A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Leelou]

I'd actually rather him prove his role before lynching her. 

[Andrej]

That's really out there.

[Andrej]

I'd actually rather him prove his role before lynching her. 

 

I'm cool with that and he said he would confirm it but I don't see the point in him lying as either alignment in this scenario.

[Hallia]

I'm with Leelou there

[Talya]

It isn't his actual role but close to it. She didn't say vote thief she said double voter.

[alannalynn]

Same here, Leelou and Hallia. I also think Heart's observation was TMI. And why didn't she question about it? It feels really awkward. I'm waiting to hear from Heart before voting.

 

I'm doubting there is both a double voter and a vote stealer in the game; if there are, I'm leaning toward one being for the town and the other for scum, respectively.

[alannalynn]

It isn't his actual role but close to it. She didn't say vote thief she said double voter.

But why would we have two double voters in the game? I would question my observation immediately if I saw doubled up roles like that

[Leelou]

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

[alannalynn]

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

Teammates?

[Leelou]

 

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

Teammates?

 

 

That is the thought going through my head, yes. 

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

Teammates?

 

 

That is the thought going through my head, yes. 

 

just for the record as the game goes on and more and more of the people on my list are up for the chopping block you have to agree that the people pushing me as mafia have to be wrong.

[dicetosser1]

If Sooh is a villager, Dice is a wolf.

 

Im Town. Sooh is Mafia

 

 

 

Official Vote Count Three:

 

Pizzaguy(1/13): AJ

AJ (1/13): Laine

Talya (1/13): Dice

Verbal (1/13): Tina

EP (1/13): Seph

Sooh (2/14): Hally, Zander

Seph (1/13): EP

Zander (1/13): Sili

 

Not Voting (15/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Verbal, Talya, Eldrick, Leelou, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Yates, Batman & Cassowary, Pizzaguy, Sooh

Official Vote Count Seven:

 

 

Pizza (1/13): Eldrick

Sooh (2/13): Hallia, Zander

Seph (2/13): EP, Leelou

Tina (1/13): Dice

Yates (2/13): Sooh, AJ

Eldrick (1/13): Pizza

Alot (1/13): Yates

 

 

Not Voting (14/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Verbal, Talya, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Batassery, Laine, Tina, Sili, Seph

 

 

With 24 alive, it's 13 to lynch!

Official Vote Count Nine:

 

 

Pizza (1/13): Eldrick

Yates (2/13): AJ, Leelou

Eldrick (1/13): Pizza

Alot (1/13): Yates

Sili (1/13): Talya

Seph (2/13): Sooh, EP

 

Not Voting (16/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Batassery, Laine, Tina, Sili, Seph, Dice, Zander, Verb, Hally

 

 

With 24 alive, it's 13 to lynch! Deadline is 12:15 AM EST on Wednesday, the 13th.

Official Vote Count Ten:

 

 

Pizza (1/13): Eldrick

Yates (3/13): AJ, Leelou, Sili

Eldrick (1/13): Pizza

Alot (1/13): Yates

Hally (1/13): Talya

Seph (2/13): Sooh, EP

 

Not Voting (15/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Batassery, Laine, Tina, Seph, Dice, Zander, Verb, Hally

 

 

With 24 alive, it's 13 to lynch! Deadline is 12:15 AM EST on Wednesday, the 13th.

Official Vote Count Four:

 

AndreJ(1/11): Krak

Sooh (2/11): Hallia, Dice

Talya (1/11): Pizza

Hallia (1/11): Alannalynn

Krak (3/11): Talya, Leelou, AndreJ

Verb (1/11): Yates

Leelou (1/11): Eternal Phoenix

 

Not Voting (11/20):

Sooh, Aiel Heart, Thane, Verb, Taborline, Seph, Tina, Batassery, Eldrick, Alot

 

With 20 alive it takes 11 to lynch.

Official Vote Count Seven:

 

AndreJ(1/11): Krak

Sooh (1/11): Dice

Krak (3/11): Talya, Leelou, AndreJ

Verb (4/11): Eternal Phoenix, Alannalynn, Pizza, TinaHel

Yates (1/11): Eldrick

Thane (4/11): Hally, Yates, Thane, Leelou

Dice (1/11): Sooh

 

Not Voting (6/20):

Aiel Heart, Verb, Taborline, Seph, Batassery, Alot

 

With 20 alive it takes 11 to lynch.

Official Vote Count Two:

 

Hallia (2/9): Yates, TinaHel

TinaHel (1/9): Eternal Phoenix

Laine (1/9): Leelou

Dicetosser1 (1/9): Sooh

Sooh (2/9): Dicetosser1, Hallia

Taborline (3/9): AndreJ, Thane, Eternal Phoenix

Eternal Phoenix (1/9): Pizza

 

Not Voting (7/17):

, Aiel Heart, Krak, Taborline, Alannalynn, Seph, Cass, Talya

 

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch. Deadline is at 12:15 PM on May 19th, 2015.

Had to really scour to make sure I got this right. My ctrl + f isn't working for some reason. Sorry if it's off, I'm counting the votes thus:

 

Official Vote Count

 

Hallia (2/9): Seph, Laine

Dicetosser1 (1/9): Sooh

White Knight (1/9): Eternal Phoenix

Eternal Phoenix (4/9): Pizza, WK, Tina, Cass

TinaHel (7/9): Leelou, Thane, Dice, AJ, Yates, Hallia, Talya

 

Not Voting (2/17):

Aiel Heart, Krak

 

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch. Deadline is at 12:15 PM on May 19th, 2015.

 

Scene incoming

 

 

So vote Talya, vote Tina, unvote.

 

Sooh all day.

