[Advanced] Arthurian Mafia

[MrsClov]

Sili, my name is spelled Lily not Lilly. Only Crusher can call me Lilly. Thanks.

 

We have 3-4 hours until deadline, and this is what you choose to talk about? 

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili, my name is spelled Lily not Lilly. Only Crusher can call me Lilly. Thanks.

I will just call you Elizabeth, or liz if i don't feel like typing the whole thing.

[Verbal32]

 

 

WTH

 

I NEVER SIMALTANEOUSLY VOTE DARTHE AND DEFEND HIM!!!

 

can we please acknowledge this.

 

I'll actually back this.  He was not voting Darthe at the time he was defending him.

 

You DID, however, make a statement that implies you were content defending him without actually pulling votes from him.  I know YOU said that's not what you meant by damaging his wagon, but it's pretty much the same thing IMO.

 

The tunnel is dark isn't it.

 

 

Do you think Clov was accurate when he tried to point out how inconsistent and contradictory you've been this D1?

[dicetosser1]

id Cop Sili Doc Darthe cause im thinking he's town but a prime vig shot and vig Barm

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

WTH

 

I NEVER SIMALTANEOUSLY VOTE DARTHE AND DEFEND HIM!!!

 

can we please acknowledge this.

 

I'll actually back this.  He was not voting Darthe at the time he was defending him.

 

You DID, however, make a statement that implies you were content defending him without actually pulling votes from him.  I know YOU said that's not what you meant by damaging his wagon, but it's pretty much the same thing IMO.

 

The tunnel is dark isn't it.

 

 

Do you think Clov was accurate when he tried to point out how inconsistent and contradictory you've been this D1?

 

Aj said I was erratic, and I think that's probably about as accurate as you can get to describing how I play.

 

Me and clov think differently, since he has a reason for everything, and I'm more adlib. To him, defending Darthe without having a villa lean was bad enough he's dead set on lynching me. But I defended Darthe because I thought the case was bad at that point, and I think that's what a villager should do.

 

Our differences of opinion on what a villager should do is where our disagreement stems from I think.

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

 

WTH

 

I NEVER SIMALTANEOUSLY VOTE DARTHE AND DEFEND HIM!!!

 

can we please acknowledge this.

 

I'll actually back this.  He was not voting Darthe at the time he was defending him.

 

You DID, however, make a statement that implies you were content defending him without actually pulling votes from him.  I know YOU said that's not what you meant by damaging his wagon, but it's pretty much the same thing IMO.

 

The tunnel is dark isn't it.

 

 

Do you think Clov was accurate when he tried to point out how inconsistent and contradictory you've been this D1?

 

Aj said I was erratic, and I think that's probably about as accurate as you can get to describing how I play.

 

Me and clov think differently, since he has a reason for everything, and I'm more adlib. To him, defending Darthe without having a villa lean was bad enough he's dead set on lynching me. But I defended Darthe because I thought the case was bad at that point, and I think that's what a villager should do.

 

Our differences of opinion on what a villager should do is where our disagreement stems from I think.

 

 

I should add that I think like Clov does.  There should be a reason for everything in mafia, and I read posts as if every single one was made with a specific reason behind it.  Hell, even my spidey memes have a time and a place (and a reason).

 

That you don't play that way makes you erratic, yes - which is the same as inconsistent.  That tendency is what makes you come across as contradictory and therefore scummy.

 

Re: the bold - Darthe has done nothing differently since I first voted him, but now you think he's scum?  THAT is contradictory.

[Sili Quirrels]

Well, that's the impression I get anyway.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

 

 

WTH

 

I NEVER SIMALTANEOUSLY VOTE DARTHE AND DEFEND HIM!!!

 

can we please acknowledge this.

 

I'll actually back this.  He was not voting Darthe at the time he was defending him.

 

You DID, however, make a statement that implies you were content defending him without actually pulling votes from him.  I know YOU said that's not what you meant by damaging his wagon, but it's pretty much the same thing IMO.

 

The tunnel is dark isn't it.

 

 

Do you think Clov was accurate when he tried to point out how inconsistent and contradictory you've been this D1?

 

Aj said I was erratic, and I think that's probably about as accurate as you can get to describing how I play.

 

Me and clov think differently, since he has a reason for everything, and I'm more adlib. To him, defending Darthe without having a villa lean was bad enough he's dead set on lynching me. But I defended Darthe because I thought the case was bad at that point, and I think that's what a villager should do.

 

Our differences of opinion on what a villager should do is where our disagreement stems from I think.

