

[unvote] God I wasted a lot of time chewing on that. I don't think I misread a word of it but I'm fairly comfortable believing it was a town mistake.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

[unvote] God I wasted a lot of time chewing on that. I don't think I misread a word of it but I'm fairly comfortable believing it was a town mistake.

 

what was?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I can add Yates to the pile as well...only strong read I saw was his willingness to vote Durin.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I have no strategy and I think you should know that.

Everyone has a strategy. I think you are probably Town, mostly because of your claim ironically enough, but I don't like that you thought you had no choice but to claim immediately. That's not a miller role. You wouldn't investigate as scum. It's MUCH more like a Beloved Princess claim, as I've already said, and your best use of that role is to try to turn a negative into a positive and to try to draw a NK. If I were scum, I'd save you for end game, now, and just snipe.

 

 

i don't like the argument here.

[alannalynn]

 

[v]Yates[/v]

 

Good.  Would definitely prefer this to Thaneballs or Talya atm.

Talya's off the plate for now, she's on the Yates train with us

 

Lunch menu is Yates and Thaneballs.  Preferably Yates, because I'm not convinced Verbal and Leelou were w/w.

Womby, get with the program.

 

 

notbob who else would you think scum besides thaneballs?

 

Maybe Sili...maybe Salami...not sure...what you think?

Not Sili. Lynch All Hydras until you find scum. Lynch Verbane and we're done.

 

/snip

 

 

OK.  I'll try since you asked nicely.  

 

Sili because he was on Laine at EOD.  At the time it struck me as a momentum vote towards Laine.  Almost got me to vote there when he went that way.  Have to think one scum was trying to get cover for Leelou and Clov obviously wasn't it.

 

Salami cause of his role + his mock outrage.

 

Thaneballs because their ISOs are the worse of the entire town.  Very little interaction, both took the path of trying not piss anyone off.  Plus, I have zero history with Thane and the guy offered me a cup of coffee.  

 

The combo mainly due to Wombat's pile on vote at the buzzer.  Leelou was the lynch for sure.  Just seemed unnecessary at the time.  Not the strongest cases but its what I got.

 

Whats in your wallet? 

*not holding a grudge against Sili, and he's already beat himself up about that vote. Get over it, he's probably town, we're not lynching him.

Csarmi may be on the table later, but not yet. Yates and Thaneballs first y'all

 

[unvote] God I wasted a lot of time chewing on that. I don't think I misread a word of it but I'm fairly comfortable believing it was a town mistake.

Join me on Thaneballs or Yates and you can't go wrong?

 

@Sili, dude you're gonna have to prove your town game, or somebody's gonna try to lynch you for the hell of it

[alannalynn]

I can add Yates to the pile as well...only strong read I saw was his willingness to vote Durin.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But did he? No. He was being a bum and not contributing. Is that the kind of villager you want in your town?

[Shad_]

 

 

[unvote] God I wasted a lot of time chewing on that. I don't think I misread a word of it but I'm fairly comfortable believing it was a town mistake.

what was?

 

 

 

 

it clear now seph?

 

Also it means mafia now have a perfect fake claim at their disposal too

Scum detected. [v]Dicetosser1[/v]

 

This is real or I'll eat my hat. And it's old and musty in the basement.

 

Dice only knows for a fact Darthe was a PR if Dice is mafia.

 

 

 

what drugs u on shad?

 

when did i say anything about darthe being a pr?

 

a Janitor gets his character name

 

 

im out for dinner cyas later

 

 

 

 

 

 

@Shad, the mafia were provided with fake claims (characters) so that if we wanted to do a mass reveal or whatever, they would have roles and wouldn't have to scramble. The problem with Darthe, is that they know his power, whether it be a PR or just vanilla, along with his character, but we don't know anything about him.

 

If Leelou claimed Leia, I'm assuming that that was one of their safe claims for the mafia

 

 

 

 

 

I did an ISO on Yates yesterday. From my perspective he seems to be buddying me. Not only thinking I'm doing townie posts when no on else is but agreeing with who I think maybe wolf at the time.