 

Then jump on Tina when it looks like she's going down.

 

Then Sooh again.

 

Not really reading this as a villagery vote record from Dice. Looks like he's attempting to avoid leaving a vote record, actually.

 

 

Talya was Joke Vote. Sooh is mafia. Tina became obvious and i couldn\t get people to lynch sooh without lynching Tina first.  Something you should know about me Pizza   once i have you as certain scum in my head I dont leave it alone. I might vote for consolidation or like Tina to make the reality of lynching my Target happen but then I come right back to it..

 

 

Hint to wolves: Villagers change their reads sometimes.

 

Lacking in your game this game, that's why you stick out like sore thumbs.

 

Not always  see above

 

 

[v] Sooh [/v]

 

The above "lynch me if I'm wrong about him" stiiiiinks.

 

 

While I think it is too, could you please read what Pizza is saying it's important for town. don't just go on a quick reaction, look at the game, at least you would if you were townie!

 

 

I dont know if hallia is Town or not but she IS right here talya

 

 

 

[Leelou]

 

 

 

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

Teammates?

 

 

That is the thought going through my head, yes. 

 

just for the record as the game goes on and more and more of the people on my list are up for the chopping block you have to agree that the people pushing me as mafia have to be wrong.

 

 

No I don't because you are in my scum list. 

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

 

 

I also find it interesting that WK has accused Heart of being a role cop, yet isn't voting her. 

Teammates?

 

 

That is the thought going through my head, yes. 

 

just for the record as the game goes on and more and more of the people on my list are up for the chopping block you have to agree that the people pushing me as mafia have to be wrong.

 

 

No I don't because you are in my scum list. 

 

let me put it terms that will make it easy to see.

 

1 Either I'm bussing an entire mafia team and am just really lucky on the list of other team which is a very risky gambit and would put all the members of the bussed team in the crosshairs or

 

2 I am telling the truth and have really lucky reads

 

of those two which sounds more likely here?

[Gabriel Kross]

@Pizza I'm going to ask you to go out on a limb and trust me. Hold your moves until we find the roleblocker if you are who you say you are. There has to be a reason you didn't die last night, and I want you to consider that.

[Talya]

 

 

It isn't his actual role but close to it. She didn't say vote thief she said double voter.

But why would we have two double voters in the game? I would question my observation immediately if I saw doubled up roles like that

I would too and think I said that or at least I was going to.

 

If WK thought she was a role cop why would he vote straight off. That could be a town role. It will be interesting to see what she has to say and what WK does.

 

This has certainly pushed the vote away from EP which is also interesting

[Leelou]

Bussing, EP. You have yet to be on a scum lynch and there was only one so far. How many anti town do you think there are? How many town do you think is left?

[Gabriel Kross]

Bussing, EP. You have yet to be on a scum lynch and there was only one so far. How many anti town do you think there are? How many town do you think is left?

Tina was one of my suspects, I suspect 2 teams of 4. Hence why my list of reads is 8. 

[Leelou]

Any other anti town?

[Gabriel Kross]

Any other anti town?

beats me. I haven't seen anything to suspect that so until I see something to suspect it I'd say multi-ball just signals 2 mafia teams. Considering at most we've had 2 deaths a night, rules out SK.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am not following the AH "tmi" case.

 

No less that two other people read the post in question the same way, because others in this game who claimed to have a double vote said "x2" when double voting.

 

And one of those people thinks AH is scum for the much, much, much more plausible reason that her leans list is entirely populated with villagers, and her one scum suspect is me. That's a total coincidence I'm sure.

 

That's what's bugging me. It just feels like a tinfoil hat case is being pushed for not-villagery reasons on a likely scum candidate. But you can get away with it because opposing scum.

 

I am fine watching the wolves self-destruct and eat each other, I'm just pointing out loony things as I see them from where I sit.

[Askthepizzaguy]

@Pizza I'm going to ask you to go out on a limb and trust me. Hold your moves until we find the roleblocker if you are who you say you are. There has to be a reason you didn't die last night, and I want you to consider that.

 

I am always considering. Do you know how many suspects I've reversed on so far this game?

 

But no, not after your quit mafia forever tactic.

 

It was clearly a tactic, because after I laid into you telling you how terrible it was to use such a tactic, your activity level stayed the same or increased, and you continued to play as if you hadn't just been called out for using that tactic deliberately.

 

If there was any truth in what you were saying, you'd not have cared as much to continue play.

 

But that's not the reason I suspected you, and I'm only telling you this as a "why I am not reversing" on you statement.

 

The case against you stands, and I have further reason to suspect you since. This is in-game stuff and it's rock solid.

 

 But regardless, you destroyed your own credibility in this game irreparably, because you lied to me about something that should never even be discussed during play.

 

Such tactics shouldn't ever be in play, but even if I were to ignore them, you still look guilty. And I will never allow a guilty person to threaten to quit mafia altogether as a life-preserver, it's so distasteful and anti-game and goes against the spirit of fair play.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Being a fair minded and not wrathful person, behind the mask, you could apologize for doing what you did and pledge to never do it in a game again.

 

We're a bunch of friends playing a parlor game to kill time and have fun together. Keep your play in the spirit of that, and I'll begin being more reasonable toward what you have to say.

 

I hope you understand this is meant to protect players, not admonish you. I've made poor choices before.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm not a saint, I just have a couple of moves I don't allow as legitimate and use my vote as a recourse against them whether it's legal to do those things or not.

 

Personal insults or angleshooty tactics such as "I quit forever" result in votes. That's how I keep things fun in games, and further, it lands on scums a lot when I do it, too.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Villagers have little need to resort to such things, and even if they do, they'll quickly learn not to while I'm alive in the game. :)