[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[hazelkrs1]

Manbat is still blue y'all

 

Yates just quit it. You're going down a dumb trail that could end up losing town this game

 

Also- ANNOUNCEMENT:

 

Its one thing to question a NA to see if you can catch someone in a lie. It's quite another to question the intelligence of a NA decision and then use that to try and cast aspersion on people. Just because someone doesn't optimize the use of their NA DOES NOT MAKE THEM SCUM. Seriously seeing a LOT of people want to fall into this trap and it's silly

[hazelkrs1]

Also something else is being looked over right now I think, so Imma be annoying and enlarge this too

 

Manbat appears to have gotten a result from his Night Action N1 - "your village has stayed the same". First off the chances of Manbat making up that result from the mod as scum here are ZERO. Second and this is more important- he was supposed to have been JKed that night, and prevented from getting any NA results or performing any actions of any kind

 

 

Actually wait AJ flipped third party and not vanilla town so I might be an idiot never mind, disregard this until I think it over more

[hazelkrs1]

I think it's confirmed then that BFKey are a RBer of some kind. I still think they're scum tho.

 

I also think Dice is RIDIC likely to flip scum here.

[hazelkrs1]

@Krak: in this setup, were there a psychiatrist, if they were blocked, would they still get a "result" on their NA? Would they receive a result of any kind in normal circumstances?

[monstrman]

I can direct you to all the times I've claimed in a strange way as town

 

 

Fir Christ's sake once I claimed I was the sk when I was the vigilante

[monstrman]

Also HALLIA IS SHOW ING NO INTO REST IN CLEAR ING HERSELF AND FINE ING SCUM TEA MS TODAY

[dicetosser1]

manbat im still waiting to hear what you got told N2 plz

[dicetosser1]

and yes i realize ure probably at work. was just a reminder

[monstrman]

Didn't get a response

 

Not really sure why

[Alanna]

Ok, I reread the last several pages while I'm sitting here in the car, and I'm going to ISO BFKey, Hallia, and Rags when I get home. And maybe dice and Pral, if I have time . Probably will only be from day 2 on, because I have pretty extensive notes on day 1. Also will probably reread day 3 entirely, because I felt like I was just bare minimum keeping up that day .

 

LOOK FORWARD TO IT :D

[Sili Quirrels]

I will look forward to it.

 

Pretty busy at the moment so I can only manage a rough poe of a couple individuals.

 

Dingus: He does unnecessary stuff and isn't economical. not fluff or anything, but he seems honest and forthright even when he doesn't need to be: the psychiatrist breadcrumbs for instance.. He also deliberates itt, his reads are fluid, flow driven, and i can understand where he's coming from when he says lynch him. overall strongest town read if only because there's minimal posturing and he appears completely honest.

 

Despothera: Serious wim. already said it all, but he might be this good at acting himself, but he isn't a safe lynch when a case against him is more tinfoil and paranoia.

 

 

--- more later gtg.

[Alanna]

YES I AM BACK ON A REAL COMPUTER.

 

Okay, going to read back on Day 3 and then get to those ISOs.

[Krakalakachkn]

@Krak: in this setup, were there a psychiatrist, if they were blocked, would they still get a "result" on their NA? Would they receive a result of any kind in normal circumstances?

 

That one I'm not gonna answer.

[Hallia]

I was at a birthday party King Manbat <3

 

 

I've stated why I chose my target.  I believe someone asked why I didn't protect Tommy?  Because I didn't really have that much belief in the claim ( and I was correct, and I feel netting an innocent on Pral is awesome.)

[monstrman]

I AM THE MASTER OF THIS DAY

 

ALL HAIL KING MANBAT

[monstrman]

I have a feeling this day is going to end extremely poorly

[Sili Quirrels]

I have a feeling this day is going to end extremely poorly

lol. if all else fails, we'll just lynch desp

[dicetosser1]

 

I have a feeling this day is going to end extremely poorly

lol. if all else fails, we'll just lynch desp

 

 

This

[Alanna]

Dice, do you think you could articulate more about why you want to lynch Despo? Having just gone through your ISO, I've solidified my townread on you, but I'm also lightly townreading Despo.

[Alanna]

FYI, I have only managed to get through dice's ISO so far, and I'm getting really tired, so I may wait til tomorrow evening to look at the others I want to look at. I wanted to look at dice because I was feeling townie on him, but couldn't really recall why - it was a gut read, and I kind of wanted to be sure of it. Looking through dice's ISO, there's a lot that makes me feel good about him. I agreed with what he said back on Day 2 about Tommy going after Despo, that because Tommy is biased against Despo, it was hard to take what he saying against Despo at face value. The progression of his thoughts on BFKey make a lot of sense from Day 1 - Day 3, and I especially liked his point about BFKey being the logical choice for a nk on Night 2, rather than Tommy. Lastly, I also liked his point that people should read him for his own content, rather than trying to link him to Verb based off things Verb was saying.

 

So dice is a green read for me now.

[Alanna]

So yeah, I'm gonna have to go to bed. I did do a quick look over BFKey's ISO and I'm still just kind of stuck on them. I feel I should have a stronger read on then than nullish at this point, but there's just not a lot to go on. BFG asks a lot of questions of other player and then doesn't seem to follow up on them, and I can't decided if that's scummy, or if she's just keeping her thoughts to herself. I feel like a townie should be more transparent. There was one post of hers in particular I didn't like, and that was her reaction to Yates' gambit where he pretended to view Pral guilty. She'd been scumreading Pral, but then said she wasn't sure she should believe Yates. Maybe she was just being cautious, but the way she worded it kind of made it sound like she didn't really want to vote him after all, like she was trying to back out of that.

 

But, meh. I don't know about them. I just think it's weird they haven't been nightkilled yet, but like manbat said, I'm trying to go more off gameplay and less off mechanics.

 

Speaking of monstr, after rereading the past several pages a few times today, I'm really starting to question my townread on him. He just seems to get very defensive anytime anyone goes after him in the slightest; in fact, he gets defensive just when someone questions him. I remember him doing this Day 1, and he did it when I and someone else (Yates? Can't remember who it was) questioned him about why the heck he thought Hallia had the same role as him in the game. And now again in these last few pages, when Yates went after him. I'm just starting to feel like he could be scum getting panicky about people questioning the gaps in what he's said about his psychiatrist role - the assumption that Hallia was one too, how he forgot who he targeted Night 2.

[Alanna]

Tomorrow I still want to reread Day 3 in its entirety (should be able to do that at work), and then I want to look over Rags, Pral, and Hallia in ISO (that will have to be in the evening after work and church). FYI, the people I'm looking at are people that I don't feel I have a solid read on, or that I thought I did but then feel that I can't recall why I have that read. After barely keeping up with the game this past week, I want to get a firmer grasp on everyone.

[dicetosser1]

will try to do this tomorrow alanna

 

 

does anyone know the page numbers of Des' big WoT and case on Verb?  a link would be even more awesome....

[Leelou]

The more I think about this the more I think BFG is lying. I'm also still having a hard time fitting Hallia in with town if BFG is town. That or scum is in the non claimants.

 

Des

Alanna

Dice

Berf/Sili

Rags

[Yates]

Leelou has the controls for this day phase.