 

I'm still not sure on Sooh, I'm not seeing what some of you are seeing as her cleared. I have t looked at Thaneballs, but will later.

 

Didn't see a problem with what Dice said. They do have a fake claim now in at least a character and maybe even a role. I'm disappointed that is all he had to say.

 

Alanna..part of your reason for thinking me wolf is because I thought Zander was and you think him town...so by the same reasoning I KNOW am town so does that make you wolf?

 

Pressure me all you like I'm waiting.

 

[v]Yates[/v] at present

Highlighted the difference between your statement and Dice's as I read it.

 

Because I don't understand what a 'perfect' fake claim is if the best they can do is pull a Leelou.

the difference is that Darthes character is REAL. It was really in the game. I purposely left the bit about the role out.No point giving mafia ideas even when they already probably know this too. And it doesnt have to be a PR to be useful. There are characters that VT would suit. You hear char x VT and nod your head cause it makes sense. Leia isnt one tho for eg.

Laine, this makes a lot of sense and I didn't know that. Thank you. Apparently Dice didn't know this either?

 

 

Think that includes everything. That was not fun to format on a phone.

[alannalynn]

zander  i wanna see thane. I thought Verb was decently townie  tho there was the lack of interaction between him and leelou.

 

yates im leaning town on

Nope. And why? Defend your read

 

Don't lynch Sili, Shad and Seph either. Might as well stay clear of the letter "S".

This feels oddly familiar

[alannalynn]

I laughed too, though I've seen Thane do that a lot lately in games. Thanks for clarifying NB

 

I don't think Thaneballs is a bad direction to go in today.

 

I think Sili's D1 looks a lot more like him as a villager but it does seem he's lost steam after the Leelou lynch which doesn't make sense to me seeing as how the GF died D1

 

Csarmi is a reluctant villager read. Don't like the claim or his attitude in some places but neither make him scum an overwhelming percent of the time.

 

The apple of my eye for today is Yates. He looked to be doing some unwarranted buddying/defending that could be TMI and generally there aren't many productive things I've seen from him.

Andrej knows what's up, you get an A+ for this post

 

I would leave Csarmi in cautiously maybe town for now

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

I can add Yates to the pile as well...only strong read I saw was his willingness to vote Durin.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But did he? No. He was being a bum and not contributing. Is that the kind of villager you want in your town?

 

 

I want Thane'sballs first...then Yates...OK?

[alannalynn]

 

 

I can add Yates to the pile as well...only strong read I saw was his willingness to vote Durin.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But did he? No. He was being a bum and not contributing. Is that the kind of villager you want in your town?

 

 

I want Thane'sballs first...then Yates...OK?

If I get nk'd, remember this and follow the plan

[Zander?]

When is DL?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

 

I can add Yates to the pile as well...only strong read I saw was his willingness to vote Durin.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But did he? No. He was being a bum and not contributing. Is that the kind of villager you want in your town?

 

 

I want Thane'sballs first...then Yates...OK?

If I get nk'd, remember this and follow the plan

 

 

Back at ya if I go down.  

[Andrej]

Tuesday I believe.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

so i make a observation and you find me wolfy.

 

you also didnt answer the 2nd question.

He did, though, indirectly. By calling you out on it. I think he *is* calling you wolfy for how you responded to his claim.

 

 

 

Weird.

 

Repost.

 

 

Funny thing, I hopped over to American Gods to see if this was normal for you.  Looks like you did kick that game off in serious mode, but one of your very first comments was to downplay the significance of getting reads out of opening posts.  You were v in that game.

 

/shrug [v]Seph[/v]

Wow. Just... Are you being serious with this vote?

 

 

As much as any vote made four hours into a game.  Why does this bother you?

 

For reasons already mentioned since. You can't "meta vote" someone based on a single game.

 

guess it could look like yates was setting ppl up against each other.

 

Sili – reactive to everything and everyone. Asks good questions. I can follow his thought process easily. I feel like this is very towny of him. He follows the game a lot in real time and asks for clarifications, which I feel is a towny thing to do.

 

Durin – Darthe-half: scum reads Seph and AH. Turin half: kinda scum reads AJ – not on the same page just yet in terms of reads. Need more time to peg.