 

 

I should add that I think like Clov does.  There should be a reason for everything in mafia, and I read posts as if every single one was made with a specific reason behind it.  Hell, even my spidey memes have a time and a place (and a reason).

 

That you don't play that way makes you erratic, yes - which is the same as inconsistent.  That tendency is what makes you come across as contradictory and therefore scummy.

 

Re: the bold - Darthe has done nothing differently since I first voted him, but now you think he's scum?  THAT is contradictory.

 

I make a big long post about my progression on Darthe. I'm not sure it's readable, but I tried.

[Leelou]

I really can't understand why you'd defend anyone without knowing their alignment.

[Alanna]

A little under 2 hours to deadline.

[Sili Quirrels]

I really can't understand why you'd defend anyone without knowing their alignment.

It's more like I argued why a case was bad from my perspective.

[Sili Quirrels]

I know there isn't much difference in effect but in general villagers should communicate. That's what I try to do.

[Verbal32]

I know there isn't much difference in effect but in general villagers should communicate. That's what I try to do.

 

Ok, but you voted me AFTER I communicated and explained my thought process on why I felt Darthe was scum.  Does that not seem to be the way a townie should act?  Yet you said I sounded fake and only seem to be relenting a little after half the playerbase disagreed with you (even Darthe).

[Darthe]

I'm not only amazed that Sili changed his opinion based on nothing but equally that Verbal hasn't.  With this much experience I'd think he would know the difference between a scummy maneuver and a perhaps poorly made town decision.  

 

He remains town, if wrong.  Please note that if he makes it to lylo you should lynch him as he has duped us all.

[Darthe]

Clov it's me or Lily today.  I'd go Sili but don't think it'll happen.  Which way you goin?

[Darthe]

The same applies to you all

[Verbal32]

I'm not only amazed that Sili changed his opinion based on nothing but equally that Verbal hasn't.  With this much experience I'd think he would know the difference between a scummy maneuver and a perhaps poorly made town decision.  

 

He remains town, if wrong.  Please note that if he makes it to lylo you should lynch him as he has duped us all.

 

Because I think it was a mishmash of the two - a poorly made scummy maneuver.  ;-)

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I know there isn't much difference in effect but in general villagers should communicate. That's what I try to do.

 

Ok, but you voted me AFTER I communicated and explained my thought process on why I felt Darthe was scum.  Does that not seem to be the way a townie should act?  Yet you said I sounded fake and only seem to be relenting a little after half the playerbase disagreed with you (even Darthe).

 

I know. If my read was wrong I'm sorry.

[Darthe]

 

I'm not only amazed that Sili changed his opinion based on nothing but equally that Verbal hasn't.  With this much experience I'd think he would know the difference between a scummy maneuver and a perhaps poorly made town decision.  

 

He remains town, if wrong.  Please note that if he makes it to lylo you should lynch him as he has duped us all.

 

Because I think it was a mishmash of the two - a poorly made scummy maneuver.  ;-)

 

Would you disagree that it has garnered a lot of conversation and reads and that if I (as a townie) lived through it that it would be +ev?

[Nynaeve]

Sili is inconsistent. It's part of his playstyle, for better or worse. I think he did put an honest effort to try to explain himself to Clov. I also totally see how someone like Clov would get lost in Sili logic.  lol

[Cass]

Cass will be replacing AJ. She has informed me she will probably not be able to check in here before Day 1 ends, because of her time zone.

What I said was I would probably be asleep at 4 am when the role PM was due to arrive - It's morning now, I'm awake and checking in!

 

Hi all :) Back properly after getting the kidlet off to pre-school.

[Nynaeve]

Hi Cass =)

[dicetosser1]

 

Cass will be replacing AJ. She has informed me she will probably not be able to check in here before Day 1 ends, because of her time zone.

What I said was I would probably be asleep at 4 am when the role PM was due to arrive - It's morning now, I'm awake and checking in!

 

Hi all :) Back properly after getting the kidlet off to pre-school.

 

 

Remember the Rules! No addiction!

[Alanna]

Vote Count:

Sili (1) - Clov

Darthe (6) - Verb, Leelou, Lily, Sili, Eldrick, Nyn

Barm (1) - dice

Lily (4) - Barm, MrsClov, Yates, Darthe

 

Not Voting: Thane, Cass

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

 

Deadline is March 8th (today) at 6PM CST. That's in a little more than an hour.

[dicetosser1]

if i have to choose between darthe and lily id go darthe cause we will get the most info afterwards. I dont particularly want to go that way tho. We could all vote Barm instead!