Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Nolder]

Nolder are you doing that thing as scum when you post a bunch in a row to bog down the thread?

 

Cuz it kinda feels that way to me with you being a lead wagon going into DL

I don't do it to bog down the thread.

What I do is wait for awhile so there's a lot for me to respond to, that way I never have to do actual scumhunting myself because I'm too busy responding to things.

 

I can see how it would look like that right now but really I'm just trying to legitimately catch up. 

If I can manage it I'm going to go pop an aspirin and then take a shower but for now...the catchup continues.

 

Good catch though, major props for remembering my scum MO even if slightly off.

[Nolder]

Nol: Why did you say Verb was on the top of his game yet you're keeping an eye on him? Seems he's in your town pile now.

People keep mentioning this and honestly I don't remember it. I'll have to go back and check later.

 

If anyone has the time a quote or page number would be awesome.

[Nolder]

Hi Nol

Don't say hi to me, it might make Verbal suspicious.

[Leelou]

 

 

Hi Nol

Don't say hi to me, it might make Verbal suspicious.

Me breathing is making him suspicious.

[Sili Quirrels]

You don't even know what a contradiction is, it looks like.

 

 

 

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

 

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

 

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

Correction, I said he was an easy 'mislynch'. Get facts straight imo.

And I'm not backtracking there. I'm reconsidering and updating the thread with conjecture.

Is there a difference for the purposes of this discussion? An easy "mislynch" is an easy lynch. You're describing it as an attribute of Thane, doesn't matter if he's town or not he'll still be lynched and that's the point of discussion. Your correction is pointless posturing imo.

 

And yeah that's totally backpedaling and now you're going even further.

Making a statement that someone is easy to lynch is a bold statement of fact. It says you know the person, you know the people you're playing with, and that this situation is normal. That it happens a lot. Now you're saying you've reconsidered. It doesn't work that way. You don't make statements like Thane is easily lynched and then say you've reconsidered. It makes no sense.

 

You are talking nonsense.

Yes, the distinction is significant. An easy mislynch is an easy bad lynch. Thane is easy to misread. Your point is that you find my contemplation weird, but I never expressed certainty about the read and your argument is baseless. Thane is easy to misread, I am cognizant of that, and I've waited for more information all day.

[Nolder]

Isn't Mafia fun?

It's the best. Now hold still while I do a Homer Simpson impression.

[Sili Quirrels]

Nol makes me laugh,  snarky AJ is grin worthy and apparently Sili's response to Nol is to be speechless

My tablet posted before I'd made a response, but you know, yeah, this inflammatory comment was totally necessary.

[Nolder]

 

 

Hi Nol

Don't say hi to me, it might make Verbal suspicious.

Me breathing is making him suspicious.

 

Yeah, you might want to stop that too.

[Nolder]

You don't even know what a contradiction is, it looks like.

 

 

 

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

Correction, I said he was an easy 'mislynch'. Get facts straight imo.

And I'm not backtracking there. I'm reconsidering and updating the thread with conjecture.

Is there a difference for the purposes of this discussion? An easy "mislynch" is an easy lynch. You're describing it as an attribute of Thane, doesn't matter if he's town or not he'll still be lynched and that's the point of discussion. Your correction is pointless posturing imo.

 

And yeah that's totally backpedaling and now you're going even further.

Making a statement that someone is easy to lynch is a bold statement of fact. It says you know the person, you know the people you're playing with, and that this situation is normal. That it happens a lot. Now you're saying you've reconsidered. It doesn't work that way. You don't make statements like Thane is easily lynched and then say you've reconsidered. It makes no sense.

 

You are talking nonsense.

Yes, the distinction is significant. An easy mislynch is an easy bad lynch. Thane is easy to misread. Your point is that you find my contemplation weird, but I never expressed certainty about the read and your argument is baseless. Thane is easy to misread, I am cognizant of that, and I've waited for more information all day.

 

Lol you're saying a lot of words but they really mean nothing.

 

Thane is easy to misread........BUT I THOUGHT YOU CHANGED YOUR MIND?

 

You can't keep a story straight with the quotes right in front of you.

[Nolder]

omg I did it this is the end of the road

 

ok aspirin and shower then I'll be back

[Tommyrod]

 

A+ gif

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

Hi Nol

Don't say hi to me, it might make Verbal suspicious.

Me breathing is making him suspicious.

Yeah, you might want to stop that too.

Can I bite him?

[Red2111]

 

Nol makes me laugh,  snarky AJ is grin worthy and apparently Sili's response to Nol is to be speechless

My tablet posted before I'd made a response, but you know, yeah, this inflammatory comment was totally necessary.

 

 

*gigglesnort*  

[Nynaeve]

Getting late for me, but I'm gonna try to stick around for a while longer.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

You don't even know what a contradiction is, it looks like.

 

 

 

 

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

 

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

 

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

Correction, I said he was an easy 'mislynch'. Get facts straight imo.

And I'm not backtracking there. I'm reconsidering and updating the thread with conjecture.

Is there a difference for the purposes of this discussion? An easy "mislynch" is an easy lynch. You're describing it as an attribute of Thane, doesn't matter if he's town or not he'll still be lynched and that's the point of discussion. Your correction is pointless posturing imo.

 

And yeah that's totally backpedaling and now you're going even further.

Making a statement that someone is easy to lynch is a bold statement of fact. It says you know the person, you know the people you're playing with, and that this situation is normal. That it happens a lot. Now you're saying you've reconsidered. It doesn't work that way. You don't make statements like Thane is easily lynched and then say you've reconsidered. It makes no sense.

 

You are talking nonsense.