 

Alannalynn – All over the page in terms of reads. Makes good observations and good points. No conclusion

 

Thaneballs – Thane: Joking, fluffy. Doesn't like Csarmi's claim. Doesn't like Sooh/Leelou/Heart/Laine thing D1. Verbal: Light hearted, soft defending Zander from Darthe.

Overall I like the light tone. I feel like the hydra confuses me, and I feel like I can't really pinpoint if this means either alignment yet.

 

Leelou – Comes in, guns blazing. Calls Seph awkward. Doesn't like heart. Calls my intro bland but is comfortable voting me. Mellows out after a while. Seems towny. I can't really explain it better. I like her points on Seph and Heart and I can understand her critizism of me from the way she explained she read my post.

 

Zander – jokey, comments on EVERYTHING. He seems interested in solving. Interested in hearing about metas from different people. Critical to Csarmi's claim. Don't have much to go on in terms of scum meta. Don't know how that would differ from regular, but this seems like free, uncensored Zander. He doesn't seem to be hindering himself in posting. I feel like that's a good sign for Town!Zander, but I don't have much to compare it to. I was mafia with him in that turbo, but that wasn't a good sample I don't think. He did sheep my reads though, so if he's doing that now that might be a sign. Somehow I doubt it though.

 

Eldrick – Comes in very critical to everyone and everything said. Questions Dice on his vote. Comments AH has a bad opening, but calls it typical. FOSes Wombat. Calls me buddying to AH. Votes WomboCombo. He seems very reactive to just about everything in the thread. I seem to remember him having about the same opening in his last game when he was town, but he also seems to want to throw shade on just about everyone in case they are

 

Talya – Doesn't like Seph being tunelled by AJ. Doesn't like Dice's vote on Durin. Hints at a WomboCombo/Seph scum team I believe. I may be reading that wrong. Not much to go on, and Talya always seems to confuse me. Don't know where to lean here.  

 

To sum up:

Sili - towny

Durin - null/unsure

Alannalynn - null

Thaneballs - null/slight town lean

Leelou - towny

Zander - towny

Eldrick - null/scum

Talya - null

 

I'll get you the rest of my reads/leans tomorrow well before EOD.

so turns out sooh doesn't mention heart at all following her reentrance into the thread on page 26.

 

=/

[seph]

don't worry alanna I will protect you!

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

When is DL?

 

Soon.  Hurry up and join the Thaneballs Express.

 

 

 

 

 

 

*Fake urgency*

[Zander?]

don't worry alanna I will protect you!

 

what did i tell you about this stuff....lololol

[Andrej]

I'm about to leave for the pool with the family.

 

Cocktails will be had.

 

Enjoy your day everyone!

[Zander?]

 

When is DL?

 

Soon.  Hurry up and join the Thaneballs Express.

 

 

 

 

 

 

*Fake urgency*

 

 

 

lolololol...i made the mistake of getting town to Lunch Sooh like right at start of day, she flipped Town may give them some time.  Verb dont play on weekends

[alannalynn]

 

 

 

I want Thane'sballs first...then Yates...OK?

If I get nk'd, remember this and follow the plan

 

Back at ya if I go down.  

Gotcha! It may seem like we're setting up lynches, but it doesn't count if we know they're scum

 

I'm about to leave for the pool with the family.

 

Cocktails will be had.

 

Enjoy your day everyone!

Have fun! Happy Fathers Day!

 

 

 

When is DL?

 

Soon.  Hurry up and join the Thaneballs Express.

 

*Fake urgency*

 

 

 

lolololol...i made the mistake of getting town to Lunch Sooh like right at start of day, she flipped Town may give them some time.  Verb dont play on weekends

Can't be any worse than waiting an entire weekend for Verbal to come online and take your side to lynch Seph *sigh*

But I'm sure here, this isn't like with Sooh

[Sili Quirrels]

like is no one reading the progression on sooh -__-

 

i don't want this to be like what happened to verbal. I start something, and the logic is sound, and u ppl only use it after i die and he ends up flipping town cause i couldn't adjust.