[Game] Best LotR Character Elimination

[Nikonis]

Hurt Gollum

 

Pippin: 25
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum:4

[Niniel]

Heal poor Gollum, hurt Pippin

 

 

Pippin: 24
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum:5

[BFG]

I offered an alliance /shrug :p

 

Heal Pippin, hurt Gollum

[Nikonis]

Hurt Gollum

 

Pippin: 25
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum:4

[Aiel Heart]

There was an alliance offered somewhere? 

I just can't stand Gollum and love Pippin!

(Sorry Tina)

(Surprised she hasn't started a "save Gollum!" campaign :P )

 

Hurt Gollum Heal Pippin :D

[dawnflower8]

Hurt Gollum

[Niniel]

Oh, he is alive. For maybe an hour or two...

 

Heal Gollum, hurt Pippin

 

 

 

I just love the Gollum - Smeagol talkes/fights. One of the things that became so good in the movies. And if it wasn´t for him the ring wouldn´t have been destroyd.

[Nikonis]

Hurt Pippin

 

Pippin: 23
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 3

[Niniel]

Hurt Pippin, heal Gollum

 

 

Pippin: 22
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 4

[Leyrann]

Heal Pippin

Hurt Gollum

[Nikonis]

Hurt Pippin

 

Pippin: 22
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 3

[BFG]

Heal Pippin, hurt Gollum

[Niniel]

Heal Gollum, hurt Pippin

 

Pippin: 22
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 3

[Leyrann]

Heal Pippin

Hurt Gollum

[BFG]

Heal Pippin, hurt Gollum

[Niniel]

Heal Gollum, hurt Pippin 

 

Pippin: 23
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 2

[Nikonis]

Hurt Pippin

 

Pippin: 22

Gandalf: 25

Aragorn: 25

Gollum: 2

[BFG]

Meanies :(

 

Heal Pippin, hurt Gollum

[BFG]

There was an alliance offered somewhere? 

I just can't stand Gollum and love Pippin!

(Sorry Tina)

(Surprised she hasn't started a "save Gollum!" campaign :P )

 

Hurt Gollum Heal Pippin :D

Please help save Pippin, even after Gollum is dead :pleads:

 

Also Pippin for the win

[Nikonis]

 

There was an alliance offered somewhere? 

I just can't stand Gollum and love Pippin!

(Sorry Tina)

(Surprised she hasn't started a "save Gollum!" campaign :P )

 

Hurt Gollum Heal Pippin :D

Please help save Pippin, even after Gollum is dead :pleads:

 

Also Pippin for the win

 

 

Sorry, I don't care which of the two (Gandalf or Aragorn) wins out but, in my opinion, one of them should end up the survivor.

[Nikonis]

Not that pippin is a bad character, just far from my favorite.

[Nikonis]

Hurt Pippin

Pippin: 22
Gandalf: 25
Aragorn: 25
Gollum: 1

[BFG]

Heal Pippin, kill Gollum (sorry precious)

 

Have you listened to Brandon Sanderson's Writing Excuses when he talks about Gandalf magic and the inherent problems for using that 'style' of magic in modern fantasy?

[dawnflower8]

I like well thought out magic systems. LotR doesn't even have a magic system, it's just random magic for the purpose of the plot. I love the books, but Tolkien could've done a better job with the magic. Gandalf's still awesome, though.

 

Hurt Pippin

[Aiel Heart]

Not that pippin is a bad character, just far from my favorite.

We're not talking about favorites, we're talking about best!

 

 

 

Hmmmmmmmmmm....... I haven't actually READ LotR in a long time, and I'm feeling conflicted based on movies.

 

Someone convince me of who I should hurt/heal and why :P