Yes, the distinction is significant. An easy mislynch is an easy bad lynch. Thane is easy to misread. Your point is that you find my contemplation weird, but I never expressed certainty about the read and your argument is baseless. Thane is easy to misread, I am cognizant of that, and I've waited for more information all day.

Lol you're saying a lot of words but they really mean nothing.

 

Thane is easy to misread........BUT I THOUGHT YOU CHANGED YOUR MIND?

 

You can't keep a story straight with the quotes right in front of you.

Your argument is horrible. People change their minds. All. The. Time. The post you quoted wasn't even me changing my mind too. You're all over the place.

 

For the record, again, you are wrong. I never express a strong scum read of Thane, and I took time to reconsider. This is not inconsistant with my assesment he's an easy mislynch. In fact it is perfectly consistent with it.

[Nynaeve]

 

LOL Me and Nyn have been on the same page for most of this game.

 

Nyn and Leelou both have had really good posts but there's been a few I didn't like as well. 

 

 

Are you talking about the posts where I was FoSing and voting you? Cause I could see how you wouldn't like that. Heh.

[The Crusher]

 

That was posts from Nolder. He is apparently catching up post to post. 

 

Nolder - can you give a list please. 

omg

 

ya'll are broken records

 

nolders mia nolders gone nolder doesnt give reads nolder give me a list

 

 

CORY YOU CHANGE MY ROLE TO GOD DAMN SERIAL KILLER RIGHT NOW 

 

[Andrej]

I've gotta head out for work. Might be able to squeak out another post or two before the bells rings but we'll see. Hopefully I can be out a few minutes early to see where the wagons are before DL.

 

Until then, I'm content lunching Dice.

 

GL

[Cory Caboose]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VGB_SspipRE

[Sili Quirrels]

@Dice, I'm looking for something pure and substantial, or at least something that promises a good day 2. If you have a scum lean I would like to hear you build a case on them.

[Nolder]

 

 

 

 

Hi Nol

Don't say hi to me, it might make Verbal suspicious.

Me breathing is making him suspicious.

Yeah, you might want to stop that too.

Can I bite him?

 

I dunno, might be seen as aggressive which is a scum trait.

[Sili Quirrels]

I don't like this conversation and how it takes priority over pushing the person you have a vote on.

 

But it's falling into the so terrible it's probably a reaction test range, so I'll give you a chance to redeem yourself.

[Nolder]

 

 

You don't even know what a contradiction is, it looks like.

 

 

 

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

 

Speaking aloud here, but maybe thane is one of those players who needs to keep notes and build his reads from the ground up. Last game he posted notes, maybe that's how he makes reads.

 

I can't really relate.

And now you back peddle and jump on the fence with Thane.

This is what I'm talking about. Why did you say he's an easy lynch and now you're backing off that?

I thought you were confident in your reads?

 

Honestly, I suspect this has nothing to do with alignment. I think this is just the way you are.

It's weird and frustrating. Reminds me of EP.

Correction, I said he was an easy 'mislynch'. Get facts straight imo.

And I'm not backtracking there. I'm reconsidering and updating the thread with conjecture.

Is there a difference for the purposes of this discussion? An easy "mislynch" is an easy lynch. You're describing it as an attribute of Thane, doesn't matter if he's town or not he'll still be lynched and that's the point of discussion. Your correction is pointless posturing imo.

 

And yeah that's totally backpedaling and now you're going even further.

Making a statement that someone is easy to lynch is a bold statement of fact. It says you know the person, you know the people you're playing with, and that this situation is normal. That it happens a lot. Now you're saying you've reconsidered. It doesn't work that way. You don't make statements like Thane is easily lynched and then say you've reconsidered. It makes no sense.

 

You are talking nonsense.

Yes, the distinction is significant. An easy mislynch is an easy bad lynch. Thane is easy to misread. Your point is that you find my contemplation weird, but I never expressed certainty about the read and your argument is baseless. Thane is easy to misread, I am cognizant of that, and I've waited for more information all day.

Lol you're saying a lot of words but they really mean nothing.

 

Thane is easy to misread........BUT I THOUGHT YOU CHANGED YOUR MIND?

 

You can't keep a story straight with the quotes right in front of you.

Your argument is horrible. People change their minds. All. The. Time. The post you quoted wasn't even me changing my mind too. You're all over the place.

 

For the record, again, you are wrong. I never express a strong scum read of Thane, and I took time to reconsider. This is not inconsistant with my assesment he's an easy mislynch. In fact it is perfectly consistent with it.

 

Yes, they do change their minds. But your statement wasn't one that makes sense to be changed. Thane is easy to lynch. The sun is yellow. These are statements of fact. Then you changed your mind? What made you change your mind that Thane is not an easy lynch? The fact that he wasn't lynched? How did you even know he's an easy lynch in the first place? How many games have you played with Thane?

 

The bottom line is a statement like "Thane is easy to lynch" is not a statement that one reconsiders during the course of a few dozen pages of one game. If you seriously reconsidered then why did you make such a strong statement to begin with?

[Nolder]

 

 

LOL Me and Nyn have been on the same page for most of this game.

 

Nyn and Leelou both have had really good posts but there's been a few I didn't like as well. 

 

 

Are you talking about the posts where I was FoSing and voting you? Cause I could see how you wouldn't like that. Heh.

 

YEP!

[Nolder]

I don't like this conversation and how it takes priority over pushing the person you have a vote on.

 

But it's falling into the so terrible it's probably a reaction test range, so I'll give you a chance to redeem yourself.

My vote is on you.

 

And lol, redeem MYSELF?

Lynch me if you think I'm scum that'll be my redemption.